14 ms·
Working Off-Grid Efficiently
- VBprogrammer 6y agoIf you found this interesting you will probably also enjoy having a read of Joey Hess' blog https://joeyh.name/offgrid/ https://joeyh.name/offgrid/
- cesarb 6y agoJoey Hess is also the author of git-annex (https://git-annex.branchable.com/ https://git-annex.branchable.com/), which helps with some of the things mentioned in the "Internet" and "Data Storage" sections of this article.
- cameldrv 6y agoInteresting article, but the extreme lack of electricity seems unnecessary, at least today. Solar panels have gotten much cheaper, enough so that generating adequate power to run a couple of laptops even on cloudy days is fairly affordable. Batteries to keep it going at night have also come down in price. Maybe the extreme power savings are more of an aesthetic thing for them.
- znpy 6y agoCongrats on reading the article and not getting the context. They live on a boat, by the sea, often in the middle of the ocean. Even with solar panel, extreme power saving is a necessity.
- walrus01 6y agoOn a medium sized sailboat the limiting factor for how much PV capacity you can have is the physical mounting space. Google "bimini top solar panel": https://www.google.com/search?q=bimini+top+solar+panel&client=firefox-b-d&sxsrf=ALeKk01kEXWJi__Qg6Apt9osy4zXsZf8wA:1610364053628&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjchYDL4ZPuAhU4JzQIHZ2pDjoQ_AUoAnoECAgQBA&biw=1680&bih=953 https://www.google.com/search?q=bimini+top+solar+panel&clien... What could be trivially easy to mount on a small off grid cabin in the woods somewhere, like two of these: https://www.altestore.com/store/solar-panels/panasonic-hit-high-efficiency-solar-panels-p40891/ https://www.altestore.com/store/solar-panels/panasonic-hit-h... could be very difficult and too much surface area and wind loading on a sailboat that people can realistically afford to buy. If you have the space and can fit one, something like the Sunpower 400W rated panels which are composed of expensive, ultra high efficiency monocrystalline Si cells would be ideal. You're looking for the greatest ratio of watts per square meter in STC test conditions. What I would recommend is first calculating the watt-hours per day consumed by your projected load, versus what the PV system could be expected to produce.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoAnother factor in sail boats is the shading caused by masts, stowed sails, hand rails and lines. It's one of the few places where micro-scale wind turbines almost work.
- jarvist 6y agoSort of... but the wind turbines often don't point well when you're at sea, and you intentionally anchor in calm places to avoid the swell. Sailing specific PV would often have 40 silicon cells rather than 36 in series, to provide some headroom for partial shading. Watt & sea hydro-generators have become quite ubiquitous recently, as if you're making passage your entire vessel is a machine for concentrating wind energy: https://www.wattandsea.com/index.php/en/products/cruising-hydrogenerators https://www.wattandsea.com/index.php/en/products/cruising-hy...
- hinkley 6y agoAlso you may be more likely to stay put on a calm day, increasing demand for power.
- jcims 6y agoI'm clueless in this area. Would a raft be viable? Presumably it would add some drag if you're underway but a small inflatable pontoon raft seems like it could run 4-6 panels and be reasonably portable when not in use.
- walrus01 6y agoI do off grid PV professionally but don't know a lot about boats. But having been on a few 42-48 ft size cruiser type sailboats, I can't think of a place you could easily pack away six 1.65x1.0 meter size (typical 60-cell) rigid, aluminum framed high efficiency PV panels, unless you basically dedicated the smaller guest bunk to storage space.
- 6y ago
- CaptArmchair 6y ago> Solar panels have gotten much cheaper, enough so that generating adequate power to run a couple of laptops even on cloudy days is fairly affordable. Batteries to keep it going at night have also come down in price. From the article: > Our work schedule is tied to the weather, as we depend on solar energy to power our computers. So, what's the problem then? Well, they've written in-depth about the challenges and constraints of solar elsewhere on the site. [1] Their vessel is on the smaller side of the spectrum. There's only so much usable space to place a solar array. [2] They do use batteries and they have a small gas generator, but those are also limited and only used as a backup. [1] https://100r.co/site/off_the_grid.html#power https://100r.co/site/off_the_grid.html#power [2] https://100r.co/site/pino.html https://100r.co/site/pino.html
- pontifier 6y agoI'm trying to run a company in a hostile regulatory environment. I've been without power since April 2020. This is in the middle of a city in the United States. I've tried generators and have gone through 3 so far. Fuel was very expensive, and the time and effort to keep them running 24/7 was miserable. I have now tried going solar but have had all sorts of problems with battery life and cloudy weather. It's not as easy as I thought it would be.
