8 ms·
How I learned to love and fear the Riemann Hypothesis
- wodenokoto 6y agoThe accompanying video popped up on my YouTube recommendation list last night and it is really good. Like, you married a numberphile video with 3blue1brown, good.
- st1x7 6y agoI don't think it comes close to 3blue1brown's video on the same topic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD0NjbwqlYw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD0NjbwqlYw Still nice of the video in the original post to give a bit more of a historical context, instead of focusing entirely on the mathematics. It could have done without the building analogy around the beginning though, that didn't come up later and was just distracting.
- pseudolus 6y ago+1 for the 3blue1brown recommendation. Between the two, a non-mathematician can acquire a layperson's comprehension of the Riemann Hypothesis. Additionally, John Derbyshire (of the unfortunate views regarding race) wrote a very good book "Prime Obsession: Bernhard Riemann and the Greatest Unsolved Problem in Mathematics" that covered both historical and mathematical aspects of the Riemann Hypothesis [0]. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Prime-Obsession-Bernhard-Greatest-Mathematics/dp/0452285259/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=prime+obsession&qid=1609856340&sr=8-2 https://www.amazon.com/Prime-Obsession-Bernhard-Greatest-Mat...
- EricMausler 6y agoThat video made complex analysis click for me
- legel 6y agoFantastic video! For me seeing this math for the first time was a very beautiful surprise.
- frankfrankfrank 6y agoFrom Georg Friedrich Bernhard Riemann's tomb: "Denen die Got dienen müssen Alle dinge zum besten dienen." Translated: "All those that serve God All things best serve them."
- jhncls 6y agoWikipedia seems to disagree (and includes a photo): "Denen die Got lieben müssen, alle dinge zum besten dienen." Which it suggests translating as "For those who love God, all things must work together for the best". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernhard_Riemann https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernhard_Riemann
- wussboy 6y agoWhich is a direct quote from a Bible verse, and would make more sense (but be less mysterious)
- earthboundkid 6y agoSpecifically, Romans 8:28.
- simonh 6y agoIt's also one of the verses that inspired Voltaire's character Dr. Pangloss to declare that "All is for the best in this, the best of all possible worlds."
- credit_guy 6y agoThe video is great. But it fails on two counts. One is that it doesn't say what the title claims. We know now what the Rieman Hypothesis is, but how did the author learned to love, and more importantly to "fear" the RH? What's there to fear? The name of the famous movie (with the bomb) doesn't even have "fear" in it, so the author had something in mind with "fear", but after watching the video, I have no clue what. Second is the promise in the beginning of the video to give us a hint why the RH is important. What we learn is that somehow each zeta zero adds another harmonic to some type of series approximation of the (cousin of the) prime counting function. Which is great; if we add enough harmonics we get to approximate this function as precisely as we want. But why is it important that these zeros are on the vertical line Im z = 0.5 ? I have absolutely no clue. Don't get me wrong, I find that watching this video was a very good investment of 16 minutes of my life. But there is no need to overpromise, especially since the video delivers a lot as is.
- Covzire 6y agoIf one could predict with pinpoint accuracy all the prime numbers approaching infinity with certainty and with trivial resources (without having to test each one for prime-ness), would it have any impact on modern day cryptography?
- simias 6y agoOn RSA-style prime-based crypto potentially but barring a much stronger result than merely being able to cheaply find primes things like ECC would probably still be safe.
- gameswithgo 6y agoBeing able to find primes faster would make modern public key crypto better I guess, since you could find large keys faster and thus use larger keys. Unless the theory also leads to faster factorization methods
- bawolff 6y agoNot an expert, but the key thing is usually factoring, e.g. finding which prime numbers multiplied together make a certain composite number. The hard part is finding which are the right prime numbers (there are lots of prime numbers). Finding numbers that are prime,just generally,is a very quick operation already.
- jbj 6y agoThe vertical scaling of the counting function with log(p) went a little quick, does someone know an easy to digest resource to this? also what would be the logic for now including the p^n of primes, p ??
- war1025 6y agoI felt that way about most of the video. I never took advanced math theory classes, but I have enough background that those classes would probably have been the next step for me if I had continued on. Seemed like every time I felt like he was about to explain something in a way that would click for me, then all the sudden he left out the last two sentences and moved on. Still a neat video though.
- jbj 6y agoSome of my lecturers throughout Uni, always glanced across the entire auditorium to see if anyone needed clarity of what was said before switching slide/erasing the blackboard. Having those extra seconds after something has been said, while being able to watch graphics/text/figures helped the information sink in for me. This moment to digest what was said is not really available in this video, but I guess youtube is different from a lecture in the sense that the whole thing can be set on pause. I think I have the impression that the visual explanation here appeared and sometimes even disappeared before him mentioning the "take-home-message". I am still very impressed with the explainer and the visual assistance though.
- odyssey7 6y agoIf someone wanted to learn more about this type of mathematics, without matriculating at a university, what would be some good starting points?
- SkyBelow 6y ago3Blue1Brown on YouTube has a number of great videos into math that help give a visual understanding without needing to sit down and do the pure number crunching. I'm not sure he has one on the Riemann Hypothesis in particular, but he does cover a number of items that would be somewhat related and help build a level of comfort with being exposed to the math, even if you can't do the pure number crunching. Mathologer would be my second recommendation. Once again not sure he has touched the Riemann Hypothesis, but he does a number of great videos where you can start expanding being comfortable with often untouched fields of math (like modular arithematic) while introducing a how seemingly unrelated fields end up having connections. Videos can go between 20 minutes to an hour and I often enjoy watching one every few days.
