12 ms·
A comparison of city building games
- coffeeboy27 6y agoTropico, in general, is always being slept on. Tropico 6 is a genre defining game in my opinion. If you're into city building games I highly recommend giving it a chance.
- elthran 6y agoAgreed with Tropico - great tongue in cheek setting and feel. For whatever reason though, which I can't quite put my finger on, the gameplay in T6 just feels worse to me than T4/5, as if its been dumbed down
- eastbayjake 6y agoStarted with the original Tropico when it first came out, just downloaded Tropico 4 to play over the holidays based on some feedback that 4 had less complex and more fun gameplay than 6. Any perspective on which is the best in the series?
- Alenycus 6y agoI've put a bunch of hours into 3 4 5 and 6. I'd rank them 4 > 6 > 5 > 3. 4 is clearly the best though, everything just seems to hit the perfect balance between simple fun and complexity, and the writing and character rpg elements made me want to play with different play styles. 6 is big, but I find myself getting bored in the middle game. 3 and 5 are just worse than 4 in essentially every way. All are fun though.
- bobthepanda 6y agoIt is different than all the other city building games listed, in that you place all the buildings by hand. That being said I would not really count Transport Tycoon as a city building game because transport is literally the name of the game.
- test1235 6y agois there a way to read this in a compiled format complete with images an' all?
- sabellito 6y agoYeah, it's kinda crazy to me that people post.. well, posts using twitter. It's not ideal to share this type of content.
- timw4mail 6y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1345955063353597954.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1345955063353597954.html
- test1235 6y agoah, awesome! thanks very much
- timw4mail 6y agoOpenTTD is a great game, especially considering it's free.
- aequitas 6y agoOpenTTD is indeed great, but I wouldn't categorize Transport Tycoon as a city building game, instead you build a transport company. You can have some influence on how the cities in the game develop, but they are more tricks to influence the city building AI in building a more optmized city instead of actual intended gameplay elements imho. Things like grid layouts for roads (which the AI won't destroy) or terraforming terrain around the city.
- timw4mail 6y agoThat's certainly true. I kind of like the fact that if you mess with a city too much they'll get mad at you .
- baud147258 6y agoDon't you need the files from the original game to use it?
- misnome 6y agoYou used to, but it now has FOSS graphics/music/sound packs that you can use.
- mhh__ 6y agoIt wasn't very ergonomic last time I tried a few years ago but you can even play it on android
- RobertKerans 6y agoDoes the AI still go crazy? The last time I played (~5 years ago iirc) it still did the trick of filling all possible space in an area with loops of train tracks (which are then impossible to shift later on unless you buy them out). Still my all-time favourite game though even despite that
- ekianjo 6y agoAnother twitter thread that should have been a blog post...
- rement 6y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1345955063353597954.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1345955063353597954.html edit: I agree with you though. This should have been a blog post.
- SECProto 6y agoI only read it /because/ it was a twitter thread. I wouldn't have clicked the link if it had been a blog post (unless I read the comments here and found a compelling reason) To defend twitter: each tweet in the thread has to have a point, something compelling about it - and in this case, an image with each. The limitations of twitter force the author to write concisely (as opposed to blogs, where paragraphs can be as rambling and long-winded as the author pleases). The medium also allows persons to reply to any individual tweet - performing a similar role as threaded comments on a site like HN, but more focused. Twitter is an ideal format for short-to-medium length content like this.
- ekianjo 6y ago> I only read it /because/ it was a twitter thread > Twitter is an ideal format for short-to-medium length content like this. So you do enjoy having text broken down in small pieces inside an interface that's obviously made for short messages, with ads on the side, and replies right in the middle of the main body of the text? All right. I guess we have different standards of readability.
- brewdad 6y agoAs if blogs don't have ads on the side or even in the middle of a post occasionally. A properly threaded message will have all of the content linked together with replies falling all the way to the bottom. Just like a blog. Twitter isn't nearly as difficult to use as some people like to make it out to be. My biggest petpeeve on Twitter. Is 30 different replies of "@ThreadReaderApp unroll".
- jagger27 6y agoI want to see a remaster, or some sort of faithful remake of SimCity 4. Something about its crisp graphics and trimetric camera projection feels irreplaceable. I still frequently listen to the soundtrack while I work too. God I love that game. If EA released the sources to it or created a “Definitive Edition” I could die happy.
