13 ms·
"Democracy is a system in which parties lose elections" - Przeworski In other words, the core concept of democracy isn't the elections or any of the other tra
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
"Democracy is a system in which parties lose elections"
- Przeworski
In other words, the core concept of democracy isn't the elections or any of the other trappings, it's the fact that it's possible for one group to lose power, transition to another group and retain the possibility to transition back in a subsequent election to the original group.
- mhh__ 6y agoOn that note, the Pa. State Senate Republicans are just refusing to swear in their new democratic colleagues. I Can't wait for this attitude to inevitably cross the pond.
- cozzyd 6y agoHere's a former PA lawmaker, nearly elected to US congress, who may have been part of the group that breached the capitol: https://twitter.com/Redistrict/status/1346938310359396354 https://twitter.com/Redistrict/status/1346938310359396354
- howlgarnish 6y agoThis is an artifact of first past the post electoral systems, which reward polarization. You can't demonize the other parties if there's more than one to choose from and your governments are coalitions that may require you to genuinely work together next time.
- manmal 6y agoI find it hard to believe that that would even work in most EU countries.
- silexia 6y agohttps://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2385 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2385 - this details the penalty for attempts to overthrow the government of the USA.
- osgovernment 6y agoThe police in the capital building were on video shaking these "protesters" hands.
- ImaCake 6y agoThis has historical precedent. The far-right in the Weimar republic were treated far more softly than the communists were. The complicit behaviour of the authorities definitely played favourites and can probably be partially blamed for what happened.
- pera 6y agoHere are two examples of this: https://mobile.twitter.com/bubbaprog/status/1346920198461419520 https://mobile.twitter.com/bubbaprog/status/1346920198461419... https://mobile.twitter.com/cevansavenger/status/1346920924310867968 https://mobile.twitter.com/cevansavenger/status/134692092431...
- maccam94 6y agoIf you look at the very end of the second video, you can see that the camera pans behind the cameraman and shows a bunch of people trespassing beyond the barricades. The position the police were defending was already compromised.
- rewq4321 6y agoI was thinking the same thing, but then, what's the reasoning behind moving the barricades out of the way? "There are too many protestors, we need to help them move the barricades" doesn't make sense. They then turn their backs on the protestors and casually walk towards the capitol. More surprising is that this protest wasn't a "flash mob" - it was planned and known about publicly for weeks - even promoted by the president. Why were they so unprepared? Certainly possible that the explanation was "sheer incompetence" in both cases.
- ashtonkem 6y ago
- ehsankia 6y agoI would understand conspiracy theories when the incumbent party keeps on winning. It's easy to come to conclusion that the game is rigged in less democratic countries where the person wins over and over with 90% of the votes, or with leaders such as Putin. But I just don't understand how losing an election that was looked over by members of your own party, and won by similar margins which you won by previously, can be this controversial. Let alone the fact that the party still did really well in all the other ballots including house and senate.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> how losing an election that was looked over by members of your own party, and won by similar margins which you won by previously, can be this controversial. this all stems from videos, witness statements, and statistical anomalies that suggest the election wasn't conducted properly; and the refusal of certain parts of the government to effectively examine these claims and their supporting evidence in a public and transparent manner. You've still got people claiming there was no evidence, even after videos emerged of ballot counting without the legal requirements and of people employing sleight-of-hand to remove a thumb drive from a counting location. These incidents may or may not be significant enough to change the outcome of the election but when they don't appear to be taken seriously and investigated properly, it creates the impression that some people aren't very concerned with election integrity.
- ehsankia 6y ago> this all stems from videos I can obviously not cover every single one, but just seeing a random van and claiming it's full of fake ballots doesn't make it true. In many of these states, the entire counting was livestreamed. > witness statements Anyone can give statements, but election fraud requires more than just hearsay. > and statistical anomalies Numbers are easy to play with, see p-Hacking. In the majority of the cases, if you apply the same calculations to previous elections, or hell, even red counties in this very same election, you get very similar strange looking results. > refusal of certain parts of the government to effectively examine these claims and their supporting evidence in a public Just because you've been told that it wasn't taken seriously doesn't make it true. Courts have gone through the evidence for 2 months and none of it went anywhere. But for some people, being proved wrong means not being taken seriously.
- dcolkitt 6y agoIt's an interesting point. One thing I've noticed is that both sides increasingly believe that each election poses an existential risk to their side. Currently you see many conservatives repeating the meme that losing the Senate means a Republican will never win the White House again. The belief being that Democrats will change voting laws, open borders and amnesty to Dem-leaning immigrants, and possibly even pack the Supreme Court and add DC and Puerto Rico as new states. On the flip-side, similar sentiments were often expressed on the left of Trump heralding the end of American democracy. Republicans in power would permanently end fair elections through a combination of foreign election interference, gerry-pandering, dark corporate money, and voter suppression. Disregarding whatever merits these views have, the fact that they're widely held by a significant chunk of the citizenry creates a dangerous equilibrium. Like you say, in a healthy democracy the losing side focuses its energy on winning the next election. But if you think the other side's gonna use dirty tricks once in power, there is no next election to win. So you go all out it to stop the other side, and start looking for dirty tricks of your own. Now you've justified your opponents' bad opinion of you, and given them even more reason to win by any means unnecessary.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lovecg 6y ago> and add DC and Puerto Rico as new states Is there a good argument against this? Apart from “but my side will lose power”.
- jcranmer 6y agoFor DC, there's an arguments about a state being able to hold the federal government hostage, which is the reason why a federal district that is not part of any start was specified. Given that the existence of the federal district is part of the Constitution, it's arguable that making DC a state requires a constitutional amendment.
- lovecg 6y ago
- js2 6y ago> How many injuries to American democracy can my Republican Party tolerate, excuse and champion? It is elementary to have to say so, but for democracy to work one side must be prepared to accept defeat. If the only acceptable outcome is for your side to win, and a loser simply refuses to lose, then America is imperiled. — Jeff Flake https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/opinion/jeff-flake-trump-republicans.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/opinion/jeff-flake-trump-...