5 ms·
Given how given to certain narratives some of these services are, I’m not surprised and I would predict more governments will do similar things pre-election. N
by mc32 6y ago
Given how given to certain narratives some of these services are, I’m not surprised and I would predict more governments will do similar things pre-election.
Now of course most of the governments that would do this would be authoritarian and would look to control their own narrative, I think this illustrates how unbalanced and agenda-driven these media and social graph services have become who bring in foreign values to local elections.
This interference used to be called neo-imperialism not too long ago by the same people who now advocate for these narratives.
- vbezhenar 6y agoSome governments can force *Store to ban whatever they want. Some can't, so they have to resort to banning stores.
- bilbo0s 6y agoOnly going from what I've observed on the continent, (especially in the EAC), but I think it's a bit deeper than that right now. Today, right across Africa, governments are studying the possibilities of restricting foreign internet services. Both as a way of controlling the information their populations get to view, but also as a means of addressing high youth unemployment among educated workers by giving their domestic internet firms the room to take root. This is actually an interesting sideshow in the more global tendency towards balkanization. But take my word for it, young startup type guys from Entebbe-Kampala, (and, with AfCFTA, even places like Dar and Nairobi), will be very active trying to press their advantage. The political side of this shutdown is predictable, but the interesting action is the long game. I think these kinds of shutdowns are dry runs for the sort of internet world African leaders are quietly pressing for in their future.
- amolo 6y agothis is incorrect. Majority of African leaders and regimes are not interested in addressing high youth unemployment among educated workers by giving their domestic internet firms the room to take root. Even local startups have little to no support from their own countries. This is purely authoritarian. They are more interested in retaining power to continue exploiting their own people.
- WaxProlix 6y agoCan you back that up with anything? Sounds a lot like pure ideologue speak in the absence of any backing. The person you're replying to made some claims that seemed to make sense on their face, and it'd be nice to have more than a "that's wrong, they're not. it's just not" as a response, since I'm actually curious what the on-the-ground situation is in these places.
- BoorishBears 6y agoWhat are they supposed to back it up with? A headline of "Local President admits focus on internet censorship is driven by personal greed, not economic protectionism?" I'm from Ghana, a country that's been touching the line of internet censorship from time to time, and I see nothing wrong with their statement. It's laughably naive to imply that they're censoring outside services to prop up the local tech scene when they can hardly be assed to get kids a proper education without using it as a political bargaining chip. Like saying they're playing 4d chess when they're not interested in checkers unless it suits them...
- petre 6y agoYouth unemploynent + unstable region = young men with time on their hands that could easily get recruited and become rebels. So the gov't must be totally interested addressing the issue.
- imtringued 6y agoThat's how it would work in a democracy. You're forgetting that authoritarian governments do not have to address these things by eliminating the root cause. They can just silence the opposition with arrests or execution [0]. Uganda is so famous for this to the point that there is an entire movie [1] about Idi Amin. If you actually cared about youth unemployment you could address it with simple economic measures first and you would seek funding from western investors, not get rid of them. Implementing tariffs in an industry that you are never going to be a world leader in is just plain stupid. Ugandan app developers can just develop for the Google and Apple store and get access to a bigger audience instead of restricting themselves to Uganda only. It only works out in China because their internal market is bigger than EU+USA combined. It could work out for India (unlikely unless they address corruption). Uganda only has 44 million people it just doesn't make sense. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idi_Amin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idi_Amin [1] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0455590/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0455590/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scollet 6y agoThis is a watershed election for Uganda. In some small hyperbole Uganda could become the next Rwanda or the next Sudan, depending on whether or not the incumbent is unseated. I would focus on the regional peoples' politics rather than the technocracy or American politics. I firmly believe your thrust is irrelevant to the core issue, if not solely for the immediacy of a democratic threat. I'm not an expert on this, but my family and I have been following this revolution for the past few months. To me, it's a promise to the people that things can get better.
- jimkleiber 6y agoI appreciate you pointing this out. The article says very little about the political context of this election and Uganda in general. From what I understand, not being an expert either but having spent quite a few months in Uganda in the last few years, Museveni has been the president since 1986 and brought a lot of stability to the country, aka brought peace after lots of conflict under Idi Amin. Some people have expressed gratitude for that and fear that Uganda will go back into the violence it faced before and yet seem very tired of the way Museveni has been running the country and want new leadership. Recently, there has been stronger opposition and in the last few years, a popular musician, Bobi Wine, decided to get involved in politics and declared to run for president. I imagine, if I were in government, I might be afraid of the US, China, Russia, or other countries bringing their political influence into the country through the internet. I might fear revolutions like the ones that happened in Tunisia and Egypt and other countries. I may also just fear my own citizens and what they want. It's hard for us in the US to know how much of the political discourse here is from the citizens vs external sources vs government sources, and I could imagine even harder sometimes in other countries to figure that out. That's the tricky part with this decision, it could be to stop foreign influences, it could be to stop local influences, it could be to amplify government influences, or a combination of all three.
