5 ms·
The author sets up a short list of technologies developed since 1996: > Since 1996 we’ve gotten: IntelliJ, Eclipse, ASP, Spring, Rails, Scala, AWS, Clojure, He
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
The author sets up a short list of technologies developed since 1996:
> Since 1996 we’ve gotten: IntelliJ, Eclipse, ASP, Spring, Rails, Scala, AWS, Clojure, Heroku, V8, Go, React, Docker, Kubernetes, Wasm.
And then waives them all away as incremental or unimpressive.
The author holds up V8 as an example of something that isn't fundamentally new, which is missing the entire point of developing a runtime for an existing language. Not to mention, V8 is an impressive achievement in itself.
I'm lost as to why the author wants to work so hard to dismiss these technologies while simultaneously suggesting that nothing else noteworthy has been developed in the past two decades.
If an engineer in 1996 fell into a coma and woke up today, they'd be greeted with an entirely different world. We're driving around in electric cars, carrying around cell phones that are orders of magnitude faster than desktop PCs from 1996, and communication technology has evolved to the point that many of us are seamlessly working from home.
Technology only looks stagnant when you're steeped in it every day of every year. Up close, it looks slow. Take a step back and it's amazing what we have at our disposal relative to 1996. Don't mistake cynicism for expertise or objectivity.
- ativzzz 6y ago> We're driving around in electric cars, carrying around cell phones that are orders of magnitude faster than desktop PCs from 1996, and communication technology I'd argue that these are primarily hardware innovations, not software innovations. The OP mentions software, not technology in general. See also Moore's law (hardware upgrades double computing speed every ~2 years) vs Proebsting's Law [1] (compiler upgrades double computing speed every ~18 years). [1] http://proebsting.cs.arizona.edu/law.html http://proebsting.cs.arizona.edu/law.html
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> The OP mentions software, not technology in general. Hardware and software are closely intertwined. We couldn't design, develop, build, and run modern hardware without modern software packages. You're just not seeing the advances in software if you're only looking at famous web services technologies. The whole article is extremely myopic, limited only to the author's narrow domain of web services and coding in text editors.
- medlyyy 6y agoOkay - could you give some examples of where you think huge advances in software have been made?
- sofixa 6y agoNot OP but eBPF, Android ( phone, TV, auto) and iOS, ChromeOS, VS Code, Go, Swift, Powershell ( it's a terrible piece of software but a vast improvement for Windows), virtualisation, public cloud platforms ( virtualisation at huge scale with APIs), the Hashicorp stack, ZFS, LXC and later Docker, Kubernetes, Redis.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhat you think of hardware innovations are often actually software innovations. Your iPhone doesn’t take a better picture because it has a better lens this year - it does because it has better software.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> I'm lost as to why the author wants to work so hard to dismiss these technologies Some people just want to find negativity in the world.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoTo me it reads as bitterness about the uptake of his personal project, which he would presumably class with the cool tech from before '96. Some of the copy on that project's page has a similar feel to this blog post: http://www.subtext-lang.org/ http://www.subtext-lang.org/ "This approach antagonizes both academics and professionals, but it is what I must do."
- Sophistifunk 6y ago> Some people just want to find negativity in the world Are you kidding? The author has (clearly) been dedicating his entire career to trying to solve these problems. He's not some drive-by hipster reminiscing about the good old days. The problem is that in a lot of ways programming is stuck in the "good old days"
- chrisseaton 6y agoI'm going to take a wiiiiild guess here that the author's personal peak was around 1996. It's just a reaction to 'the kids' coming after him not being up to how good he (mis) remembers the past. This negativity is a disappointing and growing trend among some grumpy old men in our field as that generation approach retirement. It disrespects people working today and I don't like it.
- Nicksil 6y ago>This negativity is a disappointing and growing trend among some grumpy old men in our field as that generation approach retirement. It disrespects people working today and I don't like it. Your contributions thus far in this thread have been negative with no substantive rebuttal to any points made in the article.
- meowkit 6y agoAs I get older myself, this brand of cynicism seems to be a projection of death anxiety or possibly the "loss of innocence" where grand visions of how the world ought to be were not met. 1996 was 24 years ago. You are totally correct that the progress and change in this period has been incredible on the historical scale. But 24 years on the timeline of a human life is quite a significant portion, and some may feel that their expectations of futuristic utopia have been subverted, making them cynical.
