6 ms·
The Next-Generation Browser: No URL Bar
- rooshdi 16y agoAnother potential alternative to removing the URL Bar could be to camouflage it. Instead of keeping it white, allow it to blend in with the rest of the browser's color scheme and UI when not active.
- neilk 16y agoI'm usually for removing every bit of unnecessary chrome, but this strikes me as going too far. URLs aren't optional if we want to have a world wide web. Otherwise it's just AOL redux. If URLs become this thing that only experienced users know about (or that we allow naive users to forget about) we're losing something important.
- VMG 16y agoWe are not losing something important. Right now my address bar says http://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=2570690&whence=item%3fid%3d2570434 90% of this information is irrelevant to me. URLs aren't good against phishing also. Having to discern "facebook.com" from "faceboook.com" as a normal user is much too error-prone. Better mechanisms are needed here anyway.
- mixmax 16y agoand without the addressbar how will you navigate to news.ycombinator.com? How will you know what site you're on? How will you prevent me from doing some clever SEO to turn up in a google search for your bank before their own website so I can scam you? How will you be able to return to that site you liked but don't have the address for since the URL was hidden? How will you market and position your site if noone knows the URL? How will you do offline marketing if users don't know how to get to the URL you provided? I definitely think we're losing something important.
- jonknee 16y ago> and without the addressbar how will you navigate to news.ycombinator.com? Using the same icon I used to get here today. > How will you know what site you're on? By the page title or by looking at the site, same as I do today > How will you prevent me from doing some clever SEO to turn up in a google search for your bank before their own website so I can scam you? The same as today, Chrome pops up a malicious site warning. > How will you be able to return to that site you liked but don't have the address for since the URL was hidden? Search. Same as today considering a fair number of users type URLs into Google as it is (facebook.com is one of the very top Google searches) > How will you market and position your site if noone knows the URL? Market by the URL, no one is suggesting you won't be able to use the URL to arrive at a site. It's just killing the always shown URL bar.
- rjbond3rd 16y agoIcon?
- jonknee 16y agoI have a row of favicons in my Chrome bookmarks bar (no bookmark titles, so it's just a row of icons). HN is one of them.
- Meai 16y agoYes, we all just love to see the day when the web solely consists of a few dozen apps in everyone's browser. Buttons have no significant advantage over today's url bars. Pressing a single button, I get all the sites I recently looked at, my favorites, all sorted and easily accessible.
- jonknee 16y agoBy your count it's at least 100% faster--a single click and I'm where I want to be. I also get by fine on my computer by having a dock of app icons. Similarly, it works well on my phone. It's not the end of the world.
- nazgulnarsil 16y agohow many of your friends telephone numbers do you actually know?
- 51Cards 16y agoMost of them, I'd say I have 30-40 memorized easily.
- stanleydrew 16y agoSurely you must know you are way outside the norm.
- seabee 16y agoNo kidding, most people use actual phone books or their mobile phone equivalent. The key difference between phone numbers and URLs is that everyone recognises that phone numbers exist, or at least know they're meaningful.
- jodrellblank 16y agoHow many websites do you meet the owner and talk to them first then if you like them, ask for them to text you their website address so you can add it to your contacts?
- PaulHoule 16y agoIt bugs me. I get a few inquiries a day about pages on my web sites. There are a few million of them, so I can't be expected to know what they're talking about from a vague or even a detailed description. About 1 in 5 offer me a URL right away, maybe 3 out of 5 will give me a URL once I ask for one, and about 1 in 5 doesn't know what the heck I'm talking about. It's depressing to think that it's going to get even harder for people, in the beginning of the linked data era where URLs are becoming the universal namespace.
- quattrofan 16y agothe disappearing URL bar has been happening in the Android browser for as long as I can remember
- Andrex 16y agoHaving tried Chrome's "Hide the toolbar" feature in Chrome Canary, I can honestly say I prefer having the URL bar hidden. There will be some growing pains, for instance extension badges are not yet available under this setting, and the back/forward/Wrench buttons look a little out of place, but I do agree. No URL bars is going to be the standard pretty soon.
