5 ms·
Is it though? I was having this discussion with a friend last night. If I were IT for the Capitol, I would already be operating under the assumption that all
by jedberg 6y ago
Is it though? I was having this discussion with a friend last night. If I were IT for the Capitol, I would already be operating under the assumption that all the clients are hostile.
There are constantly visitors to the Capitol, including foreign visitors who could easily be spies. Also, the Members themselves are often old, anti-tech, and not the kind of people who will remember to lock their screen when they get up. I would already assume Member computers are a huge attack vector, and act accordingly.
- watwut 6y agoRandom visitors don't go into offices. They don't look into cupboards. They don't sit behind desk with computer.
- generalizations 6y agoAnd yet you still have to assume they might.
- lumost 6y agoAuthorized individuals have classified documents on Capitol hill computers, there have been many options available to support breaching a workstation given physical access for years. In this event you don't even know if such authorized persons had time to lock their computers.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoHow about staffers working for members from the other party? Yes, you'd expect a "gentlemen's agreement" not to do such things. You might not be wise to trust it, though...
- watwut 6y agoI doubt there is anything like gentlemens agreement last 8 year's. Everyone was aware it is sociopaths run the place. So I think other party stsffers are not trusted to be left alone.
- XorNot 6y ago"You will go to jail forever" and "You will be completely unemployable forever" are still two surprisingly effective deterrents against the vast majority of the population when they have a job. There's lots of stuff you "could" do everyday, but the probability of getting caught is high, the ultimate impact to anyone else is low, and the severity of punishment immense. All that changes quite significantly when even basic access control is lost and the building is overrun by unidentified belligerents for a few hours. I'm betting a number of foreign intelligence agencies were scrambling to see if they could take advantage usefully.
- alisonkisk 6y agoThere's no "unemployable" for political crimes. It makes you more employable by the side you did the crimes to help.
- chefkoch 6y agoBut perhabs visitors like lobbyists, donors etc. could be often alone long enough with a computer to something bad. And don't forget all the viruses that tweet porn links.
- watwut 6y agoUnlikely, given that it does not happen in commercial companies either and there no one particularly has reason to care.
- MacsHeadroom 6y agoPrivate companies are compromised by visitors every single day. Outsiders on-premise are one of the largest attack vectors after insiders. This is why both the local network and endpoints are no longer trusted in security models.
- bregma 6y agoI'm sure it happens. According to what I've seen on TV, all you need to do is stick a thumb drive in a laptop and utter the magic incantation "OK, I'm in" and you can either download the entire content of the network or implant a virus in the time it takes for someone to come back into the room.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI am a random nobody and I was able to waltz in to my congresswoman's office. Obviously I wasn't digging through the desk drawers, but it's not like I was closely observed while I waited for my congresswoman's secretary to get off her phone call
- moate 6y agoThis is not similar to having 4 ours of unfettered access during a riot. They literally were digging in desk drawers, using the phone, leaving threats, carving hate speech into wooden doors, etc. I once saw a citizen with a 6-shooter strapped to his hip at a Colorado county clerk's office peacefully fill out some paperwork for 5 minutes. What does this story tell us about what rioters did or didn't do while tearing up the capital building?
- defen 6y ago> I once saw a citizen with a 6-shooter strapped to his hip at a Colorado county clerk's office peacefully fill out some paperwork for 5 minutes. What does this story tell us about what rioters did or didn't do while tearing up the capital building? 1 minute of Googling tells me that Colorado is an open-carry state, and there is no specific exclusion for county offices, so unless this was in Denver or another municipality that prohibits open carry I don't see the relevance of your story to what happened in the Capitol.
- kthxbye123 6y agoThat's his point. There's no comparison between entering the public part of an office during business hours and what happened yesterday.
- bszupnick 6y agoThis person, who seems to have more intimate knowledge of capitol IT, also mimics the concern: https://twitter.com/neurovagrant/status/1346964347684179970 https://twitter.com/neurovagrant/status/1346964347684179970
- _Microft 6y agoHere is why Foone thinks that “forgetting to lock the screen” is unlikely: https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1346924327996772354 https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1346924327996772354
- mikeryan 6y agoRelevant Picture (from since deleted tweet - Interesting that the media is still accessible on twitter...) https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ErErUqKXMAMQtyy.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ErErUqKXMAMQtyy.jpg
- _Microft 6y agoIt almost looks like a photo that an employee themselves might take after being shown such an alert message.
- chris72205 6y agoI _believe_ this is where that picture originated from https://twitter.com/mikko/status/1346922681158000640?s=21 https://twitter.com/mikko/status/1346922681158000640?s=21
- chipsa 6y agoCongress apparently doesn't use CACs, and the photo shown of the desktop shows no card reader to stick a card in.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe idea that a senior US Congressperson or Senator would have the same rules as some IT contractor is ludicrous. Her password is probably password123 or some such nonsense too.
- sgt101 6y agoSecurity problems that begin with "the user had a weak password" are strictly the fault of IT nowadays. Every application and gateway should check password complexity and reject passwords on the top 1000 list. If password123 is allowed the IT director should be fired.
- anothernewdude 6y agoThey're going to have to rebuild from scratch anyway, this event has just made sure they do so.
- admax88q 6y ago> I would already be operating under the assumption that all the clients are hostile. You can't operate assuming all computers in the Capitol are hostile. How are the members supposed to do work if their computers are assumed hostile? Why even give them computers then? > I would already assume Member computers are a huge attack vector, and act accordingly. What would "acting accordingly" look like for you in that example scenario you outlined.
- structural 6y agoYou absolutely do assume that that network is hostile/compromised. There are a number of other networks in other places where more important communications are done. It's a giant PITA, and a lot of stuff leaks from Congress because most people believe that they are too important to have to keep things secure. Being in Congress is not an automatic ticket to having all the country's secrets on your desktop, and things actually are compartmented quite heavily when necessary.
- admax88q 6y ago> Being in Congress is not an automatic ticket to having all the country's secrets on your desktop I'm not suggesting that they have _all_ the country's secrets on their desktops, but surely the speaker of the house needs access to their emails on their desktop. Those are private, but without them, why even give the speaker a desktop at all?
- spoonjim 6y agoThe actual Members are in many ways, a bug of the system, and recent events have demonstrated that very clearly. Capitol IT probably puts them on a "Guest WiFi" and lets them surf Twitter without bothering anyone. The majority of the US government apparatus functions on a day-to-day basis without any input or functional oversight from anyone, and that is the so-called "Deep State" which in reality is the only reason anything works at all. Can you imagine the country if Donald Trump was functionally the CEO the way that Elon Musk is the CEO of Tesla?