5 ms·
This feels like a ridiculous comparison. Free speech protects people from going to prison. Flexible OS options enable some personal choices with a product. Even
by UncleMeat 6y ago
This feels like a ridiculous comparison. Free speech protects people from going to prison. Flexible OS options enable some personal choices with a product. Even if we take a much wider view of free speech (protection from corporate interference), this is still a massive stretch.
Free speech is enshrined in the constitution because, although dangerous, lawmakers generally believe that protecting it is critical to the long term success of the nation (and not every nation even agrees with this). I see no world where exec permissions on arbitrary directories on my phone is critical to the long term success of the nation.
- fsflover 6y agoGeneral-purpose computing protects people from being trapped in a walled garden, from dealing with the monopoly. You bought a phone and you can only ask the vendor to fix and update it, not anyone else. Replace "a phone" with "a car" or "a tractor" [0] and see how ridiculous and anti-consumer it is. The current state results in a huge amount of e-waste instead of encouraging reuse of the smartphones. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22482598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22482598
- UncleMeat 6y agoGeneral-purpose computing is not being attacked or eliminated. Hobbyists and specialists can buy products for them if they like. The monopoly discussion is a red herring because monopolies are bad regardless of whether those business offer fully customizable software.
- fsflover 6y ago> General-purpose computing is not being attacked or eliminated. Yes, it is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279. > Hobbyists and specialists can buy products for them if they like. Which phones can I buy to enjoy the freedom of general-purpose computing (and not suffer from non-mature ecosystem)? Which vendors manufacture hardware compatible with FLOSS? > The monopoly discussion is a red herring because monopolies are bad regardless of whether those business offer fully customizable software. If the phone runs free software, it makes it not a monopoly, because I can ask another company to write software for me.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> Which phones can I buy to enjoy the freedom of general-purpose computing (and not suffer from non-mature ecosystem)? Does Libram not count? Why do you get to also demand a mature ecosystem? This feels like demanding that corporations build a product specifically because you want it. There are precious few markets where we demand that businesses provide a product that the market wouldn't naturally demand, and I personally don't think that a general purpose computing phone should be one of those. This whole discussion also feels a bit disingenuous now that you've brought up FLOSS, since Android has never really satisfied FLOSS-advocate goals. So why would it matter to you if exec privileges are changed?
- fsflover 6y agoLibrem 5 counts [0], but it just started shipping. You can only get one in several months if you buy it now. Even for Librem 5, there is a problem of proprietary software in WiFi, Bluetooth and modem. It was a great struggle of Purism to find reasonable hardware, all vendors refuse to support FLOSS [1]. > since Android has never really satisfied FLOSS-advocate goals Android was never FLOSS and it's getting even worse. AOSP is FLOSS, but you cannot use it without proprietary drivers. The latter force you to replace your phone every 2-3 years resulting in huge e-waste. It should definitely be "a market where we demand that businesses provide a product", at least for the nature. > Why do you get to also demand a mature ecosystem? Because many businesses and even governments force you to use either iPhone or Android. If I choose a GNU/Linux phone, I cannot use their services at all. [0] Precursor would be more appropriate here, but it's only on preorder and is extremely slow, and lacks the modem: https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/precursor https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/precursor. [1] https://puri.sm/posts/breaking-ground/ https://puri.sm/posts/breaking-ground/
- johannboehme 6y agodon't you think this security first approach is bad for our society? If walled golden cages like iOS become the only available option, average users will have an even harder time to get into general purpose computing and programming. Generation iPad doesn't even know what a file system is anymore. And updating an existing product i own to kill its main function i use for work is outright evil. It's like your car pushing an update restricting it to only drive on vendor approved roads, because there are some people getting in accidents on poorly maintained dirt roads.
- forgotmypw17 6y ago20 years ago, every computer available was a general purpose computer. Today, very few computers available are gpc.
- johannboehme 6y ago"Hobbyists and specialists can buy products for them if they like" Where? Linux phones are atm unusable as daily drivers.