9 ms·
One thing wasn't highlighted in the alleged suicide note was the line 'we must secure the existence of our people and a future for our children'. That language
by rchaud 6y ago
One thing wasn't highlighted in the alleged suicide note was the line 'we must secure the existence of our people and a future for our children'.
That language should be a pretty clear indicator of where this person's politics lie, even without the 'fall of western civilization' rhetoric earlier. They always seem to use the same exact verbiage.
- LatteLazy 6y agoFor those who don't know this reference... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words
- ASalazarMX 6y agoIt's disgusting how such primitive people can still exist in our modern world. Yes, we have many people doing horrible things all over the world, but people being vile because their ancestors had less sun than others is a special kind of pointless stupidity.
- mothsonasloth 6y ago>It's disgusting how such primitive people can still exist in our modern world. What a snobbish and elitist thing to say. Try saying that to the Sentinelese or Amazonian tribes that still don't have contact with our messed up globalist world. One of the reasons we are living in this chaotic time is because of a growing middle class elite living in metropolitan areas who are either unwilling or incapable of understanding people outside of their bubbles.
- llamaz 6y agothere's a few gradations of difference between Trump voters and neo-Nazis... parent is talking about the latter
- x1ph0z 6y agowell when some people are resorting to white supremacy, of course it's a big social gap that reasonable people don't want to understand.
- exclusiv 6y agoI don't think the parent meant any disparagement to actual primitive tribes. Why did you assume that?
- jariel 6y ago"I don't think the parent meant any disparagement to actual primitive tribes. Why did you assume that?" Because all of these statements of ethnicity have to be contextualized. You can't just say 'Well White this, Black that' - other than in a very American context. I live in Quebec and they are essentially the only classical, coherent 'ethnic group' (i.e. language, governance) in North America aside from Aboriginals - and due to the fact they are surrounded by the 'Angloshphere' there is a very legit concern about the erosion of their culture. New migrants basically don't want to learn French, and more and more English language 'everything' encroaches on the culture. Now - some Pro-Quebec sentiment is really ridiculous, racist, over the top and frankly dumb (they want to ban 'Staples' from being called 'Staples' because it's English) but there is an underlying legitimacy. Unspoken in all of this is that Quebec culture is defacto European and essentially (though not technically) White. Also of interesting note that intellectually it's super-secular (they don't like their Catholic past) at the same time, culturally, kind of super Catholic. Point being: there are calls for the 'saving of our culture' basically daily. It's part of the program here and it's not overtly racist or radical. My MP (like Congressperson) is form 'Quebec Solidaire' and it's the very farthest Left group in North America it actually has roots in a former Communist part. (I didn't vote for them!) - but - they are equally Nationalist! They walk a tight intellectual line with justifying their Nationalism on a 'racially inclusive' basis, even though their ideology is at the same time very exclusive to outsiders, who happen to be Anglophones ... and people of colour. In the face of Globalism 'We Are All Aboriginals' - which is to say every single culture save maybe Han Chinese is under the threat of being 'globalized' in a kind of Anglo-American hot-mess of commercialism. So yes, it's not the same thing for some French guy to be saying such things as it is for someone from the disappearing Tribes of the Amazon, but this isn't the 20th century anymore, the fault lines are changing quickly and context is really important.
- exclusiv 6y ago
- ASalazarMX 6y agoMaybe it will sound less snobbish (although more self-serving I fear) if I tell you I'm Mexican? Mexico is a mixed race country, you will find people of all colors here, the concept of race is so weak common people are barely aware of it. There are racists who see whiter people as more beautiful, or darker (specially indigenous) people as lesser, but hate is extremely rare and frowned upon. It's the hate part that I can't wrap my head around. Xenophobic tribes maybe hate visitors for their race, but they also could reject them for their effect in neighboring tribes, we don't know. TL;DR: I can understand if people find Scottish people attractive, or Mexican people ugly, but I am indeed guilty of not understanding how people can actually grow hate from that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lamename 6y agoIt's a reminder of how ancient our brains really are, despite our advancement of the average state of society as a whole.
- nostromo 6y agoI present to you the words of Kristen Clarke, Biden’s future head of the DoJ’s Civil Rights division: “Melanin endows blacks with greater mental, physical, and spiritual abilities — something which cannot be measured by Eurocentric standards.” This is just one quote from her letter, which goes on at length about black superiority. I think the problem we have right now is we have two sets of standards. People that have been reintroducing racist concepts into government, academia and the media shouldn’t be surprised when there is a similarly racist backlash. https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1994/11/4/clarke-should-retract-statements-pbtbwo-years/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1994/11/4/clarke-should-r...
