47 ms·
Scuttlebutt – A decentralized secure gossip platform
- type0 6y agoLast time I looked it was half baked and not easy to use, has it changed in recent years or months and can it be considered practical in a way that let's say Matrix is?
- newscracker 6y agoI have similar questions too. It seemed as if it was tied to a single device and transferring information from one to another also seemed cumbersome.
- hobofan 6y agoYes[0]. AFAIK fully transferring an identity from one device to the next should not be a problem. The problem is more that updating the feed from multiple devices would create diverging feeds. [0]: https://github.com/ssbc/handbook.scuttlebutt.nz/blob/master/faq/applications/multiple-devices.md https://github.com/ssbc/handbook.scuttlebutt.nz/blob/master/...
- grey_earthling 6y agoIt's common for one person to have multiple feeds/identities, so this is less of a problem than you might expect. There's no structured way to indicate that 2 feeds are the same person (aka #sameAs), but you can easily link to the other feed and just say “this is also me” (because your audience is a bunch of humans that mostly pass the Turing test). Because of this, we get the bonus feature that you can easily follow a different set of feeds on different devices — e.g. perhaps on your phone you want feeds you're less likely to reply to, because you prefer typing on a physical keyboard.
- jamil7 6y agoIt also spun up my laptops fans for minutes when syncing, I don’t know if thats still an issue. Cool project though and there are some interesting people involved and contributing.
- pluc 6y agoThat's like running a blockchain on your laptop - it first has to get the entire (in some cases, relevant) history so that it can act as a peer.
- hjacobs 6y agoYes, the initial syncing and indexing can take a moment. I would recommend joining a single Pub or SSB room [1] to find people and grow your network organically. The large Pubs [2] have a lot of content to download and also follow bots (which you would have to block). [1] https://github.com/staltz/ssb-room/blob/master/FAQ.md https://github.com/staltz/ssb-room/blob/master/FAQ.md [2] https://github.com/ssbc/ssb-server/wiki/Pub-Servers https://github.com/ssbc/ssb-server/wiki/Pub-Servers
- cel 6y agoSome updates: Oasis is a new frontend (alternative to the Patchwork desktop app): https://github.com/fraction/oasis/ https://github.com/fraction/oasis/ Manyverse continues development, including working on low-level database improvements, and gossip "rooms": https://www.manyver.se/blog/2021-01-update https://www.manyver.se/blog/2021-01-update Planetary (iOS app) approaches public launch: https://planetary.social/ https://planetary.social/ https://viewer.scuttlebot.io/%25kXEXGmyNyo%2BuKkcySMwghVKpvRmgxb6u9RBFZYrY4BM%3D.sha256 https://viewer.scuttlebot.io/%25kXEXGmyNyo%2BuKkcySMwghVKpvR...
- olah_1 6y agoManyverse’s work on room servers version 2 will be huge. The rooms will function a lot more like real life buildings. Some will be private like homes, some will be public like libraries, others will be restricted like a club. Really cool development!
- neuland 6y agoI don't see how these apps dont eventually get taken down like the Fediverse apps earlier this year. Eventually (probably once it's polished enough to be usable) the deplatformed communities will discover SSB and then Google/Apple will take the apps down.
- crossroadsguy 6y agoEvery time I try it, it reminds me of Matrix. So near, yet so far.
- robertlagrant 6y agoI clicked get started and nothing happened. Pretty pictures on the website, though.
- IvanSologub 6y agoThis is an eternal problem for radical crypto enthusiasts.
- stunt 6y ago"Tending and pruning are not a stranger’s duty, it is through near moderation and free listening that we improve our surroundings" https://scuttlebutt.nz/docs/principles/ https://scuttlebutt.nz/docs/principles/ What does "near moderation" mean?
- tao_oat 6y agoI believe it means handling moderation yourself rather than relying on platform providers to do it for you. You have to choose your peers that you receive content from carefully rather than rely on platform moderators to filter content.
- bitwize 6y agoI get it. Remember killfiles on USENET? About the only thing considered universally intolerable and subject to administrative removal, at least on USENET's alt.* hierarchy, was spam. But spammers could spam faster than cancellers could cancel, so it eventually overwhelmed the platform.
