7 ms·
I like PeerTube, but the really important part of the puzzle is the advertiser network. What makes YouTube special is that Google takes care of the advertising
by roenxi 6y ago
I like PeerTube, but the really important part of the puzzle is the advertiser network. What makes YouTube special is that Google takes care of the advertising side of things and makes it easy for people to monetise.
If Silicon Valley continues to drift into ideological activism, at some point a hugely profitable opportunity to set up a new advertising network develops.
- tamrix 6y agoDo people forget that for many years since the founding of YouTube, YouTube didn't have any video ads? The better question is, was not having ads on the YouTube platform a deliberate choice to help grow adoption over its competitors which would have had to have ads to run (at the time) the expensive servers?
- tachyonbeam 6y agoThere already are other networks. There's AppNexus in New York for one. I don't know if they are as strict with their requirements as Google. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AppNexus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AppNexus
- roenxi 6y agoI'll re-put what I'm thinking: The technology behind the fediverse is an important brick, so PeerTube 3 is interesting. But the house will only be liveable when someone figures out how companies like AppNexus integrate profitably and successfully into the fediverse.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- qwantim1 6y agoI don’t agree. It’s an important thing, not the important thing. This is a great alternative to sharing large video files with others by having someone else just watch what they want of it, if you want to ensure it’s more permanent than- let’s say- Google Music. If the fear is that an evil Google competitor will come along that will do more damage- this wouldn’t enable that. That would take a serious amount of funding and technology, not a free clone of YouTube without all of the infrastructural backing.
- judge2020 6y agoThat's kind of an issue then - YouTube is only partly (probably a single-digit-percent given they dropped the direct share feature[0]) about sharing videos with friends - most people stick around for the recommendations, ie. the endless stream of interesting/intriguing/funny content. Most of that content currently dominating YT (at least, at the quantity that it's produced) is only possible due to these creators making YouTube their full-time job and getting paid to do it. Linus Tech Tips (which also runs Techquickie and Techlinked) attributes 26% of their total revenue to YT Ads[1], and the other categories (like merchandise/affiliate links) aren't something everyone can do if their videos aren't about products available on Amazon or can't grow their merch at the rate LTT does. If PT is just about sharing videos, then you might as well run a nextcloud instance instead since 'no ads' is a huge downside to PT for creators. 0: https://techcrunch.com/2019/08/21/youtube-is-closing-its-private-messages-feature-and-many-kids-are-outraged/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/08/21/youtube-is-closing-its-pri... 1: https://youtu.be/-zt57TWkTF4?t=395 https://youtu.be/-zt57TWkTF4?t=395
- BlueTemplar 6y agoYou're forgetting about donations / patronage, which everyone can do and I'm willing to bet has been growing in share for the past years.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoI'm pretty sure that one of the main reasons that YouTube 'won' is that it was easy to just share these videos with friends/family, and also straightforward to enable/disable public sharing of them. I've never even heard of that 'direct share' feature, but have used the private and unreferenced settings on my videos many times over the years.
- Iv 6y agoI agree, but think it is the creators retribution piece that is important, and that it does not have to take the form of advertisement.
- tedunangst 6y agoThe only web advertising I ever see is from Daring Fireball precisely because it doesn't come from an ad network.
- marcinzm 6y ago>If Silicon Valley continues to drift into ideological activism, at some point a hugely profitable opportunity to set up a new advertising network develops. YouTube started moderating it's content more because advertisers asked for it. No large advertiser wants to be shown next to a neo-nazi video.
- roenxi 6y agoAbout 33% of the US actively supported Trump's bid for presidency, and accounting for turnout probably a majority didn't care if he got back in. Accounting for business owners likely leaning free-market, it seems improbable that they mean 'Trump supporters' when they say 'we don't want to advertise with neo-nazis'. They probably mean literal neo-nazi. I don't mind if literal neo-nazi are moderated off a channel. Nobody likes them.
- marcinzm 6y agoLook at all the types of videos YouTube de-monetizes, do you think YouTube wants to pay for hosting and make no money on the videos? No, that's all the types of videos that large advertisers (which pay the most) have complained about over time.
- roenxi 6y agoOf course they want to, that is why they are doing it. They'd prefer to keep the network effects going because they know an exodus would undermine their for-pay videos. If they weren't happy, they would delete the videos on demonetisation. They don't have to pay for hosting. They know these videos are drawing in a valuable audience.
- YZF 6y agoWhat's a literal neo-nazi? I guess nazis who aren't declaring their support for Hitler are not "literal" neo-nazis and are ok? I mean where you draw that line? Nobody likes them? Lots of people like them.
- nyolfen 6y ago
- wilsynet 6y agoIs it ideological activism to enforce the terms of service which prohibit the incitement of violence?
- toolz 6y agoTo directly answer your question, I would say no - however it is ideological activism to only enforce those ToS for specific services. The #killallmen hashtag has trended more than once on twitter, for example.
