10 ms·
Was LinkedIn Scammed?
- awarzzkktsyfj 16y agoGoogle's Dutch auction IPO pricing looks even more appealing after seeing this. Too bad it took a recession for them to get the bargaining power to demand a Dutch auction.
- hristov 16y agoI do not think it is a matter of LinkedIn lacking bargaining power. It is a well known company and it is the first social company to go IPO, so every bank will be eager to underwrite them so that they can say they are the experts of social. They could have had a dutch auction if they really wanted one. I think the reason they did not go with a Dutch auction is they lack the confidence of Larry and Sergey. What if it fails? What if the bankers get pissed off and sabotage it by not working hard enough to sell the issue. Having the price jump by 100% may be leaving money on the table but it is not a disaster. Having the IPO fail would be a disaster, and the management of LinkedIn would be personally blamed for it.
- iwwr 16y agoWhat if the bankers get pissed off and sabotage it by not working hard enough to sell the issue. Have things become so bad that companies must ingratiate themselves with 40-50% tributes to the banks?
- michaelochurch 16y agoHave things become so bad that companies must ingratiate themselves with 40-50% tributes to the banks? I hate investment wankers with a passion and would love to see the people involved in IPO spinning get the Paris 1793 treatment. But the "40-50% tribute" claim is not correct. LinkedIn only offered about 7% of its stock, so it was only a 3-4% tribute. Knowing how scummy banks are surrounding IPOs, this was a very intelligent strategy. Now the stock can trade to a fair level and then they can do a secondary offering at a real price.
- hristov 16y agoI think the grandparent was referring to the theory that bankers may intentionally underprice the issue so that they could extract some of the benefit from the underpricing. So for example, in the case of LinkedIn, the theory is that the bankers knew that the shares could go for 100% higher price than the IPO price and sold those shares to their buddies at a much lower price with the understanding that their buddies would pay them back a percentage of the money they make flipping the shares by doing various other business with the banks. Of course none of this is proven, but it is a theory many serious people have.
- alanthonyc 16y agoBreak out the Adam Smith? "People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public"
- pbreit 16y agoI like Henry (Joe...not so much), but they are being idiots. Pricing an IPO is not quite that easy. And a 100% pop is not the end of the world for the company. In fact it is pretty neat. Henry's analogy is asinine. Better is the owner of a 10 unit building renting to a tenant for $1000 who turns around and rents for $2000. The owner, without doing anything, has just increased the value of his building by 90%.
- zach 16y agoSeems like a great topic for a NYTimes business-section infographic: Which underwriters price IPOs most accurately and which ones leave huge amounts of their clients' money on the table?
- trotsky 16y agoThe underwriters also have a responsibility to all involved not to over price the ipo to take advantage of transient demand. If they do, and the stock ends up under water within a few days to months they run a serious risk of pissing off both their investing clients and the newly public company. Opening down or trading below what the stock priced at in the short term has a strong stigma attached to it and can make retail and institutional investors think there is something systemically wrong with the company regardless of the fundamentals. There was an editorial in the WSJ on friday that strongly suggested the price action in LNKD has to do with the current easy credit environment driving money into riskier assets. I agree this seems likely. Certainly it seems difficult to justify the valuation on any traditional metric. If when pricing the ipo Morgan also felt that any frothy demand was based more on the easing environment than real interest in LNKD as a company, perhaps they were right to hold the pricing a bit more conservative than the market was suggesting. After all, they already had increased it by almost 33%, and the current QE program is scheduled to shut down in June. Many smart people appear to be betting on interest rates climbing after the program ends, that may take enough money out of the market to cause someone like LNKD to correct. Another thing to keep in mind is that LNKD offered a relatively small amount of stock as compared to many offerings. This kept supply low and could have contributed to the large pop, but also means that they probably have plenty available for a potential secondary offering, which could allow them to profit from these very price moves down the line,
- vladd 16y agoThe factors you've mentioned should have been already priced by Morgan in the opening price proposal (low share supply, low interest rates etc). They are reasons which justify why the shares traded so high, which in turn proves that it was foreseeable by Morgan to know that.