- pjc50 6y ago> I'm trying to run a company in a hostile regulatory environment. I've been without power since April 2020. This is in the middle of a city in the United States. .. how? Which city?
- pontifier 6y agoPine Bluff, Arkansas.
- quesera 6y agoThere might be a relevant distinction between "without power" and "power is not available to me".
- pontifier 6y agoThe city won't approve the electrical hookup to the building I purchased. I've had 2 different commercial contractors try to pull permits and both of them were denied. Not denied in writing, but convinced not to file the required application. I was actually assaulted by a zoning officer while sitting in their office trying to fill out an application they didn't want me to submit.
- quesera 6y agoThat sounds miserable. Fighting (an office of) City Hall is a painful experience. You must have some idea of why they are obstructing though, right? An electrical permit is an indirect block, so I'm guessing you've fought other battles with the office in the past? In any case, you have a right to file the permit. The office might make your life hell through documented denials or overzealous inspections, but getting the permit filed should be non-controversial. Once filed, they must approve or deny. If denied, there is a formal appeals process which can run through different people/departments. If you have the time and energy for it, of course. Anyway, I know you are not here soliciting advice, but my next step would be to bring a lawyer to the filing office to ensure that the application is filed, and that no further assault occurs. Good luck.
- Steltek 6y agoMore than that, they're on a sailboat! Electric motors offer regen when under sailpower, which is absolutely huge, or you can get a towable torpedo generator. Otherwise, get a small wind turbine. You can subsist on PV alone but there are far better options, especially when available PV area is so limited.
- Havoc 6y agoBeing that internet and power constrained would just stress me out frankly. One more thing to manage...
- VBprogrammer 6y agoThe author makes the claim that these constraints lead to more creativity and perhaps focus. I mean we both probably wouldn't be here if we knew we only had one hour of battery power for the day.
- jonmal 6y agoOff-grid, yes, but no electricity, not for me. Thanks for sharing an interesting article though.
- ConfusedDog 6y agoI was just thinking about that... first thing come to mind is that I need StarLink satellite internet (said to have at least 100Mbps 20ms latency). Electricity wise, I'm not running server farm out there. Solar, wind, geothermal, even gas generators should be fine.
- Scoundreller 6y agoStarlink draws about 100w without much variation unless you shut it off completely.
- BHSPitMonkey 6y agoMaybe in the future they'll be able to offer a lower-power user terminal meant for mobile installations (RVs/boats/etc.)? There might be some opportunity there to reduce energy usage at the cost of some speed.
- jerzyt 6y agoIt would be interesting how much power you could generate by having a little outboard propeller driving a small generator. It would decrease the speed of your yacht, but if you're not on a schedule to get anywhere who cares, right? Another option would be using Peltier effect, although I have no idea how efficient it could be. But sailing in the Polynesia, I'd think that there's a good temp difference between the water below the surface and the top of the boat.
- larrysalibra 6y agoHydro generators exist! They are relatively expensive for the small amount of power they generate: https://www.sailmagazine.com/diy/know-how-hydro-generators https://www.sailmagazine.com/diy/know-how-hydro-generators
- walrus01 6y agoWhat is a typical price?
- larrysalibra 6y agoAccording to the article I linked, one that gives max 600 watts costs around US$5000. The market is very small for hydro generators for sailboats. Solar is much cheaper because you can buy products that are targeted at mass market instead of only at sailboats. Source: I was recently purchased by a sailboat.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI was recently purchased by a sailboat. And what does your sailboat intend to do with its new purchase?
- robszumski 6y agoSuck his wallet dry is the usual goal I believe.