- konjin 6y agoProof of work makes this expensive.
- grey_earthling 6y agoScuttlebutt inverts this idea of cancelling — as a new user you're just shouting into the void until you persuade someone to follow you. Essentially, each user is just writing their own diary. If you follow someone, your client periodically asks around for a copy of that person's diary. No-one's gonna ask for the spammers' diaries.
- l33tman 6y agoBut then you could just subscribe to some peoples RSS feeds (or .plans for the archaic people ;). At some point you want to "listen" to a group/forum where you don't have personal control over every member and as soon as a spammer joins you'd get their spam.. how does this work in scuttlebutt, or maybe this is not a use-case it tries to supply, is it just a twitter-clone? (I don't know anything about it...) I guess you could design a group so at first only a few get hit with junk from a new member and as long as nobody stop listening, others would eventually accept the new member as well. Just thinking on this use case as USENET was discussed elsewhere here as an analogy, maybe it's not relevant at all.
- merricksb 6y agoPast related discussions for those curious: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22915460 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22915460 (2020) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22909984 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22909984 (2020) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20828356 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20828356 (2019) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16877603 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16877603 (2018) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16273096 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16273096 (2018) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14050049 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14050049 (2017) And other smaller ones over the years... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=Scuttlebutt%20&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoI would rather not download any executables to test this out. Is this a web app packaged into an app? Then why not simply allow me to open it in my browser?
- madushan1000 6y agoIt's p2p, no webapps.
- neartheplain 6y agoOn the topic of untrusted executables, is there a decent GUI to run arbitrary programs inside the MacOS app sandbox? Last I checked, users still had to fiddle with config files and command-line incantations, but at least it was possible: https://paolozaino.wordpress.com/2015/08/04/how-to-run-your-applications-in-a-mac-os-x-sandbox-to-enhance-security/ https://paolozaino.wordpress.com/2015/08/04/how-to-run-your-...
- hjacobs 6y agoThe Oasis SSB client [1] is a webapp which you open in the browser. Oasis (like nearly all SSB clients) is a JavaScript package which you can install via npm. [1] https://github.com/fraction/oasis https://github.com/fraction/oasis
- arj 6y agoThere is a browser based demo you can try out at: https://between-two-worlds.dk/ https://between-two-worlds.dk/. It's the latest build of https://github.com/arj03/ssb-browser-demo https://github.com/arj03/ssb-browser-demo. If you need an id to follow to get some data, you can try following @6CAxOI3f+LUOVrbAl0IemqiS7ATpQvr9Mdw9LC4+Uv0=.ed25519. You need to manually add either a room or a pub under connections first.
- black_puppydog 6y agoI think this comment comes closest to the "correct" answer here: > It's p2p, no webapps. That is to say, this is not a "service" that you use, so there is no scuttlebutt.com where you just sign up. The software running the replication, and the storage backing it, will be local. Insofar you will always eventually want to run this locally. Now, of course some fine folks are working around that with modern web tech (see @arj's sibling comment) but the whole idea of this project is that you will locally control your data.
- dgellow 6y agoIt’s also available on mobile: https://www.manyver.se/ https://www.manyver.se/
- that_guy_iain 6y agoThat landing page needs a text TL;DR; explaination and not just a video explaination.
- pluc 6y agoMake a goddamn effort
- johnnyfaehell 6y agoMake a goddamn effort to figure out why someone's project is worth time investigating? Literally, that landing page has a video and links to articles. I don't want to spend minutes watching an ad. I went to the about page and read the info I should have read next to the video and understood what was what in 10 seconds. Expecting people to make an effort to find out if a product/project is useful to them is basically asking not to have as many users. Basically, you just wasted your time building the product.
- pluc 6y agoIf you're relying on Marketing to tell you what's worth your time then you must be one sad sad person. Read the documentation, if you're here you're pretending to be a technical person. Be a technical person.
- johnnyfaehell 6y agoSome of us value our time. And this is not a techincal project it's an end user project. So as an end user I want to know quickly if it's worth my time. Even on a techincal project I want to know a rough overview within a minute or so of reading. Marketing is all about giving people the info they need fast. Marketing is about selling the benefits and telling of the pains it solves. If you're unable to do that for your project, why did you build it? And I think the person who spends their time reading techincal documentation to decide if a social network is worth using is probably sadder than the person who goes and reads the about page. Not got much else to do?
