11 ms·
Human Brain Project: $1.61 billion to achieve human brain emulation by 2024
- ignifero 16y agoIt's sad to see a discussion that could be of interest to computer hackers (the current neurosimulation software is decades old, horrible and could really benefit from some new ideas) ending up to the usual blah blah about self aware robots that will take over the earth. /signoff
- dodo53 16y agoOne thing I always think about brain emulation/mind uploading/strong AI research is we need an legal/ethical framework in place before we get there. I still think it's far off, but not everyone does. If you believe consciousness is a property of running a brain or sufficiently advanced brain model, at what point are you allowed to stop running your model and it's not murder of a sentient? At one point can a model claim rights? Especially as their goal is to use it for drug tests. Also, can you simulate a brain without a body or is say hormones/blood sugar/nervous system not easily separable?
- clistctrl 16y agoI think as long as we still view it as a machine, the issue with never be taken seriously.
- Zhenya 16y agoWhat if the machine starts printing out "NOOO!! Don't turn me off, I'm alive in here" Someone's going to go soft.
- rbanffy 16y agoWhat if the machine hires a lawyer to represent it?
- Zhenya 16y agoAmerica 2.0
- nooneelse 16y agoEven a chat-bot could be designed to plead for its "life". Perhaps a new version of the Turing test is in order. Two computer programs, each pleading for their continued existence. The human judge/executioner is able to interact with both and has two kill switches, one for each. If one of them isn't turned off in 20 minutes, both will be turned off.
- pavel_lishin 16y ago> Even a chat-bot could be designed to plead for its "life". And people respond emotionally to those. Also, see http://qntm.org/difference http://qntm.org/difference
- wattsbaat 16y agoExcept instead of two computer programs, it will be one computer program and one human.
- adrianN 16y agoChat Battle Royal.
- eschulte 16y agoSo on the up side, I think turning it off would be the same as putting it to sleep. The question is do you ever turn it back on...
- jpwagner 16y agoYou should watch "the measure of a man" episode of TNG...
- JabavuAdams 16y agoOf more concern to me would be control of my own consciousness uploads. I don't believe that hell exists now, but it would certainly be possible to create a technological hell if brain uploading and simulation is possible. Torture is already horrific, but at least you can only be tortured to death once. With brain simulation, it would be possible to torture someone again and again and again.
- kentrado 16y agoWow that's fucking sick.
- dodo53 16y agoOr even without maliciousness - someone could screw up a simulation such that the simulated mind is in pain for a subjective eternity
- rbranson 16y agoThere's a light at the end of the tunnel. It's likely whatever energy source for the simulation would be disrupted by some catastrophic event. Even without sentient intervention, over tens of millions of years you've got starvation of some resource -- even if it's something like fusion or the raw resources needed to build and maintain "renewable" energy. Over hundreds of millions or billions of years you've got asteroid impacts and cosmic events, eventually ending with the heat death of the universe. Not so bad after all, just tough it out soldier.
- hasenj 16y agoThat's not really much of a consolation.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 16y agoOn the bright side, it's also possible to create heaven.
- ericb 16y agoThis is a great question. I was put under for a surgery at one point. I was effectively "dead" from my perspective during the duration of the surgery in that no time seemed to have passed between when I was put under and when I came t. My consciousness was "off" in a way that is not when merely sleeping. It seems like this is a parallel for unplugging an AI, but then you have the problem of the AI losing whatever is in RAM. The non-humanness of an AI might slow the realization that creating an AI should probably embody the same responsibilities as having a child.
- eschulte 16y agoTechnically, when you're in deep (non-REM) sleep your conscious is also turned off.
- spot 16y agoyes but during deep sleep you still sense the passage of time. when you wake up after general anesthesia, it's like changing channels. very weird.
- jacques_chester 16y agoMy most refreshing sleep feels as though I have skipped forward from night to morning without the tedious period of time in-between.
- alnayyir 16y agoI don't, when I sleep I die. (Usually)
- hasenj 16y agoThere were times in my life when I woke up (from normal sleep) thinking I didn't sleep at all, while in fact I slept for hours and hours.
- wattsbaat 16y ago> Also, can you simulate a brain without a body or is say hormones/blood sugar/nervous system not easily separable? Even if those systems are integral to brain function, I'd assume that they are easier to simulate than the brain itself. Is it important to build a "brain simulation" instead of a "full body simulation"?
