11 ms·
New measurements of the sky's blackness
- aedanman 6y agoThere are far fewer *Visible stars and galaxies than we thought
- awb 6y ago> So, what could be the source of this leftover glow? It’s possible that an abundance of dwarf galaxies in the relatively nearby universe lie just beyond detectability. Or the diffuse halos of stars that surround galaxies might be brighter than expected. There might be a population of rogue, intergalactic stars spread throughout the cosmos. Perhaps most intriguing, there may be many more faint, distant galaxies than theories suggest. This would mean that the smooth distribution of galaxy sizes measured to date rises steeply just beyond the faintest systems we can see – just as there are many more pebbles on a beach than rocks.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThis is more about the invisible stars and galaxies, the ones too far to actually count, but whose lights just gives a faint glow to the darkness.
- pvorb 6y agoThis depends on your definition of visible. If you think of visible as some form of light reaching a man-made object, then GPs statement is still true.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWell, stars whose light has never even reached us are likely out of our light hypercone, so they might not exist in the scientific sense (i.e. Their existence or non-existence is completely unprovable and has no consequences, even in principle).
- dclowd9901 6y agoI know this is goofy, but it would certainly have consequences if this realm of space contained an advanced civilization capable of reaching us before the light did.
- tsimionescu 6y agoIf the theory of relativity is wrong, than yes, absolutely, the notion of a light hypercone is wrong as well, and the notion of what is within the realm of science changes.
- pvorb 6y agoIsn't this like saying that aliens do not exist, because we never received any signal from them? Of course you can see it like that, but does it really change the probability of their existence? I think there's a difference between what we know and what actually exists.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWell, if the aliens exist outside our light hyper-cone (that is, by definitio, any kind of information from them has never reached and will never reach any piece of information we create) then it is the same. However, if any aliens have lived or will live anywhere in the visible universe, then that is something we could at least in theory confirm our deny at some point, so it is not the same. It's also important to remember that time is relative - that is, that events in far away places don't happen at a definite time compared to those happening here. That makes their existence different to me than what we normally think of as existence. Existence has two senses anyway - one is the empirically verifiable bottom of existence that science can work with: this is the one I was referring to. The other is a philosophical notion of existence that is harder to pin down. In this sense, God may well exist, the nultiverse with many big bangs may be real, infinity may be real etc. But it is impossible right now to make any kind of scientific arguments about these things, so they can only exist outside the realm of science (as we know it today).
- 6y ago
- simonh 6y agoI would argue that any reasonable definition of visible includes being able to resolve features. In support of this, many dictionary definitions include words like 'accurate', 'clear' and 'obvious', while it's antonyms include 'unclear', 'indistinct' and 'obscured' and not just 'invisible'.
- ipnon 6y agoThis paper would seem to put many others estimating the prevalence of astrobiological activity into question.
- ivalm 6y agoI don’t think so. For astrobiology we are mostly looking for life in our galaxy, this study looks at presence of very far away galaxies. For purposes of communication those galaxies are forever out of reach as they are at such high red shifts they are escaping from us faster than speed of light.
- ljlolel 6y ago"escaping from us faster than speed of light." ?????
- ksherlock 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_of_the_universe The expansion of the universe is the increase in distance between any two given gravitationally unbound parts of the observable universe with time. It is an intrinsic expansion whereby the scale of space itself changes. The universe does not expand "into" anything and does not require space to exist "outside" it. As the spatial part of the universe's spacetime metric increases in scale, objects move apart from one another at ever-increasing speeds. To any observer in the universe, it appears that all of space is expanding while all but the nearest galaxies recede at speeds that are proportional to their distance from the observer – at great enough distances the speeds exceed even the speed of light.
- drran 6y agoRed shift can be caused by Doppler shift of frequency and by loss of energy by photons. When Red shift is interpreted as 100% Doppler shift, then we have such absurd velocity. Of course, nobody saw a photonic boom when the whole galaxy crossed the speed of light barrier.
- pwagland 6y agoSpecifically, from the article: > New measurements of that weak background glow show that the unseen galaxies are less plentiful than some theoretical studies suggested, numbering only in the hundreds of billions rather than the previously reported two trillion galaxies. We used to think that we couldn't see 90% of the galaxies/stars, this study proposes that we can't say about ½ of the galaxies/stars.
