8 ms·
I can't speak to the nutritional aspect of it, but having attempted various high protein or protein/fat heavy keto diets in the past with varying levels of succ
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
I can't speak to the nutritional aspect of it, but having attempted various high protein or protein/fat heavy keto diets in the past with varying levels of success I do have to say it doesn't take long before you just get sick of eating meat. The charm of it wears off. Our paleolithic ancestors would have craved and sought out any and all carbohydrate sources, and preserved summer fruits and berries as much as they could have. First nations here in Canada made/make pemmican, a mixture of animal products and berries from the summer, as a winter food, and I'm sure this practice goes back for a very long time.
At a certain point, I'm sure being sick of meat (especially from fairly large and omnipresent megafauna), the services of a companion dog/wolf would have been worth the waste.
Also many northern hunter gatherers eat the contents of the stomach of their kills as a way to get carbohydrates, trace nutrients and vitamins, etc. Between that and a source for furs, leathers, bones (for tool/structure making), one might make more kills than necessary and have excess meat.
- k__ 6y agoTrue. I did a low-carb diet once for three months and lost 10kg. Most of it because I just couldn't see eggs, cheese, and meat anymore.
- Jtsummers 6y agoMany vegetables and some fruits can still be consumed (though not necessarily much fruit) and maintain a low-carb diet. The other thing to do, or that I did, was to use a variety of spices and herbs. Most add nothing (or very little) with regard to carbs (certainly not the processed sugars low-carb diets aim to avoid) so don't impact the diet overall. And a well-stocked spice cabinet means you can have chicken for a week or even a month and never really have the same meal twice.
- com2kid 6y ago> Many vegetables and some fruits can still be consumed (though not necessarily much fruit) and maintain a low-carb diet. The other thing people don't always realize is that the longer you've been on a low carb diet, the more carbs you can eat and stay ketosis. After 6 months or so, even an entire medium sized apple (19g of sugar) isn't likely to be a problem. This is even more true for people who work out, heck 40g of sugar from fruit followed by 1 hour of high intensity workout, probably not an issue. Starting out strict is needed to get on the keto train, but, but a low sugar ice cream with 10g a serving twice a week isn't going to kick most people out of Ketosis if they've been there for awhile.
- nafix 6y agoJust an observation that I've noticed about myself: * During periods where I am trying to lose weight or not working out much, I tend to not crave meat very much. In fact, eating certain types of meats (for example, steak) would kind of make me experience mild nausea. * During periods where I am working out a lot (lots of running and heavy weight lifting), I have a strong desire to eat lots of meat and don't tire of it. For me, the "charm" of meat depends on the physical requirements of what I am doing in some period of time.
- ddorian43 6y agoWell you need a lot of protein to gain/maintain muscle mass which you can only get it from meat. (https://burnfatnotsugar.com/p2e/AboutP2E/image27o.JPG https://burnfatnotsugar.com/p2e/AboutP2E/image27o.JPG)
- NeutronStar 6y agoProteins are definitely not only in meats. Beans have more protein per weight than meats. Even your diagram suggest not only meats are high in nutrients.
- aszantu 6y agoWhat about bio-availability of that protein?
- 1_player 6y ago> it doesn't take long before you just get sick of eating meat. The charm of it wears off. Yes and no. Food stops becoming an enjoyable activity, and just becomes fuel. If you're hungry, in the true sense of the word, you'll have meat and fat and ask for seconds. Fat adaptation works because if you have fat around you, your hunger signals tends to fade as you're already carrying a significant amount of energy. The fact that carbs and sugar are so sought after is great when you're a paleolithic man, but is the cause of the modern obesity epidemic - it's an energy source than can be easily stored and accumulated around the body, so our taste buds have evolved to encourage us to eat plenty, because it was VERY scarce until recently.
- yourkin 6y agoI have heard this recycled notion about carbs being scarce many times, but in this context it makes little sense. If fat adaptation is so efficient at converting food to energy and there is more fat around than carbs, why would the craving for carbs evolve even? I have also done keto a couple times and my experience is the same — in a month I just can’t stand anymore meat and bacon and going back to a balanced diet feels very good. I also can‘t stuff myself with carbs and start seeking both protein rich foods and fatty. Would question the whole „carbs where scarce, so we evolved to overfeed on them“ dogma. Why would fruits be more scarce for a non predator (as where human ancestors), than meat? It feels like a whole lot is missing in the story.