- dodo53 16y agoI agree you could just go on to a full body simulation - I guess you have to somehow decide what level of accuracy is needed for the key features. You're not going to be able to do chemistry-level simulations of your whole body, so you'll have to make higher level simulations of different parts (like here's a function that describes insulin reaction as a response to blood sugar function)
- pavel_lishin 16y agoAgree on the ethical dilemmas. Imagine being the consciousness in the first few actual working versions. Technology can bring us literal heaven and hell.
- nooneelse 16y agoA small room several paces across, a green floor, blue walls and ceiling. A dim bulb overhead just out of reach. Beyond the walls, nothing; void without even a large expanse and stars to ponder. I've had a couple of lucid dreams end in that room, with the walls seeming to softly vibrate, due I suppose to the instabilities of my brain's simulation of the geometry. Deep despair threaten when I contemplated being stuck there, but I always had the hope that I could wake up and get back to this nice stable world of "reality" that we share.
- jessedhillon 16y agoIMHO, relevant reading would include The Singularity Is Near by Ray Kurzweil and Altered Carbon by Richard K. Morgan. I bet everyone here knows the former book. Kurzweil's exploration of the ramifications of thinking machines is fascinating, but his response to the question of ethics can best be summed up as between "meh" and "we'll cross that bridge when we get to it." The other book takes place in a future where consciousness can be digitized, and mankind has already surpassed the threshold of computing power represented by the ability to simulate/host consciousness. The fictional treatment of this technology and its impact on society -- especially on crime and law enforcement -- is fascinating.
- nickknw 16y agoI was about to mention Altered Carbon, glad I'm not the only one who has read it. He did an amazing job of exploring many of the far-reaching impacts of being able to transplant consciousnesses. To your examples of crime and law enforcement I'd like to add religion and drug use as well. (minor spoiler alert) All that's left of Christianity is basically a small fanatic cult, and drug use is far more casual and widespread. If your body is almost disposable and death isn't necessarily inevitable, then I guess it makes sense things like this follow.
- anateus 16y agoAlthough not nearly as fast-paced and cinematic, the kinda-badly-written Permutation City by Greg Egan does a much more thorough job of exploring uploading and simulation, imho. Morgan is a wee bit oversimplifying certain aspects, in particular the tech is almost too nicely packaged and very "physical". Which is certainly a possibility, but Permutation City crosses the speculation with the distributed computing trends we are currently experiencing.
- hamner 16y agoThat is important, but extremely challenging to execute for two reasons. 1. Historically, technology has outpaced the legal framework. Look at copyright law, software patents, and internet commerce for some examples. 2. It is next to impossible to predict the impact that "Strong AI" or a "Singularity" would have on society. Science fiction literature is filled with thousands of different scenarios. Do we expect Congress or another legislative body to create a framework based on each potential manifestation of strong AI, on the 0.01% chance of it occurring in the next 10 years? Food for thought - there's a chance that the first implementations of Strong AI occur as a result of a public and government-sponsored research program. There's also a chance that they will come about by a small team of dedicated researchers who will use the technology to their (or its) own ends, legalities and ethics be damned.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- dodo53 16y agoYes, I think my current thinking is: this should be considered. But I'm also cynical that lawmakers could get it right, or that the laws would be followed. Strong AI would presumably have military applications too, or could allow rogue nations to outcompete economically if they had 'friendly' strong AI. As, as long as most of the population / electable people are religious, probably the idea cannot be debated (as many religious would say consciousness cannot be simulated).
- patrickk 16y ago"Strong AI would presumably have military applications too, or could allow rogue nations to outcompete economically if they had 'friendly' strong AI." If you wish to explore this further, you may like to read the books behind the Halo video games, they're surprisingly good. For example, one of the books has an AI character, a cowboy, who controls the agricultural systems on a food-producing planet called Harvest. Of course, there's also Cortana, one of the main characters from the Halo universe: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cortana http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cortana
- ignifero 16y agoThis is not about making a machine that thinks, rather making a useful large scale model of neurons so we can test how they respond on a very large network scale. Robots will not rise out of it. Think of it like an expensive telescope; do we need an ethical framework for that?
- eschulte 16y agoAssuming you're a materialist, a fully functional running model of a brain at the neuronal level would necessarily give rise to consciousness, and should be treated with the same ethical rules as biologically generated consciousness.
