4 ms·
Building cranes is most the boring part of this project. It's far more interesting to know how they are going to make the 35 ton weights. I don't know anything
by imtringued 6y ago
Building cranes is most the boring part of this project. It's far more interesting to know how they are going to make the 35 ton weights.
I don't know anything about the construction industry but some googling showed that 1 m^3 of concrete weighs 2.4 tons. You will need 15 m^3 weights. 1 m^3 costs $200 so each weight costs $3000.
35000kg×9.81m/s^2×100m is 34335000 Joules or 9.5kWH. $3000 / 9.5kWH is $315 per kWH.
I'm generous and assume that the tower is 100m high. I haven't seen a real number on the website.
It's possible that they are using a cheaper material mix but that's the entire problem. What materials are they using? They never say so on the website. This is not rocket science. We are merely talking about how to build the cheapest 35 ton rock on earth and yet these people are silent about that.
- londons_explore 6y agoBut each weight can be reused almost infinitely... The cost doesn't matter too much.
- ktpsns 6y agoThat's not right. Refinforced concrete will suffer from environmental influences and have a durability from maybe 30 years. That means you have a cost overhead of 3-4% per year for the replacement value. Water tanks certainly have a much worse life time, given that they will start lacking after a short time and you don't only have to repair the tanks but also provide liquid to refill.
- Retric 6y agoCycling stress like that is going to dramatically reduce the lifespan due to tress fractures. I think they would be lucky to get 10-20 years from the blocks. Stress fracture are already a significant issue for concrete dams when you frequently vary the water levels, and this is much worse as different stacking is going to stress each block slightly differently every time. In theory they might be perfectly flat surfaces meeting evenly, but in practice that’s far from the case.
- micmoc 6y agoThis was already busted by Thunderf00t: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIhCuzxNvv0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIhCuzxNvv0
- choeger 6y ago> This is not rocket science. it is literally rock science ;) Seriously, in Germany, concrete costs arount 100 EUR per cubic meter. So we would end up with around 150 EUR per kwh capacity. But they would not have to use concrete for the task. They could as well use 23 m^3 gravel (which goes down to 10EUR) and some steel scaffolding. Or even just plain water (35m^3).
- vidarh 6y agoThey're using "composite" bricks that include waste material (I can't find any obvious references to exactly what kind of mix of materials), so my guess would be the material cost will be rather low.
- moneytide1 6y ago> What materials are they using? "Just Have a Think" put out a video about this recently [1]. The project he reports on claims 30MW with 4MW available within 3s for frequency stabilization and the weight is not solid concrete (emissions penalty), but rather compressed refuse that otherwise cannot be recycled (coal ash, demolition debris). The friction would occur as long term tensile strength durability of lifting cables and high torque electrical hoists, which are the primary material penalties. But these things may be relatively cheap to produce and rotate out of service as their known operational lifetime approaches (Tesla has designated labor that changes out public charger cables within a reasonable buffer before they are expected to wear out). [1] https://youtu.be/lh1--ftWWvY https://youtu.be/lh1--ftWWvY
- tambourine_man 6y agoThat’s where I got the link from
- walrus01 6y agoI wonder how they've calculated the costs of building this giant crane and concrete block system, vs building small scale pumped storage hydroelectricity. Not by the usual method of impounding a reservoir at the top of a hill, but putting a giant array of load-balancing medium sized water tanks at the top of a hill, running a pipe to the bottom where there's the pump/generator, and a similarly sized array of tanks.
- ncmncm 6y agoA big tank is overwhelmingly cheaper than a collection of small tanks. Ground water makes a remarkably capacious reservoir, which may be deeper than your hill is high, doubling the energy storage capacity, for a possible upper limit on instantaneous wattage.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI would use depleted uranium for that. Many countries have to store thousands of tons of it, and governments will pay you for storing it. Instead of making it sit idle, you might as well use one of its finest qualities (density).
- fsh 6y agoThousands of tons is a very small amount of mass for gravitational energy storage. The capacity of small pump storage reservoirs is measured in millions of tons. Also one probably wouldn't want to use a somewhat toxic and slightly radioactive material at large scale.
- lovemenot 6y agoLet's make Fort Knox fully renewable by storing wind/solar in stacked gold bars.