29 ms·
So is Google going to throw them out of the Play store? What's the argument for banning one social media and not another. Where do you draw the line that manage
by mrweasel 6y ago
So is Google going to throw them out of the Play store? What's the argument for banning one social media and not another. Where do you draw the line that manages to keep Facebooks app available, while still being able to defend the removal of Parler.
I know many will think I'm defending Parler, I'm not. I just don't see why Facebook is continuously given a free pass for all the horrible stuff on their platform. Is it just because Facebook has other uses, because they're bigger or because an app store that doesn't have a Facebook app will experience a huge backlash from consumers?
- NDizzle 6y agoI'm going to need a few "Jump to conclusions" mats to manage all of the replies to this. Nuts. Propaganda sure does work.
- ForHackernews 6y agoFacebook is big, wealthy and mainstream. Parler was small, poor and fringe. Same reason tech firms are happy to "stand up" for democracy in small developing nations but won't say boo to China. If you're looking to big business for some consistent moral principle, you're looking in the wrong place.
- lr 6y agoFacebook, allegedly, has an "army" of moderators. Parler, on the other hand, relied on voluntary "flagging", and they admitted (quoted in some other article from today), that they had a backlog of some 26,000 posts to review. So, while this stuff looks arbitrary on the surface, I guess we will just have to see what comes out in discovery in these lawsuits and what happens with judge and jury.
- ctrlp 6y agoParler has allegedly had hundreds of paid moderators for months. They also allegedly cleared their backlog over the weekend in a foolish belief they could be on the right side of AWS politics.
- brewdad 6y agoIf Parler was so intent on staying on the right side of the law, maybe they should have cleared that backlog well before Jan 6th.
- ctrlp 6y agoYou said it yourself, Apple, Google, AWS are "the law" now.
- consumer451 6y agoSounds like a market solution, does it not? To be clear, what I mean is that they are demonstrably not "the law." This is a market problem and this was the market solution.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> What's the argument for banning one social media and not another Google’s argument would be Facebook has shown good-faith efforts to respond to the problem, e.g. by freezing Trump. Parler didn’t or couldn’t. (Counterfactual: they weren’t given much time.) In reality, a greater fraction of Parler’s users are engaging in criminal activity. By virtue of market share. (I reckon the number of problem users is higher at Facebook. Again by virtue of size.) And disconnecting hundreds of millions of voters from their kids’ photos is a good way to get slapped. Great arguments for breaking up Facebook.
- throwawayosiu1 6y agoDidn't they freeze Trump only after the entire backlash? and last I checked, Trump was not on Parler was he? Infact, that was the big issue - Trump not moving to Parler or Gab while calling out Twitter. It's funny because if he did do the move earlier, he'd have hurt twitter where it counts - their stock price. But I guess the attention on Twitter was just too much to ignore.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Didn't they freeze Trump only after the entire backlash? Yes. To be fair, Parler didn’t do much including after the backlash. But I’m not going to argue this is another advantage Facebook accrues due to its size.
- croes 6y agoHow much money has Parler?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> How much money has Parler? Parler probably pays Google and Apple more for ads than Facebook.
- croes 6y ago
- mimikatz 6y agoBecause people, not Hacker news people, but real people like Facebook. That's the reason.
- nhumrich 6y agoreal people like parlor.
- kgwgk 6y agothe wrong people /s
- DGAP 6y agoWell if white supremacists and fellow travelers are people, then yes, sure.
- IgorPartola 6y agoKnives can be used to kill people. But a lot more knives are used in cooking. So we see knives as tools that are relatively rarely used to do bad things and mostly used for good things. Guns are mostly used to kill people. So we see them as tools only useful for that purpose. That’s why you can buy a set of knives on Amazon but not a 10 pack of Glocks. Facebook is seen closer to knives. Parler was mostly guns.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoArguably true of handguns, not really true of guns in general.
- IgorPartola 6y agoYes I also chop my salads with RPGs and AK-47s :) #notallguns
- leetcrew 6y ago> Guns are mostly used to kill people. So we see them as tools only useful for that purpose. this isn't true. guns are used far more often for hunting animals than for killing humans, by multiple orders of magnitude. even more often, guns are used to shoot targets at the range.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoParler, unlike Facebook, only existed to foment the kinds of rhetoric and ideologies that lead to the 6th.
