14 ms·
Mitsubishi Heavy to build biggest zero-carbon steel plant
- kobbe 6y agoSweden is actually the first country to build such an plant. Att the moment it is mostly testing plants but the real ones will be built soon. https://www.hybritdevelopment.com/ https://www.hybritdevelopment.com/
- progfix 6y agoIn Austria as well. https://www.voestalpine.com/group/en/media/press-releases/2019-11-11-h2future-worlds-largest-green-hydrogen-pilot-facility-successfully-commences-operation/ https://www.voestalpine.com/group/en/media/press-releases/20... EDIT: I should have read the article first.
- Gibbon1 6y agoIn the 1950's Norway had a pilot plant that made iron by electrowinning sulfide iron ore. Which was a waste product from copper mining. Used a low temperature wet cell. And the steel industry was perfectly happy to take their small production runs. From memory efficiency was 4.5kwh/kg. At 12 cents/kwh that's $0.50/kg. Seems like a better idea to do that than to pretend hydrogen is 'green'.
- Hypx 6y agoThe amount of hydrogen you need for hydrogen DRI is quite small. From this source: https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2018/08/f54/fcto-h2-scale-kickoff-2018-8-chevrier.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2018/08/f54/fcto-h2-... You need about 54kg of hydrogen per ton of iron. Assuming it takes 50 kWh of energy to make 1 kg of hydrogen, you get something like 2.7 kWh per kg of iron. This is significantly more energy efficient than the idea you're proposing.
- Gibbon1 6y agoFound this report from a more recent attempt. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6918249/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6918249/ The Norwegian pilot plant used a crude asbestos separator for the anode and cathode. The above used some magic polymer. They got it down to 3.53 kwh/kg
- rtx 6y agoPollution is the enemy not carbon.
- yreg 6y agoWhat do you mean by 'polution' in this case and why do you consider it more important than the carbon emissions in this case?
- inglor_cz 6y agoAs someone who grew up in Ostrava, a city then full of heavy industry (nowadays it is rust belt): pollution in the form of flying ash and solid particles is absolutely horrible for your health. It can be seen in autopsies, where lungs of non-smokers resemble those of smokers. As kids, we were sick with all kinds of respiratory disease all the time and the air stank like burnt tires. Burning coal is dirty, dirty, dirty.
- yreg 6y agoI agree with that, however I would say that runaway climate effect and its impacts on the planet outweight (in importance/severity) the issue of decreased life expectancy of beings living in cities/near factories. Therefore I don't think its misguided to "see the carbon as the enemy". By the way I live in Slovakia and I was baffled by our previous government stubbornly keeping the dirty hornonitrianske coal mines open through public funding. Even though they are loosing money and it would be cheaper (and much much cleaner) to just pay the miners to do nothing.
- rtx 6y agoBecause carbon is a byproduct of our lifestyle. Tomorrow we will replace it with something else. Fighting carbon is a feel good intiative. Where as thousand of other pollutants are being released everyday, example microplastics. Fighting carbon could be as simple as wearing sweaters at home instead of heating it.
- djsumdog 6y ago
- djmips 6y agoWho else wondered how you could possibly make steel with zero carbon... SMH.
- gostsamo 6y agoBill Gates said somewhere that steel and cement production are the key factors for stopping climate change. That's why he invested in a startup for steel production with focusing mirrors.
- spodek 6y ago> Bill Gates said somewhere that steel and cement production are the key factors for stopping climate change. Baby production is the greater key, as noted with his promoting the solutions of Mechai Viravaidya, who helped bring Thailand's birth rate from around 6 or 7 to below 2 children per woman using methods the opposite of the One Child or eugenics policies: voluntary, non-coercive, educating, and fun.
- gostsamo 6y agoFast search reveals this. https://www.gatesnotes.com/Energy/Buildings-are-good-for-people-and-bad-for-the-climate https://www.gatesnotes.com/Energy/Buildings-are-good-for-peo...
- snarf21 6y agoYeah, population is our real problem. We need to raise the standard of living around the world and empower women to work out of the home and start business. This naturally reduces the birth rate and we get rid of the horrible patriarch societies.