- trotsky 16y agoI just woke up so I'm not sure if I'm conveying my point well. My suggestion is that these factors can combine to create a short term unsustainable pricing situation. If Morgan Stanley believes in their heart of hearts that the stock won't be able to support more than a $50 price by Aug 1, they should be loathe to price at $80 and see it fall. This won't just kill their ability to get future offerings subscribed, but also can weigh heavily on the trading of the stock long term which could easily get in the way of any secondary offerings. Besides, who can say that they actually could have floated the stock at $80? Just because some retail investors or momentum traders bought at $80-$100 on the first day doesn't mean they could have moved the whole volume of stock at that level, especially to some of their institutional clients. Just because you could potentially find one guy out there to buy one share of LNKD at $1000 doesn't mean it's a reasonable price for it or that you could find anyone to buy 100,000 shares at $1000 - but you could still get a print off of that one share transaction. None of this is meant to say that I trust investment banking firms a lick, or I'm sure Morgan did the right thing here. I'm just trying to suggest that it's a much more complicated situation than the NYT and the Zynga sound bite might suggest.
- horofox 16y agoIt wasn't a scam, just take the fact that "[LinkedIn] became the first major American social media company to go public" and you should notice that it happened due to (1) managing an IPO is HARD (2) web social media is young.
- SeanDav 16y agoHaving worked in the industry for a long time I have no doubt that Invest Banking Firms are greedy fucking bastards. However, in this situation it is more a case of damned if they did and damned if they didn't. Before the IPO there was a fair amount of nervousness about a big launch of yet another dot com. It is easy to look at this with the benefit of hindsight and say - they should have known the share price would more than double but I doubt they purposely got it that wrong.
- jonah 16y agoThe story on MSFT's IPO was fraught with uncertainty and concern over who-gets-what in the pricing scheme: http://features.blogs.fortune.cnn.com/2011/03/13/inside-the-deal-that-made-bill-gates-350000000/ http://features.blogs.fortune.cnn.com/2011/03/13/inside-the-...
- joelmichael 16y agoPrior to the IPO, everyone was saying $45 was absurdly high. Now it's absurdly low.
- tpatke 16y agoThis is a good point. Of course - for a banker it is not an opinion it is a full time job and at 7% they are very well compensated for it.
- joelmichael 16y agoGoldman evidently thought it was overvalued, too. They sold all of their stock at the IPO price. So if their goal was to "scam" LinkedIn, they didn't do a very good job of it. http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2011/05/19/goldman-leaves-linkedin-party-early/ http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2011/05/19/goldman-leaves-lin...
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- alex1 16y agoOne of the reasons LinkedIn's share price jumped so high from its IPO price of $45 was because of a very low float. There are too few LinkedIn shares trading on the public market. It is not that easy to get your hands on LinkedIn shares right now, even if you are willing to pay market price. This artificially raises the stock price. I believe 7 million shares were floated out of ~94 million outstanding shares. If more shares are floated, the price per share should go down (not considering other factors) as there will be a larger supply of shares in the public market. The assessment that the investment banks that the IPO should be priced at $45 sounds more reasonable had all 94 million shares been floated (speaking hypothetically; this never actually happens). For this reason, valuing LinkedIn by multiplying 94 million (total outstanding shares) by the current stock price on the NYSE (as most news articles have been doing) is probably not a very accurate measure.
- guelo 16y agoBut that would mean that the investors didn't know how to do math. Everybody that buys knows what percentage of the company they're supposedly are overpaying for.
- mslate 16y agoSomeone's wrong on the internet...must avoid spending time correcting them
- michaelochurch 16y agoThere are too few LinkedIn shares trading on the public market. It is not that easy to get your hands on LinkedIn shares right now, even if you are willing to pay market price. This artificially raises the stock price. Not really true. If you want to buy or sell a million shares right now, you're probably going to see that effect-- it's called "slippage" and occurs when you trade any stock in large quantity, but the market self-corrects soon after. At a few hundred or thousand shares for a decently liquid stock, slippage is not a real concern and the only cost of trading is the bid-ask spread, which is usually a penny or two.
