3 ms·
>“U.S. Capitol security needs a total overhaul. The physical breaching and desecration of our temple of democracy must never happen again,” Senator Brian Schatz
by salawat 6y ago
>“U.S. Capitol security needs a total overhaul. The physical breaching and desecration of our temple of democracy must never happen again,” Senator Brian Schatz,
I would argue that those trying to secure the structure against invasion by the People are the ones desecrating the Temple. Like it or not what many hear call an insurrection, I call an unequivocal vote of no confidence by the governed and a call to action aimed at Representatives. Not to hide away behind locked barriers, but to listen, and take to heart the fact that people are pissed enough to mobilize in the first place. A call and voice message to the Rep is one thing. Repeated letters another. Putting in a physical appearance at an office yet another.
Pushing your way into and disrupting Legislative business is an unmatched attention grabber, and to be frank, I'm not willing to deprive anyone willing to drive to D.C. of the opportunity to have an impact, nor am I willing to accept only the well heeled should be capable of regularly exercising the advantage of exploiting proximity to Federal Representatives.
A person exercising Liberty, especially to the disdain of the majority, is the quintessential act of American patriotism and civil spirit. That foreign actors may have made use of the chaos is regrettable, but nevertheless, this is American government by design. It doesn't exist and rule by it's own right or ability to trounce all comers. It exists and rules because we all let it. Something I think a lot of people do not quite grasp.
That Trump of all people is the one to bring all this out makes me want to vomit a bit, but it is what it is. So it goes.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y ago@dang, can we please ban coup advocacy on this forum?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoCan we ban banning? What is so scary about words? And how did he even advocate for anything? It is scary how quickly we are ready to silence any dissent.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWhat's scary is the five people who died in the event he's lionizing as "an unequivocal vote of no confidence by the governed and a call to action". A police officer was bludgeoned to death with a fire extinguisher (https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/police-officer-who-died-after-capitol-riot-always-wanted-be-n1253516 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/police-officer-who-died...) - to call that a "quintessential act of American patriotism" is open advocacy for violence, and I don't think I can ethically participate in a forum which permits such a terrible thing.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI do not mean to trivialize this, but five people dying is nothing in US. Hell, we just had 4k people die today of covid alone. It is an issue, even a serious issue and it is being handled by appropriate agencies ( as it should ), but by overblowing this people will only make it worse. So why not let system work? That is what it is there for. edit: "to call that a "quintessential act of American patriotism" is open advocacy for violence, and I don't think I can ethically participate in a forum which permits such a terrible thing." Correct me if I am misreading this, but you are making this an ethical issue the same way your opponent does. Note that the comment you replied to appears to view his position the same way. He, apparently, sees it as not only ethical, but a mandatory subset of being an American; a virtue. May I suggest that all of us participate freely in this exchange of ideas. You are free not to the same way he is free to. Ethics have little to do with this.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI disliked the Patriot Act too, and I'm strongly opposed to this new Domestic Terrorism Act. All I'm saying is that endorsements of terrorist attacks should be banned from reputable discussion forums and I won't participate in a forum that allows them.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI upvoted your comment, because I think this is the crux of the issue. I am not entirely convinced if it was a terrorist attack. It does fit FBI definition ( https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/terrorism https://www.fbi.gov/investigate/terrorism ), but that definition is rather broad to begin with. To me attack suggests some level of planning, forethought, end game even it is just to terrorize. FBI definition also does not seem to indicate that terrorist attacks are typically directed towards civilians ( government buildings are not civilians ). But if we accept FBI definition then what political end was achieved by this? Clearly not the intended one. Again. I think this is just another Patriot Act moment. We can calm down or go down another rabbit hole. Only this time, we will have to TSA every time we want to talk to a government official.
- daniellarusso 6y agoRespectfully, we disagree on what discourse means.