- 6y ago
- kitotik 6y agoOne of the cool features of SSB is making actual P2P a first-class feature. It works just as well on an isolated private adhoc network as it does over the web. I wish more dencentralized/federated services operated this way.
- vlmutolo 6y agoMatrix is making p2p a first-class feature, and how they’re doing it is pretty simple. They’re just embedding a “homeserver” right onto the user device alongside the client. With the new fast homeserver efforts, like Dendrite and Conduit, this suddenly becomes feasible.
- jlkuester7 6y agoJust as a reference for anyone else like me who was not familiar with this effort: https://matrix.org/blog/2020/06/02/introducing-p-2-p-matrix https://matrix.org/blog/2020/06/02/introducing-p-2-p-matrix
- toxik 6y agoI got the app Manyverse, now what?
- hjacobs 6y agoYou need to connect with others. I think Manyverse is best used with SSB rooms where you can find others (to connect/follow), see https://github.com/staltz/ssb-room/blob/master/FAQ.md https://github.com/staltz/ssb-room/blob/master/FAQ.md Alternative is a Pub, but joining a Pub is not so great with Manyverse as it will download a lot of content to your mobile phone.
- iuguy 6y agoThis really isn't a good space for most of the people here on HN. SSB is very much a work in progress. When I first started trying to use the Patchwork client, lots of SSB Pubs were down. It took 3 days to get to a point where I could see people. While censorship isn't directly possible, it's not really in the kind of state suitable for lots of people currently departing existing social networks and looking for something new. I'm not saying there isn't potential. Even for the average HN user it's possibly ready to try but not yet ready for mainstream use.
- dash2 6y agoIt's kind of funny to think that decentralised apps, built by idealistic Silicon Valley hackers, now have a potential core audience among extreme MAGA types.
- vmh1928 6y agoIn Germany the government used census data tabulated on IBM punchcard equipment to find who to round up. Later, during the liquidation phase of the effort each camp had punch card equipment to help with maintaining the inventory of slave labor skills. That's what the number on the arm was for - the primary key. Copies of punched cards were sent to the central administrative HQ of the camp organization for additional processing and were used to identify specific skilled people who needed to be moved to other camps. Authoritarians rely on the stupid for the grunt work but they're not stupid themselves and can exploit technology to achieve their goals.
- AndrewUnmuted 6y agoGiven their past, I found it just a little rich, that IBM so publicly decried the recent "insurrection." [0] [0] https://twitter.com/ArvindKrishna/status/1346932293991079936 https://twitter.com/ArvindKrishna/status/1346932293991079936
- spockz 6y agoWell the IBM of today has little to do with the IBM of 80 years ago. Just like the Germany of today has little to do with what happened 80 years ago and people living now are not and should not be held responsible for the misdeeds of previous generations.
- AndrewUnmuted 6y ago> people living now are not and should not be held responsible for the misdeeds of previous generations. I'm sure we could all agree on this point. However, the aspects of IBM that led to their assisting the Third Reich are still very much alive at IBM today. It remains in the form of their core business model of assisting the world's most powerful regimes in automating oppression, autocracy, and authoritarianism at a global scale.
- joshuakelly 6y agoSSB is such a wonderful idea. There’s no global timeline — just archipelagos. It assumes that network heterogeny is the default, and is transmission layer agnostic. Breakages will occur. Maybe you’re living on a catamaran in the South Pacific and you only have connectivity once a month — SSB will work even then. Your own timeline is a sigchain — a sequenced list of signed messages. You replicate the content in your network (2 hops away). Bridges between communities can be built or burned. Many islands can exist without needing to erase the others from even existing — mutual separation is possible. Consensus is not necessary. Is global network culture still possible? If it is, in the midst of the national internets we now live inside of, I suspect it will look something like this. A little different from what we were promised, but maybe a little better too.
- lgierth 6y agoFounder actually lives on a boat in NZ
- joshuakelly 6y agoThat’s where that reference comes from of course :)
- sytse 6y agoAnd maybe also SSB, which also stands for Single Side Band and is a way to get data over marine radio.