- nicpottier 16y agoThe more things change the more they stay the same. Remember AOL's use of keywords to go to specific pages for companies before the days of the web? A future without a URL bar gives Google that much more power, which is just how they want it. In that future you'll type all your urls in the google search box, and they get to show you ads for similar sites or topics, assuming you are lucky enough to be near the top. I wonder how long before Google introduces a 'keyword' product where you can register a specific keyword to go straight to your domain.
- Andrex 16y ago> In that future you'll type all your urls in the google search box The URL box and the search box have been merged in just about every current browser in some form or the other already. To most people, they're actually the same thing. The scarier implications of this could be for phishing, which the article touches on. I'm expecting some kind of visual cue on tabs that are HTTPS eventually. > I wonder how long before Google introduces a 'keyword' product where you can register a specific keyword to go straight to your domain. They've had it forever: I'm Feeling Lucky.
- nicpottier 16y ago> The URL box and the search box have been merged in just about every current browser in some form or the other already. To most people, they're actually the same thing. The semantics are different though. Type in 'books.com' in your URL bar. Type in 'books.com' in the Google search box. Not the same. The former is disappearing.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>I wonder how long before Google introduces a 'keyword' product where you can register a specific keyword to go straight to your domain. Forever. They wouldn't restrict their market in that way. As it stands they sell the same words over and over which makes them more money and gives a better user experience.
- elehack 16y ago> In that future you'll type all your urls in the google search box,... Many users are already in that future. One of Google's most common searches is "facebook.com" or "www.facebook.com" (if memory serves, both are in the top 10, along with "facebook"). It makes me sad, but I don't think Google's complaining.
- jbk 16y agoWhat I don't get about this trend (I must be missing something) about software hiding every toolbar (and sometimes useful ones) to get more "vertical space" like "vertical space" was a very valuable asset, while the computer industry is forcing everyone to screens with less vertical resolution... Moreover, since most websites are fixed-width and that computers are moving to 16/9, I don't get why browsers (I know, not Opera) make it very hard to make vertical toolbars (like shortcuts and bookmarks, for example) on the sides...
- Andrex 16y agoChrome does have a side tabs option, and I'm sure maximizing horizontal space will become important going forward.
- seshagiric 16y agoIf somebody makes it easy to show my favorites without using a separate toolbar for it, I think that will be far more cleaner UI than show/hiding address bar.
- nextparadigms 16y agoGoogle simply wants to make true that proposition that the web browser needs to be invisible to the user, so people consider more and more web apps over native apps. Remember, a good rule for UI design is that the UI should be invisible to the user.
- briggers 16y agoWe have a lot to thank the Chrome devs for. I'm keen to see how this new experiment fares. So long as I can still cmd-L and type with pattern matching, I'm good.
- nickolai 16y agoPhishers will most certainly love this. The users used to have a chance to see they were not on a legitimate site. Now that information is hidden at browser level.
- nodata 16y agoI don't want the URL bar going, but... Users don't know if it's a legitimate site anyway. Plus Google offers phishing protection.
- bhickey 16y agoI strongly recommend using Pentadactyl (formerly Vimperator). It removes a lot of UI kludge and simply makes browsing a better experience. http://i.imgur.com/UwhLg.png http://i.imgur.com/UwhLg.png http://dactyl.sourceforge.net/pentadactyl/ http://dactyl.sourceforge.net/pentadactyl/
- henning 16y agoURLs will continue to be an important part of the browsing experience. http://www.useit.com/alertbox/990321.html http://www.useit.com/alertbox/990321.html Jakob Nielsen wrote this in 1999 and I don't think much has changed, as recent updates to the article at the end show. I love browsers that get out of the way, so displaying the address bar in a more intelligent way is something I welcome. I doubt it will disappear entirely.
- omouse 16y agoPhishers won't like this because there will exist things like Web Of Trust that help identify bad sites. I'm assuming Google will provide the same functionality.
- p4bl0 16y agoOld browsers like lynx, w3m, ... didn't have url bar either. :-)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- PostOnce 16y agoHide navigation bar -> Ctrl+L to enter a URL. Handy on a netbook, arguably annoying on a desktop.
- stanleydrew 16y agoI'm already using ctrl-L to focus the navigation bar every time. It's very convenient.
- s00pcan 16y agoHow would I easily modify GET requests without a URL bar?
- billrobertson42 16y agoYou'll have to pry my URL bar out of my cold dead hands.