- msy 16y agoAm I the only one who feels that if I'd put in the blood, sweat and tears to build a company to the point where it could be IPO'd I'd be more likely to gouge my eye out with a rusty spoon that open it to the sharks, sociopaths, speculators and manipulators of wall st and the open market?
- vtail 16y agoYou're probably not along. At the same time, I believe significant number of people (myself included) will respectfully deem this view too gloomy and pessimistic. One could probably use the same logic arguing about the first (or second, ...) round of VC financing. In each case, you are relaxing some control of your company in exchange for something else valuable: other people's money. Whether such exchange is fair or not depends on specific circumstances; each side can always ask for more (money, control) to make the exchange fair. I don't know of any company of any significant size (e.g. with >$100M of annual revenue) that hasn't made such an exchange at some point in its history.
- msy 16y agoThere's a big difference between a VC round and the open market. The markets are often not driven by anything even related to the companies whose valuations fluctuate wildly by billions of dollars in under a second. They don't open to you (to same degree) to hostile takeovers, pump-dump schemes and naked short attacks. They force companies to kowtow to the opinionated whims of unaccountable analysts and focus on short term profits over long term strategy.
- RickHull 16y agoAn IPO is the act of selling your business to the public. You are definitely not the only one who may prefer to stay private. It's a business decision the each individual business faces.
- mdda 16y agoI'm sorry, but I don't see why people are so hostile to trading in the open market. The public stock market is a real-time debate about valuation in the open. The VCs do it behind closed doors. Being critical of the markets for being divorced from reality is fine, but surely having a public stock price is better than having it all hidden from view? If you're not a fan of more openness, maybe you are hoping to 'pick off' a VC who over-values your company, away from a public analysis of its actual worth? As for having a public listing forcing a company to do anything - it's not true at all (except for publishing audited accounts). The company is free to ignore the gyrations of the market, and keep its plans secret too.
- adamtmca 16y agoNot a scam. Inflammatory banks are evil stuff with little to no support. In hindsight it's easy to say they should have known it would get to this price but in the weeks leading up to the IPO it would have been pretty difficult to justify pricing at 80. The current price is difficult to justify and may not hold beyond this initial frothy period. Add to that the greater downside of underpricing and I just don't think the author is really making much sense.
- DavidSJ 16y agoThe fact that the stock more than doubled on its first day of trading — something the investment bankers, with their fingers on the pulse of the market, absolutely must have known would happen... No, this is an absurd claim. Investment bankers are not clairvoyant.
- ramanujan 16y agoRight. This is reminiscent of the famous line about what your accountant is supposed to say when someone asks him about profit. Profit? Who's askin'? - If it's a customer, you're making a little bit of profit. - If it's an investor, you're making a LOT of profit. - And if it's the government, you're making no profit at all. Joe Nocera wants everyone to make just a little bit of profit. If they make too much, he's calling for a Congressional investigation. And if they make too little...he's calling for a bailout: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/24/business/24nocera.html Most important, the government has made clear it will not allow a major bank to default, to avoid the replay of the Lehman catastrophe. Nocera is one of the guilty parties in the prestige press who propounded the "too big to fail" mythology. Now sovereign defaults are on the horizon, in part because we didn't let banks that made bad bets simply go into bankruptcy. His observations about banks should therefore be taken with a grain of salt.
- eftpotrm 16y agoToo big to fail is _not_ a fallacy. The knock-ons from the failures of Lehman and Bear Stearns were very visible. In Europe, the knock-ons from the failure of Kaupthing and Landsbanki were too, and they only ended up affecting insitutional investors as retail depositors got government protection. AIG failing would have caused an investor panic across banking as a whole due to their position as the leading insurer of investment risk. In the UK, Lloyds TSB and RBS (two of the 'big four' UK banks) both very nearly collapsed; the smaller Northern Rock bank did collapse and had to become 100% government owned. The alternative in each case was depositors having their assets frozen for a long period with only the promise of pennies on the pound a long time later, with a knock-on loss of confidence for the sector, combined with a large compensation bill for the taxpayers. Would you _really_ like to see what that happens when 20% of the banking market suddenly freezes?