- MartianSquirrel 6y ago25! Happy new year!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- elipsey 6y ago>> some may feel that their expectations of futuristic utopia have been subverted, making them cynical. i know i do! lot's of stuff about the future sucks, and i can't think of a way to fix anything important with faster garbage collection or better type systems... maybe that's the difference between makers and cynics. i guess i'll try harder :p
- mixedCase 6y ago> and i can't think of a way to fix anything important with faster garbage collection or better type systems I can, I am very hopeful better type systems will help heal the absolutely dreadful state of software robustness. Better types (and by extension, better type systems) help eliminate many costly tests, improves knowledge transfer from senior engineers to junior engineers, makes refactoring and adapting to changing requirements a much less error-prone process where the computer can guide you, provides a more rigid way of breaking down problems into chunks instead of a procedural approach where good boundaries are harder to intuitively determine. While education is what enables people to write better code with them, we need better type systems and languages that make this process easier for the average programmer to learn and use. Already languages like TypeScript, Kotlin and Swift are slowly getting many people to take a gander over the brick wall by exposing them to constructs like sum types and specific patterns like optionals and either/result types, that should fuel a little bit of hope at least! EDIT: That's some visceral reaction. Would be nice to see some disagreement stated in text, or if any particular point needs further explaining, or to see if just hope of things improving is what's angering people.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoAuthor failed to mention the ML ecosystem, which has made significant improvements to products used by real people every day. A number of items on their cool/before 1996 list seem to serve little practical purpose. Which is cool, but it does lead to the question of by what metric we're judging a technology's importance.
- medlyyy 6y agoI would consider the advances in ML to be mainly mathematical and hardware rather than software. Being able to write the libraries to support ML operations wouldn't have been a problem in 1996 if the hardware & theory had existed.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoWhat software do we have the theory, hardware, and use for, which hasn't been written? I guess I'm struggling to identify a useful delineation between these categories.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoRealistically yes, but as a kid promised flying cars and off-world colonies it's less impressive. Blade Runner is now set in the past shrug. These are mostly hardware I suppose. Instead we got social networking, ad tech, and surveillance capitalism.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoMeh, people always bring up the "flying cars" bit but I'm going to call bullshit that these were ever really feasible, not from a tech perspective but from an economic, energy and safety perspective. The tech for flying cars already exists, just not the tech for protecting people on the ground from flying car crashes.
- pram 6y agoThis article is just the IT equivalent of 'no good music gets made today' and so on. It's a combination of nostalgia and advancing age, the observation he's making is really no different. I remember software in 1996 too, and most of it really sucked. If you want to relive the 90s experience just go use some Oracle or IBM software. That will show you true stagnation.
- Scarbutt 6y agoWhat's so impressive about V8? that billions of dollars have being pour into it to make it fast? for a problem that shouldn't have existed in the first place?
- jiofih 6y agoIn the grand scheme of things, there is nothing impressive about V8 - it’s just a really good interpreter. Every technology we have today could be easily programmed in pre-1996 languages, they haven’t unlocked anything not possible before. We even use the exact same tooling. That is the stagnation.
- yrimaxi 6y ago> If an engineer in 1996 fell into a coma and woke up today, they'd be greeted with an entirely different world. We're driving around in electric cars, carrying around cell phones that are orders of magnitude faster than desktop PCs from 1996, and communication technology has evolved to the point that many of us are seamlessly working from home. But these things were not driven by software innovations.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gibbon1 6y agoHaving been an engineer in 1996. Really nothing wasn't foreseen by anyone with a feel for how things were going. In 1996 a friend was dating an engineer with an electric car. She'd thrown a bunch of time and money into it. Had a range of about 80-90 miles and wasn't slow at all. Around then there was skunks works a couple of buildings away from me. On the spectrum analyzer I could see spread spectrum signals showing up at 900 and 2.4GHZ. Edit: Stay classy HN.
