5 ms·
But didn't Bitcoin want to be a currency and not stocks?
by croes 6y ago
But didn't Bitcoin want to be a currency and not stocks?
- eloff 6y agoMore like digital gold. Calling it a currency is really not an apt description.
- minitoar 6y agoUnfortunate they called it a 'coin' then. Maybe it should've been Bitgold. Digimetal.
- thinkmassive 6y agoThe name Bit Gold was already recently used for a similar project by Nick Szabo when Bitcoin was announced: https://nakamotoinstitute.org/bit-gold/ https://nakamotoinstitute.org/bit-gold/ Contrary to what many people who only recently discovered Bitcoin probably believe, it was not created in a vacuum as some Ponzi scheme. Instead it was a concept that had been iterated on for decades until Satoshi discovered the right combination of cryptographic technologies and economic incentives to make a so-far-unstoppable decentralized digital currency.
- arcticbull 6y agoWell, Satoshi was more than likely Paul Calder Le Roux who wanted a way to launder the proceeds of his crime network. > Instead it was a concept that had been iterated on for decades until Satoshi discovered the right combination of cryptographic technologies and economic incentives to make a so-far-unstoppable decentralized digital currency. You know how that sounds right? Like religion, not clear-headed thinking.
- thinkmassive 6y agoI expect Bitcoin to affect monetary systems in a way similar to how FOSS changed software. My opinion is neither of those is a religion. The development of Bitcoin in particular sounds more like following the scientific method to me, but you're entitled to your own interpretation.
- kylebenzle 6y agoIt says in the title of the paper, Digital CASH. But, ever since Blockstream (Adam Back and Greg Maxwell) hijacked the GitHub repo years ago Bitcoin (BTC) has purposefully failed at this central use case. However, the project and White Paper live on in projects like Monero, Bitcoin Cash and Ethereum.
- cubano 6y agoBTC has already been legally ruled as property, not currency, I believe if I read the ruling correctly. Not digital gold, but pharmaceutical grade gold as Saylor put it in a recent Odd Lots pod, and it's hard to argue that...also quoted from the same pod..[not a perfect transcript] "...so that took us to cryptos and we looked at 6500 cryptos and we found that BTC is the dominant network. its 25x bigger than the next closest thing that looks like it, and has more than $200bil monetary energy in it. it is basically Facebook or Google for money. and this is the nuance that most people haven't realized yet..what you have is a dominant digital network that has been engineered to host a safe haven treasury reserve asset superior to gold in all respects. it's pharmaceutical grade gold [love this line]. if God [blurb] gold as a treasury reserve asset to hold for 100 years, he would create 21mil gold coins, he'd make it impossible to make any more, he would make it possible to audit it from anywhere on earth from any node every 10 minutes, make it unhackable and make it an open architecture where you could build it into an iphone or into Square or paypal or any other exchange without permission, and he would distribute it everywhere on earth with these crypto SHA256 miners so hat no company controls it, no CEO controls it, no country controls it, and no regulators control it..."[0] [0] https://play.acast.com/s/oddlots/6b8b72d0-455c-11eb-b9ed-377604512ee6 https://play.acast.com/s/oddlots/6b8b72d0-455c-11eb-b9ed-377...
- ordinaryradical 6y agoBut given the dynamics of PoW mining, isn't bitcoin defacto controlled by a handful of Chinese mining cartels, which are themselves controlled by the CCP? I feel like this whole pitch makes sense until you get to that part.
- cubano 6y agoSo in a way...who cares who mines it? Do you care who owns your real estate before you buy it? Or who mines your gold before you wear it? Probably not. Yes I suppose there is some political aspect to that side of it, but the crypto itself...it's about as apolitical as it gets.
- qw3rty01 6y ago
- squeaky-clean 6y agoThe first sentence of the bitcoin whitepaper is literally "A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution."
- chillacy 6y agoI think it's safe to say that the BTC community has pivoted to a more fitting use case for their technology. The Bitcoin Cash fork and Litecoin made scaling choices that make it better for payments.
- EpicEng 6y agoAnd if they said it were a unicorn, would that make it true? It's not a currency because you can't use it as a currency.
- eloff 6y agoIt doesn't matter what it was marketed as. It matters what it is. But they made it deflationary and a good currency needs to be inflationary otherwise you just hold onto it instead of spending it. Which had made it more like a digital gold. It has totally failed as a system for payments for this and other reasons. It is also too slow and too expensive per transaction.
- kylebenzle 6y agoBitcoin (capital B) still is! The Bitcoin Core project (BTC) was hijacked years ago by corporate interests (Adam Back's Blockstream) and crippled to push their "second layer" solutions to the problem they themselves created. The Bitcoin project lives on and most real users and developers moved to other projects like Ethereum, Bitcoin Cash and Monero the same time Blockstream wrestled control of the Bitcoin Core GitHub repo.
- ashtonkem 6y agoBitcoin is Schrödinger’s program. Whenever it’s deficiencies are pointed out, it suddenly becomes something else. Bad transaction rate? It’s not a currency, it’s a store of value! Why does it have value? Because it’s more stable than fiat! What about the volatility? Ignore daily volatility, it’s going to the moon! But why is it worth more? Because you can buy stuff with it, like a currency! Round and round it goes.
- Closi 6y ago10/10 best explanation of Bitcoin I have heard yet. The argument for bitcoins price from even bitcoins advocates usually seems to ultimately boil down to “It’s valuable because the price of it is going up”. If you ask why the price is what it is, the answer is basically that it’s high because it’s going to be even higher in the future! It might be even higher in the future, but this has no economic fundamentals behind it.
- tekkk 6y agoIt's psychological anchoring and a mixture of greed combined with a technical innovation which isn't terrible per se, but which does not in fact solve the problem it was originally designed to do. Made artificially inefficient to compute to stop the evil governments and organizations which were apparently making life impossible before the existence of cryptocurrencies. Now it has become inevitability because its price is going up and therefore by induction it has become more valuable and necessary for the whole society. With all the free money that is currently floating around bitcoin is again slowly moving towards its saturation point where the pool of potential buyers is exhausted and the prices have become unsustainably high. The psychology of the market will reverse causing a "run on the bank" (which apparently is a good thing by some gold standard advocates in this thread) and it will again sink like a stone without anything to stop its fall. A good thing to remember is that bitcoin has yet to face a real depression akin to dotcom bubble. If and when it falls to levels so unfathomably low that it would incur losses so heavy that would shake the whole industry to its core, then it might forever lose its status as a digital store of value which price increases forever to infinity. One thing I must say and what most people forget is that bitcoin is also a form of gambling and which actually explains some of its success. It has the characteristics of a sport which is fun to discuss, interesting to research and easy to bet on with a lot of volatility that can be as addicting as gambling in a casino (which again shares a lot of similarities to traditional stock investing or the collection of art pieces). Can we explain why gambling or sports are so addicting or necessary to the whole society? We humans are emotional creatures that believe in the most silliest of things that defy normal logic yet which we can not unravel like the people living in a cave in Plato's allegory. What in the end is real? God is dead said Nietzsche and therefore we are constantly seeking something "valuable" to cling onto.