- rangoon626 6y agoHow do you reconcile the whole “if you don’t like Facebook moderation go build your own” bit.
- sandworm101 6y agoIf you build your own thing then it will be subject to the moderation of whatever service you build it upon. In this case, hosting services and app stores. If you don't like their moderation either, you are free to setup your own bare metal servers, even your own app store. And then there is Tor. If you really want to live outside of any moderation, outside of even basic laws, then setup a Tor hidden service. If you aren't going to put in some basic effort to protect yourself (ie what ThePirateBay does every day) and instead run strait to the courts, then I have little sympathy.
- rangoon626 6y agoMust have missed the part where Apple allows developers to set up their own app stores.
- sandworm101 6y agoApple doesn't block websites. If they cared to keep Apple users from being blocked they could have implemented a purely web-based option for accessing the service.
- rangoon626 6y agoThey don’t block websites yet. The browser makers will find a way to make it happen if they need to.
- shlant 6y agoI don't deny there is probably some favoritism going on, but is Facebooks willingness to moderate their content not at least part of the reason? Parler was completely hands off when it came to any sort of moderation of the content its users were posting (by design) which allowed for threats of violence to go unchecked and flourish within the platform. That seems like a pretty significant determinant when considering which site had a more direct connection to the events that transpired.
- leetcrew 6y ago> That seems like a pretty significant determinant when considering which site had a more direct connection to the events that transpired. does it really? "tries but fails to moderate extremism at massive scale" doesn't seem better than "makes no effort to moderate at much smaller scale". I guess the first leaves some potential for improvement in the future, but I don't expect a whole lot from facebook.
- andrewzah 6y agoIntent does matter. Why don't you try moderating posts at the scale facebook receives them, and we can compare the results. edit: I am not advocating for or against facebook being so large. What I am saying is there is a clear distinction between facebook and e.g. parler in terms of moderation.
- jimmydorry 6y agoAs we saw with Parler, your fledgling site can get deplatformed by the few key players in the cloud / app distribution / and service providers. "Just make it" is no longer as convincing a non-sequitor as it used to be.
- spaced-out 6y agoParler only has 30 employees, has some very well-publicized security and design flaws suggesting a lack of engineering talent, and is backed by just one private investor. The only way they were even able to release an app of that scale is because of all the services they bought from companies like Amazon. The lesson the business world should take from this is: invest in your engineers.
- ashtonkem 6y agoSize is important, obviously. But so is reputation. Parler spent whatever good name they had very quickly, and it turns out things become difficult very quickly the moment people stop giving you the benefit of the doubt. Facebook has better PR too.
- Spivak 6y agoSocial networks that reach a critical mass of regular people become too big to block. And social networks that exist as landing pads for people who aren’t tolerated on mainstream platforms naturally have targets on their backs. I really don’t think this is liberal vs conservative, left vs right. Mainstream social networks are full of conservatives. YouTube is basically Fox News mixed with Drudge Report once you start down that path. Even Reddit —- once you get past the post titles you realize that Reddit commenters are actually right leaning now. They look different than the stereotypical portrayal of gods and guns conservatives but the views are the same save a few social issues. Scott Alexander called them the “grey tribe” and I expect they’ll start being called the “new right” eventually. HN is basically entirely left-passing conservatives. But then there’s this tiny subgroup of legit insane people who with nothing better to do than get angry at the internet all day and push conspiracy theories. They keep getting passed around and banned from social networks while more mainstream right-wing talking heads use them as the poster children for their victim complex.
- cbozeman 6y agoI completely disagree with your post, but I'm utterly intrigued on how you got there. My experience of Reddit is that it is extremely left-wing. I would even go so far as to say rabidly so. YouTube seems more 'anti-woke' than 'right-leaning'. Those aren't the same, I don't think. Please go into more detail on why you feel this way, or if you have evidence to support your view. You could be right, because both YouTube and Reddit are vast websites, and I admittedly stick mostly to tech and tech-related areas of both, so I may not be seeing it.
- tester34 6y agobecause stuff like this in facebook's case is tinnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy percent meanwhile what % of parler's stuff all those "bad" things are?
