3 ms·
A problem here is that heat is very easy to store. So if one can make heat from intermittent power (say, resistively, or with some kind of heat pump) then stor
by pfdietz 6y ago
A problem here is that heat is very easy to store. So if one can make heat from intermittent power (say, resistively, or with some kind of heat pump) then storage becomes much less of an issue than if one wanted to store the electrical energy itself.
In any environment where renewable power is being curtailed, the cost of using that power to make heat will be very low. Nuclear heat will be competing against a very low cost alternative.
- Pfhreak 6y agoIs that true at extremely high temperatures? I would think that high temperatures are harder to store.
- pfdietz 6y agoFirebrick or silicon carbide. The latter could store heat up to 1800 C, and act as its own resistive heater. Firebrick is century old technology, used for regenerative heating of air in steel making (outgoing gas heated firebrick, then air was drawn through that on the next pass, with two banks of firebrick being used in alternation).
- LinuxBender 6y agoI learned something new today. I was going to use kiln-fired bricks for a rocket mass heater, but I had never heard of silicon carbide bricks. They cost a lot more $10 vs $3 but for a small project, those are perfect. Thankyou!
- crote 6y agoA problem is that insulators work better with a lower temperature gradient, so hotter storage will lose more energy per second.
- pfdietz 6y agoThe studies I have seen show minor energy loss (a few percent a day) although this is a function of scale.
- bassman9000 6y agoI don't know if you can store that much heat (hundreds of °C), for that long, and with no price fluctuation due to variability of an external heating supply. One of these SMR hooked to your factory can provide it, at probably higher temps, enabling more processes, 24/7, and at a less variable cost, not having to rely on external supply.
- epistasis 6y agoAnd for rough napkin math on costs, electricity to heat via a heat pump generates 3x as much heat as electricity used to move the heat. Whereas the nuclear plant goes from 50% efficiency to 100% efficiently, only a 2x gain for using the nuclear reactor for heat rather than for electricity. So excluding the extra cost of the heat pump, and the cost savings of nuclear not needing a turbine and waste heat rejection system, renewables are starting out ahead. We would really need to see some real world systems to fully evaluate costs.
- pfdietz 6y agoIt's been proposed to use this sort of thermal store to store electrical energy, by converting the heat back to power using a thermal cycle. If a heat pump were used the efficiency might not be TOO bad. The per-energy cost of such a system could be an order of magnitude less than batteries. One interesting side of this is that it admits extremely cheap "assurance" storage. That is: if one has a fuel to heat the thermal store when needed, then this can provide an assured source of power in the event of very rare prolonged outages that deplete the usual store. The marginal capital cost of adding this capability could be a factor of 3 less than that of providing dedicated gas turbines (using hydrogen, say) for that assurance.
- epistasis 6y agoOk, that's really cool idea I had never considered before! Here's a review of "pumped thermal" energy storage: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2020.00160/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2020.0016... that postulates 50% efficiency for five day round-trip storage, and other people think they can hit 80% or so (about the same as pumped hydo). Thanks for the pointer!