5 ms·
I'm real stuck on what possible value Apple can bring to building a car. The entertainment and technology packages are an important customer facing experience,
by XorNot 6y ago
I'm real stuck on what possible value Apple can bring to building a car. The entertainment and technology packages are an important customer facing experience, but at the end of the day it needs to get you from A to B while being shielded from the weather.
Basically all the bits which make a car valuable are outside any of Apple's competencies - transmission, suspension, air conditioning, heck even passenger seating and ergonomics.
The proposal is functionally Apple trying to buy from the ground up a whole new industrial function with near zero overlap to things they're actually good at.
- 0x1DEADCA0 6y agoIf Hyundai and Apple don't work together to deliver a car similar to Tesla's, both will lose profit potential in a crowded market.
- WanderPanda 6y ago> Basically all the bits which make a car valuable are outside any of Apple's competencies - transmission, suspension, air conditioning, heck even passenger seating and ergonomics. Except for maybe passenger seating all of the things are commoditised by now, I think. I hope they take a shot at it, because competition never hurts and they still (despite their size) deliver outstanding innovative products
- zippy5 6y agoYour completely missing the point.. Honda sells commodities. Maserati sells status. Motorola sells commodities. Apple sells status. Computers are commodities, smart phones are commodities and at the end of day none of that stops people from buying from apple Cars make a ton of sense for apple because it’s a product which a decent percentage of people will all pay a premium to get the cool version.
- snowwrestler 6y agoApple’s status is based on the capabilities of their products. They try to only make stuff that works really well; as a result they don’t make inexpensive stuff. But they don’t make very expensive stuff either, the type of stuff whose status is independent of its function, like the equivalent of $800 jeans. They’ve tried a couple times (gold Apple Watch for example) and it did not catch on. So, I think it’s fair to ask what unique functionality Apple will bring to a car to differentiate it from all the other cars. And from an internal perspective, Apple leaders have repeatedly said that they are only interested in new markets when they think they can have a transformative impact. So again, I think it’s fair to wonder what that impact might be. There’s undoubtedly more to their thinking than just slapping an Apple logo on a Hyundai.
- yoz-y 6y agoWho knows what they could bring? When iPhone was rumoured the speculations were quite widely off from what Apple has actually put out. I think the only real difference between entering car business compared to other categories Apple has transformed is regulation. Cars need to look and behave a certain way because of laws in many cases.
- seabird 6y agoThose aspects of a vehicle are only commoditized if you discount the massive amount of time poured into design, integration, and manufacturing engineering. It's easy to buy some bolt-on aftermarket automotive product and attach it to your vehicle. Actually integrating that thing in a way that meets (sometimes conflicting) safety, reliability, manufacturing, cost, manpower, etc. requirements can be a special sort of hell that you wouldn't wish upon anybody.
- dataking 6y agoI bet you'd also be real stuck on what possible value Apple could bring to building a phone. All the bits that made a feature phone valuable were also outside of Apple's competencies. Thing is, cars are becoming more like computers.
- throwawayzRUU6f 6y agoThe thing is - cars are not like computers and will never be. For most workloads a normal person performs on their computer, the hardware is ridiculously over-provisioned. Most of it is idling 90%+ of the time, the utilized portion is mostly wasted in a sea of inefficiencies. Performance improvements of 100x are not uncommon. To simplify a bit - Apple's business model boils down to selling mediocre hardware at premium prices, and concealing that fact by a large amount of optimizations and polish. Cars are nothing like that; they're already at their efficiency plateau. An improvement of 10% is considered astonishing. Cars are much more like gaming rigs - raw power is required there, the games are already reasonably optimized, and no amount of sleek design and UI polish would hide the lackluster price/performance ratio. There's a reason Apple is not in the gaming business. For Apple to maintain their margins, they'd have to sell something like Nissan Leaf for the price of Tesla Model S.
- tomcam 6y ago> Apple's business model boils down to selling mediocre hardware at premium prices, and concealing that fact by a large amount of optimizations and polish. So... doesn’t optimizing and polishing something make it a better product?
- XorNot 6y agoYou're missing the point: where are they going to find these gains in the car industry without blowing out the price? Because that's going to bat in the market that Mercedes, BMW and the like are already in. What is Apple going to uniquely improve via it's current core compentencies, as opposed to winding up where Tesla is: a fantastic on paper product that they can't deliver off the production line reliably, with fit and finish issues because they're a young manufacturer shaking out their production lines? Hyundai can do these things, but they're already doing them. Where's Apple sit in there other branding which essentially makes the product a gimmick?
- threeseed 6y ago> but at the end of the day it needs to get you from A to B You really don't understand cars if you believe this. Cars are second only to property in terms of the biggest investments someone will make in their lifetime. As such people decide what to buy based on a number of factors including "how it feels to drive" and "what this car says about me". Because in most cases they are sticking with that decision for a decade. If it was based purely on the cheapest way from A to B then there would be no brands like Ferrari, Lamborghini, Aston Martin etc because they are based on desire rather than value. And if there's one company that understands desire it is Apple.
- aetherson 6y agoCars aren't investments.
- Hamuko 6y agoWell, most cars. Some definitely are, but we're talking about rare, low-production ones.
- jhoechtl 6y ago> If it was based purely on the cheapest way from A to B then there would be no brands like Ferrari, Lamborghini, Aston Martin Those brands account only for a tiny fraction of the car market though. For the rest the cost of buying and maintaining a car is certainly a bigger fraction of the acquisition decision.
- XorNot 6y ago"what this car feels like to drive" is part of the A to B part though. It's engine, suspension, transmission, steering linkages. Passenger seating. It's not a software interface.
- rswail 6y agoApple had no value to bring to music players in the early 2000s, they had no value to bring to mobile phones in the late 2000s, they had no value to bring to watches in the mid 2010s, they had no value to bring to audio in the late 2010s... Apple sells an ecosystem as a brand. Whether you buy into the branding or the ecosystem is up to you. Their brand is about status, quality, privacy, identifying their customers as the people that buy their hardware and services, not people they can sell the data to. Vehicles are about to become yet another electric/electronic device you own. In the same way that my mobile phone has a network of cell towers that someone sells me access to, I could see Apple doing that with charger providers. If charging stations become self-provisioning, with local power generation and storage, then the cost of actual power transfer to my vehicle has a zero marginal cost. So in the same way that my mobile plan is "all you can eat" in terms of calls (and data, mostly), I could see how vehicle charging could work the same way. So buying a car becomes: 1. Choose a vehicle based on status, branding, equipment 2. Choose a vehicle "plan" based on usage So in the same way as iPhones and iPads sell Apple Music, Apple Pay etc, iCar sells all the existing services, plus allows Apple to co-brand with electric networks. So think "Apple iCar and Shell EV, your safe and effective partners for travel". When autonomous vehicles become available, you can integrate that autonomy into the Apple ecosystem, in the same way that Apple Maps learns your travel patterns and makes suggestions, Apple can use that data to send a vehicle to you when you "need" it.
- sveme 6y agoMachine learning, AR, autonomous driving? That‘s Apple competencies that few car companies have.