11 ms·
Show HN: I shot high-res stitched panoramas in Iceland using a thermal camera
- ChrisArchitect 6y ago(2019) please https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20435516 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20435516
- supernova87a 6y agoIf only the cost of thermal imagers could come down and be more affordable, more people might be interested!
- jcims 6y agoThat and the associated optics. There’s some reason for encouragement however. I bought a Seek Pro, with 320x240 resolution, on sale for $350 earlier this year. The app is pretty terrible unfortunately and the camera physical construction is flimsy, but the imager seems to be of reasonable quality for the price point. Couple of examples: https://imgur.com/a/ZGsOwUm https://imgur.com/a/ZGsOwUm
- garaetjjte 6y agoSeek cameras are rather noisy though. More expensive, but much less noisy and still reasonable to buy as a expensive toy would be TE-Q1 from i3system: http://nicesuper3.cafe24.com/down/TE-Q1-compressed.pdf http://nicesuper3.cafe24.com/down/TE-Q1-compressed.pdf
- jcims 6y agoLooks good! Any idea why they make it so difficult to buy their product?
- garaetjjte 6y agoi3system is based in South Korea, and I guess shipping thermal imaging technology is PITA due to various restrictions, not profitable enough to sell to individual customers. There seems to be EU reseller (thermalexpert.eu) but they sell only to companies (likely because VAT accounting when selling exclusively to companies is much easier).
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoThermal imaging resolution is restricted by arm control laws unfortunately. There are forces at work beyond market forces.
- jcims 6y agoITAR compliance assurance isn't free and certainly impacts operational costs, but the sensor I have isn't export controlled and still normally costs >$1K when you buy it from FLIR.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoThat's only for the US though, and I'd expect such a product to come from Asia.
- jansan 6y agoI once rented an IR camera for roughly 100€. This is probably the best option for people who only need IR cameras on very few occasions. Will we ever see chap(ish) IR cameras? Is there an alternative to germanium lenses on the horizon?
- jcims 6y agoI believe there are some metamaterial-based approaches for the actual microbolometers that should help drive costs down. Ostensibly metamaterials could also be used for lenses but I'm not aware of anything there, we're probably stuck with germanium for the time being.
- CamperBob2 6y agoZinc selenide lenses for laser cutters work very well in the spectral range covered by consumer IR cameras. They are dirt cheap on eBay, Ali Express, and other places.
- giantg2 6y agoThat carboy is pretty hot.
- gandalfian 6y agoYes I do covet them. Getting cheaper but still fairly low resolution. Keep hoping for a tipping point like digital cameras where cheap decent sensors will suddenly be everywhere. Not yet though.
- jstanley 6y agoI bought one on eBay a few years ago for about £300, but it sucked so I got rid of it. It used a traditional camera to draw most of the image (itself already quite low-res), and just highlighted even-more-low-res temperature data in blue and red.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y agoI was just considering buying one. Would you share your thoughts?
- jstanley 6y agoThe resolution was too low. I didn't really have a use in mind for it, I just thought it was interesting and thought I'd find uses for it after I owned it, but the resolution was too low to be able to do anything useful. Here's the only picture I have of it working: https://img.jes.xxx/1047 https://img.jes.xxx/1047 As you can see, you can't see anything.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y ago> As you can see, you can't see anything. Thank you. I wanted to get one to (a) find creatures outside at night while camping, and (b) fix my house energy leaks. But that rez seems awfully low. So amazed at the OP for doing such an amazing job stitching images!
- dheera 6y agoI've had decent luck finding and seeing creatures with the Seek RevealPro I used, although there may be better ones out by now. I even used it to try to find a friend's lost cat once. I didn't succeed in finding the cat with it, but I did end up finding a few other stray cats and racoons. (For anyone wondering, the pet cat was found later and was taken to a shelter by some good samaritan.)
- freeone3000 6y agoFor (b) even a quite low res thermal camera can be useful. Compared to a laser thermometer, you have a much wider fov, and you can always get closer.
- soared 6y agoI'd imagine demand for thermal imaging has skyrocketed due to covid, so its possible the tech will get better and cheaper.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoI don't think cheap cameras are sensitive enough and you don't need an entire image that is better for seeing relative heat, you just need a single accurate reading. Those thermometers are only $20 and are being cranked out in bulk.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y agoIt's $570: https://www.amazon.com/Seek-RQ-AAA-Thermal-Revealpro/dp/B07B7N4DLV https://www.amazon.com/Seek-RQ-AAA-Thermal-Revealpro/dp/B07B...
- gandalfian 6y agoCunning. He took panoramas with thermal camera and simultaneous black and white photos and coloured the b&w photos with the data from the thermal camera. Interesting examples of insulation. I wonder how the result compares to the standard Flir auto blended images. Msx?
