17 ms·
Turchin's two main ideas are intriguing. a) 50 years is enough for "institutional memory" to go out of the window. This may change with longevity breakthroughs
by inglor_cz 6y ago
Turchin's two main ideas are intriguing.
a) 50 years is enough for "institutional memory" to go out of the window. This may change with longevity breakthroughs, but 50 years is currently enough for a complete generation exchange, so the new leaders have no memory of the previous upheaval and will make the same mistakes again. Or at least the same kind of mistakes, details are always different.
b) elite overproduction is a "dangerous" topic when even treading on this ground invites charges of anti-intellectualism, but I cannot help looking at the 25+ crowd with fresh degrees, tons of debt and not-precisely-excellent earning opportunities and see that universities have a great racket out of this, while their graduates not so much. If you apply the old "Cui prodest?" question (Romans used to ask "Who profits?"), the answer would be that tertiary education complex is at least as influential as the military industrial complex, and most of the value captured does not even accrue to professors.
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y ago> a) 50 years is enough for "institutional memory" to go out of the window. This may change with longevity breakthroughs, but 50 years is currently enough for a complete generation exchange, so the new leaders have no memory of the previous upheaval and will make the same mistakes again. Or at least the same kind of mistakes, details are always different. That's why education is the most important pillar of democracy. Education is everything.
- inglor_cz 6y ago"That's why education is the most important pillar of democracy. Education is everything. " The kind of people who get into positions of power - well, my impression is that they think they know better. Even if they are aware of the fact that in 1930 someone fucked up, they will not entertain the fact that they themselves might do the same. Also, some events are really complex. You can educate people about the 1929 or 2008 economic crises from very different perspectives, from far-left to libertarian, and the lessons will be very different.
- jsmcgd 6y agoI think that's why an education has to be broad. A selective education can be tantamount to brainwashing/propaganda. Give the students as many perspectives and hope that they will do something sensible as they process the information; knowing that not all will, but most. I believe that the more perspectives you are aware of, the less likely you are to be dogmatic and extreme in your beliefs and actions. You will be reminded how dissimilar real life is to simple ideas and rhetoric, that it is a shifting ocean of nuances and caveats. Or society can go the other route, assume you cannot trust the people and create a tyranny of disinformation and control.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago> Give the students as many perspectives and hope that they will do something sensible as they process the information I don’t know if you’ve gone to college recently but that was not my impression. It’s a woke monoculture. Discourse is gone.
- SantalBlush 6y agoDiscourse is narrower than you'd like; that doesn't mean it's "gone". When someone makes extraordinary claims like "Discourse is gone," that is a red flag that they are not viewing the situation objectively.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoPrecisely demonstrating my point: a hyper-sensitivity and censorious attitude against any advocacy for unmitigated debate.
- SantalBlush 6y agoYou are calling my disagreement a "censorious attitude." Sorry, but I am allowed to disagree with you.
- 6y ago
- iguy 6y agoAnd the type of education surely matters. If the goal is to break through this 50-year horizon, then presumably an important part is to really get inside the heads of people at least that long ago. Not to just translate our quarrels & concerns backwards, but rather to stay immersed in the issues of (say) 1920 long enough to feel what was important to people of the time.
- thewindowmovie5 6y ago...
- thewindowmovie5 6y agoAgree. I think the current crisis in US is because of lack of education and the whitewashing or omitting of important events in history. Just yesterday I saw a comment in here adding that deejays now have control of all three branches of the government(which was obviously false) and that was dangerous. But i guess the poster had no idea about what the three branches of the government.
- roenxi 6y agoI dunno, there are a lot of countries famous for their education which are nevertheless not ideal places to go. Culture might be a more important aspect than education. Education is relatively easy to transplant (c.f. China & the rest of Asia, or the US stealing many of Germany's good scientists after WWII, or the Brits leaching French expertise after the revolution). Culture is really hard to transplant because nobody knows which are the good bits and which are the bad bits. I'll throw these two in because I they are an interesting and relevant example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marc_Isambard_Brunel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marc_Isambard_Brunel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isambard_Kingdom_Brunel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isambard_Kingdom_Brunel
- iguy 6y agoThese examples are of technical education. German rocket scientists, and British blast-furnace wizards (to France). These things are important of course but seem orthogonal to political institutional memory. Scholars deeply steeped in Bismark's thoughts & mistakes, or in English constitutional law, didn't make these jumps.