- perlgeek 16y agoI don't know very much about the stock market, so forgive my stupid question... but couldn't you circumvent this problem by not selling all the stock at once, but rather sell it in packets of a few percents at a time? Then you'd get a feel for an appropriate price on the first few trading days, so you can't get scammed except for a few percent of the stock.
- orijing 16y agoCompanies do do that. The first sale is called the primary offering, and ones that come after are called secondaries (or follow-on). I'm not sure if LinkedIn will do that, but it's common among small companies that are capital intensive. Usually the goal is not to capture the fluctuation in short-term price, but rather the long-term appreciation from demonstration of potential. For example, if Tesla sold everything when it IPOed, it would be unlikely to get a good price for it, not to mention it doesn't need all that cash now so it's somewhat wasteful. But if it sold half then and sold half in early 2012 or so, it will be able to (hopefully) get a better deal in the second chunk. Back to the issue of short term mispricing, companies like Google hold open Dutch auctions so the actual price is very close to the fair market value. I don't know why LinkedIn didn't do that but I suspect it's because it wants to keep good relations with bankers. I hope that answered your question.
- perlgeek 16y ago> I hope that answered your question. It did, thank you.
- bhudman 16y agoIt is also possible that no matter how the opening price was, people were going to gobble it up anyways. Like others pointed out, the price slowly grew from $25, $35 and finally $45. I had placed a limit buy order for $47, and it opened at $85. If there are any finance folks here, I have a question - who set the $85 price? Was it the underwriters? It could not have been the market because the stock started trading at $85. Also, I could not get any stock data from any of the sites (NYSE, yahoo, google, ameritrade etc) untill past 10:15am EST or so. Is this delay normal for IPOs?
- ScottBurson 16y agoI think they way they set the price is to take the number of shares available, subtract out the number for which there are market orders (i.e. orders to buy at the market price, i.e. non-limit orders), then take the remaining shares and the open limit orders, and find the highest price that gets all the shares sold. So if it opened at $85, that means there were limit orders placed at that level and higher. I don't know why there was a delay in the price reporting.
- rob08 16y agoIt should also be considered that the underwriters gets paid on the amount raised (7% according to the article), so the underwriters also "lost" money from that perspective.
- phatbyte 16y agoThis is a red flag for Facebook.
- brisance 16y agoWhy couldn't the shares have been offered in 2 classes: one with voting rights and one without. Offer more of those without. Lots of companies do this e.g. Berkshire Hathaway, Google etc. That would solve the "mispricing" problem.
- OllieJones 16y agoMany institutional investors won't touch two-class shares. It's an inherently rigged model. But at least you know it's rigged, and the rigging rules are transparent.
- OllieJones 16y agoWho do the company's financial executives serve during an IPO, when the identity of the investors is changing fast? Let's not forget that the point of an IPO is to (a) provide an exit for the startup investors. (b) raise funds for the company's future operations (c) make the company's financial executives and founders rich. Who loses when the offering price is lowballed? Everybody who sold shares into the offering. That's the first two of my list. Usually the insiders have a six-month lockup; usually they can't sell their own shares until six months after the IPO. So, if the shares hold their price the execs will do well. There's a big PR penalty if the stock drops below the opening price. That will turn into a money penalty on the execs in six months unless the company can overcome it. So, the smart bet for self-interested execs is to lowball the offering price. As long as the startup investors don't call foul, the only loser is the company itself. If I were an investor, I'd insist on the execs giving me (selling me cheap) options to buy half their shares at the opening price, as an incentive for them to price the offering right.
- hugh3 16y agoIf I recall correctly, didn't the IPO of Google use some unconventional structure, like a reverse auction or something? Anyone remember the details? Anyone know why this isn't done more often?
- skybrian 16y agoThe real question is why more companies don't follow Google's lead and use an auction for their IPO. That lets anyone buy if they want to and lets the market decide the price.