- ignifero 16y agoIt will still be a machine, won't be able to kill you unless you give it a gun. Our ethical rules generally show some respect to animals, because we can empathize with cruelty against them, but even that is relative (we 're not so sorry when we eat them). I see no reason why we should preemptively allocate ethical substance to a machine that thinks. Cruel as it may sound, if a robot is mean to me, i will unplug it. All this talk about strong AI sounds more like science fiction fantasy. We need to realize that this simulation, even 10 years later will probably be extremely slow, taking minutes or hours to simulate 1 msec of brain activity (it would actually be interesting to have an estimate of the computing power that will be required).
- pavel_lishin 16y ago> We need to realize that this simulation, even 10 years later will probably be extremely slow, taking minutes or hours to simulate 1 msec of brain activity This is just a difference of degree. How stupid would a real-life person have to be before you could put a bullet through their brain, effectively unplugging them?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- csomar 16y ago
- eschulte 16y agoThomas Metzinger addresses this exact question in his book _The Ego Tunnel_ ([1] a great non-technical overview of his work in Philosophy-o-Mind/Neuroscience), and he comes down strongly on the side that any artificial generation of "consciousness" would be reckless and could likely increasing the amount of suffering in the world. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Ego-Tunnel-Science-Mind-Myth/dp/0465045677 http://www.amazon.com/Ego-Tunnel-Science-Mind-Myth/dp/046504...
- dodo53 16y agoThat sounds really interesting, thanks for link.
- eschulte 16y agoHappy to share. Metzinger takes a hard line on strong materialism and against the existence of the self. For a more general overview of current strains of scientific thoughts on consciousness I'd recommend _Conversations on Consciousness_ [1] which interviews leading researchers who are representative of the varied approaches to the field. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Conversations-Consciousness-Minds-Think-about/dp/0195179587 http://www.amazon.com/Conversations-Consciousness-Minds-Thin...
- ajj 16y agoYou raise a great point. Definitely agree on the fact that legal / ethical frameworks are required. However, it might be very hard to do without knowing what the emulated "being" looks like. Its hard to imagine placing legalities and ethics on something whose powers (and possibly, limitations) are absolutely unknown. Consequently, the law might be misplaced, restrictive, or downright abusive depending on what it turns out to be. Having said that, I agree with your broad point - having that advanced technology without the social aspects to deal with it might be a nightmare!
- tritogeneia 16y agoThese questions are important, but I doubt it's best to define the laws before developing the technology, if the risk is on the order of killing a person per upload.
- mortenjorck 16y ago`Also, can you simulate a brain without a body or is say hormones/blood sugar/nervous system not easily separable?` From my basic understanding of the nervous system, to simulate anything approximating normal function, it would be necessary to emulate the body to some degree. There's just too much interdependence with chemical reactions taking place outside the brain for a model to be of much use in isolation.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoThis is great science, and I'm sure we will learn a lot about brains, but there is no way a simulated brain will have any kind of consciousness without a simulated body as well. Without a body and an environment to interact with, the brain is like a computer program with no data to run on. Experiments have shown that if you yoke a paralyzed cat to another cat and let it experience a complete array of visual inputs, the yoked cat will still be completely blind. Interactive embodied experience is the foundation of cognition and consciousness. A brain in a vat is as empty as a computer without i/o. It would be interesting to have a full-scale simulation to learn about how activation propagates, how different systems interact, yada yada yada. But until you give it a body there won't be any ethical issues.
- hasenj 16y agoProcesses in a computer can create input/output between each other. If the brain is just another program, why couldn't some other program running inside the same computer send it inputs?
- erikpukinskis 16y agoIt could! But simulating the human body, not to mention the environment a human being grows up in, is a much harder task than simulating the brain.
- hasenj 16y agoBut the brain exists in a certain state at any given time, and this state theoretically can be uploaded (from some individual person) to a computer simulating a brain so that we don't always have to "grow" the computer brain.
- erikpukinskis 16y agoYour brain wouldn't be worth much without your body. You'd be surprised how much your body does. Think of typing for example. You couldn't do it without the exact nerve/muscle pathways in your hands. Hook up robot hands (even crudely modelled after your existing nervous/muscle/bone system in your current hands) and you'd basically have to relearn to do anything. You'd be a baby again. I think you'd be surprised how much this applies to. Speech, even things like counting we rely on our bodies for.