- collyw 6y agoBit of a catch 22, no? You increase peoples standards of living and they will use more resources but reproduce less. Mabye some women don't want to work out of the home. Do women seem happier here than before? (Though the option should be available to them).
- ehnto 6y agoSouth Australia has started producing "green" hydrogen and will be shipping it compressed to the city of Whyalla. I only mention that because one of the trouble's with hydrogen is transportation, so they must have found at least some solutions, might be worth checking out for anyone interested. In this same city, the steel plant will exceed it's emissions limits for this year, and so the hope is to see a hydrogen process start taking replacing the current coal process soon. The hydrogen plant is also supplying a mix of hydrogen and natural gas to the local gas supply, which is pretty rad too. Yet another way hydrogen can help cut reliance on fossil fuels. I don't know what the blend's carbon output is when burned, but reducing the demand for fossil fuels is a net positive in detering investment into drilling and mining. Having a renewable source for a general combustion gas is excellent.
- ginko 6y ago>I only mention that because one of the trouble's with hydrogen is transportation I think this may be the main reason why the test plant is in Austria. Central Europe has a developed energy grid with lots of energy spikes due to renewables especially in Northern Germany. Austria has an established steel industry and plenty of water, so they can probably produce the hydrogen on-site and immediately use it in the blast furnace.
- tomatocracy 6y agoIn terms of transportation, the UK has talked about repurposing the existing domestic natural gas network for hydrogen in the longer term. One first step towards this is hydrogenation of natural gas. The UK has a particularly well developed natural gas grid by international standards, but if this works well it could be a template for others to follow.
- kolinko 6y agoI wonder if it would be feasible to produce Zeppelin drones to transport hydrogen - sounds like a tried and tested tech :)
- darksaints 6y agoSure you can transport it that way, but in order for it to be lighter than air it cannot be significantly compressed. The compression factor (when liquid) is about 1000...you'd need a zepellin the size of 1000 trucks in order to transport the same quantity as a single truck. That leads to materials costs and aerodynamic efficiency being significant factors. You simply cannot transport hydrogen very efficiently using such methods.
- whalesalad 6y agoI really want to see big companies compete on green transformation. It shouldn’t just be the right thing - it needs to be sexy and cool. Space race but green race?
- yiyus 6y agoThe problem is that this already is a commercial race. As long as there are producers who do not care about emissios making cheap steel, winning the green race will only be a consolation prize.
- ginko 6y ago>it needs to be sexy and cool It needs to be profitable first and foremost.
- jinkyu 6y agook, now compete with china and india where they only care about profit, not the environment
- mikepurvis 6y agoEuropean nations and the US got a 100+ year head start over those places on the overall project of industrialization. It's profoundly unjust for us to outsource our production to them for the cheap labour and lax environmental standards and then simultaneously pin the blame on them for climate change and emissions. Even if the current state of affairs has the West not producing the bulk of global carbon emissions, there's a solid argument to be made the West still has a responsibility to pioneer technologies that can ultimately be transferred to the planet's largest polluters.
- colpabar 6y ago>the West still has a responsibility to pioneer technologies that can ultimately be transferred to the planet's largest polluters. Or we could stop outsourcing production to those polluters, and do it in countries with better environmental standards instead. It is confusing to me that this isn't the #1 goal of environmentalists right now. When will those technologies be invented? How long will it take to get them to be used globally? It feels like every few years we're given a new cutoff date for a serious course correction to prevent massive, irreparable climate change from occurring. Do we have enough time? Why do we seemingly prioritize the development of third world economies over climate action?
- hendry 6y agoUmm... Electric arc furnaces have been around a while. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_arc_furnace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_arc_furnace
- gspr 6y agoYes? And now Mitsubishi are saying they've built the world's largest. Is that a problem?
- Danieru 6y agoElectric arc furnaces are recycling, they cannot produce steal from raw iron. Iron requires carboninzation to become Steel. Thus is done using coal both to produce the heat plus the carbon. Arc furnaces are big business because we've been producing Steel for over a century and Steel only rusts a bit. Thus most of the world historic steel can still be reused once reshaped.
