5 ms·
The largest dam-removal in US history
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoI think it's an unfortunate omission from this article, but, with every question like this you have to consider things on balance. Everything you do to generate power will have some impact and conversely some benefit. They talk a lot about the impact here, but, not at all about the benefit. All of the dams on the Klamath River produce a combined power of only 169MW (and this isn't even removing all of them, I think its actually removing not even 40MW of power generating capacity. Again, you have to consider everything on balance. This is an absolutely pitiful amount of energy. For example, three gorges produces 22,500 MW of power. Common designs for self-contained PORTABLE nuclear reactors easily outclass the entire generating capacity of these dams. The balance of impact vs benefit on these is incredibly tilted against these projects continuing to exist. Also, Chinook is delicious and anything which means more lox is a win in my book.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 6y agoLots of dams are flood control projects that also produce electricity.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoTrue, that's another possible item in the benefit column, but, it also creates risk of a catastrophic failures like Michigan and almost-orville.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThe Chinese Three Gorges Dam is an electricity project (that benefits one family), and doesn't do flood control (it's 100' too short. The reason is that if it was the correct height, it could flood a major city upstream.) :)
- paledot 6y agoIndeed. This is why hydro shouldn't be considered green energy. (That, and the methane reduced when hundreds or thousands of hectares of living, breathing land are flooded and decompose in an anoxic environment.)
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoDoes anyone consider hydro as green anymore? Nuclear has far less impact.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoVery few people consider nuclear power as "green". It's better than almost all the alternatives but those arguments don't work with you average citizen any longer so nuclear power is plateaued for the forseeable future in Western nations.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> This is why hydro shouldn't be considered green energy. Minuscule emissions when it's built that are amortized over a 50 year lifespan qualifies as very green in my books. The idea that it's not green anymore is absolutely ridiculous. I sometime wonder if environmentalism greatest threat isn't... environmentalists themselves!
- sjdbdjd 6y agoYou are comparing the power output of a damn that displaced some fish to one that displaced tens of millions? Doesn’t seem very proportional
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoI wasn't trying to compare the two and make a judgement on if 3 gorges is worth it while these aren't, I'm merely saying that 3 gorges is so much more massive in scale.
- rhodozelia 6y agoThe article made it sound like they would lose less than 8% of their 2200 MW renewable generation for a reduction of less than 176 MW. Maybe the article confused the total generation from the 8 plants with and the 4 being removed. They estimated 450 million to add fish ladders and rehabilitate the facilities for the next 100 years. If it was $450 million for 170 MW $2.6 million / MW is pretty cheap construction cost. I am surprised that it isn’t an attractive investment
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoCorrect, so, 176MW is the power generation for ALL dams on that river. They are only removing 4 of them of which I think only 2 produce power and I can't find exact figures on the MW output of each of them. 169 was an upper bound and seems VERY small. 450M was the cost of removal according to the article, not the cost of adding new fish ladders?
- rhodozelia 6y ago>This is because to renew the operating licence for these dams, its ratepayers would have to foot an approximately $400m (£308m) bill for upgrades to ensure compliance with legislation (including the installation of costly fish ladders at each dam that would enable migration). Upgrading the dams cost $400m. >Overall, little will be lost in terms of renewable energy generation: the dams represent less than 8% of PacfiCorp’s 2,208 MW current renewable generation capacity, [1] indicates that you are correct and 7 dams produce 169 MW. so indeed these dams produce a relatively small amount of electricity. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klamath_River_Hydroelectric_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klamath_River_Hydroelectric_Pr...
- oefrha 6y ago> three gorges produces 22,500 MW of power. Correction: 22,500MW is the installed capacity, i.e. what the generators are capable of. It only reaches about half capacity on average, going by the numbers listed in the Wikipedia article (101.6TWh in 2018 => average ~11,600MW).
- stjohnswarts 6y agoThe problems is they aren't building any power to deal with the decrease and no one is building nuke plants that haven't been in the works for 15+ years. I all for this if they want their rivers back though, but we can act like there won't be consequences.