- joe_the_user 16y agoIndeed, there are a variety of safety questions as well. If we were simply emulating a human brain, we would not know how intelligent a system we'd create was or whether that system was sane.
- adrianN 16y agoUnless you attach arms with machine guns to your supercomputer, I don't think safety is much of a concern, really.
- dodo53 16y agoAlso - if you're interested in background on systems biology - there's a broad overview of UCLs biological modelling research group here (http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/10844/1/10844.pdf http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/10844/1/10844.pdf [pdf]) - they've got a project modelling the liver / blood-sugar-system. Apparently the canonical example that has worked pretty well is a computer model of the heart but I think it's a simpler organ in that it's mostly electro-mechanical, without such a complicated chemical system (http://www.sciencemag.org/content/295/5560/1678.abstract http://www.sciencemag.org/content/295/5560/1678.abstract - behind Science paywall)
- TheEzEzz 16y agoThere is actually quite a ways to go before we have high fidelity macro models of the heart in action. (The numerical research I do is closely related). 3D fluid simulations are expensive. Hopefully the quasi-discreteness of the brain reduces the computational requirements for a high fidelity simulation.
- dodo53 16y agoHa, that's funny, that model was the one UCL referenced in their kinda 'This is possible' motivation. I find it all very interesting, but gave up after a year as I felt like a lot of the models were going to be a bit flaky for the next decade and that was a bit of a culture shock (I was a physics student before).
- rauljara 16y agoThere are dozens of ethical concerns involved with created an artificial human conscious. A completely selfish concern of mine is this: Once the hard work of emulating a human brain is done, what's to stop the emulation from running at 10 or 100 (or many, many more) times as fast? If this is a human brain, replete with arrogance, in what way wouldn't it be right to feel superior to me? If you had the option of hiring normal speed brains vs ultra high speed brains, which would you hire? How long would it take ultra high speed brains to completely take over?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- oinksoft 16y agoPlease stop with the URL shorteners, this is not Twitter. Parent linked to http://www.emersonkent.com/images/maps/native_american_map.jpg http://www.emersonkent.com/images/maps/native_american_map.j... We like to know what we're clicking, particularly on actively monitored networks.
- pavel_lishin 16y agoIf you were running at 100x clock speed, how much interest would you have in working for someone running in real-time? You'd receive project requirements, comment on them and ask clarifying questions, and send them off... and receive a response in four months, subjective time. Then again, I suppose that was the state of the world until sometime in the 1800's, and people managed to get things done.
- dodo53 16y agoI guess the goal would be to choose work where you don't rely on people at slower clock speeds (say working on deep algorithm stuff - you can get low latency connection to a library and research stuff 100x faster). Or you could change your clock speed / put your consciousness on hold until slower-time triggers mean you can do something productive, and then ramp up so that your end of things happens very quickly.
- d0m 16y agoI often dream about "building" a digital human brain (Not that I have the knowledge to do it.. just for the sake of dreaming about it :p) That'd be fantastic.. think about all the advancement in the medical resources.. Being able to "simulate" a real-world scenario.
- pavel_lishin 16y ago"Good morning, Virtual Patient 2872. Sure, we can call you d0m if you'd like. Today, we'll be testing out a new suite of anti-schizophrenic medications. Please describe how you are feeling, in detail, so we may shut you down and try another variation."
- nooneelse 16y agoIf you set the Virtual Patient software to run with less than several square km of simulated environment or in low resolution mode, then you need to be sure and run the "defiant VP detector and shutdown routine" so as to avoid generating reams and reams of vitriolic rants mostly involving violations of human dignity. You can just filter those out of the data-set later if you want, but the d0m patient has a rather high defiance ratio, so better to shut the unhelpful instances down early and not waste the computation up-front.
- Locke1689 16y agoLet's be clear on at least one thing: they're building a simulation of the physical brain hardware. At least according to the article, there is no goal to simulate human consciousness.
- rauljara 16y agoIn what way do you think human consciousness is detached from the physical operation of the brain?
- yread 16y agoInstincts, growing up, human experience. It's the software that makes us (in this case some preconfigured parameters and training data), the hardware is going to be dumb
- pavel_lishin 16y agoA large portion of our instincts are hard-wired. What about a sadly-not-too-hypothetical case of a child being raised in total isolation? Do they not possess consciousness?