- instakill 6y agoDo you have links to expounded, introductory writing? I'd love to look into this type of architecture and play around with other domains.
- joshuakelly 6y agoFor a look at SSB in particular, I would strong recommend the protocol guide — it explains the core ideas quite well, which I think are broadly applicable to future networks of this pattern: https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide/ https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide/
- umvi 6y agoSo is this basically like YikYak?
- pantalaimon 6y agonot at all - doesn't YikYak rely on a central server?
- adkadskhj 6y agoI absolutely love the simplicity of Scuttlebutt, but the APIs and (dev)user extensibility are anything but, imo. I hope for continued work there. As an example, i wanted to write an application on top of SSB. I found it difficult to determine _how_ to achieve this though. Conceptually the appendlog is stupid simple, but SSB still has meaningful complexity in the secure handshake implementation. While they do have libs, it mostly seemed JavaScript (NodeJS) was the only meaningfully complete lib to use (where as i am on Rust). I also found it difficult to determine what the network would accept. If i write an app and start pushing blobs onto the network, will they reject it because they're not of the same type? What if my data is too big? Am i abusing the net? I also had difficulty conceptualizing how to write app data in SSB. It felt like i needed to abandon SQL or common application interfaces for data. Having to reinvent wheels in the application code because SSB-data is mostly (i think?) a JSON blob store felt bad. Shared identities also proved to be a bit of a blocker. Since the app i was writing wanted multiple devices to author data the notion of a device identity came up, and at the time that didn't seem well (or at all) supported. I didn't want to invent my own mechanism that would later seem invalid to the community. For now i decided to hold off and implement my own SSB friendly data storage mechanism. Since i know the data layer of SSB is simple, and SSB folks have proven it can handle Git fine (they distribute their source in SSB iirc). I imagine my own data later will plug into SSB without issue. These aren't critiques of SSB exactly, just highlighting some areas (for anyone interested) where SSB is currently weak in my mind. I love SSB. Even if i end up using an entirely different p2p tech stack than SSB, it has changed my way of thinking on this. What SSB does right is everything that i dislike about IPFS. SSB is small, simple tooling. It feels like Git. Not some huge complex network of IPFS nodes, but 2 people, 3 people. It can work over P2P, email, floppy disk. It can be more, but it also can be less. And that's something more projects could adopt.
- pmayrgundter 6y agoThanks for the analysis. Have you checked out Matrix? I'm looking for a p2p network layer and am most attracted to it so far but haven't used any of them yet
- adkadskhj 6y ago
- VectorLock 6y agoI always thought this would be really fun to run over ham radio.
- grey_earthling 6y agoIMO scuttlebutt's mood can be summed up by https://coolguy.website/the-future-will-be-technical/ https://coolguy.website/the-future-will-be-technical/
- gdsdfe 6y agoHaven't tried it yet but can someone clarify whether it's possible to discover sub-communities or you have to be explicitly 'invited' to those ?
- StavrosK 6y agoHow do I get started with SSB? I've downloaded Manyverse probably six times now, and then got blocked on "find something to join somewhere, good luck!". Does anyone have a community? Otherwise I'll make one for HN. EDIT: Join me: hnpub.stavros.io:38213:@PJtGRbz9IwtobscVq+i4a8y0zZBc2j220D5jsoyKgaw=.ed25519~OezW1tkZu9dX/x7uhDLL/7m5xUosz68NeoqfDjhnYXQ=
- Groxx 6y agoHistorically, I got sizable streams of posts by joining a couple pubs. None of which are offered in Manyverse, for good or bad. (definitely un-ideal for first-time users, but it does at least avoid overloading or over-promoting some) The "get started" docs on the website do walk you through it though, e.g. https://scuttlebutt.nz/get-started/#step-3-get-connected https://scuttlebutt.nz/get-started/#step-3-get-connected -> this smallish list of pubs: https://github.com/ssbc/ssb-server/wiki/Pub-Servers https://github.com/ssbc/ssb-server/wiki/Pub-Servers . You'll automatically discover more as you pull other people's content. --- I did join yours via Manyverse, but tbh I'm surprised that viewing your pub doesn't show member join/leaves, and I haven't seen any posts yet (I've made one). Have you made any? Could it be having problems perhaps? (edit: and shortly after posting this, now I see some stuff, after around 45m. So my initial minorish-complaint about Manyverse from a year or so ago is still around: it doesn't tell you what it's doing. Patchwork was much better about that, though it kinda looked like constant thrashing.)