- osamagirl69 6y agoI have done a lot of work with high resolution thermal imagers and never seen any images that look like these so I was curious what was going on. >I also simultaneously shot a black-and-white photo with a regular camera and a wide-angle lens for comparison. I then wrote my own program to color the black-and-white photograph with the actual thermal data, using a false-color scale which you see in the upper-right corner of every image. Amazing drawings, but these are not actually thermal images.
- mmaunder 6y agoPure thermal would have been quite smudged. IMHO the B&W adds really nice context - and it sounds like it's not just a straight overlay, but he's recoloring the B&W pixels, which I think provides a crisper result. I'm curious what resolutions you've worked with, if you don't mind sharing. High frame rate thermal cameras (above 9hz) are ITAR restricted. Hi-res above 640x480 is not common on the consumer market and is restricted to embargoed countries. Cooled thermal cameras are restricted too IIRC.
- osamagirl69 6y agoThe device we had was 1.3MP--rough the same resolution as the composite image discussed in this article. The camera core was expensive, but the lens actually cost more than the sensor. Yes it was ITAR regulated. As an example of what I would have expected, this product brief (not the device we were using, but similar) has a picture of the white house https://www.lockheedmartin.com/content/dam/lockheed-martin/mfc/documents/sensor-cores/mfc-sbf-sensor-cores-brochure.pdf https://www.lockheedmartin.com/content/dam/lockheed-martin/m...
- fpoling 6y agoI presume that was with 16 bits per pixel, which is not available in consumer cameras.
- mmaunder 6y agoThanks. Interesting link. I must admit I can’t help but admire Lockheed’s marketing with that whitehouse image. There’s a not-so-subtle message in there. Sounds like super interesting work!!
- mmaunder 6y agoI'm curious what kind of thermal camera he's using. I bought a Therm-App Pro 640x480 a while back and it's quite good - and reasonably priced compared to Flir - along with a github repo for different false color palettes. But what's really weird is it seems to not be available anymore. I'm guessing export restrictions or massive demand for thermal cameras during Covid along with supply chain issues. IIRC it is also 25 frames a second, which is unusually high for thermal cameras due to export restrictions. Edit: Here's a post on creating panoramic images with therm-app. https://www.flickr.com/groups/therm-app-users/discuss/72157652017273862/ https://www.flickr.com/groups/therm-app-users/discuss/721576...
- bobbob1921 6y agoI was wondering this too, the author added this info via a reply in the comments (of his site/article , not HN)- > Author here. The camera was a Seek RevealPro which has 320x240 resolution. The thermal data in the panoramas are stitched together from raw data exported by the camera and represented as color (hue+saturation, as per scale in upper right, represents temperature data). The brightness channel is piecewise-linearly combined with a corresponding visual image taken with a regular SLR to provide a visual reference of what you're looking at.
- mmaunder 6y agoI think the ThermApp cameras had the ability to combine a visual photo, but I haven't used mine for quite some time so I may be wrong.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dheera 6y agoOP here. Seek RevealPro. I added a top-level comment with some more details and links :)
- ahmadhamza19 6y agoReally amazing photos.
- smoldesu 6y agoNew Wallpaper Get!
- cs702 6y agoBeautiful. Eerie. Great work. Thank you for sharing. Your images look almost like they came out of James Cameron's vivid imagination. If you had told me these were computer-generated images of Pandora at night[a] from the upcoming Avatar sequel, I would have believed it. [a] E.g., see https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=avatar%20pandora%20at%20night https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=avatar%20pandora%20...
- dheera 6y agoHi everyone, OP here. I used a Seek RevealPro which outputs TIFF files that contain 32-bit floating point values. I created a script that takes in a Seek TIFF and outputs an 8-bit greyscale integer TIFF: https://github.com/dheera/iceland-thermal/blob/master/scripts/seek2gray https://github.com/dheera/iceland-thermal/blob/master/script... I then panoramically stitched those 8-bit TIFFs together (some with the help of hugin, and some manually with GIMP) and distortion-corrected them as best as I could to a black-and-white visible light image. I also created an artistically-chosen color map for each image. For the final output image, hue and saturation are fully based on thermal data, and lightness is a combination of thermal and visible data. Scripts to generate the final output images, along with the panoramically pre-stitched data, and the color maps I used: https://github.com/dheera/iceland-thermal https://github.com/dheera/iceland-thermal Also, my Instagram, which is mostly astrophotography of late, but I did post thermal images there before and I may do so in the future again if I can find another good set of interesting thermal subjects to do this in! https://instagram.com/dheeranet/ https://instagram.com/dheeranet/
- skybrian 6y agoHave you tried any other thermal cameras and how did they compare?