- wilsynet 6y agoAgreed. Twitter should enforce this more consistently.
- toolz 6y agoI would suggest in this specific incidence they are enforcing it very consistently in that they aren't punishing anyone for inciting that particular type of violence.
- cortesoft 6y agoSure, but no one has actually tried to kill all men. They didn't do this latest action until after people were actually killed by the violence incited.
- roenxi 6y agoThat is giving "kill all men" a metaphorical reading. That is a fair reading, it probably isn't actually a call to violence, they just feel frustrated about something. The issue is that a fair reading is not being applied evenly. Twitter interprets "To all of those who have asked, I will not be going to the Inauguration on January 20th" [0] as a call to violence. That isn't even close to a fair metaphorical reading, and it was probably meant literally. [0] https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspension.html https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspensio...
- jrnichols 6y ago> but the really important part of the puzzle is the advertiser network If your main goal is "How can I make money?" then maybe. And that's one of the huge reasons that YouTube is the mess that it is. For the rest of us, this is not important at all. In fact, I am happy that there is no advertiser network whatsoever. if I put something on the web, I do not do it because I expect compensation. I am not alone in this sentiment.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoMost content creators need to be compensated to continue making content. Advertising isn't the only solution but it does allow viewers to watch without paying. PeerTube needs content creators to get on board. Having options for monetizing content could encourage creators to use PeerTube.
- papaf 6y agoMost content creators need to be compensated to continue making content. Most videos are made by professionals? That's not my experience.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoAt this point I wouldn't be surprised if most video views were made on content whose creators are at least trying to make a living out of it.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoThat might have been a problem a few years ago, but by now many content creators are not solely relying on advertising money (which itself was prompted by YouTube fucking up).
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Most content creators need to be compensated to continue making content. That's the problem right there. "Content creators". Protein factories churning out videos for money. Not every platform needs "content creators" - sometimes people with interesting things to share are enough, and these tend to use side revenue to fund their sharing.
- cortesoft 6y agoHow is it going to be a profitable opportunity? No brand wants to be associated with the content that is being blocked, so there is no advertiser demand for alternative platforms.
- mhuffman 6y agoI think you will find that if there are eyeballs, there are brands interested in advertising. Examples include: The Pirate Bay, 4chan, pornhub, etc.
- pixl97 6y agoProfitable how? If it is not moderated, it will just be filled with spam, porn, and insane rambling. If it is moderated it can be attacked and/or controlled. It's a lose/lose situation.
- anigbrowl 6y agoEnough advertising already. There have to be better ways to monetize things than turning everything into a billboard. I'm willing to pay for stuff, but I'll fight tooth and nail against being advertised to. Besides the unwanted cognitive load it imposes, advertisers want feedback and that means they're incentivized to invade my privacy as well as intrude upon my attention.
- berkes 6y ago> If Silicon Valley continues to drift into ideological activism Just to be clear (and pedantic): Peertube is French. One could see these fediversed projects as counter-SV, actually. Not 'coming from SV', but attacking the SV status quo.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoIndeed, they are staunchly anti-GAFAM † : https://degooglisons-internet.org/en/ https://degooglisons-internet.org/en/ And have pretty much became a reference for libre alternatives : https://degooglisons-internet.org/en/alternatives https://degooglisons-internet.org/en/alternatives † By the way it's a very SV thing to do to think that everything revolves around SV, and therefore excluding Microsoft from the list of the problematic companies. (And including Netflix, which is problematic in its own ways, but at least an order of magnitude less than the "big 5".) Sadly, some politicians have also been dropping the trailing M, I guess that those big contracts with the military and the healthcare sector have something to do with that…
- BlueTemplar 6y agoThe advertiser network is one of the main things that Flixxo has tried to capitalize on, but with YouTube(/Twitch) being so dominant, and them being backed up by Google(/Amazon), it so far doesn't seem to be able to break out of its South American bubble. https://www.reddit.com/r/Flixxo/wiki/index https://www.reddit.com/r/Flixxo/wiki/index
- hobofan 6y agoAdvertisement on Youtube is as irrelevant as it has ever been. After the "Adpocalypse" where the money you could make from advertisement significantly dropped for most creators, they recognized that relying only on Youtube is a bad idea and diversified. Since then other avenues (Twitch, Patreon, merch, ad placements) have become their primary sources of income. For mid-size creators Youtube ads are not enough to make a living from it and for big creators with low production expenses (e.g. gaming videos) that _could_ make a living from it, it's not a significant portion of their income if they diversified (and most creators that haven't are not on the platform anymore).
- CuriouslyC 6y agoUnless you're a baller youtuber with subscribers in the millions, youtube's monetization sucks. The game if you're a small fish is to use youtube to get people off youtube, because if you don't, you won't make anything.
- einpoklum 6y agoThat piece of the YouTube puzzle is important to capitalists. It is of no importance to people who want to share video. And as for those who want to (try and) make a living off of sharing videos online - they can ask for monetary support and often get some.