- dcolkitt 6y agoThere's a lot of rationales you can give, but the real answer is that banning Facebook would cause Google to miss their quarterly earnings. Many people are willing to take a stand for their beliefs, many fewer are willing to nuke their RSUs.
- nip180 6y agoNuking your RSUs will also make an enemy of every other person in your company with RSUs. You might not be fired, but you’ll likely lose most of your social capital at the company.
- smolder 6y agoJust in case anyone is left wondering, RSU stands for restricted stock unit.
- sneak 6y agoWhat do you mean by "nuking"?
- syndacks 6y agodevaluing
- nip180 6y agoTaking an action that will directly result in a decrease in stock value.
- ForHackernews 6y ago
- bjt2n3904 6y ago> Where do you draw the line that manages to keep Facebooks app available, while still being able to defend the removal of Parler The phrase of 2020 was "too many". An arbitrary line. There are "too many" unarmed black men being killed. There are "too many" fake news stories being posted to Facebook. There are "too many", "too many", "too many". We have to do "something" -- and this is something. What asinine thing to say. First, does that mean there's an acceptable number of unarmed black men to be killed every year? But what this is trying to do is play yourself off as a moderate. "You know, I don't think we should be doing censorship... but there are just TOO MANY" No. You're an authoritarian playing to scared people who want the problem to stop, and don't care what it costs.
- dang 6y agoIdeological flamewar and personal attacks will get you banned here. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- commandlinefan 6y ago> why Facebook is continuously given a free pass Because there's good (or at least neutral) stuff mixed in with the bad stuff. The problem with every free-speech alternative to a heavily moderated forum is that it always ends up being 100% anger: there's never anything lighthearted to point to to defend it.
- ransom1538 6y ago"I know many will think I'm defending Parler, I'm not. I just don't see why Facebook is continuously given a free pass" This is how it always turns out: Orwellian 'At the end of Animal Farm, the pigs start to walk on their hind legs. This is significant because the animals have gone from saying "Four legs good, two legs bad" to the chant "Four legs good, two legs BETTER." Napoleon begins carrying a whip, and soon all the supervisor pigs are carrying whips. Napoleon also is seen with a pipe in his mouth. The pigs literally wear the clothes straight from Mr. Jones's closet'
- earthscienceman 6y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/books/orwell-1984-conservatives/2021/01/11/e80ce30e-5446-11eb-a931-5b162d0d033d_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/books/orwell-19... https://forward.com/culture/461861/no-the-trump-twitter-ban-isnt-orwellian-stop-saying-it-is/ https://forward.com/culture/461861/no-the-trump-twitter-ban-... https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/13/books/orwellian-1984.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/13/books/orwellian-1984.html
- waheoo 6y agoTwo paywalls and an article that describes people as seditious with zero context or point of reference. Do you have an actual point?
- cbozeman 6y agoThis is fucking fantastic... its truly Orwellian to gaslight people into thinking they're using "Orwellian" incorrectly. When what all these people really mean, but obviously can't say, is, "We didn't think we would become the Orwellian overlords!" Chomsky said it best, “Goebbels was in favor of free speech for views he liked. So was Stalin. If you’re really in favor of free speech, then you’re in favor of freedom of speech for precisely the views you despise. Otherwise, you’re not in favor of free speech.” Right now, there's an enormous liberal bias in Silicon Valley. The founders of these companies are more libertarian - some are even conservative, but their employees by-and-large are anywhere from left-leaning to far-left. That's fine. I don't see anything wrong with that. The resultant problem is with the helicopter parenting generation that produced these people, and their inability to accept things that make them uncomfortable. But... its okay, because like all complex systems, it trends toward equilibrium, and now you're starting to see the system self-correct.
- jacquesm 6y agoIt's mostly about 'principal use'. Parler's principal use seems to have been to give the extreme right a place to congregate. Facebook does not have that as principal use so it is more of a sideshow.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- onetimemanytime 6y ago>>I know many will think I'm defending Parler, I'm not. I just don't see why Facebook is continuously given a free pass for all the horrible stuff on their platform. Intent matters. Did FB purposefully tailored their site's pitch for such characters? Did they have enough mods to delete stuff or algos in place? I suppose in groups barely anyone would report posts as not appropriate.
