6 ms·
M1 seems to be pretty heavily I/O limited - the amount of supported Thunderbolt ports is way down (2 on every M1 device and no more), the screen support is down
by izacus 6y ago
M1 seems to be pretty heavily I/O limited - the amount of supported Thunderbolt ports is way down (2 on every M1 device and no more), the screen support is down as well.
Hopefully they fix it in the next iteration.
- sirn 6y agoIt might be worth noting that M1 Macs actually has two Thunderbolt controllers for 2 ports (dedicated controller for each port), whereas previous Macs shared two Thunderbolt controllers for 4 ports. The 2 ports limitation feels to me like a design decision rather than a hardware limitation (to differentiate with an upcoming higher-end model?)
- chrischen 6y agoThe distinction is moot since hubs don’t exist, so I’m still facing the problem of lack of physical inputs. At best on the market there are hubs that give 1 extra type c input for power.
- sirn 6y agoThere's a recently announced OWC Thunderbolt Hub[1]. I would still prefer to have 4 ports built-in even with two controllers rather than having to deal with hubs, though. [1]: https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/owc-thunderbolt-hub https://eshop.macsales.com/shop/owc-thunderbolt-hub
- chrischen 6y agoI did see this and it’s a bit sad that it’s been like 4 years since type c has come and hubs still aren’t generally available (even if just for USB and not thunderbolt). I mean I didn’t fully adopt USB type C just to convert the ports back to type A.
- sirn 6y agoThis is mostly because Thunderbolt hub support was optional in Thunderbolt 3 spec, but mandatory in USB 4. Apple just added support for it in Big Sur.
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhich leaves me deeply confused. Daisy-chaining had to be supported. From the host point of view, a hub is barely any more complicated. Why was it optional?
- sirn 6y agoMy understanding is that daisy chaining doesn't require a mixed USB and Thunderbolt signal, only Thunderbolt. Before USB 4, USB-C spec itself disallows hubs to passthrough an Alternate Mode and even Thunderbolt daisy chain also have to terminate at any point where USB is plugged in. In this case, I believe you can have Thunderbolt 3 hub that only carries Thunderbolt signal, but it will only work with Thunderbolt devices and not USB-C.
- Dylan16807 6y agoBut you don't need to mix signals. When you use a thunderbolt dock right now, doesn't it use pure thunderbolt as a backhaul, and have a PCIe-based USB 3 controller inside of it? If that's right, then even without mixed signals you could have a pure-thunderbolt hub, and you could have a device with several thunderbolt ports and several USB 3 ports. And it should be straightforward to combine them into dual-purpose ports. The rules for passing through alternate modes don't matter because you're not passing through, you're not a USB hub, you have your own USB root.
- sirn 6y agoThat indeed could work, and it looks like Belkin's Thunderbolt 3 Express Dock HD[1] actually does this. Though in this case, Thunderbolt is limited to just 2 (1 for downstream and 1 for upstream). I guess the biggest benefit of USB 4 hub is that allows the hub to have more than 2 Thunderbolt ports (the upcoming OWC Thunderbolt hub has 1 upstream and 3 downstream) and no longer have to worry about unplugging a device breaking a chain (usability problem). [1]: https://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-F4U095/ https://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-F4U095/
- outadoc 6y agoThe entry level MacBook Pro has always had only 2 ports, so this fits with the existing lineup. Most likely the next models to switch to ARM will get 4, like they do now.
- texasbigdata 6y agoYou pretty much need a $300 TB dock.
- chrischen 6y agoI was a bit surprised too that my new fastest processor macbook pro only has 2 ports. To make matters worse thunderbolt 3 hubs don’t actually exist!
- cl3misch 6y agoCould you elaborate on the non-existence of TB3 hubs? What is the true nature of a colloquial "TB3" hub then? DP + USB 3 + Ethernet?
- chrischen 6y agoBasically I googled for why there aren’t any hubs that add more type c thunderbolt ports (or even just type C USB ports), and apparently items because there is no chipset for it released yet. You’ll notice pretty much all the “hubs” on Amazon just take a type C port and turn it into a bunch of old USB A ports and other non type C ports. At best it would replace the type C port it takes up with a power delivery only type c port. I think OWC is about to release one that takes 1 thunderbolt and turns it into 3, but it’s large and seems to need external power.
- chrischen 6y agoAlso see this answer: https://superuser.com/questions/1381139/why-cant-i-find-a-usb-c-hub-with-multiple-usb-c-ports https://superuser.com/questions/1381139/why-cant-i-find-a-us...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rconti 6y agoThat "low end" 13" MBP has always only had 2 ports. It just happens to be that the low-end is faster than the high end during this transition :)
- Shivetya 6y agoWhich is fine as they were all declared as entry level machines into the new ecosystem. That Pro label was a bit odd but no matter the efficiency of their new systems it was shown a fan is still needed to reach full potential so it provided a means of product separation. What becomes important is if this constraint it carried forward into larger machines. I cannot believe the M series chips are constrained on how many ports they can support as that usually is all in the external chipset. The real issue I think people are looking at is memory expansion, will it always be what you buy it all you get or will there be user expansion available?
- rconti 6y agoWhat's new here? The non-touchbar 13" MBP has always had only 2 ports, as has the Air. They added the touchbar to the 'low end' 13" MBP but it just happens to have better performance than the Intel 13" MBP because the Intel one hasn't been replaced yet - it's still the "low end" model. The only one I'm missing is the Mini -- I'm not sure how many TB ports it had in the past or has now.
- giantrobot 6y agoThe Intel Mac mini had two Thunderbolt ports but 4 USB-A ports. The M1 mini only has two USB-A ports. I had a ton of USB stuff plugged into my old mini so the dearth of USB-A ports is an annoyance.