4 ms·
Is it technically possible to have end to end encryption with Signal if it evolved to first attempt to use direct connections via RTC or some other method? If
by Waterluvian 6y ago
Is it technically possible to have end to end encryption with Signal if it evolved to first attempt to use direct connections via RTC or some other method?
If they're incurring serious costs to run, that tells me Signal's days are numbered until it has to start commercializing.
- aaomidi 6y agoMore users and more attention also means more donations. I sent them something yesterday as a show of support and have set monthly donations as well.
- faitswulff 6y agoThis came up on the forum and someone raised a good point - would direct connections require the sender and receiver to be online at the same time? I feel like the architecture has to be more clever than just a WebRTC connection between clients.
- Scoundreller 6y ago> would direct connections require the sender and receiver to be online at the same time? Could always use 'indirect' connections to store-and-forward, and only relying on the central server when absolutely necessary. You do risk some lost messages when you underestimate failures, but the same thing applies to any central store-and-forward facility. Early Kazaa depended on some nodes becoming supernodes. Supposedly initial Skype was decentralized like this (particular to get around NATs), until it became exclusively client-server.
- swirepe 6y agoThere was a really good YouTube lecture about how signal works, and it addresses phones being offline. Unfortunately there's been a ton of low-quality videos on Signal released in the past few days, and it's taking me a while to find it.
- loughnane 6y agoMight be the one from computerphile
- upofadown 6y agoThe Signal protocol can deal with offline messaging, but it requires a server to do it. That is because of how the forward secrecy works. Presumably the amount of traffic would be fairly negligible for what would just be keying information.
- eat_veggies 6y agoI'd imagine that would leak your IP address to your chat partner, which is undesirable in many cases