8 ms·
The Schroedinger Equation is the most true thing I've ever encountered. It is clear, simple, obvious in its correctness; the greatest piece of physics since Max
by lmm 6y ago
The Schroedinger Equation is the most true thing I've ever encountered. It is clear, simple, obvious in its correctness; the greatest piece of physics since Maxwell. Once you've understood it it becomes almost impossible to imagine that the universe could possibly work any other way. (Contrary to this article's claim, the equation describes the behaviour of Helium atoms perfectly well; it's a failure of our imagination or exertion that we can't find closed-form stable solutions, not a fact about the equation itself). So this kind of complaint seems utterly wrongheaded.
People hold quantum mechanics to some ridiculous standard, far higher than any other physical theory. Did they really expect that the behaviour of the very small would be exactly like that of everyday macroscopic objects? Do they enjoy the mysticism of pretending that it's complex and hard to understand when it's really nothing of the sort? Frankly I think an honest approach to QM would present it as something banal and obvious.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoThis is also the thrust of the original LessWrong Quantum Physics Sequence. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7FSwbFpDsca7uXpQ2/quantum-explanations https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/7FSwbFpDsca7uXpQ2/quantum-ex... > In the coming sequence on quantum mechanics, I am going to consistently speak as if quantum mechanics is perfectly normal; and when human intuitions depart from quantum mechanics, I am going to make fun of the intuitions for being weird and unusual.
- KirillPanov 6y ago> This is also the thrust of the original LessWrong Quantum Physics Sequence Thanks for linking to this! Absolutely agree with his gripes in the first article about the traditional historically-oriented introduction to QM confusing students. The rest of the articles (still reading them) appear to be pretty much the route taken by Feynman's _QED_ book (which, of course, is fantastic). It's also very interesting how his 1960's Feynman Lectures books seem to tell the student "QM is confusing and weird and hard and scary" roughly every ten pages or so, whereas by the 1980's with _QED_ he dropped the fearmongering language.
- roelschroeven 6y ago> Absolutely agree with his gripes in the first article about the traditional historically-oriented introduction to QM confusing students. Off-topic but that's also my problem with any introduction to philosophy I've seen. This old Greek said something. This other old Greek thought something else. Some German philosopher said still something else. Maybe that's what philosophy is all about, in which case I'm perfectly happy not to learn anything about it. But I have the feeling there really is something interesting to be found, if only the books would talk about that instead of painstakingly reconstructing the whole history of the field.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoMost of philosophy is for natural reasons at least partially a response to what previous people have asserted, so if you want a good understanding of the field of western philosophy you need the background. If your complaint was actually about it just being old greek guys and nobody from other places then I can just agree, it's really just western philosophy that's taught under the name "Philosophy"
- lumost 6y agoThere are plenty of cases where newtonian or relativistic physics diverge from intuition as well, it's strange that we impart special significance to Quantum Mechanics.
- dls2016 6y ago> it's a failure of our imagination or exertion that we can't find closed-form stable solutions You better not say that when any solitons are floating by...
- thisrod 6y agoDo you mean wave packet solutions? The Schrodinger equation is linear, so I don't think it can have solitons.
- ur-whale 6y ago>The Schrodinger equation is linear Is it though? Or have we just found a linear approximation to actual reality? Also, the other day, I read in another HN thread that there are situations (Bose Einstein condensates) where the potential may depend on Psi thus making the equation non-linear (since the potential multiplies Psi).
- gus_massa 6y agoThe Schrodinger equation is linear, but the extension to Quantum Field Theory is not linear https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory so actual reality is even more weird.
- dls2016 6y agoBesides being a joke, I was a dispersive PDE guy and so have a perverted idea of what the Schroedinger equation is. It’s common in that field to study a nonlinear variant. A u|u|^2 term, for instance, admits sech type solutions.
- frongpik 6y agoWhat's natural about SE? From my limited understanding, SE tells us that all particles in the world are interconnected in a peculiar way by a "energy field" of some sort.
- wnoise 6y agoThat would indeed by very unnatural. Fortunately that's nothing like what the Schrödinger equation says. The basics of quantum mechanics are: 1. Any system can be described in a linear "state space", whose basis vectors (roughly speaking) are each possible arrangement of the things being described (every thing's location). However, all possible states include (complex) linear combinations of these. This is usually described as the "wave function", you can plug in any value for coördinates of all your things and get a number back out. 2. States in a closed system evolve according to the (time-dependent) Schrödinger equation, -i h-bar d/dt (state) = E(state). This is sometimes phrased as "energy is the generator of time translation" (note that this phrasing holds true in the Hamiltonion formulation of classical mechanics too, but with different, related meanings). Actually calculating this can be difficult, and you might need to do various tricks such as decomposing in a convenient basis. No all-encompasing energy field binding and penetrating us needed, though the equation is non-local in the sense that it could depend on the entire world. (In fact, it's quasi-local in practice; energy is usually just a function of where things are (local), and how different that coefficient is on infinitesimally adjacent states (i.e. spacial derivatives of the wavefunction). But this does let changes propagate at any speed, including faster than light. Basic QM is not Einsteinian relativistic. It is perfectly Galilean relativistic in a very nice way though.) 3. If you measure a system, you're going to get results that are probabilistic with the probabilities proportional to the (absolute value of) the square of this wavefunction. After that, the state is reset to whay you measured, and evolution will proceed according to 2.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoYou can actually skip 2, if you model yourself as part of the system as well (i.e. have an Ideal Observer who changes from “has XYZ knowledge of the system” to “observed ABC about the system” for all possible ABC, with respective amplitudes) – but then you're doing a lot of computation you're never going to use for prediction. (It's more elegant, though – even more so if you model yourself as a human, though this'll take more computational power than we have.)