- ascagnel_ 6y agoI'd want a lot more than a faithful remake of SC4 (although SC4 would be a great starting point) -- the SimCity games have always, to a degree, been games that follow suburban California's zoning laws, and they're really great at making sprawling California suburbs. Just a few things I'd want to add to city games: - Model water runoff as pollution from agricultural zones. - Transport-in-road designs -- surface level transport takes up far, far too much land space because the game doesn't support urban infrastructure properly. In SC4, things like subway entrances and bus stops always take up a full tile, when they're typically no more than a portion of the sidewalk or a road sign (and maybe a shelter), respectively. - Mixed-use zoning. It's probably been the single biggest wish I've had for the SimCity games. It's impossible to build a vertical downtown if you're stuck trying to mix together commercial and residential plots, when many residential buildings along avenues feature ground-level commercial (making them effectively "light" density commercial contained within "dense" residential).
- jagger27 6y agoSC4 has some rudimentary water pollution mechanics with agriculture being among the worst polluters. It was pretty easy to avoid just by having a separate water towers or pumps for your farms and city and make sure you didn't connect the two systems. The Network Addon Mod (NAM) addressed most of the transportation issues I have with SC4. I remember having a mod that had road/bus and road/subway combo stations but I'm not sure if it was part of NAM or not. Mixed use zoning would be amazing, absolutely. Without it, it makes designing Main St and walkable cities nearly impossible. This kind of medium density zoning is something that SimCity has always been bad at. Somehow I think Cities Skylines is even worse at it.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoSimCity is why for my first MS-DOS machine I went with a Hercules graphics card and paperwhite monitor. The added resolution and clarity seemed much more important than the color that came from CGA (EGA and VGA were far outside of my budget at the time). The game played really well on monochrome.
- meddlepal 6y agoCheck out NewCity on Steam if you want a pretty cool advanced SimCity-esque builder. Its quite advanced for early-access.
- ledbettj 6y agoJust a warning that although it claims to support Linux, on launch I got two options: * Run without wine (Linux) * Launch with wine The first one took me to a black screen. The second took me into the game but the colors were entirely wrong -- everything was red and black. So caveat emptor.
- dangrover 6y agoIt's really good! I like that the zoning is more realistic and the finances seem to make more sense (e.g. when you hit $0 cash you start borrowing automatically, rather than having to explicitly take out a loan, and also you have to pay emminent domain when you destroy someone's building). Also the regional scale is neat.
- dghouk 6y agoSkylines is far more flexible than the author gives it credit for. At this point it’s more of a platform for community content than a game, it would be very common to see almost no vanilla resources used (maybe besides roads) in a build. The vanilla assets are often both ugly and poorly optimized, something from Steam can look more realistic while also having fewer triangles! See the “low poly trees” collection for an example. It’s also very common for the player to use place every building manually, contrary to to the author’s table. If you check out /r/CitiesSkylines or YouTube, anything that looks really good is likely done this way. The game also doesn’t force you to prefer transit vs. cars, it’s very flexible and you can build an Asian, European, or American (NYC or “sprawl”) styles easily. YouTube examples I can think of: - Nydal - European – Marble Mountain – American (California) – Kobyashi Island – Japanese
- jbob2000 6y agoMy only criticism of Skylines is that it’s not a game, it’s just an art board for painting cities that move. There aren’t enough meaningful challenges to building your city, the reward for playing comes from making something aesthetically appealing.
- capableweb 6y ago> the reward for playing comes from making something aesthetically appealing More like "The reward comes from playing with your own objectives and succeeding at them" which is one of the hallmarks of sandbox games, not just Cities: Skylines in particular. I've played Cities: Skylines quite a bit, the genre is my favorite one. While I agree the game doesn't force you into completing arbitrary objectives, I've found it quite challenging myself, but that's also because I setup my own objectives to be challenging.
- mrguyorama 6y agoIndeed, if you DO actually try to "play" and build a functioning city, the inability to handle traffic in any way basically stops you dead at small town size
- 6y ago
- jandrese 6y ago> Though it's Californian to the point of having Nuclear Free Zone ordinances, SimCity allows players to set tax property tax rates above 1%. (probably because it would be unplayable otherwise) Major shade being thrown at the state of CA here.
- aidenn0 6y agoThe effective property tax rate in CA is actually well below 1%, since assessed values of properties are not allowed to rise faster than inflation or 2%, whichever is smaller. When I bought my house, the effective property tax on it went from 0.1% to 1%, as the assessed value under Prop 13 was 1/10 of the purchase price.
- qndreoi 6y agoI've been intrigued by property taxes since reading a book by Heinlein that sat on the shelf for 40 years before being published last year, "The Pursuit of the Pankera". In this otherwise forgettable story, the family settles on an Earth in a parallel universe where most of the taxes are property taxes. The rate is set by the government, but each parcel is self-assessed by the owner. The catch is that anyone, including the government can purchase the property at the assessed value at any time. It sounds like a good idea, that would encourage fairness, but I wonder if there are unforeseen consequences I am overlooking.
