3 ms·
Violent speech is pretty strongly protected under modern First Amendment law. Direct incitement to imminent violence isn't protected, but that's a very narrow e
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
Violent speech is pretty strongly protected under modern First Amendment law. Direct incitement to imminent violence isn't protected, but that's a very narrow exemption; even statements like "we need to get violent here" aren't going to be over the line. (One of the canonical free speech cases is Watts v. United States, where the defendant's statement that he'd try to shoot then-president Johnson if he were drafted was ruled to be protected speech.)
- dvt 6y ago> Violent speech is pretty strongly protected under modern First Amendment law I should clarify that by "violent speech" I just meant it as a colloquialism of the more technical Fighting Words Doctrine. That is, "speech is violent speech IFF it disturbs the peace."
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago> That is, "speech is violent speech IFF it disturbs the peace." Disturbing peace? Isn’t that very much under the scope of the BLM associated rioting? Like we’re talking many buildings public and otherwise burned to the ground. Billions of dollars of damage.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThat's a common perception, and I tend to agree it's a moral standard we should hold people to, but the fighting words doctrine prohibits only speech which will immediately disturb the peace. There's no exception in current law for speech which will inevitably but nondeterministically cause something bad to happen.