12 ms·
> but when you already work at the company that pays and treats their employees like Google, I'm not sure what more you are entitled to. Google made something
by UncleMeat 6y ago
> but when you already work at the company that pays and treats their employees like Google, I'm not sure what more you are entitled to.
Google made something like 300,000 in profit per employee in 2019. There are regular complaints about benefits and pay multipliers being cut back. Why shouldn't workers seek to capture as much of their labor as possible? People don't seem to complain when businesses do that.
- qeternity 6y agoThey absolutely should. And companies/management have a fiduciary duty to give them as little as possible. This is the competition that gives rise to capitalist efficiencies. The concern from people like myself is that another word for a union is a cartel. When companies form cartels and engage in anti-competitive behavior, we penalize them severely (in theory at least...but that's another issue). Yet when labor colludes, we simply call it a union. Tech is especially interesting because the usual claims of "workers have less power individually" (which is always true in all industries) is really really not a great argument in tech. The labor market in tech is so unbelievably competitive, and the average worker has leverage that is only seen in the upper echelons of other industries.
- ForHackernews 6y agoSure, but will these salad days continue forever? I feel like most of HN is too young to remember the dot-com crash. Seems far better to unionise and try to institutionalise and lock-in better pay and working conditions then to count on always having a hypercompetitive labor market and obscenely profitable employers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alisonkisk 6y agoManagement is a cartel. I can't negotiate my pay directly with my manager.
- qeternity 6y agoThat's not the legal or economic definition of a cartel.
- mrzimmerman 6y agoNor is a union the economic or legal definition of a cartel. A union is closer to creating a company that acts as a negotiating and protective apparatus for its employees as they do contractual work for other companies. That isn’t a cartel and there can be multiple, competing unions working for the same type of workers in the same industry.
- missedthecue 6y agoan association of manufacturers or suppliers with the purpose of maintaining prices at a high level That's the definition of cartel. Unions exist to maximize the amount they extract from buyers of labor. This is rent seeking plain and simple. What's more, they don't compete with each other, which is what corporations must do. Why does the UAW get to enjoy a monopoly on the sale of autoworker labor? Should Ford and GM and Chrysler be able to unionize together to keep wage costs lower?
- Anderkent 6y ago>I can't negotiate my pay directly with my manager. Why not? If you go talk to your manager and tell him "I have another offer at XXX, I want you to match it or I'm leaving" what is going to happen?
- johnathandos 6y agoIf I were the manager, I’d respond to this by wishing the person luck and asking when their last day will be.
- Afton 6y agoYou absolutely can. Managers will push back with "rules" that only apply if management doesn't want to pay you more. Or they will go to HR to get an exception if they think you are worth that exception (that is, if they aren't worried about not being able to match an offer for an employee that they really care about). You can absolutely negotiate. In the past, I've been quite open when I thought that I needed more money to my manager, and have even given specific ways of making me "not distracted by money concerns". Sometimes they can meet those goals, sometimes they can't. Personally, the offer as you've given it is probably more adversarial than I'd prefer. Something like "I feel like I'm worth more to the company than X, I feel like I'm worth Y, and here is a list of reasons, here is my career goals, etc etc". Then if they don't match it, you can accept that other offer. But YMMV.
- jimcsharp 6y agoI would liken unions to corporations rather than cartels.
- missedthecue 6y agoWhat about the definition of cartel doesn't match what a union does?
- acdha 6y ago> And companies/management have a fiduciary duty to give them as little as possible. This is a popular myth but if you do any research you’ll learn it’s not true. There’s no such requirement because there’s no way to reliably predict the future impact of decisions: for example, does paying “too much” for employees lower turnover and avoid them starting competitors? Skimping on maintenance, outsourcing jobs, or taking on debt will definitely “maximize” shareholder value for a little while, until the bill comes due. Think for a minute about how you’d argue any of those points in court and you’ll understand why the real laws have significant deference to executives’ judgement. Neither side would have any trouble finding people to say their decision was best, and even after the fact there are inevitably many factors which people can point to when explaining whatever happened.
- matz1 6y agoI think more accurate to say the fiduciary duty is to make money as much as possible. At least that I would want the my company to do.
- acdha 6y agoTry to find a legal statement to that effect. You’ll find a lot of people claiming that but there’s nothing binding for the reasons I gave: nothing is certain in business and people will reasonably differ about the best ways to produce growth over any non-trivial time scale. Remember all of the people who very confidently said that Apple was wasting its time with phones and would never overtake Nokia?
- rauhl 6y ago> Google made something like 300,000 in profit per employee in 2019. Isn’t this roughly the same order of magnitude as many Google developer salaries? If so, how much more expensive can any employee be before he is too expensive to employ?
- tempest_ 6y agoThat is profit, ie after the employee has been paid. So the answer is they can afford to pay 300,000 more before the employee is too expensive (based on this comment anyway)
- jethro_tell 6y agoWell 299,999 :)
- danaris 6y agoSince that's profit, I would assume (based purely on the phrasing) that it's net of obligations like salaries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jfim 6y agoThat's profit per employee, not revenue per employee. Revenue per employee is much larger, at least according to this website [0]: > Alphabet Inc's revenue per employee grew on trailing twelve months basis to a new company high of $ 2,143,353 [0] https://csimarket.com/stocks/GOOG-Revenue-per-Employee.html https://csimarket.com/stocks/GOOG-Revenue-per-Employee.html
- alisonkisk 6y agoProfit is after expenses, so employee can be $300k/yr more expensive before they are expensive to employ.