- rudyfink 6y agoMaybe, in essence, the bacteria that we host to help break down carbs start producing something that makes us crave/prefer carbs? It seems like the bacteria would, in essence, be self interested and might have developed their own evolutionary mechanism to promote the supply of their food source? In other words, if we, essentially, keep internal bacteria colonies to help break down specific types of food, those colonies may encourage consumption of their specialized food source? We may also, symbiotically, encourage the preservation/maintenance of internal processing capability?
- undersuit 6y ago
- Shivetya 6y agoFrom my standpoint, I never understood why people focus on the meat side of this diet. I never eat more green vegetables than when I am on a keto type diet. They are everywhere and I even have slight variations into vegetables I do not normally consider. However one point most people miss, you don't have to cut out BBQ or other meat condiments. You would be amazed how far that tablespoon actually goes and you still stay way under your carb limit. Once I discovered this the dieting got immensely easier. Same goes for types of salad dressing; I tend to the mix it yourself variety from Good Seasons. I do not let myself slip into reasoning "just one slice of bread" is okay though. You do however need to look beyond foods you are used to. Eventually it became a game for me which made the whole process more fun
- chlodwig 6y agoFrom my standpoint, I never understood why people focus on the meat side of this diet. I never eat more green vegetables than when I am on a keto type diet. There is a growing group of people who believe in a carnivore diet, not just a keto diet. They have an active subreddit with introductory readings, a FAQ and wiki explaining their reasoning. http://www.empiri.ca/p/eat-meat-not-too-little-mostly-fat.html http://www.empiri.ca/p/eat-meat-not-too-little-mostly-fat.ht... https://www.reddit.com/r/zerocarb/wiki/faq#wiki_2._isn.27t_the_biological_design_of_the_human_body_better_suited_to_eat_fruits_and_vegetables_rather_than_meat.3F https://www.reddit.com/r/zerocarb/wiki/faq#wiki_2._isn.27t_t... https://www.reddit.com/r/zerocarb/wiki/plants https://www.reddit.com/r/zerocarb/wiki/plants https://justmeat.co/ https://justmeat.co/ The tldr is that they believe we evolved to primarily eat meat, we get the best most bioavailable nutrients from animal sources, and that most plants have various toxins in them to discourage animals from eating them, and that even when cooked these toxins aren't completely destroyed and a lot of people experience low-level inflammation and irritation from plant sources, without realizing it.
- war1025 6y agoNotable members of that group are Jordan Peterson and his daughter Mikhaila. I personally find Jordan Peterson's content pretty interesting. His daughter on the other hand, she seems pretty scammy. Have a hard time taking that diet seriously. But I guess if it makes people happy, good for them.
- chlodwig 6y agoI can't speak to the nutritional aspect of it, but having attempted various high protein or protein/fat heavy keto diets in the past with varying levels of success I do have to say it doesn't take long before you just get sick of eating meat. What kind of meat were you eating and how was it cooked? I did a month of carnivore diet and never got sick of eating rare ribeye steak, lamb ribs, or lamb legs. I think I would get sick of chicken or pot roast or well-done ground beef. That said, I never stopped missing carby meals like mac 'n cheese or cookie dough ice cream.
- war1025 6y ago> never got sick of eating rare ribeye steak > I think I would get sick of chicken or pot roast or well-done ground beef Honest question, why do people seem to love rare meat so much? I agree that tough meat doesn't taste good, but I would argue a properly cooked pot roast is about the most tender cut of meat you can find. Having had what most "foodie" people would call a "properly cooked" just barely above rare steak, I always find it to be unsatisfying. What am I missing?
- sillycon-valley 6y agoIt's juicy. Some people's preference of "dry" varies. Some people can't fathom others liking well done, some can't fathom rare. Pink in the middle is preferred but at red it's too watery for me, to each their own.
- war1025 6y ago> It's juicy. Most of the juice in my experience comes from cooking the meat long enough to render the fat. I've had medium-rare steak before where the fat was all still solid. Didn't seem all that great to me even though all the others raved about it.