- ScottBurson 16y agoAgreed. Maybe it just takes a certain amount of chutzpah to buck the system like that. Or, maybe some of the VCs are in bed with the investment bankers. It surprises me, though, considering that Google has blazed the trail, that others wouldn't be eager to follow, if only to encourage people to think of them as "the next Google".
- robdd1 16y agocan someone explain why the middle man is needed? Why can't a company apply for a listing on the exchange. Then disclose how many shares they will be selling , then start accepting bids on the exchange? Obviously you would need regulations around this but why is there a middle man at all?
- dstein 16y agoAs usual, the middleman is not really needed. Or they wouldn't be if a new stock exchange was designed to make this process easier. I guess this is essentially what Second Market is trying to circumvent. If the shares of companies can be traded even in small amounts before going public the companies have a better idea what they are worth on the open market.
- mdda 16y agoNo! A thousand times no! Second Market's bid/offer spreads are enormous compared to the public stock market. Second Market is a web facade on a straight-forward over-the-counter trading operation. While the idea of doing a 'soft launch' IPO by building up from a toe-in-the-water market makes some sense, the reason that Second Market is being looked at hard by the SEC is because it's doing something that should be regulated far more than it is (because they're using accredited investor exemptions to get around the various disclosure/oversight rules).
- prostoalex 16y agoThat market exists, and it's called pink sheets and penny stocks. This will attract all sorts of scammy pump-and-dump schemes that will convince the public that FOR LIMITED TIME ONLY they have an UNBELIEVABLE OPPORTUNITY to invest at LOW-LOW PRICES. Like it or not, but investment banks have access to a cadre of accredited retail and institutional investors, so they serve as a filter between legitimate opportunities and outright scams. Same filter could be achieved, if you got a bunch of emails from accredited investors and just set up a Google group for them.
- nikcub 16y agoThe headline can be summaries as 'no' since his only counter-argument seems to be 'the banks should have known better' Pricing for a listing is a very complicated process. The underwriters, along with the company executives, go out on a very long roadshow and book orders well before the listing date. It is through these orders, not some magic made up numbers, that the final price is determined from. In the case of LinkedIn, they changed their list price no less than 4 times between the time they filed their S1 with the SEC and the time they finally listed. Initially it was $31, and the last hike to $45 only happen the night before the listing. LinkedIn management are professionals who understand their business and understand the process, they have a choice of underwriters to work with and a choice of investors to take orders from. This isn't a single bank taking them for a ride - to suggest that is offensive to those who run LinkedIn Where the real problem lies, and a problem that was not raised in this criticism, is in how orders are taken. This is what Google attempted to solve with their Dutch Auction system. The claim is that the banking community is so tight-knit that they collude with each other to keep the book price down. So what Google did was to hold a silent auction on bids and allotments, only to find when the process was over that most banks essentially bid around the same mark anyway. Paying out 6.5% of your company to go public does suck - but it is the cost of creating a viable and flowing public market for your stock. You can't just sell that part of the company to 4 or 5 banks and then ask them politely to pass it on - you may as well just raise another private round in that case. The point of the IPO is to diversity ownership as broadly as possibly and to engage firms that would be willing to take on and trade the stock so that a market is created. None of the alternate mechanisms work, and you need to be a very large and hot company to even challenge the status quo in the way Google did (and in a way LinkedIn did as well - with their two classes of stock). Note that the underwriters are taking a risk since they end up holding a lot of stock, and in the event of the list price dropping there would be a lot of questions asked about the prospectus and roadshow and potential lawsuits. Also on the other hand, there are not a lot of IPO's that take place, so the underwriters need to make the most of the business they do get - they are the ones with the connections to the large funds that purchase stock, so acting as a risk-bearing agent in that capacity does deserve compensation. LinkedIn didn't help their cause by listing so few shares. When there is scarcity in the market and so much demand, then there is only one way that the list price would go - and that is up. If they listed twice the number of shares to meet demand then there definitely would not have been so much volatility on the opening day (a lot of which was caused by 'market' orders - which means 'buy at any price'). tl;dr: creating a free flowing and liquid public market for your stock is a very complicated, highly regulated and risky process and nobody has figured out a better way to do it
- ansy 16y agoThis is just my theory, but saying LinkedIn was scammed because the IPO was underpriced is like saying Sony or Nintendo were screwed by shortages on the PS2 or Wii. LinkedIn sold a tiny fraction of its shares, far less than the market would bear. The IPO was oversubscribed and artificially doubled in price. Instead of selling a bunch of shares at the "fair price" up front, LinkedIn created the perception that LinkedIn is undervalued, desired, and worth more than it really is worth. All it had to do was sacrifice a tiny portion of the shares in the IPO and it's the new hot money maker. Now the company and its investors have created an environment where they can unwind more of its shares at a hefty premium, more than making up for the IPO "loss." Maybe LinkedIn didn't plan this out so perfectly. But it probably saw this as one possible result of the IPO strategy it chose.