- ryanianian 6y agoDepends on your level of {experience, intended engagement, patience for pedantics, intended outcomes}. I've found that 3Blue1Brown (youtube) gives a great starting point for many topics. Provided you actively participate in them, the videos will build up some intuition so you know what questions to ask (and why they're worth asking). The author usually links to followup resources so you know where to go next. I've found his resources a bit hit-or-miss, but they give me enough to know if I want to continue exploring. If I do, I usually check out a good textbook (I refer to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17617825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17617825 often).
- rfurmani 6y agoThis Numberphile video on the Riemann Hypothesis is also very good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6c6uIyieoo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6c6uIyieoo
- phamilton 6y agoI highly recommend https://www.amazon.com/Music-Primes-Searching-Greatest-Mathematics/dp/0062064010 https://www.amazon.com/Music-Primes-Searching-Greatest-Mathe...
- st1x7 6y agoVaguely related question - what is the best textbook that you can recommend for studying complex analysis?
- lldbg 6y ago"Complex Analysis: An Introduction to the Theory of Analytic Functions of One Complex Variable" By Lars Ahlfors was very enjoyable to me. However, I read it after I already knew Complex Analysis.
- rfurmani 6y agoI've heard very good things about Visual Complex Analysis, as well.
- ellis-bell 6y agoi second tristan needham's visual complex analysis. some other good ones: * the one we used in my undergrad course was fisher's complex variables which is great if you're learning for the purposes of applications. it's a cheap dover book. * rudin's real and complex analysis (if theory is your thing. note that rudin's books, while great, do require a good background in math). * as the article mentions, eli stein has a series of books on the four main branches of analysis. i believe the second book is on complex analysis.
- Moeg 6y agoAm I supposed to Google what the hypothesis is? Is it really too much to ask of writers to provide context first?
- Santosh83 6y agoDistantly related question. It was claimed that Alpha Zero taught itself to play incredibly high level chess from the very basic point of playing with itself millions of times after having been fed the basic building block rules of chess and nothing else. Now I'm wondering if something like this can be made to work for discovering new mathematical relationships or solving existing hypothesis by training a neural network with what we know of maths so far and then letting it "play" with the equations? Am I being too naive here?
- whatshisface 6y agoThere is a sense in which that is a great idea, and a sense in which it is a not so great idea. If AlphaProof could prove theorems as superhumanly as AlphaGo wins at Go, that would really be something, they might be able to claim all of the millennium prizes. However, the longterm usefulness to mathematics may be somewhat limited. Mathematicians are interested in proofs not so much because of the statements, but because of what those proofs add to our knowledge of the way math fits together. It isn't just about "true" or "false," it's about why. If AlphaProof generated a long and unreadable proof with no discernible structure, it would not be such a large contribution to mathematics as if a human figured out "why" and wrote it in a way other humans could understand. Of course, it is possible that clever users could tease useful information out of the black box truth oracle. Perhaps by modifying the statement of the conjecture and checking each modification, they could discover some parts of the structure of the problem, which would help inspire a useful proof. Furthermore, it would be helpful to never again waste time trying to prove a false conjecture.
- virgil_disgr4ce 6y agoTrue, and important. However, I suppose it could be argued that if the only results AlphaProof could obtain were long and unreadable proof(s) with no discernible structure, it might suggest something about the epistemic assumptions we tend to make about Occam's Razor and the (so-called) beauty and parsimony. On that angle, it could be further argued that humans are biased towards 'readable' proofs and that there are many undiscovered 'unreadable' proofs that we simply have no way of obtaining without automation of some kind. Anyway I assume there are volumes already written on this subject...
- mpettitt 6y agoMatt Haig's "The Humans" talks about humanity finding the answer to the Riemann Hypothesis being feared universally - it's simultaneously very important to the plot, and a convenient MacGuffin.
- spicymaki 6y agoThis is a great video. I think finally I understand the basics of Riemann hypothesis and the zeta function ζ(s). Thanks for posting this.
- rfurmani 6y agoI love this quote: > A meeting on how to extend the GPY method was immediately organized at the American Institute of Mathematics in San Jose, California. As a bright-eyed and bushy-tailed grad student, I felt extraordinarily lucky to be there among the world’s top experts. By the end of the week, the experts agreed that it was basically impossible to improve the GPY method to get bounded prime gaps. Fortunately, Yitang Zhang did not attend this meeting. Almost a decade later, after years of incredibly hard work in relative isolation, he found a way around the impasse and proved the experts wrong. I guess the moral of my story is that when people organize meetings on how not to solve the Riemann hypothesis (as they do from time to time), don’t go!
- rfurmani 6y agoThat said, I do wish I were at AIM's meeting on the Riemann Hypothesis :-) https://aimath.org/rh2018/ https://aimath.org/rh2018/ The lecture videos are online and are a good way to get both historical context and connection to how people are thinking about it currently. This seminar talk on how to fail to prove RH was also great https://www.math.rutgers.edu/news-events/list-all-events/icalrepeat.detail/2020/09/29/10896/-/how-to-fail-to-prove-the-riemann-hypothesis https://www.math.rutgers.edu/news-events/list-all-events/ica...
- Jabbles 6y agoIs that a link to a VoD or a historical event with no recording?
- mdoms 6y agoOff topic, but does anyone know where one gets started on making motion graphics like in that video? This combination of cool maths and animated visuals is so interesting to me, but I wouldn't even know where to begin. What kind of software is used to generate this kind of visualisation? Are there free or affordable online courses? Is there a job market for someone with this ability and also with software development chops?
- slavik81 6y agoThat was a fantastic video. I was left wondering a bit about the difference between the Riemann Zeta function and the original Zeta function, but I found this 3Blue1Brown video which explains exactly that: https://youtu.be/sD0NjbwqlYw https://youtu.be/sD0NjbwqlYw