4 ms·
I don't suppose that this opens up the door to challenging other US extradition requests based on the appalling track record of human rights and standards of ca
by sneak 6y ago
I don't suppose that this opens up the door to challenging other US extradition requests based on the appalling track record of human rights and standards of care in US prisons, in which rape, murder, and torture are not only common but widely culturally accepted as part of the standard punitive aspects of imprisonment?
How do european (or perhaps just the UK's) legal system(s) work in that regard?
I have a lot of hope that this is a first crack appearing in the western cultural monolith; at some point civilized countries will have to somewhat politically break from the US so long as the US continues its domestic institutional torture programs (american prisons and the tradition of extended solitary confinement) and human rights violations (capital punishment). With luck that means that MLAT will eventually start to be unenforceable.
- rory_isAdonk 6y agoPretty much the same reasoning was used in another case. I wouldn't be surprised if this had gone very differently had Trump won.
- sneak 6y agoI don't understand the second part of your comment.
- rsynnott 6y agoI mean, how much pressure do you think Trump can put on a British judge? Or the British political establishment, for that matter? The British judiciary is quite independent; for evidence see the various cases that the government lost over Brexit.
- Normille 6y ago>How do european (or perhaps just the UK's) legal system(s) work in that regard? The general rule is that the laws by which other nations have to abide and the standards other nations have to meet don't apply when the USA is involved. I seriously had to read the headline twice, to make sure I'd got it right, I was so stunned at the UK not kowtowing to the US, as a matter of course.
- sneak 6y agoI, too, am surprised. Perhaps the US has given up on threatening his custodians to get their way, now that so much damage has already been done to Assange, both in the embassy and now in Belmarsh. I still wonder what the CIA must have done to get those Swedish prosecutors to spin all of that bullshit for the original arrest warrant. I'd also have liked to have been a fly on the wall when the phone calls were made to those in charge of European airspace when Morales' jet was forcibly grounded over Austria for no reason other than the US incorrectly suspected Snowden being aboard.
- morelisp 6y ago> I still wonder what the CIA must have done to get those Swedish prosecutors to spin all of that bullshit for the original arrest warrant. What would it take to convince you this didn't actually happen? It still doesn't make legal sense - Obama's DOJ publicly declined to charge him given the evidence, and extradition from Sweden would still have required extradition from the UK since he would've been serving time in both countries. Assange never got charged by the US administration he actually embarassed, successfully jumped bail, waited out the clock on the rape charges, and finally got his extradition denied. It seems to me he got everything he wanted out of this - he just wasn't careful what he wished for.
- lmm 6y ago> Obama's DOJ publicly declined to charge him given the evidence Which means very little - the fact that the US has now tried to extradite him proves that. > extradition from Sweden would still have required extradition from the UK since he would've been serving time in both countries. How so? AIUI Sweden would have notionally promised not to extradite him, but there was little mechanism to enforce this.
- notahacker 6y agoThe charges the US attempted to extradite him for were based primarily on things he did or allegedly did or which came to light after the rape charges. Ockham's razor also applies. If you want Assange charged in the US on 'espionage' or similar and you have a choice of notifying the Swedish authorities that he is wanted for serious crimes in the US or instead relying upon separate local allegations that are so vague the Swedish legal system has to work its way through an appeals process to even decide to whether to pursue the case or not whilst leaving him at liberty to leave the country, you're unlikely to choose the latter.
- matthewheath 6y agoIt would require a judgment from the Court of Appeal or the Supreme Court to be able to use this to challenge any future extradition requests from the US. This is because binding precedent is only set by the appellate courts and while this judgment is persuasive, other judges sitting in this court can ignore it since they're not bound to follow it.
- sneak 6y agoThis is precisely the thing I wanted to know. Thank you!
- input_sh 6y agoFYI this isn't the first time a similar extradition to the US has been denied by the UK. Lauri Love (allegedly affiliated with Anonymous) successfully fought against extradition in 2016. Court originally ruled that extradition can happen, but the appeals court ruled differently, citing that extradition would be "oppressive by reason of his physical and mental condition". As far as I'm aware the case never made it to the Supreme Court.
- heraclius 6y agoA High Court judgment would also bind lower courts, including the Magistrates’ Court.
- lawtalkinghuman 6y agoDeciding whether under s91 of the Extradition Act, "the physical or mental condition of the person is such that it would be unjust or oppressive to extradite him", is a very fact-specific issue rather than a legal question though. The appellate courts are generally there to resolve legal questions not factual ones—I'd question the Assange case, or other similar cases would raise a similar legal rather than factual question. There has been a trend towards applying s91 cases for defendants with autism spectrum disorders: the courts didn't in Gary McKinnon's case, but the Home Secretary (Theresa May, before she became PM) justified her denial of the extradition order on that basis. In Lauri Love's case, the magistrates' court allowed the extradition order but it was overturned on appeal in the High Court on the basis of Love's not being able to cope in US custody with Asperger's syndrome. In the Assange case, the magistrates' court followed this established and rather persuasive precedent.
- mschuster91 6y ago> How do european (or perhaps just the UK's) legal system(s) work in that regard? It's actually European law that's binding here, and extradition / deportation denials based on human rights concerns are nothing new - there have been bans on deportations even to EU members such as Greece (https://www.gesetze-bayern.de/Content/Document/Y-300-Z-BECKRS-B-2018-N-24384?hl=true https://www.gesetze-bayern.de/Content/Document/Y-300-Z-BECKR...) or Hungary (https://www.keienborg.de/2018/02/19/die-12-kammer-des-vg-duesseldorf-schiebt-international-schutzberechtigte-nicht-nach-ungarn-ab/ https://www.keienborg.de/2018/02/19/die-12-kammer-des-vg-due...).
- lawtalkinghuman 6y agoFor clarity: European Convention (and Court) of Human Rights law, not EU. There's post-Brexit significance since the UK continues to be a signatory to the ECHR even though they've now left the EU. Being an ECHR signatory is a requirement of being in the EU, not vice versa. (Countries like Turkey and Russia are also ECHR signatories.)
- rsynnott 6y agoIt's somewhat common for extradition to the US to be denied on these sorts of grounds; this is by no means the first time it has happened.