- StavrosK 6y agoI agree with you, I don't really understand what Manyverse is doing. I see posts, but I don't know if they come from the pub, or from following someone directly, or what. I see four posts that I think are from the pub, but if you don't see them they might not be. I also see someone's stream, and I'm not sure why... All in all, it's very confusing.
- Groxx 6y agoYep. It's intentionally a bit of a minimal client, to make things more mobile friendly, and... it sorta works out. If you want to see more detail and higher quality, definitely try Patchwork. For manyverse in particular: if it doesn't show something you think it should, or it says it's indexing, give it a while. Like, a lot of while. After the database got a bit large and something got confused and caused a rebuild, it took over 30 minutes to recover. But it does actually recover.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoIs use of Javascript a requirement.
- jwalton 6y agoI really like the idea of Scuttlebutt. I think there are a couple of things it needs on top of what it already has; Right now, your public key is who you are, which I think is a mistake. It's easy to imagine a world where we have a "web of trust" solution here, where you can scan someone's public key from a QR code straight off their phone, and then sign said key so other people who trust you know that the key is legit. Then you could use that key to sign future keys, allowing easy key rotation. It would also be easy to post a message signed with your private key that revokes a key and all messages it has authored/all keys it has signed. I also think there needs to be multiple transports for posting content - if I want to send a message to my buddy Dan, I should be able to send it directly to him if he's online. If he isn't, though, I should be able to let other users whom we both know grab a copy to pass on to him later, or maybe have a "deaddrop" server or a "pub" where I can stash messages and have them get picked up by someone else later. It needs a top-notch client, too. Something to compete with Facebook and Twitter. But it's a very promising start, and it's the way this needs to go if we're ever going to escape the surveillance players in this industry - we need a social network that's truly distributed, based on open standards that anyone can implement.
- Groxx 6y ago>I also think there needs to be multiple transports for posting content - if I want to send a message to my buddy Dan, I should be able to send it directly to him if he's online. If he isn't, though, I should be able to let other users whom we both know grab a copy to pass on to him later, or maybe have a "deaddrop" server or a "pub" where I can stash messages and have them get picked up by someone else later. Scuttlebutt is built around enabling this as a (the?) primary feature. It's not just "supported", the entire ecosystem does this by design. It even calls that kind of server "pubs" (they're normal peers, they just auto-follow anyone who asks).
- tyfon 6y agoI see this is append only[1], so my biggest question is really if you are following someone that posts illegal content like child porn, is it stuck on your profile forever or can you somehow remove it? [1] https://ssbc.github.io/ssb-db/ https://ssbc.github.io/ssb-db/
- nanomonkey 6y agoBlob storage (images and other binary media) is stored in your file-system utilizing it's content addressable hash as a filename. You can delete these at any time. The append only log is for json messages, which will make reference to the hashes of the blobs through markdown. So, the message referencing the illegal content can't be removed without removing the user's whole ledger, but the content can be removed at any time.
- tyfon 6y agoAh, but that's good enough. The system is interesting I was just afraid of people having the ability to "brick" your account so to speak by sending illegal stuff to it. If I can effectively delete the other user (ledger) completely from my system that would also be good :)
- sor1nmarkov 6y ago@realdonaldtrump can install it on Hilary's mail servers
- russdpale 6y agoIll be honest, convincing my friends to sign up for this seems futile.
- thinkyfish 6y agoI feel like shared blocklists will become an emergent feature of this platform, as it inevitably will be used for planning violent/illegal activities and harassment, and I feel that pubs and individuals would want a way to combat such things to promote more focused membership (for topic forums for example). There will be ident wars where blocked individuals will then create new idents which have to be identified and blocked and so on, and there is little other than not inviting people to prevent this. The basic infrastructure of forum moderation seems possible, but I think automated/subscribable block lists would become a standardized feature of clients.