9 ms·
"Notable absent from that list is he fired Pat Gelsinger. Please just bring him back as CEO." - [1] 2012 on HN, when Paul Otellini Retired. "The only one who
by ksec 6y ago
"Notable absent from that list is he fired Pat Gelsinger.
Please just bring him back as CEO." - [1] 2012 on HN, when Paul Otellini Retired.
"The only one who may have a slim chance to completely transform Intel is Pat Gelsinger, if Andy Grove saved Intel last time, it will be his apprentice to save Intel again. Unfortunately given what Intel has done to Pat during his last tenure, I am not sure if he is willing to pick up the job, especially the board's Chairman is Bryant, not sure how well they go together. But we know Pat still loves Intel, and I know a lot of us miss Pat." [2] - June, 2018
"This is the same as Intel pushing out Pat Gelsinger. The product people get pushed out by sales and marketing. Which are increasingly running the show at Apple." [3] 30 Days ago.
And numerous other reference since 2009. Many more around various other forums and twitter. I am getting quite emotional right now. I cant believe this is really happening. ( I am wiring this with tears in my eyes! ) I guess Andy Bryant retired makes the decision a little easier. And Pat has always loved Intel. I guess he is pissed those muppets drove it to the ground.
This is 12 years! 12 years to prove a point! Consider 4 - 5 years of work in lead-time since he left in 2009. That is 2014. Guess what happen after 2014?
May be it is too little too late? Or May be this will be another Andy Grove "Only the paranoid survive" moment?
The King is Back at Intel, despite being a fan of Dr Lisa Su, I am little worry about AMD.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4804875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4804875
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17391707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17391707
[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25435150 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25435150
- heyheyhey 6y agoWow, I'm impressed by your persistence. Have you worked with him or know him personally?
- hangonhn 6y agoI worked at VMware when Pat first became the CEO. Pat is very much an engineer. If you ever wanted an engineer as your CEO, then that's Pat. That comes with some goods and some not-so-greats. Pat isn't very inspiring, at least not when he first became CEO. But I always got the feeling that he genuinely love engineers and is more comfortable around them than anything else. I once hosted a fun little engineering challenge (building bridges out of spaghetti). It wasn't a fancy event -- just a bunch of engineers having fun. Pat actually agreed to come by to hand out the awards at the end. I left VMware partly because I've been there so long and partly because I wasn't excited about it anymore. I felt its best days were behind it. Well, Pat proved me wrong by a wide margin. If no-nonsense engineering is what you need to win, then Pat is the right person for the job. It's a good day for Intel I think.
- ra7 6y agoWhat does this mean for VMware? By all accounts, it seems like Pat was well liked at VMware.
- huac 6y ago$VMW down 6.5%, $INTC up 7.5%, sounds like the market liked him at least
- effie 6y agoWhat are your thoughts on VMware? It seems they are too in decline...
- jacques_chester 6y agoI work for VMware, via the Pivotal acquisition. My purely personal view is that VMware's second act has begun and it'll do well. Pat deserves some of the credit for accepting that Kubernetes would be the future of the business and throwing his weight behind it. There are aspects of Pat Gelsinger's leadership that I dislike, but they're orthogonal to his management style and foresight. He's been effective.
- heimidal 6y agoI will echo this. After we were acquired, I was incredibly hesitant about Pat. Over the past year, I’ve come to believe he is an excellent leader who has fantastic vision and insight even if we disagree on many things. I’d be incredibly happy to have him if I were an Intel employee.
- ridruejo 6y agoWe will be fine. Pat is a great leader and this is a net loss though
- tambourine_man 6y agoThat's remarkable, can you share the reason for your emotional investment? Have you worked at Intel or with Pat?
- normlEyezd 6y agoDevils advocate from a throwaway for reasons; Pat foisted VMWare on a small startup trying to find its engineering footing culture wise, after being invited in to advise on the business side (loan his name mostly). Cost a bunch of engineering time and forward motion, internal politicking. Eventually it got binned after months of not getting what we wanted out of it. There was no technical reason for it. Maybe hardware really is his thing, but that quid pro quo hurt productivity.
- treis 6y agoI don't think I've seen a thread here before where the top 2 posts are such opposites of each other.
- mrg3_2013 6y agoIntel's downfall in recent times has been "Only the paranoid survive". They strayed far too away from customers and focused on competition (and their customer feedback was a redirect from what competition was up to). I doubt there will be cultural changes.
- fossuser 6y agoInteresting - you think he can pull this off? It'll be interesting to see what happens, I had written them off as on the path of inevitable decline and irrelevance. If they have someone as CEO who understand the existential threat they're facing from everywhere maybe they'll survive. The irony of the other top comment is that the AMD threat wasn't the competitive threat that mattered. AMD is also screwed.
- geogra4 6y agoWhy would amd be screwed?
- fossuser 6y agoMy long term bet is on M1 and ARM/RISC5 for the future. x86 is on the way out and can't compete on power or performance. In the end RISC won, it just took a while to get there. As things trend that direction AMD and Intel don't really have much to offer, they're competing on legacy tech. With TSMC providing fabs for designs from anyone, the serious players don't need AMD or Intel. Apple has a massive lead here, but others watching this will follow it.
- dnautics 6y ago> x86 is on the way out and can't compete on power or performance. In the end RISC won, it just took a while to get there. What exactly do you think is the fundamental limitation of x86? Most chips do lot and lots of crazy logic to go from instruction set to microcode, it's hard to imagine that the variable nature of x86 instructions are the limiting factor.
- mhh__ 6y agoAt very least having a big fat decoder costs you power and space, measuring the tradeoff in raw decoder performance is probably dependent on being an engineer working on it at Intel or AMD (or Apple). At very least, Zen 3 is a cutting edge microarchitecture on a cutting edge node with lots of transistors to play with, and it still decodes only half as many instructions per cycle as M1 - an unbelievably wide CPU, which is probably the way forward. The "x86 tax" (if it exists, I guess) is usually estimated at somewhere on the order of 5% to 10% - which is a lot of money at scale but probably not enough for a total rethink.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoPat's a great guy and first class engineer, but I think it's just too late for him to turn Intel around at this point. The problems have become too entrenched. They needed someone like him at the helm 10 years ago. Apple's M1 shows that the world has passed Intel by. I wish him luck, though.
- AWildC182 6y agoYea, I'm not sure what their plan is other than to keep trying to sell to institutions until everyone makes the switch to someone else. If they actually want to survive long term, there are two paths as I see it: A) Be legitimately better than AMD, this could include opening up the management engine, much higher performance chips at lower price points, or some sort of space magic utilizing their Altera acquisition. B) Embrace RISC-V and push it to laptops and desktops HARD, while not pulling the Microsoft Embrace Extend Extinguish™ play. If they go this route then their stock becomes an exceptionally strong buy IMO.
- fossuser 6y agoThey could give up on design and just try to be an American TSMC. There's a lot of interest in that from a national security perspective anyway.
- foobiekr 6y agoWith Intel's cashflow, they can do both without any difficulty. But yes, they should be the american TSMC.
- fossuser 6y agoI'm not sure they really can do both (because doing the TSMC model well intentionally excludes the other). Part of TSMC's offer is that they won't do design, they won't compete with you on design etc. They specialize in the best possible fab and service for your design and that's it.
- wombatmobile 6y agoIt's always too late to change the past, and never too late to change the future.
- forestfire 6y agoIntel is at heart a R&D company, without strong technical CEO I don't see how they fend off competition. Lisa bae is a good example, she is rocking the CPU monopoly boat!