- aidenn0 6y agoI heard that idea attributed to Heinlein many years ago from a friend who read everything he wrote. A few downsides I thought of 1. It makes it easier for rich people to do mean things to poor people (it's not like there aren't already lots of ways, but something to think about) 2. In rapidly changing conditions, people who neglect to file their paperwork will get screwed -- either significantly overpay or get kicked out of their houses for below-market values. The people who are neglectful in paperwork are probably disproportionately those that we typically aim to protect with government interventions 3. Eminent domain changes a bit; people would naturally price their houses for above-market values, because being forced to move unexpectedly is a hassle, so you would assess your value at a premium to avoid that hassle. This means the government would likely have to pay more for property than the "fair market value" that courts require. Depending on where you fall on the political spectrum, that may be okay. 4. Holdouts[1] tend to be popular. Making it financially untenable to be a holdout thus might be too unpopular a law to pass. 4: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holdout_(real_estate) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holdout_(real_estate)
- markwillis82 6y agoAre there any mobile versions that are good and not in app purchases / time based? I wouldn’t mind paying for a game but not a fan of the time based, gem collecting price models. Would rather pay for the app and just play
- n4s33r 6y agoPocket City is okay
- adamjb 6y agoOpenTTD has an android port but no ios port (something to do with GPL iirc)
- vestrigi 6y agoI would have recommended TheoTown but apparently they moved to a time based IAP model with their mobile app. The steam version is still a single time purchase and a great game for the low price. While checking out TheoTown on the App Store I found out that there is a paid Tropico version that seems to be a full game.
- Can_Not 6y agoIt sucks that TheoTown has a small number of "buy with gems" buildings and offers you normal game money for watching ad videos, but otherwise it really is the closest you can get to SimCity2000 on Android, maybe even better. Almost everything else is a shitware Farmville clone with city building aesthetics.
- jondlove 6y agoI appreciate the author mentioning 'Soviet Republic'; as a lover of city builders, it is my current addiction and I can recommend it as a great game if you are interested in both city building and logistics management. The thread glosses over the "player builds everything" feature, but that's not the half of it: everything in your nation is open for your consideration: the buildings you construct; the food your people eat; the transport vehicles and fuel needed to run them - you can choose to set up supply chains all the way from extraction, to refinement, to manufacturing and export - or import the things (and manpower) you don't care about, at a cost. Think "Rise of Industry" or OpenTTD meets Tropico, but you also need to source the resources and manpower to build your buildings, roads, and railways. I also find the mod selection (namely a wide variety of buildings) to be quite an asset to the game
- wry_discontent 6y agoThe import feature in Soviet Republic is especially cool to me. If you mine/process/store all the goods needed to produce a building in your republic warehouses, you can build anything essentially for free. You assign trucks to deliver the goods and use workers to build it. The only thing missing from that game for me, is a more informative and intuitive UI. It can be hard to understand how all the parts fit together and get a good overview of your republic.
- dangrover 6y agoThe wall I hit with this game was that once I figured out how to get the country self-sustaining enough to mine and refine uranium for export, it effectively gave unlimited money, and less point in figuring out all the other industries.
- ethbr0 6y ago> mine and refine uranium for export Refining uranium gives some pretty tangible benefits in the real world too. Seems fair.
- rayrag 6y agoDoes any of those games have some kind of 'free mode'? I'm not interested in playing but rather in a casually designing city, similarly to the Townscaper game. https://store.steampowered.com/app/1291340/Townscaper https://store.steampowered.com/app/1291340/Townscaper
- mhh__ 6y agoI forget the exact keybind but in Cities Skylines you can just give yourself a bunch of money and just play
- jagger27 6y agoWhen you create your city you can simply enable unlimited money.
- livre 6y agoCities Skylines has an infinite money checkbox if I recall correctly. You'll still have to properly design the city so the people move there and build but game money won't be an obstacle. Edit: found it, it is the built-in unlimited money mod https://steamcommunity.com/app/255710/discussions/0/611701360817419019/ https://steamcommunity.com/app/255710/discussions/0/61170136...
- rayrag 6y agoThanks for the info. Epic was giving it for free recently so I own it. I will definitely try it.
- zip1234 6y agoIt missed a really nice one with walkable cities: the Caesar series. I remember playing Caesar 2 in the 90s and I believe there are newer ones.
- shepherdjerred 6y agoI spent so many hours on Pharaoh and Cleopatra growing up. There was a game released in 2015 very similar to these style games called Lethis: Path of Progress. I never got into it, but maybe other fans of Sierra games will https://store.steampowered.com/app/359230/Lethis__Path_of_Progress/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/359230/Lethis__Path_of_Pr...