- paganel 6y ago> or in English constitutional law Carl Schmitt did in fact made the jump, and he's one of the most read constitutional law writers in the last century. Not sure if Max Weber would have done the same, most probably not (he was really versed in English constitutional law, his "Economy and Society" has lots of quotes to Maitland's "History of English Law"), but he didn't strike me as a fervent supporter of democracy rights either. And there was also the definite jump made by Heidegger, not exactly a legal scholar but a very well-read person nonetheless (and a mentor to Hannah Arendt, among others).
- Der_Einzige 6y agoNot just mentor, he was her boyfriend!!! And an ironic situation, given his nazi ties and her jewishness...
- 6y ago
- anewaccount2021 6y agoThis is what I would expect a technocratic forum like HN to suggest. America's most poverty stricken regions have had public education for nearly a century with almost no meaningful improvement in prospects. Tell me how rural poverty in West Viriginia is reduced by giving people humanities degrees. Better educated voters? Who cares, the poor have no representation of merit anyway; their choices are to vote for one party who ignores them or the other that ignores them.
- eloff 6y agoPublic education in the US is awful and lags nearly the entire developed world. Humanities degrees are not terribly useful, but boiling all education down to humanities degrees is a blatant strawman that signals a lot about your willingness to have a nuanced discussion. I think it's fairly self evident that investment in the future is what improves the future and education is probably the most important and significant such investment.
- inglor_cz 6y agoGood education system does not neatly translate to, say, economic success. Italy has top-class university system, much older than Columbus, and yet the country seems to be stuck in stagnation for last 20 years and the talented fresh graduates of those top schools move abroad.
- eloff 6y agoI would say it's one very important factor among others. Ray Dalio outlines many of the factors involved in nations rising and falling, including education in a freely available online book. I've found it an interesting read, although he takes a while to get to the point.[1] [1] https://www.principles.com/the-changing-world-order/ https://www.principles.com/the-changing-world-order/
- j0ba 6y ago> Good education system does not neatly translate to, say, economic success. If you think anyone said that, you should probably talk less and read more. Because it doesn't appear you're competent in either. Education is necessary but not sufficient.
- AniseAbyss 6y agoEducation doesn't work when people only watch their propaganda media. And when your entire social and professional circle is in the cult good luck breaking out.
- brightball 6y agoThis is basically the Old Testament IMO. Same mistakes over and over, separated by a couple of generations once one generation gets comfortable.
- krona 6y ago"The road to hell is paved with Ivy League degrees."
- graeme 6y agoEducation is not experience. It can help deal with situations similar to the past but it is far from sufficient to make up for the 50 year problem.
- kortilla 6y agoYet education does not help. Being told about the events does not really capture the emotions that lead to them. Education is the reason the details are different but fundamentally nothing gets prevented.
- cmurf 6y agoJosh Hawley, Ted Cruz, Matt Gaetz, and John Kennedy, are among the most educated in Congress. And yet are the most self-serving, craven, mendacious, and anti-democratic to have served in the modern era. What evidence is there that education applied any constraint on them? Where does good character come from?
- redis_mlc 6y agoI'll add this brief comment as a reference in case anybody wants to research it more. There are 20-year cycles that I've heard of recently. For Cultural Marxism in the US, 1970, 1990, 2010. Those are roughly the generational periods of new counter-cultural US university professors. There's also a related cycle starting with Betty Friedan's Marxist-Feminist book, The Feminine Mystique, in 1963 and each generation after of about 20 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betty_Friedan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betty_Friedan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Feminine_Mystique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Feminine_Mystique When Marxism, Marxist Feminism and CRT and BLM overlap, you get the amplification and extremism you see in the left in 2020, like AOC being an elected yet open Marxist, and antifa fascists.
- orange_tee 6y agoThe way I understood it, elite overproduction is about successful wealthy people, not enjoying the political influence that they believed they would enjoy after attaining their wealth.
- flybrand 6y agoIdle hands among those who have far reach will eventually do things that lead to conflict.
- simonh 6y agoIt’s not really about wealth or political power specifically. It’s about status and power generally. Some of the pseudo-elite may pursue wealth, others social status, others political influence, etc. These are largely fungible though, so the problem is when you overproduce the elite class generally, all of these go into deficit.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoTaking b) and running with it, education is, in my opinion, the silver bullet for a number of societies ills. It's very interesting to note how higher education in the US has such a high barrier to entry that it actively discourages outsiders. It feels as if the Australian Government wants to move in the same direction, and / or have already been doing so for a few years. Education has its own benefits to society as a whole, therefore we all suffer when a majority are locked out of pursuits that require and encourage depth of thought and logical thinking.
