10 ms·
No More KYC with ShapeShift
- ur-whale 6y agoThe article is light on technical details, but if Eric managed to actually pull that off in a truly decentralized manner, this is quite an accomplishment, congratulations.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoSeems unlikely that they are actually going to be able to get around KYC.
- StavrosK 6y agoWhy would they need KYC if they don't handle any money?
- zadler 6y agoThey wouldn’t, but they might still be considered to be running an exchange if they keep a centralized orderbook. So i don’t know how they will get around that.
- tigereyeTO 6y agoShapeShift has never had an order book.
- parliament32 6y agoIf they don't handle any money, how do they make money?
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoI just think the law will either be changed or re-interpreted to not allow this. Too great a potential for use in laundering money/tax evasion on capital gains.
- brokensegue 6y agohow will they make money if they aren't involved in the transaction and won't transact with the customers?
- vlovich123 6y agoYeah, this is an astute observation. If they're taking a cut of the transaction, I suspect they'll still fall under KYC (either because the legislation today is sufficient or because it'll be changed as soon as they become a threat).
- simon_kun 6y agothey will release their own governance token through an airdrop. It's the new way to fund decentralised startups - no need for VC. Essentially it's the equivalent of an IPO on day 1.
- aidenn0 6y agoIPOs raise money in exchange for equity, they don't create any profits.
- simon_kun 6y agoI understand. Governance tokens are equity (usually with voting rights), and are used to generate a capital base for a decentralised product (think: crowdfunding). Not all governance tokens are airdropped and the secondary market for said tokens often results in them appreciating over time. I would suspect shapeshift to fund itself and generate wealth for the founders through doing this both at the point of issuance and over time.
- vlovich123 6y agoWith no incoming revenue, it seems like you've just described a pyramid scheme, albeit with extra technical steps. Can you help me understand the difference?
- udfalkso 6y agoFor certain ERC20 tokens... but great move, and hopefully they can extend it to Bitcoin and others soon as well.
- zadler 6y agoBitcoin is challenging because sadly most wallets don’t support custom transactions like metamask does.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI assume that Treasury will have their own view of this, but I generally applaud attempts to shake status quo. I will be checking on you guys from time to time now.
- ur-whale 6y ago> Treasury will have their own view of this, What will be interesting to see is if these views are physically enforceable. Having more technical details would be interesting.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoAs long as the officers of ShapeShift or its shareholders are within reach of the U.S. government, those rules are physically enforceable.
- ur-whale 6y agolol, good point, it's not like actual rules matter anymore.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoOn the contrary, the rules -- especially their spirit -- are what actually matter. Not the games people play with numbers in computers.
- csomar 6y agoIt's a mouse and cat game. As of now, there are no KYC rules for decentralized exchanges, and thus they are under the radar of the law. It'll take a couple of years before the SEC/FTC catches up with them, by that time they would have already found another loop hole.
- vlmutolo 6y agoDecentralized trading seems like it would be a problem from the perspective of paying your taxes. Or maybe not. Maybe it’s just the honor system. Keep track of all your assets, what you bought and sold them for, and tell your accountant if you have one. Or learn the tax laws surrounding capital gains.
- rmah 6y agoDid ShapeShift migrate to a Uniswap-like dex?
- cblackstock 6y agoNo, we're simply integrating with DEX's on the platform. ShapeShift is moving away from handling the exchange and turning that functionality over to outside providers.
- delaaxe 6y agoBut then why not use the DEXes directy?
- tigereyeTO 6y agoShapeShift's software sets it up so that customers DO use the DEXes directly.
- otterley 6y agoRegulations have a way of evolving to meet people's attempts to evade them. Whatever ShapeShift is doing might work for a while, but in the long run it looks like a cat-and-mouse game.
- spurdoman77 6y agoEverything is cat-and-mouse game in the end.
- markkat 6y ago>When an individual is accused of a criminal offense, it may be reasonable to dissolve their privacy to some degree in the search for truth about that offense. >However, KYC dissolves the privacy not of certain specific individuals accused of wrongdoing, but the privacy of all individuals, none of whom have been accused of anything. >We can do better than that as a society. Warrantless surveillance of all people cannot be our standard. So glad to see this view rising up. When so many private and public parties are required to collect my private data, how can it remain private? I've had unemployment claims made in my name this year due to a breach, and it was on me to fight the fraud that would harm me. The collection of private data does not protect us, it results in a honeypot and puts us at risk.
