5 ms·
It doesn't matter what country you are in - there is no such thing as a "friendly conversation" with any level of law enforcement - there are so many laws about
by ck2 16y ago
It doesn't matter what country you are in - there is no such thing as a "friendly conversation" with any level of law enforcement - there are so many laws about everything and anything and you can be contributing to your own arrest and prosecution without even realizing it, doesn't matter if you are actually not guilty, why set yourself up?
Laws aren't necessarily logical or fair and you might never grasp the danger of that until you are on the wrong side of one. Unless you are purposely trying to get arrested to make a protest, stop chatting with cops! Their policy is typically "arrest anyway, get them in the system, let the courts sort it out later".
Cops know they can get more out of you by being non-confrontational and mirandizing you well after you've told them everything they need to know to make up a very damning arrest report - you'll never get a warning.
What's really surprising in this case is only that this particular person didn't grasp the concept. He probably got to walk away only because they knew the ipad data could make much better evidence to arrest others than forced testimony. But they obviously used his arrest to leverage him giving it up without a fight.
- bigiain 16y agoHere's ~50 minutes of video from Moin A. Yahya, Associate Professor of Law at U. Alberta explaining why you don't ever "just talk" to police. http://lawiscool.com/2009/04/16/why-you-should-never-talk-to-the-police/ http://lawiscool.com/2009/04/16/why-you-should-never-talk-to... Tell them what you have too by law (and make sure you know enough of your local law to be reasonably sure where you are required to answer and where you are not), and never ever ever "just chat". It's not that "the cops are out to get _you_", it's mostly that the metrics and motivations they're operating under while doing their job will _very_ rarely end up even aligning with your civil rights, never mind aligning with your best interests... They're not joking when they say "anything you say can _and will_ be used against you." That very much includes anything you say before they miranda you...
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoI strongly second this. Watch the videos linked in the article, which includes a former police officer. Unfortunately, your best bet is always to just shut up. It is too easy to incriminate yourself in something unrelated that you didn't even know was illegal.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoWorse: it's easy to incriminate yourself in something that is not even illegal. You could say that you were not at the store that was robbed, but actually at your grandmother's place two hours away. However, if someone (incorrectly) believes that they've seen you, the police now has (incorrect) evidence that you are lying.
- hga 16y agoThe other excellent resource I've found is the book Arrest-Proof Yourself: An Ex-Cop Reveals How Easy It Is for Anyone to Get Arrested, How Even a Single Arrest Could Ruin Your Life, and What to Do If the Police Get in Your Face (http://www.amazon.com/Arrest-Proof-Yourself-Ex-Cop-Reveals-Arrested/dp/1556526377/ http://www.amazon.com/Arrest-Proof-Yourself-Ex-Cop-Reveals-A...), which other HN readers have found to be useful (e.g. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1533188 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1533188).
- dhbanes 16y agoExcellent video. Also, print out the ACLU bust card and carry it with you. It's folds up into a wallet-sized cheat sheet to remind you of your rights when you're stopped by police: http://www.aclu.org/files/assets/bustcard_eng_20100630.pdf http://www.aclu.org/files/assets/bustcard_eng_20100630.pdf
- Joakal 16y agoI understand you pointing it out. Unfortunately, the article and arrest was made in Australia. Different laws and cultures apply differently. Refusal to comply may indicate guilt.
- ck2 16y agoHe was chatting with them, they weren't making any demands until they came back and insisted on the ipad. When a cop starts chatting with you, your first question to yourself should be "why"? Then, don't volunteer reasons why.
- lukevdp 16y ago"Refusal to comply may indicate guilt." Can you elaborate? As far as I know, you have to identify yourself and provide id, but thats about it.
- radu_floricica 16y agoThat may be true, but it's not a solution. Personally, I want to live in a world where law enforcement is the ally, not the enemy. And if this is not possible, that's the bigger problem.
- pyre 16y agoLaw enforcement is tasked with enforcing the laws. Until there are no laws on the books that you disagree with or that could be used to suppress you, then you can never claim them as an ally. More like a fair-weather friend.
- ck2 16y agoThink of every other job in the world where people cut corners and slack and get corrupt. Everyone from the guy who has to flip burgers to brain surgeons. Now imagine them with the ability to completely screw up your life at their whim, from arrest to prosecution to judging. Law enforcement is a massive, for-profit industry. Everyone is out to improve their arrest/prosecution record. If you can't afford to defend yourself, you are an easy target. Even if you win, you still lose for having to go through the process.
- jdietrich 16y agoThe job of law enforcement is to prevent crime, to detain criminal suspects and to gather evidence. If the police are talking to you then by definition they are trying to incriminate someone, that's their job. Police officers are obliged to use any legal means available to obtain evidence - anything less would be negligence. As they are obliged by law to tell you, anything you say or do can be held against you in a court of law. You have a legal right not to incriminate yourself, but you don't have the right to un-incriminate yourself in hindsight, even if you incriminated yourself only inadvertently. If you have evidence that proves you did not commit a criminal offence, then it is in your best interest to use your right to legal representation to ensure that you give that evidence as clearly as possible and do not say anything that could undermine that evidence. Not talking to cops is a basic principle of privacy, like shredding your credit card bills or using a password on your e-mail account. Once information is out there, you can't get it back, so it's your duty to preserve it at all costs. If talking to the cops made sense, the cops would be doing a lousy job.
- danssig 16y ago>It doesn't matter what country you are in - there is no such thing as a "friendly conversation" with any level of law enforcement [citation needed] In my experience US cops tend to be more aggressive than cops most anywhere else. EDIT: In most any other 1st world country. I can't speak on the top of 3rd world country police as I've never dealt with one.
- yardie 16y agoI guess it depends on what a "friendly conversation" entails. Speaking to a cop outside the club or in front of the bar has been pretty friendly. Speaking to a cop that was interested in finding the whereabouts of a friend wasn't friendly at all. Once they get their bead on you it can be very uncomfortable situation. And this has been in a few different countries.
- matwood 16y agoCops know they can get more out of you by being non-confrontational and mirandizing you well after you've told them everything they need to know to make up a very damning arrest report - you'll never get a warning. It's also easier for the cops to flat out lie on the police report once you start talking. If you refuse to talk and ask for your lawyer you have removed all opportunity for the cops to gather evidence directly from you and/or simply lie about it later. It's much easier to defend knowing you said nothing rather than you talked for an hour and can't quite remember just how you said something.
- varikin 16y agoOne strange aside to this is from the journalists perspective. My mom was a reporter for many years in a small town and talked frequently to the cops. She was good friends with some of them and not so good friends with others—due to politics in a small town. Through this prospective, I understand why the reporter was talking with the cops, because he was thinking as a report instead of a suspect.