9 ms·
NFL player IQ by position
- fallentimes 18y agoNo real surprise that the player who is tackled the most (Tailback) has the lowest IQ.
- jm4 18y agoThe Wikipedia entry for the Wonderlic test has some interesting information as well: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wonderlic_Test http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wonderlic_Test There's also a "fan-made" sample test online: http://www.efplfp.stealingisgood.com/wpt.html http://www.efplfp.stealingisgood.com/wpt.html While somewhat indicative of the types of questions you could expect to see on the test the real thing is much more difficult. The questions start out very easy and get progressively more difficult. Many of the questions are not multiple choice either. You write in your answers. Wikipedia says one football player, Pat McInally, got a perfect score. That's an absolutely huge accomplishment. There is only a relative handful of people in the world capable of that. In fact, the vast majority of people don't even finish. Mensa uses the Wonderlic as one of their admission tests and you can qualify with plenty of room to breathe even if you've left 10 questions blank.
- DaniFong 18y agoInteresting. Yet in this study the Wonderlic is keyed to position, not performance in that position. We know that people largely stay within their positions, and we know that metrics like the Wonderlic and the drafting Combine strongly influence both draft decisions, and fielding decisions. We know that such metrics are designed to correspond with existing ideas: in this case, that quarterbacks were smart and tailbacks not so much. It is plausible that this correlation represents bias in the decisions of the coaches, not real ability. In fact, that's what suggested by Malcolm Gladwell. He points out that if you sort by Wonderlic scores, those who come out on top haven't really panned out as great quarterback. If we then look at some of the best quarterbacks of all time, you find that, on the Wonderlic, players are all over the map. Malcolm Gladwell discusses this, on his talk about 'the mismatch problem'. I highly recommend it. http://www.newyorker.com/online/video/conference/2008/gladwell http://www.newyorker.com/online/video/conference/2008/gladwe...
- jimbokun 18y agoAnecdotal, but the article does cite the Patriots offensive line as high scorers on the Wonderlic. They are also considered probably the best offensive line in football. But, yeah, Gladwell raises a lot of surprising points in that talk.
- dpapathanasiou 18y agoI didn't like Gladwell's talk because he ignored baseball: teams like Oakland and Boston have started to understand what metrics do work in assessing player performance (Michael Lewis wrote about this in detail in "Moneyball"). By ignoring something because it doesn't fit in his neat theory, Gladwell loses credibility on this topic.
- mattmaroon 18y agoAnd every topic he writes about.
- michaelneale 18y agoYeah I have noticed that. Reading his stuff reminds me of junk food, kind of nice at the time but not long before either I want more, or regret having read it. I think its the journalist style writing that I find unsatisfying (his books are one of the few I end up leaving lying around, unfinished and never seem to want to pick up again).
- DaniFong 18y agoYou might like to know that Malcolm was asked in an interview elsewhere about Moneyball, and he mentions it as one of his favorite books, and indeed he calls it one of the most important works of nonfiction of the past decade. Apparently he's found a way to resolve these difficulties, but not in a way that found it into a 20 minute talk -- I guess it has to wait for the book.
- dpapathanasiou 18y agoI suppose Gladwell likes Moneyball because it's everything his books are not: a Big Idea that is actually corroborated by all the evidence. I remember reading Blink and thinking, "hey, this anecdote just contradicted a point he made earlier". Gladwell is a great storyteller, but he wants so badly to find larger patterns at work that he overlooks the possibility that there aren't any.
- demandred 18y agoWhen asked about the balls he dropped in big spots, he responded, ‘What about the ball I caught?’” So while an exceptionally score on a standardized test might suggest dyslexia, the guy’s an egotistical bonehead even without mitigating factors. And that is why Manningham is in the NFL and OP is the one writing about him. Excuse someone for wanting to focus on their accomplishments and not their failures and for having a little backbone -- must be a terrible thing to have. Great athletes who aren't uber confident (whether or not they express it externally) aren't great athletes.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoI don't know enough people in sports to be sure about this, but my guess is that the people who try to fix their mistakes rather than crow about their successes are the ones who improve over time.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoThere's no contradiction there. You can crow about your successes all you want, so long as you also consistently try to fix your mistakes. In certain sports, anyway. In other fields -- customer service, for example -- things are different.
- byrneseyeview 18y ago"Doc, the pill you gave me made me vomit uncontrollably all day, and once I recovered I realized that I was still as sick as before." "Oh yeah? Well what about all the times I told people to get some rest and drink lots of fluids?" Yes, I can see how this would be a good success strategy. (I do agree that it's important to recognize when you're doing the right thing, especially in a creative field. But when you're playing a game according to strict rules, on a team, the need to avoid failure is probably greater than the need to avoid success. Especially when you consider that the people who make it to these teams probably emphasized pursuing success over avoiding failure when they were younger, because someone in the 50th percentile in a professional sport might have been in the 99th percentile as an amateur. If nothing else, they should dampen their individuality to reflect the higher average performance of their peers).
- pg 18y agoIt may not be anything so complicated as smarter people being closer to the ball. It looks to me as if there is an inverse correlation between IQ and the running speed necessary in a position. So the simplest explanation for this pattern is that running speed and intelligence aren't highly correlated, and you can't simultaneously optimize for both. E.g. you can pick a smart guy to be your center even if he's slow, because he doesn't have to run much. Whereas in a wide receiver or a running back you just want the fastest guy you can find.
- ojbyrne 18y agoOffensive lineman have other physical traits of value though. Namely they're very large (and strong). You'd have to argue that size and intelligence are highly correlated, which seems a stretch.