- fewrites 6y agoSmall wind generators at the top of the mast and a few other places might help.
- ctdonath 6y agoI run my “office” on portable solar much of the summer. Two takeaways: Solar averages ~10W/m^2 long term (days/weeks) with wild fluctuations. Getting easy reliable output retirees a lot of surface & batteries. When those storage batteries deplete, it’s a hard stop. Recharging takes considerable time, competing for scheduled direct use. Plan on at least doubling panel surface just to recover from outages, and plan on more storage than you expect because long uncooperative weather happens more often, with more consequences, than you expect. Unless you are willing to shut down completely at times, or spend enormous sums, you must have a reliable on-grid source ... which then may as well be your primary.
- chrismorgan 6y ago> Solar averages ~10W/m^2 long term (days/weeks) That figure surprises me. What I’ve heard before is that full sun is roughly 1kW/m², and that over time you should expect to get 4–5 useful hours (depending on latitude and weather conditions of where you are—some will be outside this range on either side), so if you take 21% efficient solar panels, the total would be 1000 (watts) × 4 (hours) / 24 (hours) × 0.21 (efficiency) = 35W. 10W is a lot less than 35W. I presume I have some incorrect assumption or am overlooking something. (I’m interested in this because I’m planning to build a velomobile and live out of it while going round Australia for a year. Power systems are something I’ve been putting a fair bit of theoretical research into, but I have no practical experience whatsoever. I’ve been planning to build solar panelling into the body.)
- ctdonath 6y ago35 is pretty close to 10 when you start at 1300 and prune obstructions. Now address clouds, angles, dust, snow, opacity, malfunctions, storage inefficiencies, panel aging, and chronic optimism. 10W.
- chrismorgan 6y agoMost of that is what the 4–5 useful hours per day figure is supposed to take care of (that’s a year-round thing, too, averaging summer, which may be as much as double that, and winter, which may be half). Hmm… storage inefficiencies? Are you including battery storage and perhaps an inverter in your calculations? I guess that’d account for some loss. I’m guessing also from “snow” that you may be in a place that gets comparatively little sunlight?
- leokennis 6y agoNot qualified to comment on any technical aspect of this. But this observation: > "Living and working aboard a sailboat was for us a constraint, it liberated our imagination by eliminating possibilities." Rings very true to me. When you're in a tent in the woods, without mobile internet and just human company for "entertainment", it's incredible how easy it is to have long conversations or to think/make up games to pass the time.
- eigenvector 6y agoIndeed. I've had the good fortune to pass long periods of time (from days to months) hiking and it's amazing what entertainment just meeting a new person after weeks can provide. And no matter what book you bring along, you will finish it in a couple days without constant distraction.
- driverdan 6y agoI've been living mostly off grid for the past 3.5 years in a bus I converted. Solar isn't expensive anymore, panels can be had for <$1/Wh. The cost of batteries is still significant but some of that can be mitigated by buying used packs for 1/4 the price. The key with being off grid is redundancy. One is none and two is one. For example, if there are storms that last a week you'll get almost no solar power. You need another way to get power, typically a fuel-based generator.
- hinkley 6y agoAnd you need to ventilate and supply that generator like it'll be running all the time. See also winter storms, where going outside is a lot more problematic than just getting wet.
- beagle3 6y agoProbably a good thread to ask: A few years ago when looking for it, I was able to easily find deep-discharge 100Ah 12V lead-acid batteries at reasonable prices, which would have allowed one of my projects to go off-grid. However, what I couldn't find was a charge controller that would be able to reasonably e.g track charge and time. I didn't have the time and sufficient expertise to design such a charge controller myself. My options ended up being buy a pre-made, significantly more expensive UPS and pay for the up-down conversion loses; Or just used my 12V feed with no monitoring and hope for the best. I chose the latter, which ended up OK given this was a research project with a limited time horizon. Is the situation any better today?
- mastax 6y agoThere are many DIY charge controllers nowadays from aliexpress to commercial grade. I remember looking at them for LiFePO4 batteries but almost all of them will support Lead Acid since it's just a few more lines of code.