- dclowd9901 6y agoOne of my favorite statistics is the "we don't even know what we don't know" statistic. Every time, it's a session of imagination trying to figure out how they figured that out.
- iso1631 6y agoReports that say that something hasn't happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns—the ones we don't know we don't know. And if one looks throughout the history of our country and other free countries, it is the latter category that tends to be the difficult ones That statement was ridiculed at the time, and not by people pointing out the unknown knowns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_are_known_knowns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_are_known_knowns
- detritus 6y agoI never unserstood that ridicule - I always thought it was an apt-description of the levels of ignorance we can honestly presume for ourselves. Refreshingly honest of Rumsfeld, if anything.
- mncharity 6y ago> I never unserstood that ridicule Perhaps try the response with a different issue and respondent swapped in? Q: There are reports there is no evidence of a direct link between [...] Vaccination-autism policy advocate: Reports that say that something hasn't happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; [...] But there are also unknown unknowns—the ones we don't know we don't know. And if one looks throughout the history of our country and other free countries, it is the latter category that tends to be the difficult ones. Q: The real situation is worse than the facts show? (later NATO press event) UFO-abduction policy advocate: The message is that there are no "knowns." [...] Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.[1] [1] https://www.nato.int/docu/speech/2002/s020606g.htm https://www.nato.int/docu/speech/2002/s020606g.htm
- tsimionescu 6y agoThis is the money quote: > New measurements of that weak background glow show that the unseen galaxies are less plentiful than some theoretical studies suggested, numbering only in the hundreds of billions rather than the previously reported two trillion galaxies. The new data is based on observations of the luminosity of deep space images from the New Horizons program, which is outside the inner solar system. The older estimate was based on Hubble images along with mathematical models to try to account for the glow of space dust.
- kkaranth 6y agoNoob physics question: I assume this talks about stars close enough that we can receive their light. Can we say anything about the number of stars & galaxies that are further away than that?
- permille42 6y agoMy main response to this article is essentially the same question. I think the article is presuming some things to come to this conclusion. The main thing that is being presumed is the "big bang". If you proscribe to believing in the big bang, then the entirety of everything we see is an expansion from a single dense explosion of matter. It is still a valid theory but I myself don't understand the physics of what is observed well enough to be convinced this is true. I believe that they are seeing something similar enough that it could be perhaps a "localized bang" or something like that. The main evidence used as "proof" of the big bang is the observed data seeming to show that the everything in the universe is "dispersing" slowly. That is at least what I've heard claimed.
- permille42 6y agoWhy in the fuck is sharing some knowledge of what I know about science that leads to people believing there is nothing outside the observable universe downvoted? I can see having a dislike of my opinion and beliefs ( which is not a valid reason to downvote by the way according to what Hackers News itself says... ), but downvoting me when I am attempting to communicate useful information. Come on now.
- andy_ppp 6y agoIt’s because opinions are not equal to science and suggesting your opinion without massive corroborating evidence isn’t going to fly here. It’s the same as suggesting climate change isn’t real and COVID is just like flu... these things are made up, not researched science.
- layer8 6y agoI didn’t downvote, but you demonstrated a very poor understanding of the big bang, and put forward equally ill-informed conclusions/suspicions based on that. It is not useful.
- crazydoggers 6y agoImportant to note, that this number refers to the “observable universe”. The number might be much higher, especially given inflation theory, but those galaxies currently lay outside our observable universe due to speed of light constraints. Another interesting possibility is a finite but unbounded universe which means we might see duplicate galaxies from light circumnavigating (think of an old video game where you leave the screen at the top and appear on the bottom). In that case there might be fewer actual galaxies than what we observe. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe
- dclowd9901 6y ago> Another interesting possibility is a finite but unbounded universe which means we might see duplicate galaxies from light circumnavigating (think of an old video game where you leave the screen at the top and appear on the bottom). Would this mean the universe would be spherical?