- jboy55 6y agoIts pretty much the same number. An L4 at Google makes $250k and an L5 makes 340k on average according to levels.fyi. My experience with countering Google offers would indicate these are a bit low. Edit: Then you have to factor in the free breakfast/lunch/dinner, buses, electric car parking and the fact all my Google friends seem to rarely work > 40hrs per week. That being said, all the 'grunt' work at Google is done by contractors, who are paid far less and while they get the free food they do without things like PTO and Sick time.
- thinkloop 6y ago> Why shouldn't workers seek to capture as much of their labor as possible? That is not a fair framing. Labor is not the sole cause of profit. Imagine a company that spent billions to automate every process requiring only a single human to push a button every 10 minutes to produce its output. This company would be making "billions per employee", but it wouldn't make sense to pay that employee billions for that job.
- flamble 6y agoAll of that capital was produced by labor, except what fraction of the value derives from raw natural resources pre-extraction. So it is absolutely a fair framing to state "why shouldn't workers seek to capture as much of their labor as possible?". If their labor produces capital which produces profits, why are those profits not fair game to bargain over? In your example, it wouldn't make sense to pay the one remaining employee all of the profits, but it would have made perfect sense for all the employees who produced the perfectly automated factory to negotiate for a share of the profits.
- chii 6y ago> all the employees who produced the perfectly automated factory to negotiate for a share of the profits. if they were employees, they would've been paid compensation for making such automation. Unless they are a shareholder (either by investing initial capital, or by negotiated compensation in the form of equity), they are absolutely not entitled to any profit from their output.
- GavinMcG 6y agoThat's the water we swim in, but can you actually make an argument for why things should be that way? We allow infinite returns to "shareholders" long after their risk has been reasonably rewarded. Why should we?
- _-o-_ 6y agoThat was the deal made when those shares were created and sold. Compared to all other parties they seem to be more deserving - at some point shareholders took a financial risk.
- antisoeu 6y agoJust call it what it is, greed. Why is it greedy if company owners want to make money, but "good and social" if workers want to make money? I don't think the "earnings per employee" metric entitles employees to anything.
- salawat 6y agoI disagree, particularly as someone who worked fror a firm making over 1000000 per employee. It's hard to square that kind of return only benefitting shareholders. You'd be hard pressed as an employee to get a 3% raise or whatnot to keep up with inflation, or you'd have the call center people making pennies, or micromanaged down to the second, but over a milkion per employee was earned. There is a certain point where one has to stop and reevaluate the nature of the value transfer going on. That same business ate years of my life keeping it afloat, but at the first opportunity for equity holders, dropped the floor out by sellout. Not that I'd want to go back given the business model but it does lead to somber reflection and a heartfelt contemplation of tge advantaged position held by the middle-man.
- antisoeu 6y ago"That same business ate years of my life keeping it afloat" Presumably you were paid for your services. If you were unhappy with the pay, you should have renegotiated or changed jobs.
- xpe 6y agoI find this to be comment to be unhelpful. I hope you didn't intend it, but the comment comes across as critical and judgmental. The comment doesn't show that you are curious about the broader context. Would you consider thinking about this from a different perspective? For example, try thinking and asking about what history and experience underlies this. In my view, someone who writes "That same business ate years of my life keeping it afloat" has a story to tell. Think about this possibilities: comments are with real people, not abstractions. Every comment brings the opportunity to get to know someone's situation and experience.
- 6y ago
- mordymoop 6y agoI wonder if the company will respond to this sort of incentive by hiring hundreds of thousands of new employees to absorb the “profit” rather than pay employees far in excess of market rate.
- Frost1x 6y agoIsn't there a massive 'labor shortage'? If that's already the case, that proposal seems even more impossible. You could hire non-tech workers and pivot to other industries where you can employ other people. I suppose they could try outsourcing again/more and see how that works out.
- jandrewrogers 6y agoEmployee compensation is tied to profit in the form of RSUs. A decline in profit would substantially decrease the value of those RSUs and thus compensation. You can't just decrease profit in a vacuum and hand that revenue to employees, you have to consider the second-order effects.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt's more complicated than that, but it would in the end be close to 300k salary increase. The correct way to think about it is, what if the company was entirely owned by employees? How would income change, then?
- Simulacra 6y agoBecause they are workers. If they want to “capture” some of that profit, to start their own company, or work at a different company. Unions today are more about punishing the owners for making too much profit than it is about keeping anyone safe or fair. Just because you work at a company does not give you “ownership.”
- minimuffins 6y ago> Why shouldn't workers seek to capture as much of their labor as possible? Yes. This is the correct way to look at it. Another point I don't see so many people making here is it's about more than just raw compensation. A lot of people at Google don't like some of the things the company has sprawled out into doing now, e.g. war and surveillance tech. A union is about creating some collective agency so labor can get what it wants, instead of being led around by the nose all the time by managers and owners who are motivated only by profit (or are at least not obliged to consider any interest, economic or moral, that laborers might have). A union would give some strategic agency to labor--that is, the people who do all the work--at Google. If a majority does not want to make war robots anymore or whatever, they can assert their agency and get what they want, and stop making war robots or whatever.