2 ms·
The researcher suggests that finding private youtube video id's itself would be a bug... Youtube video ID's were generated by taking an internal integer, and e
by londons_explore 6y ago
The researcher suggests that finding private youtube video id's itself would be a bug...
Youtube video ID's were generated by taking an internal integer, and encrypting it with a fixed key. That key has been leaked in the early days of youtube (pre google buying it).
That means there are a bunch of early video id's that are predictable. That makes this bug much worse.
- swyx 6y agoi dont see how that would be a "bug" per se - the concept of "private" is set based on the account ownership, not the id itself. you could set a public video to private, or vice versa. whatever the ID, google still has to check against your authz before showing the video. this seems better than relying on security by obscurity.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> the concept of "private" is set based on the account ownership, not the id itself I feel like this article should demonstrate why private should be both things whenever possible. > you could set a public video to private, or vice versa You could, but if you don't leak the ID all over then it should provide an extra step of security. > security by obscurity Hiding an ID like this isn't all that different from hiding a key.
- bredren 6y agoAlso, notable, already linked, YouTube videos are made private all of the time. So this big created a method for continued albeit silent and low res access to private but known videos of note. I think videos after being made private can be edited by the owner. So it would be possible for new “private” data from a known video id to leak this way.