- hwillis 6y ago> The book, she said, “was generating wide acclaim for its racist views” and her intention in opening the letter “with an absurd claim that Black people are superior based on the melanin in their skin” was to “hold up a mirror to reflect how reprehensible the premise of black inferiority was set.” > “It was meant to express an equally absurd point of view — fighting one ridiculous absurd racist theory with another ridiculous absurd theory,” Clarke explained, “and the goal was all about [exposing] the ugly racist underpinnings of the Bell Curve theory. It was deeply personal and profoundly important to Black students and other students of color who felt that their right to be on campus was challenged. And frankly, the fight that we were leading as students is a fight that I am still very much a part of today.” https://forward.com/news/national/462089/bidens-deputy-ag-pick-touts-record-on-antisemitism-amid-criticism-of/ https://forward.com/news/national/462089/bidens-deputy-ag-pi... The full letter certainly seems consistent with that: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1994/10/28/blacks-seek-an-end-to-abuse/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1994/10/28/blacks-seek-an...
- nostromo 6y agoSo she sets the record straight over 20 years later, only after being appointed by Biden, that she was only pretending to be racist. Yeah... sure... Would you accept this statement from a white supremacist? Again, we need consistent rules against racism. Otherwise you're opening the door to racists and extremists on both sides.
- jancsika 6y ago> It's disgusting how such primitive people can still exist in our modern world. Disgusted sure, I am with you on that. But "can still exist?" With the number of stories just on HN about social media dark patterns and recommendation engine rabbit-holes? It's difficult to understand that as anything other than puffery.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoI expect some people will do horrible things for personal gain, we all are egoists to a degree after all. What I have a hard time digesting is the irrationality of racism: why not pursue material instead of imaginary gain? Racism is more crazy religion than ideology.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIf people can't (won't) compete by being smarter, working harder, taking long term views, innovating, up skilling etc, they fall back on "but I'm white". That's all this really is. The economy has moved forwards. People either moved to cities and upskilled (hence the hate for a mysterious metropolitan "elite") or they sat in rust belt towns complaining their disability cheque is late again and worrying someone poorer than them might get the money instead. That's Trumps whole platform really. That's where the racism fits in. That is all the bs about draining swamps and elites. That's "make America great again". That's rolling back climate change rules (even the tiny ones the US actually has). Bolt on anti-abortion single issue voters and tax cuts for trillionaires to keep the senate on side. This whole thing is what happens when you have 25 years of social and economic progress and people get left behind and refuse to make any effort to catch up...
- TheTacoMerchant 6y agoIs it not possible for people to remain in small communities and not be seen by you as "refusing to make any effort to catch up"? I'm not American, so if I can offer ab outise perspective it's this: Trumps base was/is made up of majority poor white rural Americans, with a coalition of racists and extremists bolted on. What's crucial in that is the majority are just poor white townspeople. They lost their jobs because overseas laborers are willing to do the same work for less; because consumers don't care if the latest iPhone is made in Cali or in some Chinese interment camp. Same thing for coal and oil jobs. The world changed and these are the people who lost their livelihoods for it. I've been watching American politics my whole life, and Trump was the first politician I saw to truly acknowledge that there is a large portion of the population that are suffering economically for things out of their control and told them it wasn't their fault.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSome People can stay local and retrain and do something, good luck to them! Leaving aside fault for the moment... The jobs are gone. So we have a few options: * people can do what I said, retrain, maybe move, do something else * people can do nothing and get benefits to sit there doing nothing. I don't think there is a third option, but let me know if I'm missing something? The issue is, 80% of people refuse to the first one. They sit in rust belt towns and die deaths of despair. So what do we do? Trumps solution, which they have chosen, is nothing. We do nothing. No healthcare for them, no improved benefits, no retraining. Since they chose that, I could live with it. But I don't want to be tied to them and live with the rest of the shitty things trump wants to do. I'm more than happy to hear a solution here. I've tried not to blame anyone. I honestly believe that it wasn't their fault the coal mine (etc) closed. I just don't see an option beyond waiting for them to die before we can progress economically or socially. And that's not really acceptable to me. I'm gay, and I don't think I should be forced to be a second class citizen just because other people are bitter about their life and voted for a Fuck Everyone candidate. I'm sure there are women who will want reproductive health rights that feel the same way. I'm sympathetic, I came from just suck a place. But there does come a point where I feel like saying "you're not dragging me down with you". Full disclosure: I'm actually a brit. But we have the exact same thing happening here. Only its Boris Johnson and Brexit (which will last much longer than trumpism). I hope you can understand where I'm coming from.