- csomar 6y agoSolar production in the US is growing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_United_States#/media/File:US_Monthly_Solar_Power_Generation.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_United_Stat... No need for them to produce electricity, they can trade fish for electrons.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoUnfortunately, the usefulness of solar is limited by our energy storage capabilities. Water is one of the best ways of fixing this (either to supplement solar, like running a hydro dam on a cloudy day, or as a direct storage system, where excess electricity is used to pump water uphill so that the potential energy can be harvested later)
- csomar 6y agoThe way I see it, we haven't worked had on energy storage capabilities. We optimized for cellphones and Laptops, and these cover most of your day or more now. For homes, the market is still no that big, because batteries are expensive and electricity is widely available. As we move to solar, electricity will become very cheap in the day and very expensive at night. This will create the required capital to create storage solutions in houses and factories. Also you don't need a portable battery when installing it at home, so I think the cost could be reasonable.
- Retric 6y agoPeaking power plants actually cost more per kWh than solar backed battery storage. However, until we install enough solar that’s a pointless exercise as simply directly using solar energy is more efficient and there isn’t a regular surplus to capture. The economics of this get really interesting. In a largely solar grid, 1 axis Solar tracking systems add production in the morning and evenings, thus offsetting the need for a lot of battery storage. However, we aren’t currently using significant battery storage so that isn’t worth it yet. Similarly shipping a surplus East / West time shifts it, but we don’t currently have that surplus.
- eigenvector 6y agoWell said. To paraphrase Wade Davis, the question is not hydro or no hydro but where, how much and for whose benefit. Many dams produce very little electricity and can be removed with minimal impact to the cost or carbon intensity of our power supply. We should not conflate dams that are integral to the power system like Grand Coulee with those that are insignificant.
- ncmncm 6y agoEliminating Grand Coulee could produce overwhelmingly greater benefit for fisheries.
- mschuster91 6y ago> Common designs for self-contained PORTABLE nuclear reactors easily outclass the entire generating capacity of these dams. None of these designs has been turned to production yet, and no one has solved the waste storage question.
- dredmorbius 6y agoNameplate capacity (power, in MW) isn't the only consideration in electrical generation, but total generation (energy, in MWh), dispatchability, cold-start capability, pollution, other impacts, maintenance, storage, accident risk, waste storage, and other factors. Even smaller hydro sites are valuable in that they represent very raapidly dispatchable load --- a dam's turbines can be put online or taken offline in seconds to minutes, where other sources (notably conventional and nuclear thermal power) require hours to days to make large cycling changes. Solar and wind rely on incident available energy, and are not deployable at operator discretion, though balancing over the grid or via storage, or dispachable load, may be possible. Hydro banks power in the form of impounded water. And with relatively simple moddifications offers 90%+ efficient pumped hydro storage capabilities. The downsides are the large ecological impacts noted in the BBC article, sedimentation (a particularly large problem on the silt-heavy Colorado River), as well as some risk of structural failure, though the US record on this is generally quite good. With many thousands of dams, there've been a handful of major failures. Planning, alerts, and response generally eliminate of minimise deaths, though disruption from evacuations, or property damage can still be substantial. Long-term consequences spanning centuries, as with nuclear failures, are not a factor, even in utterly catastrophic failures, largely experienced outside the US. I'm not defending the Klamath hydro facilities, only noting factors. Your obsevation that there are both benefits and negative impacts is true of any technology or technological intervention.
- seltzered_ 6y agoHonestly this framing just makes me wonder about what the impacts of three gorges dam has then, or it's risks. It's more complicated than just finding balance vs. impact on dam power level, it's the other things introduced by human population that isn't aware or engaged with the local ecology. To ramble aloud, Recently tire dust was linked to salmon getting sick ( https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/03/climate/salmon-kill-washington.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/03/climate/salmon-kill-washi... ), and in talking with people in the northwest home construction around urbanism/single family home suburbs over the past 30 years has hugely impacted the pacific northwest ecology.
- bmitc 6y ago> Also, Chinook is delicious and anything which means more lox is a win in my book. The salmon isn’t for you. It’s for the orcas who are literally starving.