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoI got 22.5 hours on Lethis: Path of Progress. Its only sin in my eyes is that it makes a great impression of being a reskin of Emperor: Rise of the Middle Kingdom (which I thought was the most refined of Sierra's old city builders) meaning it doesn't really offer anything radically new. There are a few touches here and there, particularly the use of steam - you need to build a network of pipes to transfer steam in the places where it's needed (e.g. factories that produce automata that you need to run the service buildings that will attract a bourgeoisie who will pay the most taxes, similar to elite housing in Emperor). But in general it's a game that stays very, very close to the Sierra formula. Even down to walkers starting to get lost as you build more new buildings, leaving swaths of your city without essential services and causing them to cycle between the lowest and highest possible house quality periodically. Exactly like good old Sierra games! Which is fine by me, I'd probably not like it as much if it was indeed radically new. Weird, huh? That said, I would sure like to see a genuinely new take on the old formula that didn't also trample all over what made the old formula work.
- xvedejas 6y agoThere were also some follow-up games with Egyptian and Greek themes (called Pharaoh and Zeus) which I recall being similarly fun. And looking it up just now, there's also one I missed, called "Emperor" and set in ancient China.
- carapace 6y agoI've heard anecdotally that SimCity started at an attempt to model Christopher Alexander's Pattern Language. If I had a "roundtuit" I'd make something like that. I was playing with Godot engine a few months ago and it's pretty fun itself. A city-building game-building game...
- mcphage 6y ago> If I had a "roundtuit" I'd make something like that. Hmmm, are they out of stock at Amazon? It does claim to be the everything store...
- scyzoryk_xyz 6y agoI thought I'd throw in this link to the awesome donoteat1 playlist about city building made with skylines: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vln5Ri4Zpgo&list=PLwkSQD3vqK1Q4BP-itzN6gMpJBTsfPucy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vln5Ri4Zpgo&list=PLwkSQD3vqK...
- Pfhreak 6y agoIt's interesting to stack up other city builders against this as well. Airborne Kingdom, Frostpunk, Tropico, Anno 1800, etc all focus on different elements of the genre. I'm working on a city builder as a side project, and it's fascinating how many little choices there are that totally change the space of the game.
- Voline 6y agoI became addicted to SimCity 2000 in 1996 when I was in economics grad school. I loved it, but was so frustrated by the neoliberal assumptions built into the game. The game rewarded strategies that were not backed up by empirical study, or even common sense: You could lace a city with rail from residential to industrial and commercial zones, and the people would still clamor for more and wider roads; There were no mixed use zoning (You cannot shop in your neighborhood?); Your people would demand more police and if you didn't give it to them, they'd riot! The game rewarded you if you tried to make a California town. (But not Davis — no bike paths!) The city government could not build public housing … (The majority of housing in Helsinki is publicly owned). I wanted to be able to twiddle the parameters based on the way real people and cities have been observed to behave. New study comes out that says that people seek out 15 minute walkable neighborhood? Go to the settings panel adjust the parameters accordingly … The people should riot if you give them too many cops. When Yannis Varoufakis took a job as house economist at Valve (before he was appointed as Finance Minister of Greece), I thought it might be a good time to pitch the idea to them, but he left soon after.
- aakour 6y agoThe city of Helsinki owns about 17% of the residential building stock, not the majority. (https://www.asuminenhelsingissa.fi/fi/content/kaupungin-omistama-asuntokanta https://www.asuminenhelsingissa.fi/fi/content/kaupungin-omis... - in Finnish)
- Voline 6y agoI apologize. I think I was remembering this passage incorrectly. "And there, the Finnish capital is fortunate. Helsinki owns 60,000 social housing units; one in seven residents live in city-owned housing. It also owns 70% of the land within the city limits, runs its own construction company, and has a current target of building 7,000 more new homes – of all categories – a year" https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/jun/03/its-a-miracle-helsinkis-radical-solution-to-homelessness https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/jun/03/its-a-miracle... 70% of land is not 70% of housing.
- dangrover 6y ago
- koziserek 6y agoWhere's the Dwarf Fortress?
- capableweb 6y agoIn the twitter thread "A comparison of colony management games", not here with the city builders, as it's not really a city builder sandbox.
- 40four 6y agoNice thread, I always loved city building games. Here’s it is easier to read https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1345955063353597954.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1345955063353597954.html
- paulie_a 6y agoI was feeling nostalgic and got a simcity 2000 book I originally had when I was younger. It came complete with the original receipt from CompUSA from 1997
- paulie_a 6y agoAny recommendations for ones that run on ubuntu?
- elvis70 6y agoOpenTTD, which is a very good open-source remake of Transport Tycoon Deluxe: https://www.openttd.org/ https://www.openttd.org/ I have 20.04 LTS and it is available as the 'openttd' package.