6 ms·
If the Iranian employee logged into the Github account, isn't blocking the account exactly what the law says they should do? If all they did was apply a merge r
by jeroenhd 6y ago
If the Iranian employee logged into the Github account, isn't blocking the account exactly what the law says they should do? If all they did was apply a merge request in one of the repos then would reverting the merge and blocking the account would be enough to comply? Is there some alternative way to comply with US export restrictions?
The real question here is why people even consider using US cloud companies when they know they have employees working in countries subject to severe US trade restrictions. If you're willing to risk your company being denied business with American companies, then you should also have a mitigation strategy when you get caught. It sucks that you have to work around US regulation to do normal business but this is just how the world works right now.
- canofbars 6y agoWould it not be sufficient to just block requests from Iran rather than shut down the account and the groups they are in? That way when they return home they can still access the site.
- ceejayoz 6y agoGiven the legal penalties for violating sanctions and the vigor with which they are pursued, probably not. Should it be this way? No. Is it entirely Github’s fault they overreact to any sign they’re serving Iranian users? Also no.
- austincheney 6y agoI believe that would be illegal. I suspect the reasoning is that the US is not on friendly terms with the government of Iran, which is a political squabble and not a conflict with the people therein, even though the practical consequences are indecipherable. The US military has been wrestling with that reasoning for about 20 years. If the majority of attacks and intrusions on military infrastructure originate from a single nation state and there exists evidence that most such attacks are sponsored by that nation state it would make sense to simply block all IP addresses originating from that nation state. This does not occur because the attorneys will not allow it due to both diplomatic and legal reasons.
- jfrunyon 6y agoIranian company uses VPN service to get around the block - VPN goes down and their requests to GitHub go directly - GitHub blocks those requests; the Iranian company continues using them once the VPN is back on - US government finds out - Bye bye GitHub
- brmgb 6y agoIt's not an Iranian employee. That's just someone visiting Iran and login to their GitHub account. GitHub reaction is outrageously disproportionate. They should just prevent login from Iran. They had no basis for blocking a legitimate customer in Europe based on this.
- cies 6y agoFunny how GH gets shit for what the US has as laws. I'd focus my outrage on the law, the lawmaker, and those who uphold it. GH is merely trying to go by the book/ avoid penalties, as expected.
- matsemann 6y agoA single person has no way of influencing this. Twisting Github's and others' arms is a great proxy. If they get flak for their handling of this, they can go argue with law makers.
- brmgb 6y agoThe US embargo prevents doing business with Iran. Providing service in Iran would be a violation of the embargo. Blocking a whole European company not conducting business with Iran because one of its employee tried to login while there is not respecting the embargo, it's just overreach. GitHub should get flak for that in the same way Paypal regularly get flak for randomly freezing accounts.
- kitd 6y agoThe real question is why GH blocks an Indian company and all its Indian employees (all legal and outside the US sanctions list) when an employee logs on in Iran. Does US law require application to such an extreme degree? If not, then why is GH doing it?
- rad_gruchalski 6y agoBecause github is a company based in the USA and must comply with the law of USA. It does not matter where the customer of github is based. It would be the same with gitlab because they are based and hosted in the USA. If you are German and USA decides to apply sancations on Germany because of NordStream2 tomorrow, well, good luck setting up your own gitlab ce...
- kitd 6y agoOfc GH has to comply with US law, but you missed the question: does US law require blocking access to cover those who are not on the sanctions list? Or look at it another way: this is an Indian company. Does one employee opening their laptop in Iran make it an Iranian company under US law?
- richardwhiuk 6y agoIf the employee was Iranian, then yes, GitHub would be required to do this.
- kitd 6y agoNo it wouldn't. https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/faqs/118 https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/...
- ChrisLomont 6y ago"If the employee was Iranian, then yes,...."
- agilob 6y ago>If the Iranian employee logged into the Github account, isn't blocking the account exactly what the law says they should do? Does everyone in the world need to subscribe to "a list of countries US jurisdiction doesn't like" just so we will be able to work, check email or review opensource code while being on holiday in an exotic country?
- gnopgnip 6y agohttps://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/faqs/118 https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/... 118. I have a client that is in Iran to visit a relative. Do I need to restrict the account? Answer No. As long as you are satisfied that the client is not ordinarily resident in Iran, then the account does not need to be restricted. See FAQ 37.