- ncmncm 6y agoThere was once plenty for everyone. There could be, again, given time and action. The destroyed fisheries always produced more value than the electrical production that replaced them. The dam people just had enough political influence to overcome reasoned opposition. Central power production represented Progress, vs. distributed, disunited and archaic fishing communities that, you know, fed people.
- lumberingjack 6y agoNearly weekly and sometimes daily outages in Sand City and surrounding areas people actually packing up and leaving and they're still using our tax dollars to tear down infrastructure. My tribe was also in that area still is the fish are fine. Just because this tribe was on the American side of the border when they drew the lines doesn't mean that they are the only tribe that used that area. California has a blanket ban on any nuclear energy projects or research in California it's never going to happen. get ready to buy China coal because that's what you're going to be using in about 6 years.
- reportingsjr 6y agoPlease leave the fear mongering to other sites, and try to use critical thinking a bit more. Your comment history is full of half truths to try and make some terrible arguments, which is seriously unethical.
- labster 6y ago> On 17 November 2020, a new agreement was signed between PacifiCorp, the Yurok and other stakeholders to facilitate the dams' removals. Should federal regulators approve, the project will begin in 2022, with the demolitions slated for 2023. These damn removals take too dam long. The Matilija Dam has been waiting for over 20 years and has only been symbolically demolished. Everyone agreed it was a good idea to remove it in 1998, and it’s still standing.
- ars 6y agoAccording to Wikipedia the issue with the Matilija Dam is that there is so much sediment built up behind it that they can't figure out how to remove the dam without causing a disaster. There are various proposals, but it seems none are good enough.
- rhodozelia 6y agoIt is odd that dams don’t incorporate a means for sediment to continue its path downstream. If there were a channel that ran the length of the reservoir that was narrow enough it would Keep the velocity of the water high enough that the sediment wouldn’t settle out. It could then be run through the turbines, admittedly causing more wear, or allowed to settle behind the dam in an area with a sluice gate that could be used to flush sediment out. Probably much easier said than done so the problem has just been universally ignored.
- eigenvector 6y agoFrom a hydrotechnical perspective, it's a feature not a bug. You do not want sediment going through your turbines. Suspended sediment is a major maintenance issue for run of river hydro plants.
- rhodozelia 6y agoI acknowledged that sediment suspended in water moving through the plant causes wear and suggested designing such that it would be deposited in front of a sluice gate to allow it to be flushed without going through the water conveyance plant and the turbine. I think the sediment building up behind the dam is a bug and not a feature 1) the reservoir fills up with sediment reducing the volume of water that can be stored and the amount of stored energy 2) according to the article, depriving the downstream reaches of the river of sediment is detrimental to the ecosystem. 3) for run of river plants as you have indicated the sediment builds up behind the intake structure and once that volume, which is often quite small for run of river plants, is full it has no choice but to go down the penstock and through the turbine anyway, and depending on the abrasiveness of the sediment and velocity of the water it can be extremely effective at removing metal. Clearly it is better for sediment to continue moving downstream past any dams or intake structures. Maybe some kind of dredge system / conveyor system would be another option.
- Doctor_Fegg 6y agoAnother aspect of dam removal (though not on the Klamath River) is that dams with locks facilitate level pounds and boat navigation. Several locks in the US have been removed or closed in recent years, making navigation impractical. It seems strange from a UK viewpoint: here, many formerly derelict canals and rivers have been restored to navigation over the last 60 years, and work continues. Right now, for example, fish passes are being installed at the locks on the River Severn - the idea of removing the locks entirely would be unthinkable. (Though, in a sign of how attitudes have shifted, the once-popular notion of building more locks to extend navigation further upstream has died a death.)
- reportingsjr 6y agoAfter about five years of researching UK wildlife/natural areas I have come to the conclusion that the UK should be considered one of the worst examples of how to manage nature. It is amazing how much Brits insist on destroying their nature rather than working with it, truly a sad thing. Just look at the total destruction of basically all of the chalk streams, the insane struggle to reintroduce beavers (beavers! Not even that crazy of an animal to bring back), badger culls, grouse moor monocultures for hunting, nearly complete destruction of any native woodland, the list goes on and on and on. The UK really needs to take a step back and look at what they've done to their nature.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]