18 ms·
Turning off the internet isn't impossible per-se, it's just very difficult without disastrous effects on the local economy. I don't know how developed Uganda is
by Nextgrid 6y ago
Turning off the internet isn't impossible per-se, it's just very difficult without disastrous effects on the local economy. I don't know how developed Uganda is, but I can tell you for sure that if the internet is blocked in the US or any major European country, everything stops, including real-life things such as card payments and even airport timetable signs (interesting fact: most of the UK ones run a Chrome instance displaying a webpage hosted by a Romanian company). Even if access to national services is unaffected, those services themselves depend on various SaaSes that would be affected by the international blocking.
- iso1631 6y ago> it's just very difficult It's really really simple, as shown by Uganda, Egypt, Pakistan, Turkey, India and many more countries.
- aaomidi 6y agoIran, last year. Internet was out for like two weeks.
- Nextgrid 6y agoMy intent was to say it's difficult without incurring major side-effects to the economy. I've updated my comment to clarify. Of course, if you don't have a significant economy to begin with or something else has already disrupted it (riots, uprising, etc - which could also be what prompts you to shut down the internet) then it's not a problem.
- freeone3000 6y agoOr you simply value control over money. The economy is not the primary goal of everyone, not even all governments.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoYou need some degree of economy to have control though.
- iso1631 6y agoBut evidence shows countries turning the internet off all the time, let alone specific filtering, and their economies haven't collapsed. India does it dozens of times a year. In most cases you don't need to completely turn everything off, just shut down the mobile networks, and maybe the big domestic broadband networks, and that's good enough.
- megous 6y agoTurn off internet or block social networks?
- celim307 6y agoNorth Korea says sup
- imtringued 6y agoIf your country has natural resources it is very easy to heavily control that part of the economy and suppress the less controllable parts of the economy (by shutting the internet down for example).
- Izkata 6y agoDidn't Egypt end up with citizen-run satellite or mesh networks that crossed borders? I vaguely remember people from other countries organizing on Twitter to provide it somehow.
- londons_explore 6y agoPeople always talk about networks like that. But the reality is they tend to only be a few thousand people max, while millions are still left unconnected. They're good for exfiltrating news.
- xxpor 6y agoIt's simple if you setup your infra in such a way you expect to be able to turn it off. It'd be a lot harder in the US where things are a lot more decentralized. In Uganda, I wouldn't be shocked if all connectivity to outside of the country went through one physical building.
- iso1631 6y agoMaybe the US, which is a very large country, but issue an order to the major ISPs (cellular and cable) to stop carrying domestic network traffic and you accomplish pretty much the same thing. Sure there may be some WISPs in the middle of nowhere which aren't affected, but you've accomplished most of your goal. There's two ways for internet to be shut down. One is legal -- the government tells registered ISPs "stop forwarding packets". Doesn't matter how good your connectivity is when you simply have to turn it off. Your protection there are courts etc, but it's not technically difficult. The other approach is extra-legal -- e.g a terrorist attack. Just look at the effect from a car bomb in Nashville last month, I quote from a newspaper: > The immediate repercussions were surprisingly widespread. AT&T customers lost service — phones, internet or video — across large parts of Tennessee, Kentucky and Alabama. There were 911 centers in the region that couldn't take calls; others didn't receive crucial data associated with callers such as their locations. The Nashville police department's phones and internet failed. Stores went cash-only. > At some hospitals, electronic medical records, internet service or phones stopped working. The Nashville airport halted flights for about three hours on Christmas. Rival carrier T-Mobile also had service issues as far away as Atlanta, 250 miles away, because the company uses AT&T equipment for moving customer data from towers to the T-Mobile network. The area effected was about 100,000 square miles, roughly the same size as Uganda. From one carbomb outside one building. I think there's only one major Internet Exchange point in Uganda (just like it seems there was one in the south east of the US), but there's certainly multiple fibres in and out. If you're in Mbarara and sending traffic to Rwanda it's unlikely to go via Kampala. Here's a network map of one provider in Uganda: https://bcs-ea.com/service/uganda/ https://bcs-ea.com/service/uganda/ The UK has a few exchanges, but almost everything runs through Docklands in London - various Telehouse buildings within a mile of each other, Telecity etc. Almost all internet traffic in the UK runs through London, and the sites that aren't are owned by Linx (IXLeeds is the only one that isn't). A major flood breaching the Thames Barrier will cause chaos.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y agoI hope we never find out what happens if the US internet goes down. But with 2020's track record and what 2021 is starting to look like, we might find out!
- ckdarby 6y agoNot trying to talk about existing politics. Outside of a rogue president that convinces the military to act in illegal activity or a true government overthrow it won't happen. No running or existing government in the USA will pull the plug because they know that would end their career. All their fundraising gone. Wall Street RIP. Riots all over the place.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agohttps://thekashmirwalla.com/2020/12/high-speed-internet-ban-in-kashmir-500-days-and-counting/ https://thekashmirwalla.com/2020/12/high-speed-internet-ban-... here 500 days and counting of no high speed mobile internet for 8 million + souls. thats worlds biggest democracy for you /s honestly i have seen how life crashes without internet, its not fun
- selimthegrim 6y agoHow many online businesses got shuttered that you know of?
- iso1631 6y agoHere in a G7 country there have been many offline business shuttered this year. Life goes on.
- selimthegrim 6y agoMy point was people in India love to sneer at Kashmiri supposed backwardness but kneecapping their ability to do business online is not going to win them plaudits.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoIts not just business online. 8 million people includes millions of school children who have not gone to school since 5 August 2019. Then since March the corona happened and they had to stay back again. 1.5 years of no formal education but with a twist. While the world across everyone was on zoom, here in the valley the kids had to suffer because "buffering", no video, only either audio on zoom calls or the teacher snaps photos of Notes and forwards on WhatsApp, students copy that photo and work done. Same for audio messages on WhatsApp. Point is, we dont know when schools will open but students are being prevented from getting some semblance of an education. I have a 4 Yo kid in the extended family and he's been in school for 8 days only. Hits out at anyone who mentions school.
- 6y ago
- ny2ko 6y agoUgandan here. I spoke with my family in Kampala yesterday (cell phone calls still work) and whilst some things like atms not working are an issue, for the most part things are working, especially since there is a large use of mobile money for payments