- serjester 6y agoDepends on the wattage but I just bought a 20 watt charge controller for $30. If you're just trickle charging a lead-acid battery that's plenty.
- turtlebits 6y agoThere are lots of solar charge controllers, cheap to expensive. If you want to track charge reliably, you'll need a shunt. Victron energy makes a good one which is monitorable via BT.
- throwaway981374 6y agoIt's pretty amazing that the article and the whole comment thread neglect OSes. I use Debian with i3 on a 10 years old laptop with 4GB of RAM. It's my only workstation and I'm a software engineer. I usually run two browsers including a tab for slack. Everything works fine. Tip: install the documentation OS packages for all the libraries you need and also read manpages. Works well when you are on planes often and makes you a better developer than relying on search engines.
- horsawlarway 6y agoI'm not really sure I understand. Most modern laptops are much more power efficient than older models. If you're really looking to save watts, and ARM chromebook is pretty hard to beat.
- throwaway981374 6y agoI'm providing an example on how efficient software can run on limited hardware resources. I'm not advocating for old hardware. (facepalm) More tips: use powertop. Use CLI-based stuff. Download email locally in bulk/batches. Don't use software that does home-calling or any other unnecessary network traffic. 1 large monitor is more efficient than a dual screen setup
- flobosg 6y agoI’ve been following Hundred Rabbits’ Rekka[1] and Devine[2] for a while. Their sites are full of interesting tidbits on different topics and projects. If you liked the article I recommend having a look at them. [1]: https://kokorobot.ca/site/home.html https://kokorobot.ca/site/home.html [2]: https://wiki.xxiivv.com/site/home.html https://wiki.xxiivv.com/site/home.html
- baliex 6y agoWhat a beautiful website -- so inkeeping with their mission and ideas (this comes up quite often but, those dithered images really remind me of https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/power.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/power.html)
- hutzlibu 6y agoI did this for years, but in the form of backpacking/hiking/cycling and still do it on occasion (when my family lets me). Meaning much bigger constraints in weight. 10 years ago, it was really expensive getting the equipment, I used a solar gorilla/power gorilla pack. Very nice, but also heavy. I think around 500€. Today I use 2 Anker 21 solar W and 3 power banks for half the price and at least triple the power. (downside is only USB charge, meaning not possible for many laptops, unlike the power gorilla) Also laptops really improved in battery life and power efficency, meaning, when I started doing it 10 years ago, I could only really work consistently, when I had a real power source nearby. Otherwise it was maybe 2 days of full-time working. Today I can work forever off the grid, on my cheap rugged Asus Chromebook, as long as the sun shines from time to time and I have a safe place to put up the solar panels. All in all my mobile office equipment is 4-5 kg. For short trips with laptop, 1 panel and 1 powerbanks, cables,.. 2.5 kg. Which is managable, even when you carry also your tent and food. Combining working in nature really helps my creativity and I can recommend trying this out. The tech really is ready today, unless you want to do heavy video editing or 3D Design. But coding, in my case mainly with chrome dev tools and node, really works fine off grid. There are new insights to be gained, from top of a mountain, tree, or next to a river, compared to your never changing office wall.
- gtirloni 6y agoHow do you manage(d) working with npm modules?
- hutzlibu 6y agoMy chromebook is in dev mode, so I can use chromebrew and just install npm. But I just use and do not create npm packages, so I don't know if theres a limitation there. (in theory I could boot a full linux in embedded VM, but that is too ressource intensive for my taste) In general, ChromeOS sucks, but the driver and firmware is really optimated, which means fast sleep/wakeup and long batterie life and with my basic tools running I am quite happy, even though my control over the system is much restrained compared to my manjaro laptop for example.
