11 ms·
I couldn't disagree more with your post. The author is basically just putting out a detailed study plan for passing an exam. If a doctor posted a plan for passi
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I couldn't disagree more with your post. The author is basically just putting out a detailed study plan for passing an exam. If a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" That seems like a ridiculous stretch in my opinion.
To your second point, I hear this all the time in threads about tech interviewing: "Tech interviews are biased and make no sense" and also "I'm too busy to have to do a lot of work for this interview." If you don't want to put the time in to prepare, fine, don't, and then see how you do. Again, in my mind it's very similar to studying for the medical boards - in most cases doctors have many, many thousands of hours under their belt in training before still needing to study a ton to pass their boards.
- logicchains 6y ago>in most cases doctors have many, many thousands of hours under their belt in training before still needing to study a ton to pass their boards The difference is that what the doctors put so much time into learning can actually be quite useful for their job. The vast majority of competitive coding stuff isn't. Interview procedures based around it completely fail to assess some of the most important abilities in software engineering, like API design. As anyone who's ever used any of Google's open source libraries would have noticed, hiring people who do well at competitive coding problems is no guarantee they'll be able to produce decent software.
- tuvistavie 6y ago> The difference is that what the doctors put so much time into learning can actually be quite useful for their job. I'd be curious to hear what a doctor would think about that. My intuition would be that, as for almost any exam, a lot of time is spent on things that will not be useful for any other purpose than the exam itself.
- cableshaft 6y agoEven if it isn't, do doctors have to retake these exams multiple times (as developers have to do this for multiple interviews) every two years when wanting to switch jobs (doctors often don't have to switch jobs, they often have their own practice).
- reidjs 6y agoIn somewhat of a parallel, you don’t have to switch jobs either, you can start your own software company at any time ;)
- cableshaft 6y agoI've tried doing freelance before, and I was a terrible marketer for myself. While that's definitely an option for people in this industry, I'm not sure it's a great path for me.
- s0rce 6y agoSame with medicine. Although under-served markets are common you still have to market yourself in private practice. New specialists advertise to GPs to get referrals for example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dntrkv 6y agoThey also have to go to school for 10 years before they’re even allowed in the job market. I’ll take our sometimes silly interview processes over that.
- filoleg 6y ago>They also have to go to school for 10 years before they’re even allowed in the job market. Not to mention that during that time they are accruing loans in insane amounts (we are talking about $200-300k) and get worked in insane shifts (24-36 hour shifts are not unheard of during residency rotations). Oh, and they don't get paid at all until they start residency rotations which is AFTER 4 years of med school, and their pay during residency is on the order of $30k-50k for what effectively amounts to 80-100 hours a week. Mind you, that's on top of the fact that in the US, you only enter a med school after you already got a college degree. So you enter a med school at the age of 23. I have respect for the doctors, but I definitely do not envy their position. Their real work doesn't even start until their 30s, at which point they are already really deep in student loan debt. Of course it is manageable, since they get paid handsomely. But their work-life balance and the entire process where you start your "real work" after the age of 30 with $200-300k in loans, at that point, isn't something that a lot of people consider when they think "those doctors are having it nice." It isn't even a second thought to me that I would much much rather study for interviews every single time i switch a job as a software engineer than deal with what doctors deal. And that's not even mentioning that studying for a typical software dev interview is absolutely nothing compared to the studying that med school students have to do in order to pass their board exams.
- UncleMeat 6y agoIs that true? I don’t know anything about medical licensing, but after having a few friends take the California bar exam, I’ve heard endless complaints about having to study things like divorce law in order to become a privacy advocate.
- SaltyBackendGuy 6y agoLaw might be different. An anecdote my Dad (Lawyer) used to tell me. > I went to school to learn the law. After school I had to teach myself how to be a lawyer.
- nunie123 6y agoYes, the bar exam requires you to learn much law you'll never use. They are a general test that covers all areas of the law. Boards are for specific specialties. You don't take a board to be a doctor, you take a board to be a podiatrist, etc. Personally, I think both exams are about protectionism more than anything else. Source: have taken a bar exam, have a wife that's a doctor.
- wyclif 6y agoIt's the same in land surveying with the LPS licensing exams.