- oh_sigh 6y agoI have no idea how this system works - how are you harmed if someone claims unemployment in your name?
- underdown 6y agoYou still have to pay taxes on unemployment income
- thomaszander 6y ago... they get the money you could have received.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoDid this get checked by a lawyer before posting? Reading this, I get the hacker vibe: "The law says this, but I came up with this clever hack so it does not apply to me." Unfortunately for this view, the law and judges who apply the law care a lot about intent, and are not very impressed by "hacks" of the law. Advertising that you are doing an end-around KYC, is something that a judge will find very interesting if this comes to court. In addition, KYC is a big priority of the US Treasury department and there is pretty bipartisan support for it. Basically, the US Treasury Department does not want any company to facilitate large money transfers anonymously. If you are doing that, they will likely come after you, despite whatever clever legal "hacks" you may think you have. I don't see this ending well.
- delaaxe 6y agoBut then they would have to go after all the other decentralized exchanges like Uniswap etc. no?
- tigereyeTO 6y agoFirst, it's important to note that we will continue to KYC users when they trade directly with us as the counterparty (this is our old model and we have to KYC in this case). When it comes to DEX trading, it means we are not part of the trade; we are not a custodian, a counterparty, or an intermediary of any kind. Thus, we are not regulated in that case because we are not engaged in a regulated activity and are in full compliance with regulatory guidelines.
- tigereyeTO 6y agoCISO of ShapeShift here. If our values speak to you, and you're a security researcher - WE ARE HIRING https://shapeshift.com/careers https://shapeshift.com/careers In liberty, --Michael
- Permit 6y agoI'm trying to better understand Shapeshift's business model. How do you make money?
- tigereyeTO 6y agoShapeShift is a platform that provides users with much more than just trading: we are a mobile wallet, a hardware wallet provider with KeepKey, a DEX, and an easy place to manage your crypto assets while retaining control of your private keys. And, for developers, we’re building a powerful software development kit (SDK). ShapeShift is building an ecosystem with the FOX Token at its core, and there are many opportunities to ensure a sound business model within it. We are looking to continually build value into FOX Tokens for the benefit of its holders while establishing a solid financial foundation for our company and our employees.
- mbesto 6y agoCan you simplify a bit? Can I take my USD dollars and buy crypto on your platform or not? If not, how would I obtain crypto and leverage those solutions that you support?
- tigereyeTO 6y agoShapeShift partners with Banxa to process debit and credit card transactions. This allows you to buy BTC directly with USD, and the BTC is delivered directly to your own wallet with keys that are in your control. Note that Banxa performs their own KYC for their own MSB services. Once you have some crypto, you can then trade it for other crypto with a few taps on your smartphone, or clicks in your browser. Search your smartphone's app store for ShapeShift and give it a whirl yourself :)
- mbesto 6y ago> Bad guys: we are not your friends. There are various ways of surveilling blockchain transactions that are far more effective than KYC. Not only will we continue to cooperate with authorities where required by law, but we actively collaborate with industry groups to monitor and root out sinister activity. We are here to protect good people, and as such, stand resolutely against evil. "Against evil"...now where have I heard that before... Translation: "We, a private corporation, get to determine what good and evil is. YMMV how/why you qualify for either or."
- oh_sigh 6y agoWhat's the alternative to every individual determining for themselves what they view as good and evil?
- mbesto 6y agoHow is this an example of that? The company is explicitly saying that IT is determining who is a bad actor and who is not.
- thomaszander 6y agoAnd the worst they can do is choose to not do business with them... Whereas you doing full KYC with most companies, who are by law also forced to determine who is a bad actor, doesn't scare you?
- googlryas 6y agoA company is a collection of individuals. It wouldn't make sense to say an individual can determine X but 10 individuals voluntarily organizing together can't determine X.
- mbesto 6y ago> A company is a collection of individuals. What's your point? Facebook is a collection of individuals, but if Zuck wants political ads barred from his platform he can snap his fingers and make it happen. Having individual private companies become the arbiters of justice for good/bad actors is not a sound resolution...especially when it comes to fraud/identify theft.
- vizzah 6y agoApplause. KYC is the most abused wealth verification requirement, worst modern plague of freedom, personal data protection and privacy of wealth accumulation.