- diego 18y agoHis point is that there may be a larger pool of people to choose from, and that you would choose the person with the higher IQ all else being equal. Also a stretch.
- pg 18y agoNo, just that size and intelligence are more correlated than speed and intelligence. My guess is that the correlation between size and intelligence is close to zero. So that would imply there's a negative correlation between speed and intelligence. That would be easy to test: just compare the results of the players' IQ tests with their 40 yard dash speeds.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoThe correlation between size and intelligence is positive, because malnutrition can lower adult IQ and adult size. That correlation is a lot stronger when you control for other variables, of course. And 'speed and intelligence' is not quite the correlation you want -- IQ correlates with mental reaction time, so smarties may be 'faster' for short distances because they get a head start. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Height_and_intelligence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Height_and_intelligence (The talk page for this article is delightful, by the way)
- jonknee 18y agoIt's not everything though. Dan Marino had a famously low Wonderlic--15. It's definitely believable when you hear him speak, but he still got it done in amazing fashion on the field. There's a big list here (it's a SWF and takes a while to load, but is very interesting): http://www.macmirabile.com/wonderlic.htm http://www.macmirabile.com/wonderlic.htm
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- mynameishere 18y agoThey should compare staff positions instead, as coaches and water boys probably display regular IQ patterns.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI'm not sure what you mean here. Do you think the average NFL coach is not of above average intelligence? That job is far too competitive for that to be true.
- mynameishere 18y agoErr, I mean: Instead of comparing linebackers and centers, compare different types of staff on the teams, viz, coaches and water boys, etc.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI would be interested in that. It seems coaches need a lot of the sorts of intelligence (social, etc) that the IQ test misses entirely. But I'd be willing to bet they're still among the smartest guys on the team.
- occam 18y agoHi, Occam here. This is just a map of the white/black ratio of each position. There is a 15 point difference between the mean IQ of European-descended (white) Americans and African-descended (black) Americans Please note this is something You Can't Say so don't speak publicly of it. The most interesting thing to note here is that white players score about half a standard deviation higher than the national white IQ, and black players score about half half a standard deviation higher than the national black IQ. Since life is sort of an IQ test, this isn't too surprising. There are a lot bad decisions you can make to screw up your football career before making the NFL - a higher IQ will keep you away from these things. As always Steve Sailer is indispensable in these matters: "Are football players dumb? Actually, they are fairly smart. The NFL requires draft prospects to take the Wonderlic IQ test. Offensive guards averaged 107, centers and punters 106, quarterbacks and kickers 104. The speed positions averaged lower: halfbacks, free safeties, cornerbacks, and wide receivers averaged from 91 to 94. Still, at both the white positions and the black positions, prospects scored about a half standard deviation higher than the respective white and black national means. Of course, IQ tests do a lousy job of measuring improvisational mental ability, which football players, especially the black ones, are particularly good at. (See my classic article "Great Black Hopes" for the full story.)" That article is here: http://www.isteve.com/blackath.htm http://www.isteve.com/blackath.htm
- run4yourlives 18y agoYour last point main me feel a little better. I was really unimpressed to see that the safety positions were rated so low. In many respects, this is the hardest position on the field to play, because you need to adjust how you play it not only every play, but several times during the play.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- logjam 18y agoInteresting that you simply term this a "white/black" ratio of each position. Why didn't you call it an "advantaged/disadvantaged" ratio? Why not a "beneficiary/victim" ratio? If you are trying to chalk up these differences to some kind of genetic disparity, that in fact Has Been Said, repeatedly, for hundreds if not thousands of years, continues to be loudly parroted by certain segments, and has been repeatedly shown to be uninformed swill. Why don't we see any discussion here about differences in IQ scores of people from different economic classes, in a nation where opportunity (and even access to healthcare) is so disparate between races?
- mattmaroon 18y agoI can't say I agree with his conclusion. Lineman are there mainly to be big and collide with other lineman, whereas receivers have a much more skill-intensive job. They have to try to run in pattern while still breaking free of defenseman, but doing so in such a way that the quarterback still knows where to throw the ball. They have to then catch the ball (requiring them to predict its flight path and adjust their path accordingly, an exercise in physics) then run with it and avoid tackle. I would think 10 extra IQ points would benefit a receiver or a running back far more than a lineman.
- evgen 18y agoIt is obvious that you have never played football. Go read "The Blind Side" and then get back to us.
- dpapathanasiou 18y agoI would think 10 extra IQ points would benefit a receiver Well, these two wide outs are certainly using the old noodle: http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3166/2691471704_abbceab973_b.jpg http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3166/2691471704_abbceab973_b....
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- bouncingsoul 18y agoDon’t tell Tufte that I’ve used the radius, not the proportional area, of the circle as the value for each ellipse! A cardinal sin that I’m using in this case to improve proportion and clarify a point. I don't understand why this is okay. I imagine he means it was hard to perceive the difference between correctly scaled circles, but that means the data is close, not that you should misrepresent it. I can see he's written a book about this, so I should assume he has good reasons, but the ones he gave don't seem it. The problem is that simply scaling the radius exaggerates the difference between numbers because: * 26 is 30% more than 20, but * a circle with radius 26 is 69% larger than a circle with radius 20. I just read an article criticizing this exact thing, but I can't find it again.
- willchang 18y agoActually both area and radius are completely meaningless as a representation of intelligence. Perhaps some figure that represents percentile score would work better -- something like an empty glass for 0%, a glass half-full for 50%, etc; or something like the circles that Consumer Reports uses for rating products.
- chwolfe 18y agoInteresting Outlier: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2008/writers/the_bonus/07/17/rolle/index.html http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2008/writers/the_bonus/07/1...