- apl 16y ago> A large portion of our instincts are hard-wired. Not accurate, or at least misleading. There's a lot of plasticity in the brain even at the very basic levels. Raising a kitten in an atypical environment (e.g., without edges or contrast), for instance, yields profound functional differences from retinal ganglion cells over V1/V2 up to the dorsal and ventral streams of the visual system. We are what we are because our brains are hard-wired to adapt to typical environments. Full isolation would cause substantial aberrations -- that's exactly what you observe in real-world cases.
- EricBerglund 16y agoWhat do "software" and "hardware" even mean in the context of the brain? All of what you call "software" is just the result of combinations of neuron patterns and chemicals, all of which could be included in a simulation.
- sv123 16y agoMaybe we are all already living in a digital brain simulation.
- zackattack 16y agohttp://blog.bekahbrunstetter.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/PBF111-Reset.jpg http://blog.bekahbrunstetter.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/...
- jasongullickson 16y agoIt would be neat, and perhaps useful as a diagnostic tool (for troubleshooting the real thing) but I'm not sure how emulating the brain has any practical application (they are fairly common and inexpensive to acquire through natural means). I'm not saying I wouldn't love to burn billions of OPM building one, but then again practicality is rarely a requirement for me personally.
- ignifero 16y agoIt's still extremely difficult to observe network activity in vivo. Even the most sophisticated methods can only observe tiny fractions and only a single property of neurons at a time. A large scale in silico network makes it trivial to tinker with properties of cells and neurotransmitters and observe how the activity of the network changes
- thisisblurry 16y agoI was kinda hoping that this would be a Kickstarter project.
- car 16y agoThe question that pops in to my mind is, how could we model a human brain, while we still have no clear idea how it works? There are many many unknown genes and pathways involved in brain development and function. So without knowing these details, how would one go about 'emulating' a brain. edit:[removed snark]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- dardila2 16y agoBefore starting to evaluate claims that this model will replicate any human behavior, I think it's important to consider the case of C. Elegans. It always has exactly 302 neurons, and we know exactly how they connect to one another (we know its connectome), yet the furthest models have gotten with replicating its behavior is simplified, feedforward models of locomotion. In light of this, it is very hard to believe that we will be able to reproduce the behavior of 100 billion neurons which are constantly changing. This is not to say that Blue Brain is not an immensely useful tool to develop knowledge about the brain: it will be an excellent way to study what the implications of the vast amounts of data we have collected about the brain. However, to claim that the model will behave like a human brain seems like a stretch.
- Devilboy 16y agoThe c elegans models are better that you think. Which nematode behavior is not able to be replicated by our models?
- dardila2 16y agoI'm not familiar with your models, but I'd be delighted to learn more. Could you post a link? EDIT: I was going off this quote from an article by well known computational neuroscientist Christof Koch: " Consider this sobering lesson: the roundworm Caenorhabditis elegans is a tiny creature whose brain has 302 nerve cells. Back in 1986, scientists used electron microscopy to painstakingly map its roughly 6000 chemical synapses and its complete wiring diagram. Yet more than two decades later, there is still no working model of how this minimal nervous system functions. Now scale that up to a human brain with its 100 billion or so neurons and a couple hundred trillion synapses. Tracing all those synapses one by one is close to impossible, and it is not even clear whether it would be particularly useful, because the brain is astoundingly plastic, and the connection strengths of synapses are in constant flux. Simulating such a gigantic neural network model in the hope of seeing consciousness emerge, with millions of parameters whose values are only vaguely known, will not happen in the foreseeable future."
- 16y ago
- apl 16y agoMain problem appears to be construct validity. If they're building a computationally vast model based on impoverished data (i.e., a pre-selected subset of current morphological/functional knowledge), nobody will be able to determine whether its electrical behavior tells you anything at all about a real brain. More to the point: If they want to get this thing running within ten years, they'll have to simplify at each step without knowing the potential repercussions of each simplification. I thus find it disingenuous to call their project a "model of the brain." It's an implementation of a very specific reduction of neurobiological state of the art. Sure, that can be useful, but only within strictly confined limits. You won't be able to do drug tests on this thing -- so much is certain.