- dheera 6y agoNot too many, for personal projects I'm mostly budget-constrained. I tried the Flir C2 but the thermal data was extremely low resolution, and returned it. I also tried a Flir Lepton 2 module since I could use an RPi and some gadgetry to do the panorama scanning and stitching automatically, but it too was low resolution (80x60). The Lepton 3 seems to be decent at 160x120 though, which is probably good enough for a project like this, so if I were doing this again I'd probably use a Lepton 3 and a 2-axis servo scanner with a RPi, and maybe even combine it with an RPi HQ camera to automate the entire process into a single push button. The Seek RevealPro is slightly annoying in that it doesn't have programmatic access so I had to press a button to take every piece of the panorama. It's a great general-use device though. I use it when camping or doing astrophotography in remote locations for some peace of mind since I can spot any potential wildlife and people threats from a distance, and I can easily identify whether a parked or seemingly abandoned car has been recently occupied. (My fears may be unfounded, but either way I'm much more at ease when I can see in the dark.)
- deadw3ight 6y agoThat's sick! Brilliant and creative idea. Those shots look beautiful.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoAwesome stuff! Thanks for sharing it! I'm used to thermal cameras being so lo-res you can barely tell what they are.
- brianjunyinchan 6y agoLove the beautifully haunting perspective.
- systemvoltage 6y agoWhy are Thermal cameras lagging in resolution? Visible wavelength cameras can be had upwards of 50MP for $5k.
- supernova87a 6y agoAs I recall, IR sensors are also much more expensive to produce, as in, 1Kx1K is already a very large array and costs thousands of $. So any ordinary consumer is not likely to be using something with very high resolution.
- giantg2 6y agoI agree. The median income in the US is $35k, and many of these things are 5-10% of that. I'd really like a monocular, but anything decent is very expensive.
- 0xFluegel 6y agoThe sensor needs a lot more energy. This produces two types of IR cams: actively and passively cooled. The passive cooling is easy to take around with you but only possible with a smaller sensor. As for the price per pixel: I don't know from memory.
- semi-extrinsic 6y agoI think it's a combination of physics (wavelength is 20x larger than visual light, making optics and sensors trickier) and export control, as you could (literally) weaponize a high-res thermal camera to make an autonomous drone/missile targetting hot exhaust etc.
- jzwinck 6y agoThermal cameras measure much larger waves (7-14 microns as described in the article), and their sensitivity to amplitude is high. A major limiting factor in camera sensor resolution is signal to noise ratio. It is well known that if you bump up the "ISO" (light sensitivity) to make photographs at night, you see more noise. The higher the sensor resolution, the smaller each photosite and therefore the less signal (fewer photons) captured in the short time of one exposure. Larger sensors can solve this problem but these are CMOS devices whose cost increases superlinearly with area (like microprocessors, see die yield). Most customers won't accept dead pixels. Economics is also a major enabler of kilobuck 50 MP visible light cameras, miracles though they are. Industrial users aren't going to re-buy all their cameras every few years like DSLR users do.
- pachico 6y agoFrom what I know, it's hard not do do awesome pictures in Iceland. What a marvelous place...
- NDimCube 6y agoNice results, thermal cameras aren't easy to work with, especially in terms of artistic result. I've seen problems with stitching resulting with artifacts in panoramas. As I understood (I'm not thermal cameras expert) it's due too the fact that sensor warms up -> thermal camera calibration doesn't correct the result enough -> stitching needs corrections. To put it one dimension higher, in Pix4D we work on 3d models based on the thermal images: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-jp9a1bpVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-jp9a1bpVU Example: https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/thermal-model-of-pix4d-headquarters-b1cbbc0f9111465cba8606524d32df5e https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/thermal-model-of-pix4d-headq...
- kbutler 6y agoThese are beautiful. Any thoughts on why the photographer reversed the spectrum (red cold, blue hot) for the fumarole? https://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2019/07/image10-1.jpg https://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2019/07/image10-1.jpg (just looked cooler?) Or why the distant horses have breath showing, but the closer ones do not? https://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2019/07/image1.jpg https://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2019/07/image1.jpg (maybe a resolution/compositing issue?)
- dheera 6y agoPhotographer here ;) I took some artistic liberty in choosing color scales for each photo (a) to make them look unique (b) to make people actually look at the color scale (c) because as someone with a physics background it bothers me deeply that people associate hot with red and cold with blue and even go so far as to call 6000K "cool white" and 3000K "warm white" when those are literally blackbody temperature equivalents. So I flipped it around on one shot :)
- kbutler 6y agoAlso physics background, and I realized it looked right to me, and had to go back and look at the others...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- devenvdev 6y agoI wonder why the church's second floor window is black (fifth photo from the end). Do they insolate floors too? But then why do the walls of the second floor and the roof leak?
- simlevesque 6y agoI think that yes they isolate floors too and it looks like the front of the house leaks more heat than then roof.
- joshvm 6y ago> (Note: Glass windows are opaque to thermal cameras; the temperature measured here is the surface temperature of the window.) This is not completely correct. Glass tends to reflect infrared radiation. For example if you view a car windscreen from the air with a thermal camera, you'll see a reflection of the sky. It's more complicated than that, because you'll also detect the emitted blackbody radiation from the glass (for whatever temperature).
- jacquesm 6y agoFantastic images, never before did I see a more clear image of what 'continental drift' really looks like.