7 ms·
No, blockchains are not the future, they are really the reason why one transaction can happen at a time in the whole world. Even Ethereum 2.0 will have shards w
by EGreg 6y ago
No, blockchains are not the future, they are really the reason why one transaction can happen at a time in the whole world. Even Ethereum 2.0 will have shards which will do away with this anomaly. The only reason flash loans even work with no collateral is because you can be sure nothing else is running on the “world computer” while your transaction runs, so you can roll it back with no risk except gas fees.
Vitalik himself acknowledges this, the guy is quite honest and straightforward about its limitations: https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2019/08/19/vitalik-buterin-ethereum-blockchain-almost-full-scalability/ https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2019/08/19/vitalik-buterin-e...
Vitalik Buterin: Using Ethereum is expensive, and its blockchain is ‘almost full’
He also said blockchain's 'problem' is that every computer verifies every transaction
Actually blockchains are a first-generation technology that do global consensus for every block, which literally means all transactions in the world must go through one computer in the world (the miner) although it’s a different one each time. And the situation is actually worse, since you don’t know who would mine the next block in advance, every transaction must be sent to every potential miner! Imagine if BitTorrent had every computer store and seed every movie instead of using DHT.
The ability to send or loan arbitrarily large amounts for a fixed fee is a symptom of centralization. In a fully distributed network, transaction fees would have to be proportional to transaction size!
Almost every other protocol on the Internet does not have such bottlenecks in its design. No one asks how many emails or websites can be served per second. Blockchain is trying to secure every transaction using the entire network! That is why so much electricity is wasted just to do 7 transactions per second.
The next generation of crypto will actually be able to power payments using embarrasingly parallel architecture. Until then, we have blockchain.
Ethereum is nicknamed the “world computer” for a reason. Gas fees are super high for small transactions like paying for coffee or voting in a secure election. Just one app KryptoKitties can clog up the entire network.
We built Intercoin apps on top of Ethereum (https://intercoin.org/applications https://intercoin.org/applications) but we are not going to wait around for Ethereum 2.0 - which is blockchain also. Kik Messenger and others have long gotten off.
- qqii 6y agoSharding is simply not ready, as far as I know no project currently with smart contracts have non a blockchain structure. That said currently ethereum has many L2 solutions (https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/layer-2-scaling/ https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/layer-2-scaling/) that "run in parallel" and result in low gas fees. So far I've not seen any hint of an "embarrasingly parallel architecture" that can satisfy the safety requirements that a blockchain also does and run smart contracts. I'd be happy to read up if you can point me to any research or projects that I've missed.
- EGreg 6y agoYou can start here: https://forum.intercoin.org/t/overview-and-implications-of-intercoin-consensus https://forum.intercoin.org/t/overview-and-implications-of-i... However, the actual technical research paper with rigorous mathematical proofs is still going through peer review, but if you email me I am happy to share it with you.
- MacsHeadroom 6y agoWhat do you think of David Chaum's xx? Each transaction only sent to end charged by a random pool of 5 nodes that reshuffles every 10 seconds. Throughput scales linearly with network size.
- EGreg 6y agoYes, it is a good step forward. Really, what you need is a distributed hash table (like MaidSAFE), or randomness beacons (like Algorand) to select a subset of the network. This paper shows mathematically that the probability of a double-spend goes down exponentially with the number of notaries, and having the entire network secure every transaction, no matter the size, is wayyyy overkill: https://arxiv.org/pdf/0802.0832v1.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/0802.0832v1.pdf
- pawelduda 6y agoI wonder what are your thoughts on Avalanche (https://www.avalabs.org https://www.avalabs.org). They claim to offer throughout of 4500 TPS and smart contracts with EVM compatibility. Make sure to check the whitepaper for the protocol consensus, it's supposedly a novel thing and there are a some knowledgeable people behind it.
- EGreg 6y agoWill definitely check it out! This space is really home to many interesting projects (including our own) to have alternative architectures. The trick is how to remain compatible with EVM since most of the developers targeted it.
- hanniabu 6y agoSo in other words you're shitting on Ethereum as a reason to shill your own coin since there'd be no reason for your coin unless you make people believe Ethereum is garbage? Ethereum is moving to proof of stake and there's also L2 networks. There, problem solved.