- onethought 6y agoTrue, if you are on the right (political spectrum) you do not want to encourage higher education, it shifts people to the left, as analytical thinking starts undoing idealism. US is a good example of this, with most universities having more left communities around them. Perhaps it is an intentional long play by the Right in Australia to pursue this kind of minimisation of education
- loopz 6y agoYou could say that analytical thinking undo gullibility. Idealism and principles though, may better be understood, applied and defended, with well-rounded education.
- onethought 6y agoGood point. I think that is a better way to describe what I mean
- WatchDog 6y agoI don't think analytical thinking has anything to do with political leaning, I'd argue that the US higher education system particularly the humanities is a breeding ground of idealogues. I would say the tendency of education to lean left is largely due to left leaning people being more attracted to working in academia.
- 6y ago
- watwut 6y agoElite in pollitical sense does not equal "someone with college degree".
- yyyk 6y agoTurchin (not in the linked article, but elsewhere[0]) explicitly refers to rise in number of underemployed graduates as a trigger for the creation of a counter-Elite. [0] http://peterturchin.com/cliodynamica/the-storming-of-the-u-s-capitol/ http://peterturchin.com/cliodynamica/the-storming-of-the-u-s... "Elite overproduction, and especially overproduction of the youth with advanced degrees, continues unabated. Our institutions of higher education have been churning out law, MBA, and PhD degrees, many more than could be absorbed by the economy. In a Bloomberg View article published just a few days ago Noah Smith provides the numbers for the overproduction of PhDs (America Is Pumping Out Too Many Ph.D.s)."
- satellite2 6y agoI think, it's an interesting model, and would probably work all else being equal. But in that case, I believe he misses one critical variable. We are much less violent than 50 years ago because kid beating largely went out of fashion.
- inglor_cz 6y ago"We are much less violent than 50 years ago" I would say that the population is, on average, much older and has more to lose. Fortysomethings do not regularly engage in street chaos. This is even more visible in Europe, even in formerly violent places like the Balkans or Northern Ireland. Once the share of the young hotheads in the population drops, you have much smaller probability of really serious riots.
- watwut 6y agoYoung people are less violent then they used to be. It is not just about their share in population, they behave less violently then young people 50 years ago.
- flybrand 6y agoPeople who are less violent can easily become violent because they don’t understand the cost and destruction of force escalation.
- watwut 6y agoAfaik, generations that grew up in violent times are more violent then those who grew up in peaceful times. Being used to violence, seeing it and/or being traumatized by it offsets whatever lack seeing the cost does.
- vladTheInhaler 6y agoReally the violent people are the actual pacifists, and the peaceful ones are secretly capable of great violence? [CITATION NEEDED]
- neartheplain 6y agoPerhaps unfortunately, 50 years might not be long enough for generational turnover in US government. Joe Biden and Mitch McConnell are both 78 years old. Nancy Pelosi is 80. Senators Diane Feinstein and Chuck Grassley are 87.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoIt's 48 years since Joe Biden became a senator, and he was one of the youngest senators ever. None of those people held a national-level office 50 years ago. There has been a complete turnover in leadership in the past 50 years.
- jessaustin 6y agoWhew, thank goodness! I'd hate to see centenarians in Congress!
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoThe new Georgia senator is the youngest elected senator since Biden. That was... an odd factoid to take in for me.
- paganel 6y ago>at the 25+ crowd with fresh degrees, tons of debt and not-precisely-excellent earning opportunities There are numerous studies and theories saying that late 19th-early 20th century revolutions wouldn't have happened if they hadn't been coordinated by educated people who hadn't found a stable job (mostly as government employees, not that many private white-collar jobs back then). The Russian revolution definitely wouldn't have happened without university-educated Lenin and Trotsky, and I'd say that even Stalin falls under "educated but with no stable job" umbrella (if I'm not mistaken he had gone to a priest seminary). In my country (Romania) most of the inter-war intellectuals had turned extremists for exactly that reason, i.e. too few white-collar jobs to chase for people who had finished university. The most well-known examples are guys like Eliade or Cioran, but a more relevant one is Corneliu Zelea-Codreanu [1], which is currently well liked by some people in the US [2] and in Northern Italy [3]. A very relevant book on the subject can be found here [4], unfortunately for the time being with no English translation. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corneliu_Zelea_Codreanu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corneliu_Zelea_Codreanu [2] https://www.chicagotribune.com/nation-world/ct-charlottesville-college-campuses-20170818-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/nation-world/ct-charlottesvil... [3] https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2018/11/20/news/lealta_azione_documentario_sky-212139492/ https://www.repubblica.it/cronaca/2018/11/20/news/lealta_azi... [4] https://www.amazon.com/Limitele-Meritocratiei-Intro-Societate-Romanian/dp/973465148X https://www.amazon.com/Limitele-Meritocratiei-Intro-Societat...