- cbozeman 6y agoI thought Parler tailored their site's pitch for be for people who didn't want to be restricted on their speech? That's what it seemed like when I signed up for Parler. Many of my friends signed up. There was never hateful or violent rhetoric in their feeds, nor mine. You can be removed from these platforms at any time, with almost no appeal. That's a significant flaw, not a design feature. Like it or not, Facebook and Twitter are the public square for the Internet now. I don't personally like it; I hate it... but that's the way it is. Maybe that's the problem. Maybe its time for everyone to build their own website, host their own video and audio, etc.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoParler, as far as I know, was billed as a refuge for all those too radical for Twitter and FB. Not all the people of course. I agree with you on censorship and honestly there's no right way of doing this. What if someone in a certain position used Twitter to call for another gathering to "save our country" fight and show "our strength" and then we have dead senators and army boots in the ground? You can say we want no violence right after saying "fight like hell for the country" but... Maybe a timeout was the lesser of evils?
- tschellenbach 6y agoParler doesn't moderate their content. Facebook has the worlds most advanced content moderation systems and team. I mean you can dislike Facebook, but they clearly try to moderate their platform.
- mumblemumble 6y agoDefending Google's right to choose who to do business with - for (with certain notable exceptions involving protected classes of individuals) any purpose, no matter how petty, is not excusing Google for being capricious. It's recognizing that the norms of civil society mean that there are certain times when you need to just hold your nose and acknowledge that someone gets to do something you don't like, because the cure would be worse than the disease. If there's a problem here, it's that Google has grown to be so powerful. Nobody was ever concerned about Lifeway Christian Bookstores being extremely selective in whose products they would carry, for reasons that many would consider quite discriminator. Why? Because Lifeway has lots of competitors, and no effective way to compel people to only buy books from them.
- LatteLazy 6y agoHere are a couple: Facebook could have 100 times more violent content than parler, but it would be a much smaller percentage of content because Facebook is 1000000 times bigger. It's that simple really. Banning Parler is more efficient. Also, Parler went out and sold itself as somewhere this was allowed, protected and encouraged. Facebook didn't, quite the opposite in fact.
- zpeti 6y agoGoing down this path, consider that Facebook caused genocide, the active killing of a population. Parler caused 1 night of rioting. How is that for percentages of content being objectionable?
- LatteLazy 6y agoWell, neither "caused" those events per see, they were just places where people gathered and talked about doing them and riled each other up. That's one of my frustrations with this: these issues should be dealt with by police and governments and society as a whole. The total failure of those leaves us looking to Big Tech firms to do things they were never designed to do (change human nature, police speech AND make a profit). Things they really can't do without collaboration and intrusive behaviour. But enough of my hair splitting... Re the percentages, Any platform over a certain size will have racists (and pedophiles and other illegal or undesirable users). The question isn't whether someone on Facebook is being racist. The question is whether Facebook encourage it and whether they effectively moderate it when it is reported/discovered. Facebook is huge and has much less racism etc than Parler did exactly because they ban it and mod it. They're not perfect, but they're making an effort. That is all you can expect from a platform that allows user content. Parler encouraged and refused to moderate the same content. That's how it grew from zero users up. That's how it marketed itself. It could have moderated, it removed all sorts of legal content that didn't fit its brand. But it's taken little to no action on violent right wing groups. Quite the opposite, it's encouraged and courted them. Percentage measures are a measure of the effectiveness of the mods and the actions of the people running the platform and that's what we can reasonably expect. Absolute measures are at least partly just down to size of platform. The also percentage matters because parler is small right now. If we ignore it because it's "only a night of rioting" what happens when parler has 330mil users like twitter? Or 2.7bn users like FB? You'll get a lot more than 1 genocide out of a mega-parlar... Density also matters. If I browse reddit, Facebook, twitter and parler randomly, how long before I see crazy conspiracy theories or calls to violence? That's what's concerning here as well: echo Chambers. All the others are much broader, but on parler you just got a very right wing, fact free and urgent set of inputs. That's much more likely to lead to someone being radicalised than the same amount of BS spread over a much bigger collection of cake recipes, kitten pics and funny gifs. That's the other reason percentages (a density measure) matter. At least that's how I understand it. Back to my soap box for a moment: I think we have a real problem with people who are not used to social media not having any BS filter. Thats the root cause of both the riots and the Burmese genocide (I assume that what you refer to, correct me otherwise). We don't have a solution to that. Facebook et al tried to solve it by dilution and moderation. Parler saw it as an opportunity to profit off of and lean into. Those are 2 different business models morally even if its a difference of degree rather than ultimate outcome.