- billfruit 6y agoInfact Nucor the largest steel producer in the US, uses arc furnaces to produce most of the steel.
- csours 6y agoThe question is: what are Nucor's inputs. As I understand it, their input is scrap metal, not ore. (I lived down the road from one of their plants, and work with someone who used to work there, but I don't have extensive first hand knowledge)
- niftich 6y agoNucor steel mills in the US are set up to melt scrap with electric arc furnaces. A varying amount of semi-processed iron (pig iron or direct reduced iron) is added to a batch; they get this iron by shipment instead of producing it on site. As of time of writing they have one facility in the US that makes direct reduced iron from iron ore and natgas; this plant is in Louisiana at (30.08, -90.86).
- roenxi 6y agoThis is a looked for and rather important development, but not because it is zero-carbon. Who cares about carbon from steel production? If anyone does, consider reassessing your priorities. 1 plant means nothing. What is hopeful here is it represents Europe's hydrogen strategy to find a sink for all the currently-wasted energy from the renewable energy facilities that they've been building in Europe. This is looking to bring electricity in to the industrial process in a new way. In a sentence, this is about the energy storage problem of renewables, not about some sort of pollution problem from steel.
- kolinko 6y agoSteel production is responsible for 8% of global co2 emissions. Of course it matters!
- agumonkey 6y agohow much is livestock ?
- mikepurvis 6y agoIf every industry and government has someone else to look to as being "even worse" then that's a recipe for gridlock and nothing changing. This is important progress.
- agumonkey 6y agoIt wasn't my goal, don't read negativity in my comments, it very very rarely happen (and I spend time to explain that this is subjective viewpoint when I do most of the time). Actually, and it's very harming, I was trying to list the most polluting industries we rely on blindly.. in order to keep that in mind on a daily basis. ..
- kolinko 6y agoWhy would it matter in this discussion?
- jinkyu 6y agowont it be just an iron plant then?
- hinkley 6y agoHigh carbon steel is only a percent or two carbon. You could easily source that from renewables if that was the bulk of the carbon equation. I’ve heard it said from a couple of sources that ironworks were a major contributor to deforestation in Europe prior to the development of coal-fired smelting, which has a sulfur problem in addition to carbon and oxygen.
- jinkyu 6y agoi cant wait for the us gov to tax me in order to spend 2x the cost for "carbon free" steel in a building project in a state i dont live in, tied to some other critical legislation that is to important to not pass!
- AngryData 6y agoThat is good, but of course we also need the clean electrical energy generation to power it, and it likely uses much more power than a non clean plant of the same size/production. We need nuclear plants going up now. As cool as solar and wind is, I don't think we can build enough of it fast enough to undo the damage we have done and prevent large scale climate catastrophes.
- epistasis 6y agoYou have our build capabilities exactly reversed. Wind and solar are fast, reliably deployed, and cheaper than any fuel based energy source. In the US alone, the pipeline has 174GW planned for deployment through 2024, however we will deploy far more than that because planning and deployment takes far less than 5 years for renewables: https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/latest-news-headlines/us-renewable-pipeline-poised-to-add-172-5-gw-through-2024-61902543 https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights... In contrast we have only 2 reactors, 2.2GW of nuclear under construction, they are more than 2x behind schedule, 3x over budget. There were an additional 2 reactors started at the same time with the same design, but they were abandoned due to construction difficulties and budget overruns. We cant build nuclear in any sort of effective way. Wind and solar get deployed all the time, are always on time and always on budget. They are our only hope for decarbonizing our grid, nuclear offers us zero help.
- gibolt 6y agoDo you actually think nuclear can be built faster than solar + wind? Most new 2020 generation was renewable, at least in the western world
- pjc50 6y agoIt takes roughly 15-20 years to build a nuclear plant, looking at Hinkley Point C. In that time you could have half the lifespan of a set of solar panels. Nuclear cannot be build fast enough to deal with climate change. We need renewables until then.
- 08-15 6y agoWow, I had no idea! I was under the mistaken impression that France managed to build 57 reactors, which produce about 50GW, in 23 years, and the first of those took only 7 years to build. There's even a rumor that some were built in only 5 years. Good thing you taught me that nuclear power cannot possibly be built that fast, or I would have died believing that crazy conspiracy theory!