- TheEzEzz 16y agoNot too long ago it was Markram himself accusing another group of what you accuse him of (oversimplification), http://nextbigfuture.com/2009/11/henry-markram-calls-ibm-cat-scale-brain.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2009/11/henry-markram-calls-ibm-cat... From what I've read about Blue Brain it appears that validation is a central theme of their work. They are actively validating the small piece that they have already built (the neocortical column).
- tedkimble 16y agoEveryone in the comments seems to be quickly attributing consciousness directly to a sufficiently connected deterministic system. This seems to guarantee a deterministic view of life, which I find troubling. Have any of you thought of the role of the nodes themselves? I find Stewart Kauffman's recent work intriguing [PDF]: http://stuartkauffman.com/index_25_1612352741.pdf http://stuartkauffman.com/index_25_1612352741.pdf
- ak217 16y agoThat author, like everyone else I've ever heard argue against the basic connectionism/neurobiology first principles model, takes a bit of biology, a bit of physics, and then throws in philosophical crap that has nothing to do with science, engineering, or any reasonable way to analytically understand the brain. This mixing of science and navel-gazing is useless.
- nkassis 16y ago<shameless_plug> "Jülich Katrin Amunts has begun work on a detailed atlas of the brain which involved slicing one into 8,000 parts which were then digitalized with a scanner." The lab I work for is working with them on this project. Basically those slices are taken at 10 microns and we are working on fixing some of the problems (when you cut a brain that thin you end up with a lot of tears and deformations) Then our lab is reassembling the slices (with algorithms) realigning the slices so you can cut through the slices in any directions and get the cross section of those slices and look at them. Realignment of the 8000 slices can take weeks or more (depending on how many cores you can run the stuff on) and is a rather complex process. Here a link for those wanting more info: https://cbrain.mcgill.ca/tools/visualization https://cbrain.mcgill.ca/tools/visualization Scroll to the bottom (well look at the whole page, brainbrowser is what I've been working on). You can see a image of the interface and some of the slices. I'll try to find a video of the project. </shameless_plug>
- apl 16y agoImpressive. > Basically those slices are taken at 10 microns and we are > working on fixing some of the problems (when you cut a > brain that thin you end up with a lot of tears and > deformations) Can you talk about how you deal with the inherent deformations? I've spent hundreds of hours on cryostats preparing rodent brain slices for autoradiography, and getting usable ones at 15-20 microns is a painful process. Should be even worse if you need to retain morphological information...
- nkassis 16y agoI'm probably not the best person to explain the whole process but I can put you in contact with the person who's working on it. (My email is in my profile). I'll try to explain what I know: For the most major tears and breaks we've actually had to fix them ourselves (Some were quite awefull, for example part of the right hemisphere on one slice broke off and was put back upside down ;p). For the less major thing, they can be fixed by looking at the surrounding slices, this is also how the slice are realigned, it's an iterative process where you take chunks of slices and aligned them then increase the chunks etc. At least that's what I gather. (Software developer talking about Brain imaging stuff is a bad idea ;p) EDIT: Also as for the morphological information I'm pretty sure that some of it will be affected by the process but I don't know how much. Our interface will provide the original and modified slices and a heat map of changes for comparaison in those cases. I don't know how that can be avoided.
- gnosis 16y agoWill this project "emulate" a human brain down to the subatomic level? Down to even the atomic level? Both are probably far too ambitious for this project. I'd even be quite surprised if they managed to accurately simulate a brain down to a molecular level. What this sounds like is yet another attempt at a grossly simplified simulation of a subset of what is actually going on in the brain. It remains to be seen how useful this is, nevermind whether this will bring us any closer to AI (how would you even measure the "intelligence" of a simulated brain without any sensory organs or an ability to communicate?)
- a-priori 16y agoWill this project "emulate" a human brain down to the subatomic level? Down to even the atomic level? The short answer is that each part of the simulation, from ion channels and synapses to cell bodies to network topologies and cell distributions, is done at the lowest level that people in the laboratories can effectively isolate and study. From that they can derive mathematical models of each part, and integrate those models to simulate them interacting over time and space. Is it a simplified model of the brain? Yes, but its the most detailed model that science can produce (or at least it aims to be). how would you even measure the "intelligence" of a simulated brain without any sensory organs or an ability to communicate? What makes you think that's difficult to simulate? It's been shown that primate brains are capable of learning to interpret novel inputs, such as a grid of electrodes 'painting' an image onto cortex. There was also a study where they implanted electrodes in a monkey's brain where the rate of activation of the cells surrounding the electrodes moved a cursor on a computer screen. The monkey learned to move the cursor. This shows that simulated inputs and outputs wouldn't have to perfectly correspond with reality in order for the brain to be able to process it.