- AJ007 15y agoI saw this same story a while back right after the Zipcar IPO. Seriously I expect better from the NYTimes. Especially considering that everywhere else is reporting this as a bubble. Which is it, did LinkedIn scam investors or have investors scammed LinkedIn?
- dreamdu5t 16y agoOne thing is clear: Speculation is playing an enormous role in LinkedIn's valuation and capitalization.
- mdda 16y agoAside from all the investment banker bashing, is the valuation of Facebook and Twitter being more rationally set away from the public by the VCs?
- rdl 16y agoI miss the Google/WR Hambrecht style auction priced IPOs. Hopefully, after a couple more companies IPO, the big fish (Facebook, maybe Twitter) will IPO using an auction to allocate and price.
- fleitz 16y agoThese kinds of articles are seriously insulting to the leadership of the companies involved in the IPO. I seriously doubt that the board of LinkedIn would let themselves be scammed by a bank. If the article is true and this scam has been going on for years and LinkedIn allowed it to happen to their company then that would send me a signal not to invest. However, I think they knew the risks and choose a lower IPO to ensure upward price movement on the first day. There are many ways to IPO (auction, etc) and you have to keep in mind that a big IPO pop makes everyone feel good about the stock. Yes, perhaps LinkedIn possibly could have made an extra $352 million, but if that strategy resulted a $70 IPO with no pop then they would have lost $1 billion in market cap. Pricing and seeing an upward trend have a big impact on the perception of value. Stocks are not priced according to some logical rational algorithm, it's about perception of value and big returns and amazing articles about how it doubled in value on it's first day help fuel those perceptions.
- kevinpet 16y agoI was initially on the "scammed or at least poorly served" side, but then someone with more experience in these things than me pointed out that the shares the traded hands in the IPO were a smaller fraction of the company. If you sell 10% of the company at at 50% discount, you've actually only given away 5% of the total value of the company, and you've gained a huge marketing win. Also, for reasons that seem irrational to me, I'm told institutional investors consider it a strong indicator things are going downhill if a stock ever trades below it's offering price.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoCan anyone explain why a company has to dump all their shares at once? It seems like it would make sense to just offer, say 1% of the shares every five minutes at whatever the previously issued shares are trading at. I'm sure there's a good reason, I'm just curious.
- johnl 16y agoI am going to get slammed for this but I really doubt if they care. 7.84M shares was the IPO makes a total of 94.5M shares outstanding. That's less than 10% outstanding if I am reading the press correctly. The other 90%+ shareholders will want the IPO to pop just so the market impression of the company is positive so they can sell their shares at a good price when their holding period ends. Like any investment, I would look at the current position of the company and it's long term prospects before investing.
- dpatru 15y agoWhy can't the new shares sell in a uniform price auction the way treasuries are sold? Per wikipedia (article on auctions): Debt auctions, in which governments sell debt instruments, such as bonds, to investors. The auction is usually sealed and the uniform price paid by the investors is typically the best non-winning bid. The underwriting bank would just take bids for a set period of time, and then the winning bidders would pay the highest losing bid. This would help ensure no first-day price spike since any buyer who wanted shares could have bid his top price for them in the auction.