- dirtyid 6y ago> might be afraid of the US, China, Russia, or other countries bringing their political influence Incidentally Uganda was previous battleground of US campaign against Huawei with reference to Wine. >Huawei technicians have been helping governments in Uganda and Zambia spy on their political opponents, a new report says https://www.businessinsider.com/huawei-workers-helped-african-governments-spy-opponents-report-2019-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/huawei-workers-helped-africa... Snarky, but interest reading dissecting the agenda behind WSJ article. Choice quote: >The WSJ doesn't say how it obtained the documents, though it does reveal that Wine was recently in Washington DC where he had briefed the US government on events in Uganda and had received offers of assistance. https://www.theregister.com/2019/08/15/huawei_uganda_report/ https://www.theregister.com/2019/08/15/huawei_uganda_report/ TLDR; Washington upset Huawei prevented them from meddling in domestic Uganda affairs. Huawei lawful interception implementation erodes US influence operations abroad. No surprise tech sovereignty is gaining momentum in any place that is able.
- kstenerud 6y ago> Now of course most of the governments that would do this would be authoritarian Would they be? Consider what just happened in the USA: All of the major social media companies blocked a significant portion of the population because of the attempted subversion of democracy in the country. Now imagine if some similar subversion were attempted in another country, say Ecuador? Would these social media companies be as willing to silence a faction in another country? What if it were to happen in a more important country, say Australia? South Korea? Japan? Germany? At what point should these companies be interfering through censorship, and at what point are the issues too blurred or difficult to figure out who's right and who's wrong? Sir Richard Wharton in Yes, Minster once quipped: "Once you start interfering in the internal squabbles of other countries, you're on a very slippery slope." Naturally, these companies will resist the push towards becoming arbiters of Truth (until they actually BECOME such arbiters, then god help us all). So non-American governments will have no recourse but to plead with Youtube, and then block them when the answer is "no".
- BoorishBears 6y ago> All of the major social media companies blocked a significant portion of the population because of the attempted subversion of democracy in the country. Where did this happen? Because I saw some specific tags blocked calling for a VP to be killed blocked (vs some generic "kill all humans" hyperbole)... and specific account blocked after its owner triggered an attack on the Capitol that resulted in 5 casualties (and breaking the rules of the platform for 4+ years) - Are you trying to say people who were pro-talking about killing Pence and storming the Capitol are a significant population? Because last time I checked there were still tens of millions of conservatives on Twitter who aren't banned
- kstenerud 6y agoWhat I'm talking about isn't so narrow as liberals or conservatives; it's about social cohesion and the censorship that's necessary in order to preserve it. We've been living charmed lives up until now because the ability to broadcast to large audiences has only been within the capabilities of a select few media outlets that were vetted and controlled to varying degrees by the government to make sure they didn't sow too much discord. And this is healthy, because a divided nation loses its international competitiveness and in the worst case risks collapse. We're now in the unprecedented situation where individual people can out-broadcast even nation states with the help of social media companies, most of which have their head offices in the USA, limiting their dependency upon and reachability from other governments of the world. It's a decent situation all around because having such companies headquartered in a repressive regime would have damaging effects worldwide. But we still run into some problems: 1. Their morals are local, but their reach is international. This has caused a lot of friction in the past, and that friction will only increase going forward. 2. They're being pressured to bow to local "truths" or risk being banned in a number of nations. These "truths" generally come to light from local issues, and while they can be easy to decypher in autocratic regimes, they absolutely will NOT be so easy to arbitrate in functioning democracies. We'll eventually reach the point where every social media company will need a team of sociologists and political strategists in order to figure out what's behind every government's complaints over what's being broadcast by their citizens, and how best to respond (making them higher arbiters of truth than even the government). The national self-determination issues alone are staggering. The endgame of this is increased government regulation and increased pressure for a single national "truth", which must be defended vigorously in order to keep the government functional. The increased conflict between these American companies and local governments will increase to the point where eventually the companies will win and essentially set the policy of truth worldwide, which leaves us in a very centralized and fragile state when it comes to corruption, especially since companies - unlike governments - have only profit as a motive, and do not answer to the people.
- imtringued 6y agoI don't even understand what you mean by western influence. The worst thing western nations did is physically invade nations through wars. Providing internet services is in the "lets sit in a circle peacefully and share things" bucket. It's about the furthest you could go from a war. >I think this illustrates how unbalanced and agenda-driven these media and social graph services have become who bring in foreign values to local elections. Considering the existing rulers fail to live up to their responsibilities that's not necessarily a bad thing. >This interference used to be called neo-imperialism not too long ago by the same people who now advocate for these narratives. The countries who accept them can often be more successful than those who refuse them. Hong Kong is a pretty good example. Democratic values and capitalism forced down the throat of people. This became a threat to the authoritarian regime in the Chinese mainland and the rulers have to make concessions to their population. They built special economic development zones and simply copied the ideas that worked out in Hong Kong and were compatible with Chinese values at the time. Western investors suddenly had a reliable business partner in Hong Kong and a large "proxy" workforce that was manufacturing goods on the mainland which got shipped to Hong Kong and could be sold to the west. The story ends with China becoming a world leading economy, not because of the west but rather because the west forced the government to listen to the people.