- roel_v 16y agoDoes it matter? As far as I know, we don't know yet what level we need to simulate at to simulate consciousness. If it's at the molecular level and we achieve that, who cares about the atomic level.
- possibilistic 16y ago
- erikig 16y agoIf it were my own cash, I'd wait until a couple years and buy the desktop version of the human brain for 1,600.00.
- csomar 16y agoInteresting discussion here, but I just want to highlight one point: consciousness happens not because of the brain, but actually of his interaction with the external world. So Designing a brain won't make consciousness. If constructing a brain model needs $1.61Bn, then constructing the virtual world might need a dozen and may be more. After that, uploading a brain copy to the brain computer and a world copy to the world computer will create a real person like you. No one actually can prove his existence. We are a bunch of mixed senses. And since this can be a stimulation, we can't prove that we are real and we do exist. Certainly, you can know who is behind you (and probably there is someone); but only by committing suicide. But an interesting question that pops in my mind: Does our world allow more than one self-awareness existence? That is, if I upload my mind to a computer which is stimulating my same world, wouldn't it be me?
- giardini 16y agoIs there any reason why they'll end up with a human brain instead of a lizard's? And what about teaching it? A human brain requires a human body to learn. This is cargo-cult science. They'll be lucky to end up with anything useful, except 20 years' government funding!8-)) This project could be almost as good a gravy train for researchers as Cyc (20 years without significant results and still funded).
- apl 16y ago> Is there any reason why they'll end up with a human > brain instead of a lizard's? Don't accuse people of cargo-cult science without a basic understanding of brain anatomy. There are vast differences in physiology and anatomy between mammalian and primate brains, let alone the CNS of a lizard. Also, nobody's growing a brain here -- they're building a mature forebrain.
- kwamenum86 16y agoDoes the mythical man month principle extend to money? That is to say does throwing twice as much money at a problem make it take half as long? Not being critical. Just seems like budgeting a huge hunk of money to make something happen more quickly might not be the best decision.
- mkramlich 16y agoFor bonus credit, the brain emulation must be written in JS and run in a browser.
- MikeCapone 16y agoNot exactly the same thing, but this interested by this should check out the Whole Brain Emulation Roadmap by Nick Bostrom and Anders Sanberg. Very advanced and I didn't understand most of it, but it was still fascinating: http://www.philosophy.ox.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/3853/brain-emulation-roadmap-report.pdf http://www.philosophy.ox.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/3...
- mgdiaz 16y agoA friend of mine is directing a 10-year film-in-the-making chronicling the development of Markram's research. Here's Year One of the project: http://vimeo.com/8977365 http://vimeo.com/8977365
- givan 16y agoThis means that they figured out how the brain works? I doubt it
- ozziegooen 16y agoIf it's estimated to cost $1.61 billion to achieve emulation by 2024, we should spend $160 billion and get it done by 2016. I'm skeptical, but a technological singularity is not to be underestimated.
- CamperBob 16y agoScience does not work that way
- pygy_ 16y agoAs far as I know they use adult brains as models. A functional brain has "meaningful synapses", i.e. neuronal assemblies that represent a given concept, shape, etc... . Getting these out of the box is impossible AFAIK, because of the sheer number of neurons and connections to relate to one another. Especially, since the neural code is far from being decrypted. You'd have to replicate the development process, probably starting with a model of fetal brain. Is there anyone familiar with the research around? Are these concerns baseless? If not, how are they addressed?
- spottiness 16y agoThis is good stuff. I'm surprised he didn't mention Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff's work on quantum consciousness. If Penrose/Stuart are right (that a lot, if not most, of the computation in the brain takes place in the microtubules of each neuron, taking the complexity of the brain to unfathomed territory) all these models of the brain based on the network of neuron connections, will be basically irrelevant. http://www.quantumconsciousness.org/Google_000.htm http://www.quantumconsciousness.org/Google_000.htm
- Coko 16y agoChatroulette with bots coming soon.
- sfjunk 16y agoHow are they handling the fact that a human brain simply won't work if they don't have sensory input (eyes,ears,touch, ,...,BREATHING)