- djsavvy 6y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI've lived for extended periods (up to 9 months) in my self-built Sprinter, with 550W of panels on the roof, and 455aH of battery inside. That system runs the lights, the fridge, the toaster, an electric kettle, the heater fan/pump, water pump, a 40W audio amp, and my purpose built computer. The computer is a mini-ITX i7 quad core, with a "micro power supply" that lets me plug it (almost) directly into my batteries. Things I've learned: 1) you can't plug directly into the batteries if you've got a smart solar charge controller. That will sometimes take the DC circuit voltage up to levels that the micro PSU considers unsafe, and the computer will shut down. I had to add a voltage regulator to keep the DC V levels seen by the computer (and other equipment) within range. My Morningstar charge controller will lift the DC V to 14V fairly often if there is a lot of sun and the batteries are moderately discharged. 2) Monitors are a problem. Some years ago, you could find monitors that accepted a standard 12VDC power plug fairly easily. Then someone figured out how to shrink the monitor PSU (thanks, Apple!) and they vanished inside the monitor case. You now have to hunt really hard to find anything that is 12VDC native. This is another argument in favor of laptops. 3) Native (desktop) software development is a totally different ballgame than webdev for this scenario. As I mention a lot here on HN, compiling my software is a major issue no matter whether I'm grid connected or not. It takes time, and it takes power. It actually takes more power than the refridgerator. If you're going to just "be online" all day, or just working in the cloud, or just pushing data to and from the cloud, you don't need much power (my setup would last for 4-5 days of that kind of work. But if you're going to be compiling code (i.e. 100% CPU utilization) for extended periods, you need a lot of power. That means panels and/or batteries. 4) Laptops offer more power flexibility in part because they have their own batteries. You can get them fully charged during peak insolation, which doesn't take long, and then allow the remaining sun to keep charging your main batteries. Sometimes you can get another charge into the laptop batteries before sundown, giving you another nice blob of energy to use in the dark. You can also use them outside the vehicle, which for some people is important (it isn't for me, in general) 5) I experimented in the beginning with a wifi antenna on an extensible mast. It connected to an internal router (also directly powered by 12VDC from the batteries/voltage regular). I gave all that up fairly quickly. Open wifi worth using is vanishing rare (thanks, telecoms). I ended up with a Verizon jetpack (grandfathered into an unlimited 4G data plan for US$70/month) and use that exclusively. It has been really great, generally even better than trying to use the wifi when we stay at friends/family. 6) in the not too distant future, I will switch out my aging AGM (lead-acid, but better) batteries for lithium ion, which will effectively double the size of our battery store (Li batteries can be fully discharged) 7) smart charge controllers are great for battery life but terrible for power collection. They will (correctly) limit the current to the batteries based on their current charge level, tapering off as the batteries near full. This can lead to situations where there is full sun available all day, but it still takes hours to get back to 100% because the charge controller is being careful and looking after your batteries. This is good for longevity of lead-acid batteries, but infuriating if you need to "bank" the power as fast as possible (e.g. its going to be cloudy this afternoon). This issue, IIUC, goes away with Li batteries, which are happy to accept about as much current as you can give them (they just need to be above freezing).
- pmlnr 6y ago"off the grid" - except for the social media presence, the website, the cloud backups, etc which are all outsourced, on-grid, big power eaters. Articles like these always feel like Japan itself: clean, because all the trash and polluting industry was sent away to the rest of Asia. /me grumps away EDIT that said, there are good thoughts in the article, eg: "Hard copies: Paper is a stable and widely accessible material, unlike digital devices which are subject to breakages and obsolescence". I'll have to print a lot of photos one day.
- ashkankiani 6y agoWhy live for years in the forest and write a book to be released afterwards when you can just show off how minimal you are in realtime? Thoreau would've just micro-blogged all of his thoughts on Twitter probably.
- bob29 6y agoDon’t forget the diesel, petrol, and propane. The dirty secret of most “off grid”.
- bob29 6y agoDOWNVOTED FOR TRUTH
- gabereiser 6y agoWhy, when I got laid off due to funding, that I’m constantly reminded by my dream to set sail and work remotely. Dang it. This is my dream right here. Live off grid, conscious of my impact, and make a living doing what I love, being in the ocean. I bookmarked this under “Retirement goals”. Whether it’s an RV, a sailboat, a troller, doesn’t matter. Housing is ridiculous and I’d rather spend my time doing something adventurous than sitting around waiting for the grim reaper.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoAWS' James Hamilton lives pretty much on a boat around the world most of the time [0]. I was at AWS 2008-2014 and had a few chats with him. Super nice, very smart, humble. For a little while he used to be a car mechanic for Italian cars in his younger years. [0]: https://mvdirona.com/ https://mvdirona.com/
- aarchi 6y agoGreat outlook on working culture and hours: > We work less, by keeping our needs small. We both cannot deal with working within rigid schedules, and we both know that we find our best selves when working close to nature.
