5 ms·
By that standard, Instagram is a propaganda weapon. It both: a. pays popular users b. Puts warnings on political issues, like statements that Biden's crime b
by whimsicalism 6y ago
By that standard, Instagram is a propaganda weapon.
It both:
a. pays popular users
b. Puts warnings on political issues, like statements that Biden's crime bill contributed to mass incarceration [0]
[0] https://twitter.com/ben_awareness/status/1339293381625864195 https://twitter.com/ben_awareness/status/1339293381625864195
- bzb6 6y agoThat’s true but Instagram doesn’t claim to be a free speech platform
- whimsicalism 6y agoSo that makes it permissible for private actors to publish 70TBs of private Parler users' messages?
- bzb6 6y agoI did not say anything like that
- whimsicalism 6y agoI guess I'm confused as to the relevance to this thread. This person claimed that two attributes made Parler a "propaganda weapon", I noted that other major platforms have those same properties, so you tacked on another condition. Presumably this was all in an effort to say something along the lines of - "because of the unique situation Parler is in, these actions were permissible." No?
- bzb6 6y agoI’m one of the most right wing and pro free speech humans to ever set foot on this site. You are beating up the wrong person. I was merely replying to you regardless of what your parent comment said.
- KnobbleMcKnees 6y agoThey're using this bad faith / fallacious argument all over the thread, so, at the least, it isn't personal.
- whimsicalism 6y agoI'm in perfectly fine faith, and I'd love for you to point out the fallacies.
- muyuu 6y agoit's a sensational title they are doing bulk scrapping of Parler and they do many other sites like Reddit too, and particularly stuff that is being taken down for archival purposes also there is nothing - and I mean nothing, but particularly threats of violence - in Parler you don't see in Twitter in more abundance, only it's more typically leftists on Twitter and rightists on Parler
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoI didn’t see anyone claim that.
- vegcel 6y agoYes
- crispywalrus 6y agoInstagram doesn't claim to be a "free speech" platform. You have to only be mildly interested in it to see that it's all about "engagement" Parler explicitly claimed "free speech" as a goal
- whimsicalism 6y agoSo because the owners claim the platform to be something other than it actually is, it is okay for this person to leak the Parler users' private images and videos?
- jabberwcky 6y agoUnfortunately you won't find much interesting commentary in a politically charged thread like this, best to just scan and pattern match the kind of exchanges occurring before moving swiftly along.
- julianmarq 6y ago> best to just scan and pattern match the kind of exchanges occurring before moving swiftly along. How do you do that? I've noticed lately that HN commentary (at least in threads like this) has trended increasingly pro-censorship[1] lately, and it's pretty disheartening to read. Would rather do something like what you say, but I'm not quite sure what you mean. [1]: Which is a bit ironic, thinking about it.
- awb 6y ago> increasingly pro-censorship[1] lately The US has always had limits on free speech. > Freedom of speech and expression, therefore, may not be recognized as being absolute, and common limitations or boundaries to freedom of speech relate to libel, slander, obscenity, pornography, sedition, incitement, fighting words, classified information, copyright violation, trade secrets, food labeling, non-disclosure agreements, the right to privacy, dignity, the right to be forgotten, public security, and perjury. Justifications for such include the harm principle, proposed by John Stuart Mill in On Liberty, which suggests that "the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech Incitement, sedition, public security and harm to others seem to be relevant to this discussion.
- syops 6y agoYou've made an argument that Instagram engages in some form of advancing certain viewpoints. You have not demonstrated that this is extensive and that Instagram enforces ideological conformity or that Instagram actively pays people to engage in said advancement of political agendas. There appears to be quite a difference between what Instagram does and what Parler does. The two do not appear to be comparable.
- bzb6 6y agoGet an Instagram account and say something against feminism, diversity, fat people, etc and see what happens.
- beepboopbeep 6y agoIt's not unreasonable for a person instigating something through negative posts to receive negative reactions in return. That seems self evident.
- dd36 6y agoConsequence free speech seems to be what is desired on these platforms. This was inevitable. You can’t monetize consequence free speech. It has to be in dark places like 4chan.
- Wintamute 6y agoI think the point is that you don't need to make "negative posts" about those topics, rather discussing them from any angle that isn't the accepted progressive orthodoxy results in the ban hammer.
- lghh 6y agoThat claim about the Crime Bill is mostly accurate. The vast, vast, vast, majority of incarceration is the fault of states and not done at a federal level. While the bill was deplorable, it didn't really contribute all that much. https://twitter.com/johnfpfaff/status/1128369019164200960?lang=en https://twitter.com/johnfpfaff/status/1128369019164200960?la...
- leereeves 6y agoThe 1994 crime bill included a number of provisions that increased incarceration at the state level, such as: > $9.7 billion in funding for prisons, [including] incentive grants to ... qualifying states that enforced mandatory sentencing of 85% of a person's sentence conviction, > [eliminating federal grants for] lower-income prison inmates to receive college educations during their term of imprisonment, and funding for 100,000 more police officers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-strikes_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-strikes_law
- whimsicalism 6y agoI think this is a contested claim and you can find prominent academics on the other side talking about a. how federal action modeled action for states, including substantial incentive schemes for incarceration (indeed that is how almost every Federal bill works) b. how the rate of incarceration given the crime being committed increased post-crime bill. I think it is a discussion to be had, not something to be a priori fact-checked as "False."
- hnuser847 6y agoThere's a legitimate debate to be had over the consequences of the 1994 crime bill and whether or not is was a good policy. The point is that Instagram (and every other social media platform that puts these disclaimers on their posts) is not merely moderating content any more. They're actively participating in politics and trying to persuade their users to feel a certain way about controversial topics. Which is to say, they're really no different than Parler or any of the big box media outlets.
- chrononaut 6y ago> b. Puts warnings on political issues, like statements that Biden's crime bill contributed to mass incarceration I assume that point was an extension of OP's comment of: "that they use to ensure ideological conformity in their posts." For those interested, here is a link to the USA Today article from the screenshot evaluating whether "the crime bill brought mass incarceration to Black Americans": https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/07/03/fact-check-1994-crime-bill-didnt-bring-mass-incarceration-black-people/3250210001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/07/03/fac... > Stephen Ross Johnson, of Knoxville, Tennessee, a board member of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and past president of the Tennessee Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, told USA TODAY that it is "over simplistic" to say the 1994 crime bill led to mass incarceration. > Asked if the bill caused or largely contributed to it, Johnson says: “The bottom line answer to that is no. Was it a link in the chain? Yes. Is it the beginning of the chain? No.” > Johnson argues that the roots of mass incarceration can be found in the late 1960s and early 1970s, with legislation that created, among other things, the RICO statute, which broadened the scope of federal law as the war on drugs began to take shape. I'd say I agree with the points in the article over the non-contextual, anonyomous, blanket statement that the crime bill brought ("caused") mass incarceration of Black Americans.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> I'd say I agree with the points in the article over the non-contextual, anonyomous, blanket statement that the crime bill brought ("caused") mass incarceration of Black Americans. Perhaps it is not an appropriately nuanced claim - I would be curious if there is equal enforcement of the "contextual" clarity of claims made in all political memes though. My guess is no, and it is also a quite common view among academics that the crime bill is a large link in the story behind mass incarceration. I haven't, for instance, seen fact-checking of memes about Russia "stealing" the election or Donald Trump being a servant of Putin, despite those claims being potentially "non-contextual." You may agree with the points. But does that make it beyond the pale of discussion and must be "fact-checked" away? e: Rather than downvotes, I would be curious what others' thoughts are here.
- 6y ago
- debt 6y ago"a. pays popular users" Source?