3 ms·
What I think should be made illegal is that Google (and others) is essentially collecting another toll even when users enter in the brand name of the target bus
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
What I think should be made illegal is that Google (and others) is essentially collecting another toll even when users enter in the brand name of the target business in the first place. That is:
1. User types CompanyFoo (whose real URL is www.companyfoo.com) into their address bar, which lands them on Google (because Google owns Chrome and pays billions for the privilege on other browsers).
2. Since Google will sell this keywords to others, many businesses always bid on their own brand name to ensure it comes up first.
3. Thus, an ad for CompanyFoo shows up first, even though www.companyfoo.com is the first search result, so when user clicks on the CompanyFoo ad Google takes its cut. Again, this is also because Google has done as much as possible to make ads as visually similar to SEO results as possible - just the teeny 'ad' banner, compare to the big yellow box of early Google.
I don't have as much objection for other companies buying branded keywords, but the way Google has set up things up they are taking their cut from everyone even when they are giving very little value.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoYou are under no obligation to use Google's browser or search engine if you believe it doesn't provide you with a valuable search experience.
- mark-r 6y agoYou have no control over the browser or search engine your potential customers use.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoWhat do you expect should happen? The browser should automatically load the first google search result? Google should prevent companies bidding on their own name? Or that they should make bidding on their own name free?
- harry8 6y agoHow about they clearly separate search results from ads and don't put the ads first. There was a search engine that got really popular doing that. I think they were called Google..?
- beefield 6y agoWell, I think there are two options. Either Google should take a note from the old days when they were not rent-seeking jerks but did no evil and actually distinguished search results and ads by placing the ads to the side bar. Or their practical search monopoly and all the profitablity from there should be regulated to oblivion. That's just what I think should happen. The sensible me understands that obviously neither is going to happen.
- fredophile 6y agoI'm pretty sure that if I typed foo in my browser back in the early 2000s I'd go to foo.com or www.foo.com. Now I type foo in Chrome, see the logo for foo, but end up at a Google search page. This is very clearly a step back in terms of user experience.
- Miraste 6y agoIn modern Safari this pattern will often take you directly to the website (or some other, non-Google website when it guesses wrong). When it works it's very nice.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoI wonder how it works, if its powered by google or if its their own search engine in use.
- npx13 6y agoThis Google squeez also happens when a company spends on offline ad campaigns as often the first action in response to an ad is to type the company name into the browser. The searcher then arrives at the Google gate where friction is applied to divert a percentage of those to click on competitor online ads. Google is also taxing global offline ad spend.