- programmertote 6y agoI agree with your comment. My wife took USMLE exams (all three steps) and she would complain to me that most of the stuff she memorize there, she'd forget them in a year or so (and eventually resort to Google and/or https://www.uptodate.com/home https://www.uptodate.com/home to refresh/review). :)
- hinkley 6y agoBut in the case f doctors and lawyers, they pass it once, not every time they interview for a new job. Software doesn’t have licensing, so we do this bullshit every single time.
- meesles 6y agoI tend to be on your side of the fence but I have to nitpick your argument: At these companies, algorithms and the basics are fundamentally important. Because you tend to work on tiny parts of a massive whole, there is no tolerance for cowboy-coding and not following best-practices. IMO the interviews test that you can fall in line and follow the patterns that have been in place for decades. With regards to using API design as something that is not assessed: System design questions do test this. Also at a company like FB, there's a handful of people designing APIs that are at the top of the pyramid, and even then long-standing conventions around API design at those companies will short-circuit the need for most devs to think about how to organize and name their endpoints. At my small startup where most of us write an API endpoint, it's important to know. For a UI dev or someone optimizing DB lookups at massive software companies, API design is not something that needs to be tested. Personally I can admit to feeling frustrated that passing these types of interviews is not my forte. It sucks that I would have to study for weeks to not flop these interviews even though I consider myself a good software engineer. But that doesn't 100% invalidate their interview process.
- danenania 6y agoThat all makes sense for hiring people to work on big existing systems, but many of these large companies are also trying to innovate and build new products with smaller, more agile teams. Sure, you’ll still need to integrate with established APIs and focus more on scalability than you would at a startup, but the kind of people who excel in each type of role will have very different personalities and skillsets. Grading them on the same curve in interviews seems like a pretty bad idea.
- xiphias2 6y ago> That all makes sense for hiring people to work on big existing systems, but many of these large companies are also trying to innovate and build new products with smaller, more agile teams. Which innovation of Facebook are you describing? Instagram, WhatsApp, or the stories?
- 6y ago
- gamerDude 6y agoMy ex girlfriend is a pediatric cardiologist who recently passed her boards. When I talked to her about it, she was very much on the side that she wished she didn't have to study for it because it didn't have much to do with her job at all. She just wished she could spend her time getting better at the skills she actually used rather than a wide range of academic material that didn't matter to her day to day. Her friends from residency thought similarly. That's just a few data points and maybe some doctors are helped, but it definitely isn't every doctor.
- lhorie 6y agoSimilarly, I spoke to a pharmacist recently, and they said the same thing: the board exams expected the person to know information about medication that was no longer even in use.
- mathattack 6y agoIs it that they need to create some objective barrier to entry?
- gowld 6y agoYes. It's a way to artificially limit supply, to prop up wages for people on the inside. It's common to most "licensed" professions.
- base698 6y ago> "What the student thought was it temporary concession to the system-"I'll play along just enough so that I can get what I want from the system"-turns out to be the beginning of it forced, permanent adjustment to the system." This is common to all professional disciplines. https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B008GRDKPG https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B008GRDKPG
- reaperducer 6y agoNice affiliate link there. Is that your own book you're flogging, too?
- dntrkv 6y agoVirtually every FANG interview I’ve done has covered API design as part of system design. My brother is currently in med school, a huge chunk of his time studying is spent on rote memorization. Their Leetcode equivalent is Anki (flash cards) which they spend hours on every day, for years. At least with Leetcode, it’s taught me to quickly recognize algorithms and implement my own when needed.
- adrian_b 6y agoVery good point. I completely agree that being good at designing new APIs is one of the most valuable qualities of a programmer and I have never seen a job interview or test that could check this.
- jrd259 6y agoIt's one of the questions I ask when I interview people. I could care less whether you remember some algorithm you could look up in Knuth. I want to know if you can put yourself in your customer's place and design an API that meets their needs.
- hinkley 6y agoLanguage design is one of the hardest skills to master, and as the qualities of a good language include maintaining backward compatibility and longevity, most people who do master it never get to apply what they learned. Instead we only get to see their practice pieces. Their almost but not quite masterpieces. It’s why I could immediately see that XML was going to fail in the long run. Everyone is a language designer? Sure, that’s going to work out. APIs are tiny languages, so learning to do it well is a microcosm of language design. You don’t have to be good at all parts, but if the API you need isn’t in your wheelhouse, everyone will know. And if you build enough of them you’ll discover the limits of your skill.
