6 ms·
Entrepreneur, the Magazine That Sues Entrepreneurs
- InfinityX0 15y agoEntrepreneur Magazine is the exact match domain of the magazine world. Because of the name entrepreneurs will always read it, but the content is rarely good enough to be worth buying or even shelf-reading.
- dpcan 15y agoI totally disagree about the content. I find it to be the absolute best small business / entrepreneur magazine out there. I prefer it over Inc and others by far. It opens your eyes beyond tech as it covers so much ground.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- stevenj 15y agoSingle page: http://www.businessweek.com/print/magazine/content/11_22/b4230078121476.htm http://www.businessweek.com/print/magazine/content/11_22/b42...
- Joakal 15y agoParagraph that sums the article: An attorney with the corporate law firm Latham & Watkins informed Castro that EMI owns the U.S. trademark for the word "entrepreneur." With 2,000 lawyers in 31 offices around the world, Latham polices EMI's intellectual property aggressively. The firm even instructed Castro to surrender his domain name to EMI. "If you fail to abide by these demands," the letter said, "Entrepreneur Media will have no choice but to take appropriate action to prevent continued use of an infringing mark and domain name." Looks like an app store issue! How can a business trademark a single English word that effectively describes the industry?
- superppl 15y agoI'm curious if it would stand up in court. Microsoft owns the trademark for "Windows", but walk into a hardware store and you'll see dozens of companies that freely use windows in their name. I've never heard of Microsoft going after them.
- bullseye 15y agoNo one is likely to confuse panes of glass with an operating system. If those same hardware companies started selling branded software, or probably even computer hardware for that matter, it would likely be a different story.
- gaius 15y agoLegend has it that DEC and Hoover periodically sued each other over the trademark for VAX.
- Joakal 15y agoTrademarks are granted for certain products and services. In Microsoft's case, it's computer services or something. If you try to offer an operating system with a name that has Windows in it, then you would be sued. Here's an example: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Microsoft_vs._Lindows https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Microsoft_vs....
- 6ren 15y agoYou're right in general, but that example doesn't support it: MS didn't win, but bought the trademark. For $20 million.
- Joakal 15y agoHere's a list of other trademark litigation cases: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Microsoft_litigation#Trademarks https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Microsoft_lit...
- lukejduncan 15y agoWow
- lukejduncan 15y agoDo any HN'ers actually read Entrepreneur magazine?
- armandososa 15y agoI used to. Like another comment says, because of the name many aspiring entrepreneurs read it. The thing is, when you don't know what you don't know it takes a while to recognize good advice from piles of obvious bullshit like this magazine articles.
- HeyLaughingBoy 15y agoI used to subscribe. It's not bad: gives a nice overview of different businesses each month. But I let the sub. lapse after two years because it wasn't worth it. However, I did go to one of their (free) conferences and it was pretty good.
- dotBen 15y agoHere's a sideways look at this: If you have a trademark you are legally required and compelled to go after anyone who is infringing on it. Otherwise it is deemed that you have let it lapse into the public domain. enter debate on trademarks, patents, blah blah etc... My point is that clearly EMI should not have been awarded a trademark on the term "entrepreneur" in the first place. However, once that trademark was granted, there was no other option but for them to start aggressively guarding it. (and to a lesser extent EMI, if they had any decency, shouldn't have attempted to trademark it). Don't hate the player, hate the game, etc
- Joakal 15y agoBoth are guilty of this. EMI wasn't under duress to trademark it.
- dotBen 15y agoUnless someone else was threatening to trademark it instead. I have personal experience of someone having to trademark something simply because if they didn't the other party was going to and then they'd have no choice but to lose all rights to it. Like I said enter discussion about the brokenness of patents, trademarks, etc
- esmevane 15y agoThat's kind of a can of worms. On one hand, you probably wouldn't be noticed for not suing people for the name. No one would really have the opportunity to appreciate your benign decision to not engage an exclusivity to your trademark. On the other hand, if you were so benign, then one day another magazine comes along, called "New Entrepreneur", and you try to defend yourself - only to find your case thrown out when they can prove you routinely don't defend your trademark. But then again, doesn't that lead to another point? You can defend that you don't seek to have the trademark ubiquitously across industries, just in the magazine and publication industry. Or is trademark law so sweeping that a business is unable to have a trademark in only the practicing industry? (If so, Square & Square Enix come to mind as outliers from this example.)
- Confusion 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- yuhong 15y agoStardock was one of the victims that had a game called it.
- 6ren 15y ago> In the end, Ernst and EMI settled their differences confidentially and out of court. Pragmatic. Curious side-note: when it was first introduced into Victoria Australia, Hungry Jacks (Burger King in US) failed to trademark the term "whopper", because was a generic term. But, today, it's a registered trademark. Over time, advertising can create an association.
- sradnidge 15y agoI'm not sure what the author of the article is trying to prove... that trademark law can be (and is being) abused? At least he had the integrity to quote the EMI lawyer throwing examples back of Bloomberg engaging in similarly questionable legal action. As several people have already pointed out, there is Windows, there is Time. Oddly no-one has yet mentioned Face and Book.
- khafra 15y agoThere is a difference: Microsoft Windows has nothing to do with panes of glass in walls; Time Magazine is not about clocks or watches. You're not supposed to be able to trademark a pre-existing industry term within its own industry; Lowe's Hardware should not be able to register "plywood" as trademark for plywood and sue Home Depot.
- bearwithclaws 15y agoThey also own a magazined called "StartUps": http://www.entrepreneur.com/magazine/startup/index.html http://www.entrepreneur.com/magazine/startup/index.html Does that mean they will sue all the companies with the word "startups" in their domain name as well?
- amosson 15y agoShould 50 people be allowed to create magazines titled "Entrepreneur", regardless of whether the word is commonly used. If you are the first to think of something, shouldn't you have some limited right to protect whatever investment you are making in developing the idea. It is certainly fair to ask if someone else's magazine title is sufficiently similar as to be confusing, but that isn't a question for a judge and/or jury to adjudicate. As technologists, we may instinctively view most attempts to use the law to protect intellectual property as abusive, but at least there is a transparent, although expensive, way to solve conflicts. Think for a moment about how brands, like Entrepreneur Magazine, are built on the internet. The authors work very hard to develop interesting content and then try to get Google to rank the content. Unless you get very large, or spend a lot of money in traditional brand advertising, it is unlikely that anyone will find your content without Google's help. If someone comes along and steals your content, and puts it on a more "trusted" site it may well be seen by more people than the original (there have been plenty of Hacker News articles pointing this out). In this case, the only redress is to try to get Google to listen - certainly an uphill battle. Again, as technologists, we may feel that Google system is fairer because its an algorithm, but when a spammer abuses the system there is rarely any redress.
- troymc 15y agoWhen I hear EMI, I don't think of Entrepreneur magazine. I think of the EMI Group, the British music company. It seems this "EMI" has some other brand confusions to take care of. A quick search on uspto.gov reveals that there are several "EMI" trademarks.
- NHQ 15y agoquoth: EMI sees no irony, let alone bullying. In an e-mail, the company's lead attorney at Latham, Perry J. Viscounty... lol Perry J. Viscounty
- slindstr 15y agoGiven this article, I'm kind of surprised that they are using @EntMagazine for their Twitter handle. Why not sue @entrepreneur into submission too?