- hnick 6y agoYes, I think most juiciness is actually fat/oil, not water. Pretty sure one of those more serious food blogs measured it once. This is why basting in fat is important sometimes. I was gifted some leftover thin wagyu cuts recently. I cooked them through because they have so much fat they're still tender, and the brown adds flavour. It just had to render enough. I guess they were technically "well done" but perfect for me, as someone who prefers medium on typical steak.
- sandworm101 6y agoFar far more kills than was necessary for caloric content. This idea that early humans "took only what they needed from nature" is quaint. They took what they could use, which means basically whenever usefulness outweighed the risk of the hunt. I remember an early history class about a buffalo jump. Teacher told us that "all parts of the animal were used." Well, not that giant pile of bones. If the dogs were hungry, or one needed some fresh bones to carve a tool, some large herbavore was killed. Im sure that lots of useful meat was left to the elements, just as with hunters today.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rainbowzootsuit 6y agoLinked below is a PDF of an interesting book about one of the famous buffalo jump sites Head-Smashed-In in Alberta Canada https://zerocarbzen.com/2015/05/01/imagining-head-smashed-in-by-jack-brink/ https://zerocarbzen.com/2015/05/01/imagining-head-smashed-in...
- refurb 6y agoThat’s probably dependent on the relative abundance. Massive herds of Buffalo don’t require using everything. Living in the arctic where it’s a lot more effort probably resulted in a more efficient use of the animal.
- astrange 6y agoIs there a technique to eating organs I don't know about? I assumed a stomach would be like eating vomit. Liver is still popular to this day, but maybe the animals whose organs we eat don't have as many metabolites in there as I thought.
- nkrisc 6y agoI would guess much of it depends on the diet of the prey animal. Eating the contents of a carnivore's stomach would probably be awful, but that of an obligate herbivore is probably not as bad, comparatively, since it would mostly just be plant matter, perhaps slightly fermented. You only need to take a look at the difference between the feces of carnivore and herbivores. Cow dung or rabbit pellets really aren't all that bad. Wolf or otter feces, as two examples, is pretty vile stuff.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- war1025 6y agoI think a lot of eating organ meat involves washing it or soaking it to get the more unpalatable flavors off. Not something I've really been adventurous enough to try though.
- tharkun__ 6y agoIt's all about preparation. I don't think I could eat certain organs without puking just from the thought/looks. You couldn't get me to eat heart for example. I've tried to but couldn't get over it (chicken hearts actually). And even liver, I'm not sure I'd eat. German Liver Sausage? That is one of the most delicious things on earth! How's this for a "recipe": Beef trim (50%), beef liver (20%), beef heart (15%), and beef kidney (15%). Take a nice piece of rye bread (best is a real sourdough rye bread), spread the Leberwurst very thick, top off with a cornichon and/or pickled mini onion. Heavenly.
- 6y ago
- soperj 6y agoExcept pemmican was usually made without berries unless it was being used for ceremonial reasons. It would have been the way to preserve the meat from large game kills, since pemmican lasted for a very long time.
- com2kid 6y ago> I do have to say it doesn't take long before you just get sick of eating meat. I got tired of avocados first. After several years, I still can't stand them! But keto is a lot more than meat, it is nuts and berries, dairy[1], and lots of green leafy vegetables. The # of things I can't eat on keto comes down to bread, potatoes, rice, and super sugary fruits, but it isn't like the 170 grams of sugar (!!!!) in 1/2 a watermelon was ever good for me. [1] https://www.darigold.com/darigold-fit/ https://www.darigold.com/darigold-fit/
- coolgeek 6y ago> But keto is a lot more than meat, it is nuts and berries, dairy[1], and lots of green leafy vegetables. This is the crux of it. You can have a very varied, and very flavorful experience on keto (or its variations). > I got tired of avocados first. This is where we have to part ways. I can see avocados, alone, getting old quickly. But I could eat guacamole every day for the rest of my life and never tire of it.
- downrightmike 6y agoIf you don't eat enough fat with the protein, you will still starve. You can't survive a winter on winter hare as they have no body fat left. https://www.fieldandstream.com/story/survival/survival-myths-that-can-get-you-killed/ https://www.fieldandstream.com/story/survival/survival-myths...
- Apofis 6y agoI would die without Salads and other veggies... meat only would get old very fast for me. If I don't have a very heavy garden salad for too long I feel really weird and my cravings for vegetables are through the roof.