- elipsey 6y ago>> If an engineer in 1996 fell into a coma and woke up today, they'd be greeted with an entirely different world. i was little and didn't know shit, but i was already learning to program, and i think about this all the time. like mind blown, every day. 8 threads and 2GB of ram in my cheap ass phone? crazy! and we got so good at writing compilers they give them away for free! JS was way slow because MSIE wasn't supposed to compete with desktop apps :p also, transpilation, JIT, virtualization and containers seem like a pretty big deal to me -- virtualization was academic in the 90's. also, a lot of that "old" stuff like python and ruby and even C++ really weren't as mature and feature-full. memory safety/auto-management and concurrency language features are prevalent now, and i think people don't always appreciate (or remember?) when your computer couldn't walk and chew gum at the same time. it seems to me like our tools have clearly improved -- i think a more useful conversation could investigate how to apply what we now have to improving productivity, safety and security.
- icedchai 6y agoVirtualization isn't that recent. It at least goes back to the 60's with the IBM 360 mainframe. For micros, it has been available, in some form, on x86 since 1985 when the 386 processor was first released. Remember the vm86 mode that let people run DOS apps under Windows 2.x?
- jcranmer 6y ago> Remember the vm86 mode that let people run DOS apps under Windows 2.x? That's not really virtualization. In the x86 world, hardware virtualization extensions don't crop up until 2003. Efficient dynamic binary translation (a key component for efficient virtualization without hardware support) I generally reckon to start with DynamoRIO (~2001), with Intel's Pin tool coming out in 2004. (Do note that hardware virtualization does predate x86; I believe IBM 360 was the first one to have support for it, but I'm really bad with dates for processor milestones).
- jlokier 6y agoJust a data point. VMware Workstation came out as a product in 1999, and did excellent x86 virtualisation without hardware support using dynamic translation and code scanning techniques.
- Isamu 6y agoThe great inventions do not look to be incremental because they are presented that way. Personally I find it fascinating to burst that bubble by looking into the rare histories of what lead up to what are considered the great tentpole developments. I really think everything is incremental in progress. Where things are closer to us, we can see the incremental steps. Where we think of the great things of the past, we are completely ignorant of the incremental steps that came before.
- PicassoCTs 6y agoThey are nothing new. Just re-iterations and refinements. Incremental innovation is no real innovation. True innovation is destructive, removes whole fields from the map, while creating new ones. I don't like being called a coward, even if the words wrapped in velvet, but in this case the truth sticks. PS: Machine learning is old too, although application - again due to incremental hardware improvement, has finally arrived.
- greggman3 6y agoI totally agree with you. But, just as an anecdote on the other side, I recently did some Blender tutorials, the famous donut scene by Andrew Price. When I was done I was happy I learned Blender better but I was also disappointed that making 3D hasn't changed much since 1995. In 1995 I learned PowerAnimator (predecessor to Maya) and in 1996 I learned 3DSMax. The techniques used to build the scenes are exactly the same, still super tedious. What changed is better renderers, sculpting (z-brush), but not much else.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoDevil's advocate here but I sort of agree. I think that all of the hard problems with computers will continue to be hard problems until some groundbreaking new computing is discovered (quantum?). All of these technologies are mere transformations with the same hard problems with computing still present underneath. A lot of these are also fads that will pass. Are there any problems today that were unsolvable in 1980 given enough time? Wow, smaller transistors, more clock cycles, big whoop. We have more now but it's not fundamentally different is it? >If an engineer in 1996 fell into a coma and woke up today, they'd be greeted with an entirely different world. I'd also be disappointed. Oh we are on DDR4, Windows 10, multiple cores, cpp 20? Ok. So we basically just extended the trendline 25 years. Boring.
- m4rtink 6y agoYeah, lots of progress being made left and right: huge improvements in image processing and recognition, SLAM in every cleaning robot (and we have cleaning robots!), much improved machine translation, much better voice recognition and transcription, ubiquitous video conferencing software, super complex virtual worlds accessible to anyone and also most of what was desktop only now also available on mobile devices, which was far from a small task to achieve.
- AndrewKemendo 6y agoMy guess is that the author is comparing the rate of change from 1971-1996 to 1996-2021 (25 years each), but didn't do a good job with explaining that. In which case software has "stalled" in terms of "invent anything fundamentally new " - and I'd agree.