- EGreg 6y agoYeah, I am saying global blockchains are a first generation technology. Sorry it hurts your feelings. I would like to also “shill” MaidSAFE and Solana: http://maidsafe.net/ http://maidsafe.net/ https://solana.com/ https://solana.com/ If you don’t like ME saying it — here is VITALIK HIMSELF saying it, the guy is quite honest and straightforward about its limitations: https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2019/08/19/vitalik-buterin-ethereum-blockchain-almost-full-scalability/ https://thenextweb.com/hardfork/2019/08/19/vitalik-buterin-e... Vitalik Buterin: Using Ethereum is expensive, and its blockchain is ‘almost full’ He also said blockchain's 'problem' is that every computer verifies every transaction Actually Ethereum 2.0 should be “fast enough” for many applications. It’s still going to be doing a global consensus, but at least it will be able to handle actual real world usage - people paying for coffee, let’s say, or voting in elections. In fact, a major reason that so many ICOs from 2017 were considered scams is that the tokens could not actually be used for their intended purpose. Teams like Kik Messenger discovered this early on and moved away: https://medium.com/kinblog/kin-pushing-ahead-next-steps-on-the-migration-to-solana-aa412b5adb1d https://medium.com/kinblog/kin-pushing-ahead-next-steps-on-t...
- imtringued 6y agoBig question. Why would I want to pay capital gains taxes on my coffee?
- fidelramos 6y agoI don't think anybody wants to pay capital gains taxes when purchasing things with cryptocurrencies. Fortunately there are countries with a sane tax policy regarding cryptocurrencies where you don't pay taxes on cryptocurrencies, such as Portugal [0]. Maybe Americans should be pressuring their government for changes to the laws so cryptocurrencies can be useful for payments like they were originally intended? [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2019/09/19/portugal-tax-authorities-clarify-that-buying-or-selling-cryptocurrency-is-tax-free/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2019/09/19/por...
- seibelj 6y agoEven if there can be parallel computation a flash loan can still occur. The concept is borrowing a huge sum of money for a split second to take instant advantage of an opportunity. This can happen outside of a single threaded VM model.
- EGreg 6y agoWell, yes but only if all the smart contracts that are being called are on the same shard. Ideally under Ethereum 2.0 these assumptions will disappear. In fact Ethereum 2.0 should be “fast enough” for most applications.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoI don't think you understand why we use blockchains.
- EGreg 6y agoPlease explain. Perhaps I am missing something. The main reasons seem to be trustless security and immutability.
- Animats 6y agoThe next generation of crypto will actually be able to power payments using embarrasingly parallel architecture. Been hearing that for years. Anyone yet have anything running that allows a digital currency to scale without being vulnerable to the attacks Bitcoin can resist?
- EGreg 6y agoNot that I know of. From the mainstream ones, Ripple and Stellar come the closest. MaidSAFE has been in development since 2006 and is launching soon. What can I say, the first generation of any technology is laughably inadequate as a replacement for what came before. That is why for example hardlh anyone uses Bitcoin in everyday transactions and why we still don’t use technology to secure voting, but that will change. As an aside, I don’t think blockchain is the best technology for voting but it’s the buzzword that people understand: https://www.coindesk.com/in-defense-of-blockchain-voting https://www.coindesk.com/in-defense-of-blockchain-voting
- DSingularity 6y agoLiterally nobody thinks Blockchain is good for voting.
- EGreg 6y agoPerhaps that’s a bit too overstated? https://cointelegraph.com/news/russian-blockchain-voting-system-shows-up-on-github https://cointelegraph.com/news/russian-blockchain-voting-sys...
- literallycancer 6y agoIt's not good, on the other hand it can easily be better than the monstrous only-working-by-accident software some government contractors can come up with.
- Geee 6y agoNano is the only currency that is capable of hundreds of transactions in a second without fees, and runs in a trustless and decentralized mode (https://nano.org https://nano.org) For the time being, no one has found vulnerabilities in it.
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>The only reason flash loans even work with no collateral is because you can be sure nothing else is running on the “world computer” while your transaction runs, so you can roll it back with no risk except gas fees. The more important reason flash loans work on Ethereum is that Ethereum runs programmatic contracts that can take the output of a function call from a different contract as their input. This is something that doesn't exist outside of the world of smart/programmatic contracts. The blockchain just provides the immutable ordering of transactions and credible neutrality of access-control needed for the state of programmatic contracts to accrue value.
- Vinceo 6y agoCheck out avax (avalanche) for your dapp. It actually scales in a decentralized manner unlike most of the other "ethereum killers".
- literallycancer 6y agoSharding is a dead end. Zero knowledge rollups solve most of the scalability problems without compromising security.