- millstone 6y agoPlease elaborate on why you find it to be clear, simple, obvious!
- mpfundstein 6y agohe is obviously a much smarter individual than us regular mortals
- KirillPanov 6y ago> Did they really expect that the behaviour of the very small would be exactly like that of everyday macroscopic objects? I expect a theory predicting otherwise to bear the burden of demarcating exactly where the boundary between "macroscopic" and "weird not-macroscopic" lies (waving your hands and mumbling "thermodynamics" does not count). I expect that such a theory's proponents should be absolutely burning with interest in probing, studying and understanding what goes on at this peculiarly discontinuous boundary in Nature. Those two things haven't happened, which is kind of sad. Quantum Mechanics predicts the results of experiments better than anything else. If "predicts experimental results" is the only thing you care about, then Bohr was right, QM is complete, and there's nothing more to be written in that book.
- kirrent 6y agoThere's a discontinuous boundary? That's news to me. It's pretty well known that classical mechanics is reproduced by quantum mechanics in the large scale. There's no discontinuity between the two. There's also a whole heap of people competing on trying to put ever and ever larger objects in superposition. Finally, decoherence has seen plenty of study and seems to be exactly what you're lamenting the lack of.
- KirillPanov 6y ago> There's a discontinuous boundary? That's news to me. I too find it unlikely that there is such a discontinuity. Quite a large number of physicists (and quantum computing people) seem to speak as if there is one. > Finally, decoherence has seen plenty of study I get the impression that decoherence is treated as merely a problem for technicians working on experimental apparatus, or an engineering issue to be dealt with on the road to quantum computation. Are there any results on fundamental limits to the degree of entanglement in a system? We've been trying to get that damn cat into superposition for ~85 years now, with no luck.
- im3w1l 6y ago> Quite a large number of physicists (and quantum computing people) seem to speak as if there is one. The reason they seem to speak that way is because they are being a little sloppy for the sake of brevity. The physicists all understand that there is a blurry boundary. There is an amusing instance where there was a similar confusion though: the soft diffraction limit was mistaken by many for a hard one. So super-resulution came as a bit of a shock.
- salty_biscuits 6y agoIf you go back in the past, contemporaries of newton were critical of his gravitational theory having an instantaneous action at a distance. Familiarity has just bled us of its strangeness over time.
- ur-whale 6y ago>Contrary to this article's claim, the equation describes the behaviour of Helium atoms perfectly well; Yes, I was disappointed to read this as well. I suspect what he meant is that we can't derive closed form solutions for the Schrödinger equation in the case of the Helium atom. But the equation can perfectly be integrated numerically ... in these days of rather powerful computers, closed-form solutions to diffeqs aren't as important as they used to. As a matter of fact, for most problems in QM, I suspect there's just no other way. One step further, when reading QM books, there seem to be a strong tendency to try and assign "physical meaning" to purely mathematical techniques used to find closed form solution to diffeqs (eg separation of variables). I am not convinced that it is a fruitful endeavor. Another reason he may be saying this could also be because with the Schrödinger equation for the Helium atom, assuming it isn't separable along space variables, the solution ψ is a map from the configuration space, (i.e. ℝ6) to ℂ, something that's hard and annoying to visualize, whereas for the Hydrogen atom, you can draw pretty orbital probability density pictures in ℝ3, something everyone can "understand".
- andi999 6y agoWell, Maxwell is Lorentz invariant. Schroedinger equation is not.
- gus_massa 6y agoThere is an extension made by Dirac that is Lorentz invariant. It is even more weird, and to write the extension you need to consider positrons, so he predicted the existence of the positrons from this extended equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_equation
- ur-whale 6y ago> simple, obvious That's a little bit of a stretch, don't you think? I mean, here are questions about the SE I've so far never received simple, intuitive answers to: - Why do we need complex numbers in the SE, what do they bring to the table and how does that tie in with physical intuition? - How was the equation derived, intuitively? - The laplacian in there feels like it's a "diffusion" term (as in the heat equation, things tend to spread and smoothen over time). Why isn't there ever a intuitive explanation in text books about this? - [edit]: Many book trumpet that classical mechanics is just an approximation of QM, but unlike in special relativity where speed going to zero obviously gets you back to classical mechanics, I've never seen a clear example of a system where the quantum behavior "transitions" to classical behavior as a variable (e.g size) increases or decreases. - the list is long
- disabledalpha 6y agoRegarding your second to last point, have a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_limit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_limit
- gus_massa 6y ago> The laplacian in there feels like it's a "diffusion" term (as in the heat equation, things tend to spread and smoothen over time). Why isn't there ever a intuitive explanation in text books about this? In an equation like df/dt = k Δf the Laplacian create a diffusion-like effect only if k is a real positive number. If k is a real negative number, it creates the opposite effect that concentrates whatever f represent and make it more spiky. When k is an imaginary number, it is not like diffusion o anti-diffusion (I don't know the technical name). The associated operator is unitary and the behavior is different. Many books about the heat/diffusion equations and Schrodinger equation have this discussion. And the generalized versions where k is a functions that depends on x or t, or is a complex number instead of a real or complex number. For an intuitive idea of what is happening, the idea is that you consider at time=0 the function f(x,t=0)=A sin(ωx). If k is real and positive, the amplitude of the function decrease with time. And when ω is big, it decrease faster, so the small features disappear very faster than the smooth parts. If k is real and negative, the amplitude of the function increase with time, and you have the opposite effect. If k is imaginary, the function just rotate in the complex plane but does not increase or decrease the amplitude. So you get a wavy effect instead of a diffusion effect. The initial equation is linear, i.e. there is no f^2 or something like that. With some hand waving you can extend the simple cases where f is sin or cos to more complex cases. The technical details are in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_transform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_transform