- jordan_curve 6y agoThe content of the boards exam is actually quite comparable to the content of these interviews. They both cover general knowledge and fundamental concepts that very few working programmers or doctors will ever use, but absolutely should know.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI always wondered why every OSS software project done by / blessed by Google or FB ends up having a terrible API and developer experience (think Angular, React, Go, Tensorflow, Kubernetes), while delivering great functionality (heck, I used all of these and endured the pain for it). I was going for people scratching their own itch during their OSS-at-work time and wanting to show off - but this could very well be a better explanation.
- jimktrains2 6y agoI don't think that a comparison to a doctor is warranted: 1) Every employer of a doctor doesn't force them to sit boards for every interview, or ask a cardiologist to know the same as an oncologist. (Sure, there is a good deal of overlap, but there is a good deal that isn't either.) 2) Doctors are a licensed profession and have specific requirements.
- ori_b 6y ago> If a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" If the exam was used to determine seniority of both dermatologists and anaesthesiologists, instead of basic competency heck entering the field, it would indicate a problem.
- endtime 6y agoThe OP doesn't say it's for all technical roles at Facebook, it mentions one specific job title.
- pseudalopex 6y agoSenior software engineer is specific?
- endtime 6y agoYes! When a Senior SWE gets promoted the next title is Staff SWE. See also E5 and E6 at http://levels.fyi http://levels.fyi.
- pseudalopex 6y agoA level is a rank. Not a specialty.
- ori_b 6y agoAh, I see, exactly the way an plastic surgeon gets promoted to pediatrician.
- xienze 6y ago> The author is basically just putting out a detailed study plan for passing an exam. My issue is that someone at a senior level (yes I realize at some of these companies "senior" means "two years of experience") should have to study for 30 days to pass an interview. It should not require the equivalent of preparing for an advanced CS course final exam to evaluate the abilities of someone who has presumably been in the industry for many years.
- drchopchop 6y agoAgreed, just because you're a senior engineer with decades of experience doesn't mean you shouldn't brush up on general fundamentals every once in a while. Leetcode, while being pretty useless in the real world, does get your brain into "answer hard questions under pressure" mode. Systems design questions prompt you to architect things which may be considerably different than you deal with during your day-to-day. Preparing for an interview, for more senior developers, is mostly mental - even if you know the information required, can you retrieve it quickly? Do you get flustered under time pressure? Are you in hour 4 and getting tired/sloppy? A bit of studying can help make some answers automatic, and help you present your best self.
- pseudalopex 6y agoThe interview pressures and the job pressures are completely different.
- sombremesa 6y agoA better comparison is getting into Harvard. Do you really want to go to a school where getting in is a matter of acing a prescriptive test? There's a reason college applications value experience and diversity.
- Simon_says 6y agoYea, to keep the Jews out. https://www.businessinsider.com/the-ivy-leagues-history-of-discriminating-against-jews-2014-12?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/the-ivy-leagues-history-of-d...
- Dirlewanger 6y agoThis hasn't been the case for decades. Go look up how many Jews are in the Ivy Leagues now.
- jimbokun 6y agoYes, now it's used to weed out the Asians.
- Kranar 6y agoI can't speak for Harvard, but in the vast majority of the world, going to college is strictly on the basis of entrance exams, with some countries also using high school grades, nothing more. This is done to avoid bias and/or favoritism. I am not an expert in U.S. admissions but my understanding is that they give points for things like whether your parents are alumni or have donated, whether you play sports, whether you were school "president" or other tests of popularity, and a host of things that in my opinion are pretty poor indicators of whether one should be admitted.
- compiler-guy 6y agoHigh stakes entry-exams have their own problems. Among many other issues, they measure peak performance, rather than sustained performance. US college admissions have many problems, so don't hear me say they don't need reform, but you are also assuming that academics are the sole thing that college is about. It isn't, at least not in the US. US schools value many things beyond pure academics. Among them being leadership (whether or not you were class president is one such indicator), personal initiative, success against the odds and many other things.
- _qulr 6y agoThe US Medical Licensing Examination is mainly for medical students not "senior" physicians, and the pass rate is extremely high for U.S. M.D. medical school graduates, over 90%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Medical_Licensing_Examination#Steps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Medical_Licensin... In other words, it's not a standard job interview technique for doctors, it's a one-time requirement for licensing. The other difference of course is that doctors are legally permitted to open up your guts with a knife, unlike Facebook engineers.
