6 ms·
Many scientists citing two scandalous Covid-19 papers ignore their retractions
- jansan 6y agoSo why is not every paper that cites a retracted paper automatically flagged? THe peer reviewing process seems to have a lot of room for improvement.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 6y agoCiting a paper doesn't imply you think it's either good or bad. You have to read the text to understand what the authors say about it.
- yawnxyz 6y agoeditors and peer reviewers really need to do a better job flagging citations of retracted papers...
- chrisseaton 6y agoAgain, the issue is not the citation... it's what the citation is used to do. If an historian cites Mein Kampf it's not because they're agreeing with it, is it?
- jjk166 6y agoIf a historian cites Mein Kampf, they're using it as a primary source - they might not agree with the opinions expressed within but they do believe Hitler expressed those opinions. If a historian cited a work that turned out to be a forgery, and did not acknowledge in their paper that it was a forgery, then their paper would certainly be suspect. True citing a retracted paper is not automatically 100% unacceptable, but it is something that should automatically demand further scrutiny.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> If a historian cites Mein Kampf, they're using it as a primary source - they might not agree with the opinions expressed within but they do believe Hitler expressed those opinions. Yes... same as a scientist uses citations. Citing someone doesn't mean 'I fully believe and support this person', it means 'I'm referring to what this person said' and they believe that's what the paper said. That's all. The text using the citation adds the context of what the author thinks.
- jjk166 6y agoYou've completely missed what I was saying. A historian doesn't cite Mein Kampf to give context to what they're saying, the historian uses Mein Kampf as data. For a historian, Mein Kampf is perfectly valid data. On the other hand, Mein Kampf 2: Meiner Kampfer is not valid data, and any paper citing it as if it were should be immediately considered suspect. A scientist citing a retracted paper is like a historian citing a forgery: fine if it's a harmless aside, catastrophic if their claims hinge upon its reliability.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> the historian uses Mein Kampf as data So... the same way that a scientist could cite a retracted paper. To say that these people said this thing and then it was retracted. To discuss the context of that retraction and what it means, and so on.
- jansan 6y agoMein Kapmpf is not a scientific paper that can be retracted. Or have I messed some recent developments?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Mein Kapmpf is not a scientific paper that can be retracted. I didn't say it was. > Or have I messed some recent developments? Why are you being sarcastic?
- jansan 6y ago>Why are you being sarcastic? It's my nature.
- ta988 6y agoflagging doesnt mean forbidding, just a warning to make sure everybody is aware.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoBecause the way papers are reviewed is highly manual and relies on individual reviewers who are acting as volunteers and don’t work full time doing review work. This makes it very difficult to implement systematic checks of the sort that would catch minor pieces of retracted work that aren’t central to this paper’s results. To fix this systematically you’d either need automated systems or human-executed “checkbox processes” with training. Of course you could implement those systems, but they’d be costly either in terms of further centralizing the peer review process behind companies like Elsevier or taking critical human time away from reviewing the actual results. And the benefits if you implemented these review systems might be highly limited, plus you’d probably run into a host of additional problems. On the “highly limited” side, many papers have a related work section that doesn’t list primary results that are relevant to the paper’s findings, but instead mainly serves as a reference guide. You might be writing a paper on (here I’m making up silly analogies) LED light bulbs, and you’d have a set of references that begins with “a line of work looks at incandescent light bulbs”. An accidental citation to a retracted work there is sloppy, but mostly scientifically irrelevant when no result in the paper actually refers to anything in those citations (which is why these citations slip by manual reviewers, who focus their valuable review time on citations that affect the scientific results in the paper.) You also have the more annoying problem that citation formats aren’t standardized, so it’s easy for a retracted paper to be cited in a format that an automated review system will miss. Google Scholar throws all the might of Google’s systems at this, and still treats the preprint version and conference version of my papers as different works. (This might be the right treatment or it might be the wrong one, but it’s murder on retraction scanners if the author cites the preprint.) Plus then there’s the additional burden of dealing with unimportant retractions that are issued after a paper that cites them has been published, which should be addressed but largely just cause annoying work for scientists and publishers and (as the article notes) are aggravating because it’s difficult for readers to distinguish a minor correction regarding an unimportant reference from a major one that affects the findings of the work.
- jansan 6y agoScience needs a standardized and open reviewing and publishing process. The current reviewing process may have been alright in the 80s, not so anymore. Bill Gates, are you litening? This is a chance to revolutionize science!!!
