4 ms·
I am not sure, in there own world some tribes might have been far happier than 95% of society is today
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
I am not sure, in there own world some tribes might have been far happier than 95% of society is today
- dantheman 6y agoThat is until they die from a simple infection.
- geodel 6y agoSeems better than perennial back pain from sitting long hours and getting brain fried from implementing same logic of micro-service 1000th time for a 'challenging' project.
- winston_smith 6y agoGo try it and let us know how it works out
- oblio 6y agoThis virtue signalling about hunter gatherers is funny. It's not the first time I've seen these kinds of discussions :-)
- taneq 6y agoOr starvation, or being eaten by a grue. People who think being a hunter-gatherer sounds great should go try it, there's nothing stopping them from doing so. They don't because actually, living in civilization with abundant cheap food, clean running hot and cold water, indoor plumbing, heating, air conditioning, and entertainment is great.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> People who think being a hunter-gatherer sounds great should go try it, there's nothing stopping them from doing so. Well, I mean, except property rights and the people that will defend them in most of the places in the planet suitable for human habitation.
- winston_smith 6y agoPlenty of hunter gatherer tribes still around for the people crazy enough to want to join them
- lodovic 6y agoIt is not likely any of them will gladly accept new members.
- winston_smith 6y agoGaining acceptance by a tribe and finding ways to not die if you ever become disfavored seems like part of the whole hunter-gatherer package, don't you think? They tend not to be very wealthy by modern standards. Maybe you could ingratiate yourself to them with them gifts of things that require modern manufacturing infrastructure.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoYour argument literally defeats itself. You were born into the tribe, and stayed there your entire life. Also there were no laws on hunting, setting traps, etc.
- winston_smith 6y agoGolly, if hunter-gathering means I'm stuck in whatever group I was born in, and that other more organized groups can keep us off their turf, then maybe hunter-gathering just isn't that great.
- dang 6y agoWe've banned this account for using HN primarily (exclusively? I skimmed your history and didn't see a single exception) for political and ideological battle. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for, so we ban accounts that do it regardless of which side they're battling for. You've also broken the site guidelines frequently with snark and attacks on other users. Not cool. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- killtimeatwork 6y agoThis argument is a fallacy. There's plenty of stuff stopping me from being a successful hunter-gatherer: 1. HGs are very skilled, and they build their skills throughout their lives - crucially, starting with childhood and adolescence. I, an adult brought up in a Western civilization, would be totally clueless in a rain forest the same way that those HGs would be totally clueless in our world. 2. HGs live in groups. I would need to find a group of HGs that would accept me, which is highly unlikely because of the language and culture barrier, plus my lack of skills - why would they want to have anything to do with an useless guy in the first place? My CV full of accomplishments does not impress them at all. Unfortunately, just like transplanting an adult HG into our society most likely ends in them becoming a homeless addict, most likely result for me heading for the jungle is fairly quick death.
- taneq 6y agoI guess I should have said "there's nothing stopping them except lack of will to do the required work." Which I guess makes sense since the motivation generally seems to be a desire for a return to some noble-savage-in-Eden life of plenty and ease.
- killtimeatwork 6y agoHow do you integrate with a HG community that doesn't care about you or, even worse, kills you and eats you? It's not only about "required work" but also about serious life-threatening risks involved. Whereas if you were born as a HG, those risks aren't there.
- lovecg 6y agoAnd don’t forget murder. So, so much murder: https://ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeological-evidence-on-violent-deaths https://ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeological-e...
- imtringued 6y agoI don't think I am able to make this judgement but I can talk about what happened after hunter gatherer tribes disappeared. If you are a hunter gatherer you just need a good hunt every now and then. There is no pressure to perform work all day if you get enough food. This is different if you are a farmer. Farming is highly labor intensive. There is so much work to do that you are never done. You will have to repeat the same motions every single day. Swing the same tools the exact same way. People are tied to their land and it is possible to conquer the land violently. You are dependent on a military force which implies that a local ruler must collect taxes to pay the soldiers. That ruler also has power over you which can easily be abused. Democracy is definitively fairer than having an authoritarian ruler but it can be subject to tyranny of the majority or the minority and still cause failure in leadership.