14 ms·
What? Is the merchandise rioting now? This is idiotic and is a non sequitur to the unadvised happenings at the Capitol. This is a political statement that sa
by mc32 6y ago
What? Is the merchandise rioting now?
This is idiotic and is a non sequitur to the unadvised happenings at the Capitol.
This is a political statement that says only some political views are acceptable and others are not approved.
It’s so blatant.
- cecja 6y agoIf there is shit in front of your doorstep you sweep it away. For some people shit smells like roses but that is their problem.
- type0 6y agoHas he violated their terms of service?
- mc32 6y agoGood question. I think you mean “they”. I wonder what terms those would be?
- gdgdhdushhd 6y agoShopify doesn't allow organizations that promote or incite violence. Should have done long time ago.
- mc32 6y agoDoes the org selling the paraphernalia incite violence? Does music with violent or misogynistic lyrics incite violence. Do songs with gunshots in them incite violence? Do songs that make people think of suicide constitute violence? Do violent or misogynistic movies or videos incite violence? So much potential for removal and delisting!! Chomp, chomp.
- cecja 6y ago...but think about the neonazi children they have to buy their hats somewhere.
- RL_Quine 6y agoAre you saying that companies should be forced to do business with parties they don't want to?
- abernard1 6y ago"Isn't there some other restaurant you people can go to?"
- gambiting 6y agoThis is a business relation between two companies, not a company refusing to sell to minorities. It doesn't enjoy nor should it enjoy the same protection. Being able to do business with whoever you chose to is the cornerstone of business everywhere.
- abernard1 6y agoI'm sorry, but they're exactly the same. In the South, racists didn't want to do business with black people, and the government intervened and said they had to. There are many other protected classes, it's just politics isn't one of them. We have not had anything remotely like the ability "to do business with whoever you chose" for 55 years in the U.S. because of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. What people supporting this are implicitly saying is they don't think political affiliation is or should be a civil right.
- libraryatnight 6y agoThe line seems blurry https://www.theguardian.com/law/2018/jun/04/gay-cake-ruling-supreme-court-same-sex-wedding-colorado-baker-decision-latest https://www.theguardian.com/law/2018/jun/04/gay-cake-ruling-... Also, this seems like a valid terms of service breech. Is the choice to uphold it an excuse to make a statement? I think probably.
- abernard1 6y agoPart of having a liberal society, as opposed to a strictly libertarian society, is that the larger social contract of law overrides any contract between two individuals. I, for instance, cannot sell myself into slavery. Shopify cannot have terms of service in a contract that violate federal law. The whole concern with terms of service on HN just convinces me that the practitioners need to get out more. They should also quit foisting some weird conception of software onto society. Irrespective, the objective fact that there are many ironclad things business cannot discriminate on is true and has been for a long time. Simply put, Shopify believes they should be able to discriminate against people for holding political views.
- gdgdhdushhd 6y agoWhat if it was ISIS store? Would you say same things?
- zanellato19 6y ago> This is a political statement that says only some political views are acceptable and others are not approved. That has been the case since forever. White supremacy gets you banned from sites, for example, and that is a political stance. What is the difference between that and whats happening here?
- mc32 6y agoOne is an extremist group just like ISIS or the weather underground, the other is a mainstream political party?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoNah. Even his own party is calling him out.
- mc32 6y agoSo? It doesn’t make them right. We’re going on principles here. Politicians go on what’s expedient.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoYou said mainstream. If even his own party thinks he is extreme, I don’t know what to say.
- mc32 6y agoI don’t see the disconnect. The store sells merchandise. It’s not selling riot gear or items taken from the ill advised occupation. I don’t know if anything the store sells which is controversial. Even Snowden and Greenwald people the left admired when expedient, disagree with how social media is tripping over itself to seem pious. All these media who are virtue signaling have awful offenders on their sites. They don’t care. They only care if it makes them look virtuous. Glenn and Edward are on the left politically but they are honest leftists who see the idiocy behind these moves. The utter and disgusting loss of the freedom of speech among Americans.