- guerrilla 6y ago> They always seem to use the same exact verbiage. There's a reason for that [1] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourteen_Words
- three_seagrass 6y agoWell, it's not far off from some of the speeches at the insurrection last week either: https://twitter.com/always_margot/status/1346578062700400647 https://twitter.com/always_margot/status/1346578062700400647
- anigbrowl 6y agoAlso, the bit about 'the industrial revolution and its consequences that have been a disaster for the human race' slightly paraphrases the opening of Ted Kaczynski's manifesto Industrial Society and its Future, which is quite popular with accelerationists and eco-fascists due to his relative success as the 'Unabomber'.
- api 6y agoI recall thinking of the Unabomber manifesto when I first started seeing the alt-right emerge in a big way in the early 20-teens. The alt-right and adjacent movements sort of do belong under the umbrella of neo-primitivism. There are a lot of ideological parallels and deep similarities in the emotional appeals. It takes me back to when I read the Unabomber manifesto online as a teenager when it was first printed. I largely rejected it, but there was this part of me that resonated with the emotional appeal to a simple world with simple ideals and a connection to nature. I knew enough to realize that this was a fantasy, but it's an appealing fantasy that also finds expression in the popularity of comic books, pseudo-medieval fantasy epics, and other forms of escapist fiction. I think what it boils down to is that we are not neurologically wired for abundance, huge scale societies, or the types of labor that pay the best in the modern world. We're not built to sit in front of screens and solve puzzles all day, and without something to struggle against parts of our emotional nature seem to go haywire. I've speculated that the immense paranoia and prevalence of all kinds of neuroses might be an emotional analogue to the hygiene hypothesis for allergies. Without real traumas and existential struggles, our emotional system starts attaching the coping mechanisms that exists for these things to other more mundane aspects of existence like politics and relationships.
- chillacy 6y agoI read it too after reading Kevin Kelly's analysis in What Technology Wants. I recall it was very meandering, not particularly well supported, and from what I understand, not very novel either. In retrospect, if Ted Kaczynski thought that he could start a movement with that much wandering text, there wasn't much hope for anything super cogent.
- naoske3 6y ago>That language should be a pretty clear indicator of where this person's politics lie Where? Do white people and their children don't deserve a future? Think wisely, because the answer will expose why some people believe this so called "conspiracy theory" of white replacement.
- capableweb 6y agoI'm not sure if you were the one butchering the quote, the author butchered it or if the author wrote it wrong on purpose. Laid out like in your comment, there isn't anything wrong with the line. "our" could refer to humanity. For reference, the famous quote that is VERY similar is "We must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children". Notice the missing "white" from rchauds quote. Again, not sure if on purpose, or who butchered it, but it might not mean what you think it does.
- freeone3000 6y agoYou don't use wording like that on accident. Being one word off from a white supremacist quote in a message sent to white supremacists is incredibly unlikely to be accidental.
- capableweb 6y ago> You don't use wording like that on accident Stupidier things have happened in the past. I bet more than half of HN wouldn't know that quote if you removed the "white" part, so not so unlikely that someone who doesn't know it, sends it to others as the sentiment (without the "white" part) is actually pretty good.
- anigbrowl 6y agoUnknowingly reproducing (albeit imperfectly) a somewhat famous extremist catchphrase is of course a possibility, but the odds of doing it twice in a short document like this are too low to be plausible.
- adrianmonk 6y ago> more than half of HN wouldn't know that quote The donor here is not comparable to typical HN users. They've gone out of their way to make a large donation to known white supremacists. Also, if you read the donor's suicide note (in the article), there is a reference to the Weimar Republic and there is a holocaust denier code phrase. (I won't encourage its spread by copying it here, but it's in one of the highlighted sections.)
- jacquesm 6y agoIt's a variation on the theme 'purity of essence', satirized by Kubrick and originally promoted by a crappy painter from Austria.
- kls 6y agoThis is a well know white supremacist's phrase and originates from an organization that was known as The Order. It is called 14 words, if I where on the receiving end of a donation with that phrase I would be quick to distance myself from it and donate the proceeds to a worthwhile charity. While I know it is routine to paint the right and specifically the alt-right as all being racist white supremacist's the reality is they are a small minority that has banded onto the right given their conservative views on certain items. The right needs to do a better job of making it known that they are not welcome but things like this really don't help them in doing just that. I know the guy with the buffalo headdress has a Valknut tattoo prominently tattooed on his chest so I think it's pretty safe to assume he is a white supremacist's. So to me it looks like a small band of white supremacist's organized to incite the mob into action. People should really be aware of who they are throwing their lot in with.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]