- XorNot 6y agoNope! Lots of possible finite but unbounded shapes - i.e. a torus shaped universe would have no observable edge, and also wouldn't be obviously wrapping around (you are at no risk of seeing light from yourself headed back at you from the other direction). You can then twist those geometries up into all sorts of knots and strange shapes to get all manner of universes where there is no edge, but light paths don't obviously loop back around.
- antonvs 6y agoThe standard FLRW metric[1] that's used to model the universe is "not necessarily simply connected," which means it allows for shapes such as toruses, multiple connected toruses, and so on. There's one proposal for something called the Poincaré dodecahedral space - see "Is the universe a dodecahedron?"[2] But a sphere, or rather, a higher-dimensional hyperspherical equivalent, is the simplest possibility for that kind of scenario, and the FLRW metric allows that. This article, "The Shapes of Space", has some nice explanations: http://www.ic.uff.br/~aconci/poincare.pdf http://www.ic.uff.br/~aconci/poincare.pdf [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann%E2%80%93Lema%C3%AEtre%E2%80%93Robertson%E2%80%93Walker_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann%E2%80%93Lema%C3%AEtr... [2] https://physicsworld.com/a/is-the-universe-a-dodecahedron/ https://physicsworld.com/a/is-the-universe-a-dodecahedron/
- jldugger 6y ago"It's just the same 20 galaxies, and the universe is just wraps around itself."
- permille42 6y agoUm. What? Is this the new "the earth is flat"? Space is infinite. I believe it goes on forever in every direction. Whether you can see whatever is out there from here in no way proves that it isn't...
- crazydoggers 6y agoThat’s not known. This article refers to the observable universe which is bound by the speed of light. Whether the universe is infinite or not is an open question. It might be finite but unbounded. Spacetime geometry is complicated.
- permille42 6y agoNeither the title nor the summary say anything about the "observable universe". They make broad claims beyond that. The detail of the article in no way mentions that there could very well be infinite duplicates of what we see out there beyond observable distance.
- crazydoggers 6y agoBecause this is an article that’s using the layman terminology. The scientists involved surely understand the difference. In fact read the Wikipedia article and you’ll see the old estimate of 2 trillion for the observable universe. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observable_universe
- Cederfjard 6y agoThis is the first sentence in the lead paragraph: >How dark is the sky, and what does that tell us about the number of galaxies in the visible universe?
- joering2 6y agoWe have no proof Universe is infinite, but we can also argue that the building blocks of Universe - atoms? - cannot come in unlimited quantity. At least it sounds more reasonable that way. Unless of course we are all in a symultation and our whole Universe takes up half a sq. inch of a silicone chip.
- maga 6y agoDoes this mean there is "more" dark energy since we still have all the effects of extra matter but less visible matter?
- crazydoggers 6y agoDark energy and dark matter are separate concepts. Dark energy refers to a factor that increases the expansion of the universe, ie a cosmological constant. Dark matter on the other hand is matter we can’t detect currently, but we theorize is there from its gravitational effects. There’s a lot of other data like galaxy rotation rates, CMB, gravitational lensing, etc that effect dark matter estimates. I’m not sure how much of the current estimate is based on larger observable universe structure, so it’s an interesting question.
- maga 6y agoI understand that, I mean the matter-energy balance in the universe at the moment accounts 5% to ordinary matter, 26% to dark matter and the rest to dark energy. Since we now assume there are less stars, hence, ordinary matter, but the galaxies are still accelerating at the same rate, doesn't that mean the dark energy accounts for more than the estimated 69%?
- Keysh 6y agoNo, because only about 10% of normal (baryonic) matter is actually in the form of stars. The rest is mostly in the form of hot, dilute gas in intergalactic space. The idea that about 5% of the total mass-energy budget of the universe is in the form of baryonic matter is well-determined by cosmological observations (including the relative amounts of hydrogen and helium formed in the Big Bang). It if turns out we've overestimated the amount of baryonic matter in stars by a factor of two, that just means that 95% of the baryons are in the hot intergalactic medium instead of 90%.
- m_herrlich 6y agoanyone else reminded of the Spinal Tap album "Smell the Glove" cover discussion? > How much more black can it be? None! None more black