- erikpl 6y agoThank you so much for posting this! Found it a while ago and found it very inspiring, but I recently tried to find it again without succeeding. So thank you!
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI have never found a nice, compact wing generator that i could use for a cabin in the woods or similar - that would be viable for personal use in a northern country Solar seems to be doing so much better in terms of cost per watt, reliability (no moving parts), etc. Are there trully no decent wind turbines that don't break the bank?
- sdfjkl 6y agoWe're living on a boat. We have 600W solar and that's sufficient for most of our power needs. Of course living off solar means on some days you'll not be doing GPU intensive stuff on the computer (which tends to turn it from a low-power, quiet machine into a hyperventilating 90W monster), but that's fine. We usually have enough power left to run the 12V watermaker. Biggest problem is crap software. Everything seems to be designed to be online all the time and expect you to have unmetered high-speed internet. We often have various combinations of metered, slow and unreliable (packet loss, high latency spread, interruptions). Nobody even tests their software for this scenario anymore. Obviously you can forget about using Xcode with its multi-GB updates every couple weeks. Or any cloud software. Even MacOS gets annoying, as it wants to verify an app before starting it and if the connection is flakey it can take a minute before that request either goes through or is detected as offline and your app finally starts (yes, I know you can turn that off). Websites with dynamic forms often don't work, as the programmers falsely assumed their XHR always goes through and never implemented retries or network error handling. Download pages that generate dynamic URLs are a big sin too, so when you try to continue from a partially downloaded file you can't because your URL is no longer valid. What works well is keeping data offline but occasionally syncing it, like IMAP for email, Unison file sync, etc. Piracy is also important, because when you travel from country to country, geo-IP blocking is a constant problem. Suddenly the TV show you were in the middle of watching is no longer available in your country (because you sailed to another country) or the entire service is blocked (Amazon Prime Video). And it's safer to use cracked software that won't suddenly stop working because it couldn't contact its license server in a while or demands you to download a multi-GB update. Or software that doesn't require such nonsense. Hardware is less of an issue, if you keep it dry, which requires some care, but so does the rest of boat life. I've had a keyboard die from circuit board traces corroding away, but am still on the same 8 year old laptop. Had one netbook get accidentally wet once, but managed to save it by immediate taking apart and rinsing out with alcohol. External drives are kept in waterproof plastic food containers. Backup is offline only and consists of two external drives in another waterproof box, which go with the grab bag (the one you take with you if ever have to abandon ship). There is no real need for off-site backup, as the nature of life on a boat means either you and your grab bag make it off the boat, or neither (in which case you won't be needing your data anymore).
- turtlebits 6y agoI wish the article had more details on their equipment and the pros/cons. My office is off grid (not in my backyard), and a huge time sink was researching what components I need and which ones to buy. Now that I'm setup, I'm surprised at how cheap solar can be, considering most home setups are in the $15k+ range and don't get any storage. My complete solar setup with battery was about $2000 (300W solar, charge controller, inverter, 100AH battery), and can be done today for $1200 (battery prices have dropped).
- artaak 6y agoThat's pretty cool - reminds me about an experiment of improving small fridge efficiency by adding insulation on the sides of the fridge. In the end it worked out favourably for energy efficiency angle. https://coolfridge.blogspot.com/ https://coolfridge.blogspot.com/ I'd be grateful if folks point out more improvements/builds that target off-grid home/office setups.
- _libertine_ 6y agoI’m off-grid in a jungle on the Big Island of Hawaii. For internet I’ve been using a GlocalMe global portable modem with a data package and a VPN. Data is $100/50GB/month though I’ve realized I only use about 20/mo, and the modem talks to cell towers—all of them—and has its own data provisioning contracts. Internet solved—faster than tethering your phone.