- jac241 6y agoThere are specialty board exams that you take once you're done with residency. Some are written exams. Surgical specialties do oral board exams where they present cases to you and question you on management. Pass rates for those are not as high. Many specialty boards make you take recertification exams every x number of years.
- _qulr 6y agoBut again, these are not job interviews, they're professional licensing requirement imposed by the government, not by employers. And I don't think Facebook requires its engineers to re-interview for their own jobs every x number of years, so that's disanalogous too. Ironically, the last thing that Facebook engineers want is for the government to regulate them. Just wait until they face the professional ethics boards. ;-) When has a programmer ever been kicked out of the industry for unethical behavior? More likely, they get promoted.
- RHSeeger 6y agoDoctors don't need to pass the medical boards for every job they apply to. I don't see how there's even a comparison there.
- vechagup 6y agoThey do need to retake their boards periodically to stay certified. My surgeon father was pulling out his textbooks periodically into his 60s.
- onion2k 6y agoIf a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" That seems like a ridiculous stretch in my opinion. It's more like an oncologist posting that every doctor needs to revise cancer treatments for a month before applying for a role in a hospital without realising that other doctors have spent 10 years specialising in different areas of medicine, and then the hospital being amazing at treating cancer but wondering why they're absolutely terrible at mending broken arms. In this analogy cancer is advertising, and broken arms is privacy.
- georgeglue1 6y agothis is off topic, but medical training (at least in the US) is unfortunately about as dysfunctional as you describe. there's are years of inefficient labor from students, residents, fellows, and junior doctors on procedures they'll never do again (because they relatively cheap)
- dvdbloc 6y agoI’m not sure exactly what you’re describing but sounds like they could be getting practical experience? Like a junior dev doing some scripting grunt work that no one else wanted to do but they are gaining other skills along the way possibly?
- llimllib 6y agoBut at least when you're 10 years into your career you aren't judged based on your boards any longer
- tobmlt 6y agoYou do need to take them every so often to stay certified. This cartel isn’t for slackers, come now. (I jest - half my family is in the medical business. I studied economics for a while)
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoFirst of all, I'm not sure where this "10 years" is coming from. I know many/most "senior" developers who reached that level long before 10 years out of university. Secondly, programming doesn't have a standard licensure process like medicine. If it did, I think a lot of these kinds of interviews that companies do would not be necessary. But as it stands I've interviewed many engineers with years of experience who couldn't competently program, and I'm talking about maybe a tad above FizzBuzz level proficiency.
- vincentmarle 6y agoThat’s a great analogy but doctors will work on saving lives and Facebook’s software engineers will work on ... ads
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoIsn't this just one person's opinion? It's not like this was posted on Facebook's blog - right? At a company Facebook's size - a random Senior Engineer doesn't carry that much weight.
- redisman 6y ago> If a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" That seems like a ridiculous stretch in my opinion. This analogy doesn't work. It's basically the final part of your education in that field (and others). If every hospital / medical center made you quit for a few months to study for their interviews when you switch jobs it would be an analogy. Oh we only hire people who can find a vein in 15 seconds under a suboptimal lighting situation.
- pc86 6y agoIf every hospital felt the need to interview doctors assuming they didn't know how to practice medicine, doctors would definitely take time off between to study. But they don't, because they know everyone has a base level of knowledge. On the flip side I've interviewed people who simply cannot do basic coding tasks.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI'm not sure in which universe you live but I've met plenty of incompetent and ignorant doctors who gave advice which didn't make any sense. Same with lawyers and accountants (accountants have so many certifications it borders the ridiculous). More than the knowledge you've proven to have once, it's important to evaluate ongoing performance and care on the job. That's something you can hardly prove during an interview. A market based model of work with a system of reviews would be an improvement in my book
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jrimbault 6y agoThis feels like a troll post : comparing a final exam with a job interview. One is the end, total sum, of 10 years of study, the other is just... a job change. It's important, but not worth a month of my lifetime. I've only got a few hundreds of those.
- ttymck 6y ago> If a doctor posted a plan for passing the medical boards would your first thought be "Wow, look at that massive medical monoculture problem!" That is fairly close to describing a well known issue with MCATs and medical school admissions, as well as boards, see [0] - note, while I'm not familiar with Pacific Standard, I felt that article gives a good overview of the issue and acts as an omnibus to a number of links of the supporting scholarly information. [0] https://psmag.com/education/be-a-good-doctor-study-the-humanities https://psmag.com/education/be-a-good-doctor-study-the-human...