4 ms·
I’m counting on capitalism. We have already seen renewables become more affordable than coal and nuclear. Now it’s just a matter of handling base loads and we
by mulmen 6y ago
I’m counting on capitalism. We have already seen renewables become more affordable than coal and nuclear. Now it’s just a matter of handling base loads and we have no shortage of ideas there. Excess energy can be dumped in to carbon sequestration. Market forces have and will drive all of this.
- kolinko 6y agohear hear. capitalism already works in solar’s favour and the moment solar+storage become cheaper than coal the energy sector will switch almost instantly. with other sectors we need governments still to make the transition
- epistasis 6y agoWe also need to make sure that the government does not prevent the transition to solar. This is a huge problem, with large moneyed interests sponsoring state legislation to prevent deployment of renewables. State legislators have been arrested in Ohio for taking bribes to pass anti-renewable legislation, but despite their arrest, the legislation they enacted is still on the books. The companies got what they wanted, the government still is suppressing solar in Ohio, despite the legal system putting corrupt politicians in jail.
- foerbert 6y agoWhat market force do you see driving the use of excess energy to sequester carbon? What force is going to ensure enough carbon is sequestered? Climate change is a kind of prototypical example of a tragedy of the commons. Capitalism has not been particularly noteworthy for solving these sorts of problems. I can certainly see it helping to make renewables more affordable, but that's simply not enough at this point.
- mulmen 6y agoQuick quack suggests CO2 can be converted to carbon fiber. Also looks promising as a feed stock in the chemical and plastics industries. We figured out a use for gasoline, I’m sure we will think of something. Doesn’t hurt for the government to put a thumb on the scale either.
- allworknoplay 6y agoThis just results in more junk. Where do you think it all goes? It's a shell game.
- mulmen 6y agoWell we could bury it. Is that so different from taking it out of the air and putting it directly in an old oil well? Not sure what the recycling story is with carbon fiber. I suppose we could make extremely durable goods but that may not be desirable until we pull enough carbon out of the air. These were just quick examples though. There’s bound to be a lot of uses for carbon, it’s abundant for a reason. The point is we can leverage our consumer nature to incentivize markets that help solve climate change. We can literally consume our way out of this mess.
- allworknoplay 6y ago"We can literally consume our way out of this mess" is my new all-time favorite HN quote. Sorry if you were being tongue-in-cheek, it's just too good.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 6y agoWhat do you think a just transition will look like? One person's "consumption" and growth is another's "I finally have electricity in my village, powered by solar and batteries," or "EV purchasing grew so much that the oil refinery a mile away shut down and my family no longer gets sick like they used to." What exactly does a Green New Deal look like? Massive consumption is a huge component of it. And this is why white environmentalists are not trusted by the environmental justice community. Too much vague moralizing, not enough understanding of the plight of people who are being oppressed by the current system, or even what the current system actually is.
- radicalbyte 6y agoCapitalism is exceptionally good at solving problems when there is money to be made. Putting the right price on carbon will solve that.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Capitalism is exceptionally good at solving problems when there is money to be made. Well, unless the money is to be made by exacerbating the problem, but sure. > Putting the right price on carbon will solve that. State intervention to set prices to try to steer the market to make progress on social goals that it would not without State intervention is not capitalism.
- mulmen 6y agoRegulation is an important part of a capitalist system. “Setting the price” is something the market does. Regulation can influence that by manipulating incentives. That does not mean prices are set by the state.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Regulation is an important part of a capitalist system. If by “capitalist system” you mean “bourgeois socialist mixed economy that replaced capitalism throughout the developed West generally around the mid-20th Century through the efforts of a broad coalition of people fed up with the horrors of actual capitalism”, that's true. But that system isn't actually capitalism, and the central role of government regulation aimed at channeling the effort of “private” industry by rearranging incentives to different places than they would be set by the free market is one of the central ways in which it differs from capitalism. The only reason people pretend otherwise is to maintain the fiction that they are on the opposite side of the global capitalist/socialist struggle that predated general disillusionment with capitalism in the West, because even though actual ideology shifted, ideological tribal identity didn't.
- kortilla 6y agoProperty rights is an important part of capitalism and CO2 emissions could be modeled as property damage to everyone else.
- bottled_poe 6y agoBut what if humanity only gets one chance? Is it still best to rely on the capitalist market? This market only reacts to regulation. It is not proactive. All stick, carrot don’t work no more.
- winston_smith 6y agoWell the ussr had its chance and collapsed into oligarchy. But maybe the Chinese system of authoritarianism and reeducation camps for uighurs can still save us.
- allworknoplay 6y ago| renewables become more affordable than coal and nuclear And yet emissions keep climbing, because capitalism requires growth and demands deregulation. | Excess energy can be dumped in to carbon sequestration There is literally no scalable strategy for this, and no serious combination of strategies. Really. Nobody who actually studies this (who's not also trying to profit) thinks there is. Do the math on the world economy continuing to double every <20 years. Or maybe check out the book I shared above, it's really very good.
- epistasis 6y ago>And yet emissions keep climbing, because capitalism requires growth and demands deregulation. If your theory is in direct contradiction to actual facts and evidence, then the theory is not super useful for analyzing the world. Emissions are down over the past 10 years: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co2-emissions-per-country?tab=chart&time=1971..2017&country=Europe~USA®ion=World https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co2-emissions-per-... "Growth" as defined by GDP per capita is up over the past 10 years, https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/average-real-gdp-per-capita-across-countries-and-regions?time=1971..2016&country=Eastern%20Europe~USA~Western%20Europe https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/average-real-gdp-per-capi... "growth" defined as population is up over the past 10 years in the US, but falling in Europe: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/projected-population-by-country?tab=chart&stackMode=absolute&time=1971..latest&country=Europe~USA®ion=World https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/projected-population-by-c... Also, capitalism is just fine with a shrinking economy, there's depressions and recessions. What does this grand theory say about those? Throwing around broad terms with shifting meanings, and then changing those meanings around to fit each set of facts about the world, is a crazy way to deal with the world. > Do the math on the world economy continuing to double every <20 years. Easy enough, what's the problem. What sort of resource constraint are you thinking we hit? What defines a "dollar" or "doubling"? Based on your descriptions, there's zero chance I will bother to read the book you recommend, because it sounds like it has negative information content. I mean, come on, what sort of BS statement is "capitalism demands deregulation"?? Capitalism demands regulation through policing. What sort of possible definition of "deregulation" can you ever provide that fits both these situations? The best reflection on your source is that there is some sort of very technical definition where this statement makes sense. But repurposing common words to narrow meanings such that they become jargon, then attempting to use jargon without explaining that there's a difference with the commonly accepted meanings of those words is just a completely unproductive way to communicate to the world.