- mabbo 6y agoHydrogen production is a fascinating energy case study because of the many possibilities for production. Consider solar and wind. With variable production, there will always be time where you have more energy produced than you need. Why not use the excess to create hydrogen and store it? Now the energy doesn't go to waste. Consider nuclear power. Nuclear doesn't scale down well- it's most efficient at a specific rate of production. But demand is quite variable- 2am on a not-so-warm-or-cold day, who needs all that extra energy? Why not use the excess to create hydrogen and store it? Now the energy doesn't go to waste. In short, the energy used to create hydrogen can be very low, provided you have a cheap means to store and move it to where it needs to be, and provided you can deal with variable production rates. If this provides an income for the energy producer, then it becomes more financially viable to use wind, solar, and nuclear- all non-CO2 emitters.
- hannob 6y ago> Why not use the excess to create hydrogen and store it? This is a very popular idea, but it doesn't work out as well as it sounds. The reason is that electrolyseurs aren't free, the capital costs are high. Not saying this is impossible, but it's challenging to make this economically feasible. One more thought is that you can basically adapt all industry production to excess energy. I think the reason people want to do this with hydrogen electrolysis is because a) it's new and b) they associate both with energy transition. But neither means it's the best option.
- epistasis 6y agoThis is a good point. Renewable energy is getting so cheap that throwing kWh away can be cheaper than the cost of idling other capital infrastructure. We will need to rethink a lot of our economic assumptions in energy very soon. Solar farms are already designed to produce 30% more DC energy than their inverters can handle, because it's the lowest cost balance between PV panel capacity and inverter capacity. If somebody has an application for DC energy that can be co-located at solar farms behind inverters, and can be economical running only a few hours a day, there's huge amounts of nearly free energy already available.
- djsumdog 6y ago>The plant will use hydrogen instead of coal in the reduction process for iron ore. Where does this hydrogen come from? The vast majority of hydrogen for fuel cells comes from petroleum and natural gas reserves. > New blast furnaces require trillions of yen (1 trillion yen equals $9.6 billion) in investment. Although DRI equipment produces less steel, the investment is estimated at less than half of blast furnaces So they're building a much more expensive furnace to produce less steel. Wouldn't this create more pollution (not just carbon) because you'd want to hit the same outputs and now you need more energy? I don't understand "zero-carbon" in these cases. You still need trucks to bring in the tools and equipment to build the facility. All of them use hydrocarbons. You have hydrocarbons needed for the roads. Even if all your construction equipment is electric (they're not) you still have all the massive amounts of carbon put in to producing the electric batteries, not to mention all the waste product that comes from creating lithium batteries. Are they using all this coal and oil and then saying it's being offset by some credit? How would that even remotely work? You plant a thousand trees for ever square meter? What about all the hydrocarbons needed to transport those seeds, feed the planting crews? Most "Green energy" is really just burning trees (woodchips). This whole zero-carbon thing would fall apart when you really started breaking it down. It's marketing bullshit.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoA case can be made that it's still a step in the right direction, even if there are still some unaccounted externalities.
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoHe literally just explained why it's not a step in the right direction.
- pjc50 6y agoNo, he explained why it's not a complete solution. It is a step in the right direction even if it's not strictly zero carbon.
- darksaints 6y agoI wonder how they solved the water problem...burning hydrogen produces water, and water in the smelting process can be problematic for the quality of the pig iron...it leads to pitting in rolled steel.
- CamouflagedKiwi 6y agoThe hydrogen is burned to produce energy (i.e. heat), it doesn't have to be burned in the same furnace as the steel.
- exabrial 6y agoAs a side note, I'm wondering if this will provide lower radiation steel... The big problem why pre-World war II steel is so valuable is because it has been refined in our atmosphere pre nuclear age. Finding a niche market buyer is usually there toehold a new technology needs to gain traction, research, and investment.
- RhodoYolo 6y agowait... what? Do you have any resources where i can learn more about this? There's enough radiation in the atmosphere to forever alter the composition of steel going forward?