If it was giving to charity, and not telling people they are worthless, it might be a good novelty in this world where gift giving has become a meaningless wast

If it was giving to charity, and not telling people they are worthless, it might be a good novelty in this world where gift giving has become a meaningless waste of money. “I’m giving you nothing, but some less fortunate kid got school books!” As it stands it just comes across as being mean/nasty.