- inglor_cz 6y agoHello fellow Central European :-) In interwar Czechoslovakia, we had quite a few intellectuals who were openly Stalinist.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anewaccount2021 6y agoAll of the Bolsheviks were well-read. Even their token thug, Stalin, was probably reading political theory at what we would describe as a doctoral level. While Lenin did not respect Stalin as an intellectual peer, we do know that he spent a great deal of time pouring over dense political tomes. No TV, radio, internet...people read books to entertain themselves. But, to put a fine point on it, the Russian Revolution happened without Lenin or Trotsky. The Bolsheviks overthrew the February Revolution in a coup.
- throw0101a 6y agoSamuel Huntington observed 'convulsions' every 60 years in American history: > American history is driven by periodic moments of moral convulsion. The late Harvard political scientist Samuel P. Huntington noticed that these convulsions seem to hit the United States every 60 years or so: the Revolutionary period of the 1760s and ’70s; the Jacksonian uprising of the 1820s and ’30s; the Progressive Era, which began in the 1890s; and the social-protest movements of the 1960s and early ’70s. * https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/10/collapsing-levels-trust-are-devastating-america/616581/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/10/collapsing... The 2020s was about when the US was 'due' for something to happen, so the next decade or so will apparently be a bit of a ride.
- wwweston 6y agoI feel like there's an important data point overlooked in the 1860s?
- SantalBlush 6y agoNot to mention the labor upheavals of the early 20th century.
- dehrmann 6y agoHow was the the revolutionary period "moral convulsion?" Political, sure, but not moral.
- marcusverus 6y agoThe widespread adoption of the civil libertarian ethos (under the guise of unalienable rights, endowed by a creator) might be the greatest moral convulsion in human history.
- vulcan01 6y ago> civil libertarian ethos People living in the colonies already had this. When Parliament started asserting more control over the colonies, they fought to restore their control over government.
- mcshicks 6y agoI read Turchin's Secular Cycle where he goes over the data sets he uses to draw these conclusions on earlier societies. While the things he's trying to measure are not easy (for instance he uses the number and dates of found coin hoards as a relative measure of instability in England), the amount of data is pretty impressive. I actually gave up after he did all the data on England and skipped France, the Islamic Empires and I think there was one other society, and went to the conclusion. I haven't read "Age of Discord" yet, but it looks like he has a pretty detailed summary here. http://peterturchin.com/age-of-discord/ http://peterturchin.com/age-of-discord/
- rossdavidh 6y agoI realize this is what you meant but just want to clarify that Turchin did not skip the data for France, the Islamic empires, etc. He covers each one in some depth.
- mcshicks 6y agoYes sorry that's exactly what I meant. He had me convinced at the first few sets of data.
- andrew_ 6y agoWithin the professions that make up "tech" 10 years is enough time for institutional memory to go out the window.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoWell except certain groups within Apple, TSMC, the big japanese corps, IBM mainframes, and lesser known places.
- BurningFrog 6y agoAre you saying most tech people only spend~10 years in the industry? That's much less than what I would think. But maybe I misunderstand. It happens regularly :)
- AniseAbyss 6y agoYeah we have fascists in Germany again. People forget. And who the fuck really reads history books anyways?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bjourne 6y agoB) is a myth. Statistics show consistently and over and over that those who do the best in the US are the college-educated. Media is produced by the college-educated so it is their class' problems gets the most attention but it is clearly not their problems that are the worst. It's all those who were too dumb or too socially disadvantaged to get a higher education what will be SOL in the future. Those who voted for Trump and will vote either for him or his successor in 2024.
- erichocean 6y ago> tertiary education complex is at least as influential as the military industrial complex If you gave me full control (on the sly, so they maintained the role they currently have) of Harvard, Yale, NYT, and WaPo—I wouldn't care who held the Presidency or sat in Congress, and the military is a distant afterthought. All would follow my dictates to the letter and I would be able to entirely transform every aspect of the country. So who, again, is in power? Votes (and by extension, voters) don't matter because they do not affect actual power. It's kayfabe on a grand scale.
- vmception 6y agoyes but how many false positives are there from other clairvoyants and how many of those have just as succinct rational