- harimau777 6y agoI don't know that I think it was right to kick out Parler, but it seems like there's a "if you lie down with dogs, then you get up with fleas" element to this. Parler targeted a toxic demographic and their brand became toxic.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> What’s the argument for banning one social media and not another. The argument for Parler from at least some platforms seems to have been that they were unable or unwilling to police content after they had actual notice. Whether it is as sufficient or not may be debatable, but Facebook has at least visibly made steps to address the problem as attention has been focussed on it.
- marcusverus 6y agoBy "actual notice", I assume you're referring to the paltry 24 hours notice provided by Apple. To my knowledge, Google did not provide notice.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> By “actual notice”, I assume you’re referring to the paltry 24 hours notice provided by Apple. No, I mean actual knowledge of the content, by whatever mechanism.
- ardy42 6y ago> So is Google going to throw them out of the Play store? What's the argument for banning one social media and not another. Where do you draw the line that manages to keep Facebooks app available, while still being able to defend the removal of Parler. Probably something like S/N ratio. Even though there was insurrectionist and para-insurrectionist activity on Facebook and Twitter, it was a far smaller percentage of the total, and they are more effective at moderating it (once it reaches their awareness). Parler's whole raison d'être was to capture people who got kicked off Twitter for posting that kind of stuff, so it stands to reason its proportion must have been far higher there.
- bostonsre 6y agoBecause Google and Facebook made a deal to work together: https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-facebook-agreed-to-team-up-against-possible-antitrust-action-draft-lawsuit-says-11608612219 https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-facebook-agreed-to-team-...
- laurent92 6y agoAlso, why is Discord not on the conversation? Seems a far worse offender to me. At least Parler chats were public.
- trianglem 6y agoParler/fab were made to serve fascist rejects from those main social networks. Those discussion make a small segment of facebook’s overall discussions.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> What's the argument for banning one social media and not another. Where do you draw the line that manages to keep Facebooks app available, while still being able to defend the removal of Parler. Parler was created because Facebook and Twitter wouldn't allow certain types of speech. Fundamentally that same speech that was banned from Facebook is what got Parler kicked from pretty much everywhere. Parler knowingly allowed threats of violence, murder, and rape on their platform. Facebook and Twitter grudgingly booted the groups and individuals who made that same sort of speech off. I do agree that Facebook is given too much latitude, but there are pretty significant gaps. Facebook is mostly used for speech of a more mundane sort.
- marcod 6y agoParler was kicked out for refusing to take down violence inciting posts... Facebook on the other hand is doing the bare minimum :p
- manfredo 6y agoThe main arguments are proportionality and enforcement. Facebook probably had more violating content in total but out of a much much larger pool of content. In other words, the percentage of violating content on Facebook is still much smaller. Likewise, Facebook still makes efforts to moderate and police content. Pointing to the large size of ToS violations on Facebook and concluding that Facebook is a dangerous platform is akin to pointing out how many Honda Civics and Toyota Corollas get into collisions and concluding they are dangerous models of cars. They're perfectly safe cars there's just a lot of them on the road.
- spoonjim 6y agoI was a Parler registered user and there is no comparison. If you scroll through Facebook you see mostly unflatternig selfies, ads for stupid crap, somebody's random complaint about something you don't care about, a few Trumpies from high school, and maybe 1 comment every 200 meters saying something borderline-violent about Nancy Pelosi etc. If you scroll through Parler, you barely had to go 1 meter before there's something aggressively violent.
- dwd 6y agoGoogle has their own complicity as their algorithm similarly encourages monetising conspiracy theories - which is the problem. Facebook just have a bigger problem in that their monetisation requires a captive audience which amplifies any groupthink, not just showing people what they might be looking for. Call it the Alex Jones method. Promote a conspiracy theory and monetise the traffic via advertising views, affiliate links or actually selling products that mitigate the effects of conspiracy theory you pushed. All online advertising makes this profitable to anyone and that's what needs to be addressed.