5 ms·
"Using Maps would load many tiles images, which could overwhelm NAT of CGNAT." Just curious, were these image resources all hosted on the same domain?
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
"Using Maps would load many tiles images, which could overwhelm NAT of CGNAT."
Just curious, were these image resources all hosted on the same domain?
- codebje 6y agoI'm afraid I don't recall. I suspect that they could not have been, based on best practices for performance at the time and the fact that the problem existed at all. I did, however, find a reference to the problem: https://meetings.apnic.net/32/pdf/Miyakawa-APNIC-KEYNOTE-IPv6-2011-8.pptx.pdf https://meetings.apnic.net/32/pdf/Miyakawa-APNIC-KEYNOTE-IPv... Slides 12-15 show the degradation of Maps in action. 20 connections per user is a heavily over-committed CGNAT, but that level of port sharing does happen.
- Dylan16807 6y agoBut the "connections per user" limit is per-webserver. You'd have to have thousands of users simultaneously loading maps off the same google server just to run out of ports on one IP. I bet you could put 10k people behind each IP and never even get close to an issue of this type.
- codebje 6y agoCarrier grade NAT puts thousands of users behind the same IP address - that's what it's for. You can't put 10k people behind each IP and not have problems. That's 6.5 ports per person, you need one for each connection. Pretty much any website will have issues with that little connectivity.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> Carrier grade NAT puts thousands of users behind the same IP address - that's what it's for. It doesn't have to. 100:1 would work just fine. With IPs being about $25 each that's an acquisition cost of less than a dollar per user. > That's 6.5 ports per person, you need one for each connection. That's not how connections work. Each user could make a million connections as long as they're spread around different servers. The 65k limit applies to simultaneous connections to a single webserver. Only the most-connected server matters, so probably something at google/youtube/facebook, and even then most of those servers have multiple IPs.
- alphager 6y agoNo, and that's by design, as many browsers limit you to two http-connections per domain. When you're loading tens of images (like map tiles), you want to use as many different subdomains as possible to load them in parallel.
- mfontani 6y agoWith HTTP/2 one is way better off using one connection to one domain instead. How has the world changed.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoFor many years before "HTTP/2", I have been using HTTP/1.1 pipelining, outside the browser, to download hundreds of files over a single TCP connection.