- sndean 6y ago>> A lead author of the paper, biomathematician Maik Pietzner at the University of Cambridge, said that although the paper was submitted after the retractions occurred, it was written beforehand, and “the current pandemic requires immediate response.” However, the paper was published 4 months after its submission. Particularly during the pandemic, the peer review / publishing process has become so slow in some cases that it's easily understandable to have not removed a citation, or to have had a year go by before publication. 1) I can't think of too many times that I've gone back to the source to read a paper. I download the PDF and never go back the website. How would I know about the retraction? 2) Changes to the text can require another round of review (possibly adds two months?). 3) Authors are generally against issuing corrections post-publication since the box that's added to the top of the paper looks similar to a retraction [0]. 4) Authors are busy or lazy. >> Given that no editor or reviewer caught the problem, she said, “I plan to discuss with the staff incorporating such screening into manuscript processing.” Shouldn't it be the responsibility of the publisher to add a notification to papers that cited a retracted paper? ("Be wary of things relating to ref #32.") We pay Nature Communications (cited in the article) ~$5000 to publish [1]... this should already be done for you. [0] e.g., this PNAS paper: https://www.pnas.org/content/116/32/15877 https://www.pnas.org/content/116/32/15877. Why not make the retraction notification a bright red box? [1] https://www.nature.com/ncomms/about/article-processing-charges https://www.nature.com/ncomms/about/article-processing-charg...
- ta988 6y agoZotero, a Free citation manager will tell you when a paper is retracted. it will also tell you (with a plugin this time) if it is discussed on pubpeer.
- netizen-9748 6y agothat's a feature I was unaware of. I used EndNote for a while but I don't know if they also offer this service. Is Zotero the only one that does this? That's an insanely helpful feature for research
- 6y ago
- samizdis 6y agoHere is a list of retracted Covid-19 papers, as collated by Retraction Watch: https://retractionwatch.com/retracted-coronavirus-covid-19-papers/ https://retractionwatch.com/retracted-coronavirus-covid-19-p...
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIt would be nice if retraction watch publicly messaged those who cite retracted papers and publicly logged their responses.
- danappelxx 6y agoThis is gold “Worst paper of 2020?” https://scienceintegritydigest.com/2020/07/23/worst-paper-of-2020-5g-and-coronavirus-induction/ https://scienceintegritydigest.com/2020/07/23/worst-paper-of...
- andrewflnr 6y agoWow, the comments under that are wild. Is is just me or is the fraction of crazy people in that thread pretty high?
- mhkool 6y agoThe biggest scandal so far: a retraction paper for the SARS-CoV-19 PCR test was submitted in November 2020 but ignored so far. The retraction paper is here: https://cormandrostenreview.com/report/ https://cormandrostenreview.com/report/
- bigcorp-slave 6y agoThis appears to be a totally unrelated set of authors attempting to force a journal to retract someone else’s paper. They literally have a dedicated website to promote this retraction and if you look up the authors, some of them headline their Twitter with it. The first author just today posted on Twitter that mRNA vaccines can alter your DNA. The intent of the retraction seems to be to suggest that the epidemic is overblown, to which I would respond by pointing to the the two million dead people, and the excellent correlation of positive test results with new dead people.
- briandear 6y agoIs the retracted paper correct? That’s the only question that matters. And perhaps those scientists have developed their views by actually looking at the science? Is that possible? Don’t shoot the messenger.
- morsch 6y agoThere is no retracted paper. Like the GP correctly points out, this is a website designed to pressure another group to retract their paper. The authors of said paper have not retracted it, although there were minor addendums (none of them in response to the website, I hasten to add). The paper in question -- Detection of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) by real-time RT-PCR[1][2] --, was the first paper (as far as I know, one of the first, certainly) outlining a protocol for a PCR test protocol for Sars-CoV-2, back in January 2020. In other words, these were among the first people who documented a way to detect whether a sample represented Sars-CoV-2. The authors have previously published about other coronaviruses like Sars-CoV-1 and MERS, e.g. [3] appears at first glance to be a well received paper. Here's [4] their paper on the detection of Sars-CoV-1 (or, back then, just Sars-CoV) via PCR. [1] https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.3.2000045 https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.E... [2] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=14452026284756058061&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=en https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=1445202628475605806... [3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0065352718300010 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S006535271... [4] https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/ese.17.39.20285-en/ https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/ese.17.39.2...
- AntiImperialist 6y agoAnyone who believes vaccinations don't potentially cause autoimmune disorders, which includes some autism spectrum disorders, is a retard. If you know how vaccinations work, why the f would vaccinations not cause autoimmune disorders in a significant number of people? Pharmaceuticals use their financial powers to constantly go after researchers who pursue studies that show these links.
- de6u99er 6y agoA couple of years ago I had an idea how to solve this issue. IMO blocchain technology could be actually a solution for such a problem, where one publications cryptographic hash consists of the content of the publication and the cryptographic hashes of it's citations. If a citation get's invalidated for whatever reason, papers citing it would automatically get invalidated too, and so on. Until someone fixes or removes the faulty citation and revalidates their part of the chain, and so forth. Just imagine authors having puplic wallets proving their authorship. If someone wants to pick up this idea, I'd be happy with 10% of the earnings that can be made with it.
- runsWphotons 6y agoI guess everyone is down on blockchain ideas but this seems cool.
- rurban 6y agoEasy to explain: politics. Amongst scientists everybody ignored those political papers, just as the many political models with doomsday predictions (also Lancet). They understand the need for politicians to be inaccurate and unscientific. Within the covid-19 community most flaws in preprint papers were immediately pointed out, but you could not blog about without loosing your job (Trump), but nevertheless news magazines still published the worst nonsense.